TIP Obligated Projects FY 2017

Re gionProjectPhaseProgramRouteTownDescriptionTot al C ost $ (0 0 0 )Federal Cost $(000)State Cost $ (0 0 0 )Local Cost $(000)50080-0131PEBRZBENSON ROADMI D D L EBURYREHAB BR 01160 OVER I-84 (PD)35028070050130-0165CONBRZSPRUCE BROOK ROADSOUTHBURYREPLACE BR 05032 O/ TRANSYLVANIA BROOK2,7452,196549050017-0189PLCMAQBRISTOLDPW VEHICLE ROUTING EFFICIENCY756001550151-0321ROWHPPSTRAI LWATERBURYMUL TI -USE TRL , S MAI N ST & P L ATTS MI L L RD16613303350151-0321PEHPPSTRAI LWATERBURYMUL TI -USE TRL , S MAI N & P L ATTS MI L L (FD )831664016650151-0273CONNFRPI-84WATERBURYUPGRADE EXPRESSWAY – PHASE 3 (80%)13,61013,6100050151-0332PENHPPI-84WATERBURYNHS – REHAB BR 03191F RAMP 197 OVER RAMP 202 MEADOW STREET (PD)25022525050166-0103PENHPPCT 69WOLCOTTREPLACE BR 03240(NON-NBI) O/ MAD R (PD)30024060050151-0334PENHPPCT 8WATERBURYNHS – REHAB BR 03178 & 03179 O/ MN RR (PD)510408102050080-0129CONNHPPCT 63MI D D L EBURYREHAB BR 06691 O/ SHATTUCK BROOK (CULVERT)570456114050151-0333PENHPPCT 8WATERBURYNHS – REHAB BR 03176 OVER NAUGATUCK RIVER AND LOCAL ROADS (PD)600480120050110-0136PENHPPUS 6PLYMOUTHINTERSECTION IMPROVEMENTS & REALIGNMENT (PD)1,000800200050130-0182CONNHPPI-84SOUTHBURYI-84 IMPROVEMENTS AT EXIT 163,0472,438609050080-0130CONNHPPCT 63MI D D L EBURYREPLACE BR 06692 O/ WOOSTER BROOK (NON-NBI)3,5712,856714050017-0182CONNHPPUS 6BRISTOLWIDENING, CAROL DRIVE TO PEGGY LANE8,6348,6340050151-0273CONNHPPI-84WATERBURYUPGRADE EXPRESSWAY – PHASE 3 (80%)13,00013,0000050151-0273CONNHPPI-84WATERBURYUPGRADE EXPRESSWAY – PHASE 3 (80%)30,00030,0000050130-0182CONREPF16I-84SOUTHBURYI-84 IMPROVEMENTS AT EXIT 16514110050151-0273CONREPF16I-84WATERBURYUPGRADE EXPRESSWAY – PHASE 3 (80%)7627620050130-0182CONREPS16I-84SOUTHBURYI-84 IMPROVEMENTS AT EXIT 1645036090050151-0273CONREPS16I-84WATERBURYUPGRADE EXPRESSWAY – PHASE 3 (80%)5,7115,7110050110-0132CONSECT 129FALL MOUNTAIN WATER ROADPLYMOUTHRECONSTRUCT A 780' SECTION760360040050174-0419PESIPHCT 63NAUGATUCKREPLACE TRAFFIC CONTROL SIGNAL ON CT 63 AT RUBBER AVENUE (SLOSSS) (PD)41410050017-0182CONSIPHUS 6BRISTOLWIDENING, CAROL DRIVE TO PEGGY LANE5,0005,0000050174-0402CONSTPAVARIOUSDISTRICT 4PRESERVATION WORK ON VARIOUS NON-NHS BRIDGES IN DISTRICT 44,7603,808952050025-0145CONSTPATRAI LCHESHIRE(S) FARMI NGTON CANAL TRAI L CONSTRUCTI ON: CORNWAL L AV TO WEST MAI N4,8414,8410050151-0273CONSTPAI-84WATERBURYUPGRADE EXPRESSWAY – PHASE 3 (80%)5,2775,2770050110-0132CONSTPHFALL MOUNTAIN WATER ROADPLYMOUTHRECONSTRUCT A 780' SECTION21016804250153-0123PESTPXCT 262WATERTOWNUPGRADE ACTIVE RAILROAD DEVICES AT FROST BRIDGE RD (FRA #503937W) (PD)252500107,146102,8743,616656Re gionProjectPhaseProgramRouteTownDescriptionTot al C ost $ (0 0 0 )Federal Cost $(000)State Cost $ (0 0 0 )Local Cost $(000)60036-0200OTH5307CVALLEY TDDE RB YNVCOG/Valley TD – Admin Cap/Misc Support Equipment FY 1632025664060036-0200ACQ5307CVALLEY TDDE RB YNVCOG/Valley TD – Replace 14 Paratransit Vehicles FY 161,200960240060036-0186CON5307CVALLEY TDDE RB YNVCOG/Valley TD – Facility Expansion/Rehab Add'l funding FY 163,0002,400600060126-0171ROWBRZLANE STREETSHELTONREHAB BR 05949 O/ MEANS BRK715701460126-0171PEBRZLANE STREETSHELTONREHAB BR 05949 O/ MEANS BRK (FD)1209602460002-0125CONHPPSVARIOUSANSONI AANSONI A P ARK AND RI VERW AL K – P HASE 2681544013660002-0125CONHPPS-EXTVARIOUSANSONI AANSONI A P ARK AND RI VERW AL K – P HASE 27867860060126-0170CONNHBRCT 8SHELTONNHS – FULL PAINTING AND STEEL REHAB OF BR 00571, CT 8 O/ RT 110 & HOUSATONIC RV13,05413,0540060002-0125CONSTPBVARIOUSANSONI AANSONI A P ARK AND RI VERW AL K – P HASE 2689551013819,92118,705904312Funding Obligated in Federal Fiscal Year 2017 for Projects Receiving Funding under Federal Transportation Programs in the Naugatuck Valley Planning RegionIncluding Projects from the Central Naugatuck Valley Region Metropolitan Planning Organization's 2015-2018 TIPand the Valley Portion of the Greater Bridgeport Valley Metropolitan Planning Organization's 2015-2018 TIP*Bike and pedestrian projects have been highlighted in yellowCentral Naugatuck Valley Region Metropolitan Planning Area*Freight projects have been highlighted orangeGreater Bridgeport Valley Metropolitan Planning Organization Re gionProjectPhaseProgramRouteTownDescriptionTot al C ost $ (0 0 0 )Federal Cost $(000)State Cost $ (0 0 0 )Local Cost $(000)700170-XXXXOTH5310EVARIOUSBRPT/STFD URBAN AREASEC 5310 Prgrm-Enchanced Moblty of Seniors/Individuals w/Disabilities- Brdpt/Stmfd1,0707290341700170-XXXXOTH5310EVARIOUSOTHER URBAN AREASEC 5310 Prgrm-Enchanced Moblty of Seniors/Individuals w/Disabilities- Other Urban7825350247700170-XXXXOTH5310EVARIOUSRURA LSEC 5310 Prgrm-Enchanced Moblty of Seniors/Individuals w/Disabilities- Rural313253060700170-XXXXOTH5311TSECTION 5311VARIOUSSECTION 5311 Prog Adjust to Actual APPR, ADMIN & RTAP PROG FFY 20188288071111700170-3423PEBRZLOCAL BR PROGSTATEWIDELOCAL BRIDGE PROGRAM CLE SERVICES (CME)12012000700170-3422PEBRZLOCAL BR PROGSTATEWIDELOCAL BRIDGE PROGRAM CLE SERVICES (CJM/BL)60060000700170-3441TRCMAQSTATEWIDETRAFFI C SI GNAL SYSTEM CI RCUI T RI D ER P ROGRAM (4 /1 /1 7 – 3 /3 1 /2 0 )29529500700170-3383OTHMGSVARIOUSSTATEWIDELOAD RATINGS FOR BRIDGES – NON-NHS ROADS (1/1/16-12/31/20)201640700170-3413OTHNHBRVARIOUSSTATEWIDECE BRIDGE INSP – NHS ROADS (9/1/16 – 8/31/21)9,8527,8821,9700700170-3362PENHPPVARIOUSSTATEWIDESIGN SUPPORT REPLACEMENTS (FD)10820700170-3436TRNHPPSTATEWIDEAASHTO TRAI NI NG & W ORK FORCE D EVEL OP MENT (1 /1 /1 7 – 1 2 /3 1 /1 7 )15015000700170-3382OTHNHPPVARIOUSSTATEWIDELOAD RATINGS FOR BRIDGES – NHS ROADS (1/1/16-12/31/20)2,0001,6004000700170-3411OTHNHPPVARIOUSSTATEWIDESF BRIDGE INSP – NHS ROADS (9/1/16 – 8/31/21)2,6452,1165290700170-3415OTHNHPPVARIOUSSTATEWIDECE SIGN SUPPORT INSP – NHS ROADS (9/1/16 – 8/31/21)3,2432,5946490700093-0215OTHNHPPVARIOUSVARIOUSSTAFF NEWINGTON OPS. CTR. (8/1/16 – 7/31/18)4,4973,5978990700170-3362CONNHPPVARIOUSSTATEWIDESIGN SUPPORT REPLACEMENTS4,9993,9991,0000700170-3413OTHNHPPVARIOUSSTATEWIDECE BRIDGE INSP – NHS ROADS (9/1/16 – 8/31/21)6,7745,4191,3550700174-0415CONSIPHVARIOUSSTATEWIDEINSTALL RUMBLE STRIPS STATEWIDE49049000700170-3455OTHSIPHVARIOUSSTATEWIDECHAMP SAFETY SERVICE PATROL (7/1/17-6/30/20)1,5671,4100157700170-3455OTHSIPHVARIOUSSTATEWIDECHAMP SAFETY SERVICE PATROL (7/1/17-6/30/20)2,9702,6730297700170-3383OTHSTPAVARIOUSSTATEWIDELOAD RATINGS FOR BRIDGES – NON-NHS ROADS (1/1/16-12/31/20)2200700170-3414OTHSTPAVARIOUSSTATEWIDECE BRIDGE INSP – NON-NHS ROADS (9/1/16 – 8/31/21)130104260700170-3412OTHSTPAVARIOUSSTATEWIDESF BRIDGE INSP – NON-NHS ROADS (9/1/16 – 8/31/21)7157140700170-3383OTHSTPAVARIOUSSTATEWIDELOAD RATINGS FOR BRIDGES – NON-NHS ROADS (1/1/16-12/31/20)9237391850700063-0715CONSTPAMI SCSTATEWIDEDRS: MOTOR FUEL TAX ENFORCEMENT (FY17-19)353500700170-3434CONSTPAVARIOUSSTATEWIDERAPID RESPONSE BRIDGE REPAIRS BY STATE FORCES (THRU 12/31/20)5040100700170-3383OTHSTPAVARIOUSSTATEWIDELOAD RATINGS FOR BRIDGES – NON-NHS ROADS (1/1/16-12/31/20)5544110700170-3338OTHSTPAVARIOUSSTATEWIDEBRIDGE SCOUR MONITORING (3/1/15-2/28/18)7560150700170-3434CONSTPAVARIOUSSTATEWIDERAPID RESPONSE BRIDGE REPAIRS BY STATE FORCES (THRU 12/31/20)7560150700170-3431TRSTPASTATEWIDESURFACE TRANSPORTATION WORKFORCE DEVELOPMENT (THRU 9/30/19)10010000700170-3359CONSTPAVARIOUSSTATEWIDESIZE & WEIGHT ENFORCEMENT PROGRAM (EFFECTIVE 9/9/15, YR 3)5004001000700170-3439PESTPASTATEWIDETA P ROGRAM – P ROJ ECT D EVEL OP MENT/SCOP I NG (FED EL I GI BL E) THRU 3 /3 1 /2 252852800700170-3340OTHSTPAVARIOUSSTATEWIDECE BRIDGE INSP – UWATER – NON-NHS ROADS (9/1/15-8/31/18)1,2009602400700170-3459OTHSTPAVARIOUSSTATEWIDEROAD WEATHER MANAGEMENT THRU VEHICLE BASED TECHNOLOGY (GPS/AVL)1,1251,12500700170-3412OTHSTPAVARIOUSSTATEWIDESF BRIDGE INSP – NON-NHS ROADS (9/1/16 – 8/31/21)1,8111,4493620700170-3346CONSTPAVARIOUSSTATEWIDEINSTALL ROAD WEATHER INFO SYSTEMS (RWIS) AT 25 LOCATIONS5,6824,5461,1360700170-3414OTHSTPAVARIOUSSTATEWIDECE BRIDGE INSP – NON-NHS ROADS (9/1/16 – 8/31/21)10,8688,6942,1740700170-3437PESTPXVARIOUSSTATEWIDEUPGRADE ACTIVE RR DEVICES ON CT PROVIDENCE & WORCESTER RR CO. LINES (FD)252500700170-3437PESTPXVARIOUSSTATEWIDEUPGRADE ACTIVE RR DEVICES ON CT PROVIDENCE & WORCESTER RR CO. LINES (PD)505000700170-3437CONSTPXVARIOUSSTATEWIDEUPGRADE ACTIVE RR DEVICES ON CT PROVIDENCE & WORCESTER RR CO. LINES2,4932,243249069,02156,55211,3561,112Re gionProjectPhaseProgramRouteTownDescriptionTot al C ost $ (0 0 0 )Federal Cost $(000)State Cost $ (0 0 0 )Local Cost $(000)710171-0305OTH5307SCTFA S TRA KHA RTFORD/NE W B RITA INCTDOT – CTfastrak Operation Funds – Tranfer from FHWA-CMAQ15,00012,0003,0000710171-0426PESIPHVARIOUSDISTRICT 1INSTALL RUMBLE STRIPS IN DISTRICT 1 (PD)303000710171-0409PESIPHVARIOUSDISTRICT 1INSTALL SIGNS & PVM'T MARKINGS ON HRRR HORIZONTAL CURVES (FD)808000710170-3350CONSIPHVARIOUSDISTRICT 1INSTALL CENTERLINE & SHOULDER RUMBLE STRIPS17917900710171-0434PESIPHVARIOUSDISTRICT 1REPLACE TRAFFIC SIGNALS @ 5 SLOSSS LOCATIONS (PD)20620600710171-0396CONSIPHVARIOUSDISTRICT 1REPLACE PED SIGNS IN DISTRICT 136936900710171-0393CONSIPHVARIOUSDISTRICT 1SIGNAL IN NEWINGTON43943900710171-0409CONSIPHVARIOUSDISTRICT 1INSTALL SIGNS & PVM'T MARKINGS ON HRRR HORIZONTAL CURVES60560500710171-0409CONSIPRVARIOUSDISTRICT 1INSTALL SIGNS & PVM'T MARKINGS ON HRRR HORIZONTAL CURVES1601600017,06814,0683,0000State wideCTDOT Maintenance and Construction District 1 Re gionProjectPhaseProgramRouteTownDescriptionTot al C ost $ (0 0 0 )Federal Cost $(000)State Cost $ (0 0 0 )Local Cost $(000)730173-0466CONNHBRVARIOUSDISTRICT 3BRIDGE JOINT PRESERVATION PROGRAM-NHS2,3651,8924730730173-0472CONNHPPCT 15GREENWICH-MILFORDREPLACE SIGNS, INCLUDING VMS, VICINITY OF EXITS 27-536,1256,12500730173-0481PESIPHVARIOUSDISTRICT 3INSTALL RUMBLE STRIPS IN DISTRICT 3 (PD)303000730173-0442ROWSIPHVARIOUSDISTRICT 3GUIDERAIL – NON-NHS ROUTES505000730173-0487PESIPHVARIOUSDISTRICT 3REPLACE TRAFFIC CONTROL SIGNALS AT 2 SLOSSS LOCATIONS (PD)838300730173-0477CONSIPHVARIOUSDISTRICT 3INSTALL CENTERLINE & SHOULDER RUMBLE STRIPS33933900730173-0485PESIPHVARIOUSDISTRICT 3INSTALLATION OF SIGNS & PAVEMENT MARKINGS FOR HORIZONTAL CURVES (PD)1,0441,04400730173-0451ROWSTPAVARIOUSDISTRICT 3OSTA TRAFFIC SIGNAL S IN DISTRICT 316016000730173-0451PESTPAVARIOUSDISTRICT 3OSTA TRAFFIC SIGNAL S IN DISTRICT 3 (FD)1651650010,3609,8884730Re gionProjectPhaseProgramRouteTownDescriptionTot al C ost $ (0 0 0 )Federal Cost $(000)State Cost $ (0 0 0 )Local Cost $(000)740174-0415PESIPHVARIOUSDISTRICT 4INSTALL RUMBLE STRIPS IN DISTRICT 4 (PD)303000740174-0399PESIPHCT 8 & 35DISTRICT 4TRAFFI C CONTROL SI GNAL S ON RT 8 NAUGATUCK , RT 3 5 RI D GEFI EL D (FD )454500740174-0399ROWSIPHCT 8 & 35DISTRICT 4TRAFFI C CONTROL SI GNAL S ON RT 8 NAUGATUCK , RT 3 5 RI D GEFI EL D505000740174-0412CONSIPHVARIOUSDISTRICT 4INSTALL CENTERLINE & SHOULDER RUMBLE STRIPS38538500740174-0391CONSIPHCT 68NAUGATUCKTRAFFI C SI GNAL REP L ACEMENT – CT 6 8 AT SR 7 2 353653600740174-0417PESIPHVARIOUSDISTRICT 4INSTALLATION OF SIGNS & PAVEMENT MARKINGS FOR HORIZONTAL CURVES (PD)1,9501,95000740174-0392CONSTPAVARIOUSDISTRICT 4OSTA TRAFFIC SIGNAL S IN DISTRICT 4 (FY1 7 P ROGRAM)2,9352,8805505,9325,877550Re gionProjectPhaseProgramRouteTownDescriptionTot al C ost $ (0 0 0 )Federal Cost $(000)State Cost $ (0 0 0 )Local Cost $(000)750170-3450OTHCMAQVARIOUSSTATEWIDEFY17: STATEWIDE TRANS DEMAND MGMNT (NY-NJ-CT MODERATE)2,9802,38459602,9802,3845960Re gionProjectPhaseProgramRouteTownDescriptionTot al C ost $ (0 0 0 )Federal Cost $(000)State Cost $ (0 0 0 )Local Cost $(000)760170-3451OTHCMAQVARIOUSSTATEWIDEFY17: STATEWIDE TRANS DEMAND MGMNT (GREATER CT MODERATE)1,8701,49637401,8701,4963740Re gionProjectPhaseProgramRouteTownDescriptionTot al C ost $ (0 0 0 )Federal Cost $(000)State Cost $ (0 0 0 )Local Cost $(000)790401-0012ALL5307CCTTRA NS ITHA RTFORDCTDOT – CTTransit Hartford Facility Improvements/Expansion20,00016,0004,0000790400-0057ACQ5307CCTTRA NS ITVARIOUSCTDOT – CTTransit Systemwide Bus Replacements 40-ft Buses13,35010,6802,6700790400-0061ACQ5307CCTTRA NS ITVARIOUSCTDOT – CTTransit Systemwide Commuter Bus Replacements6,0004,8001,2000790430-0026ACQ5307CCTTRA NS ITWA TE RB URYCTDOT – CTTransit Waterbury Replace Paratransit Vehs FY 168506801700790400-0062OTH5307CCTTRA NS ITVARIOUSCTDOT – CTTransit Admin Capital/Support Equipment2,1831,7474370790170-3403OTH5307CCTTRA NS ITVARIOUSCTDOT – Transit Capital Planning1,0008002000790301-0181ALL5307PNHL -MLNORWA L KCTDOT – New Universal Interlocking at CP 243 on New Haven Mainline80,00064,00016,0000790300-0190CON5307PNHL -MLVARIOUSCTDOT – NHL – Track Program – C3125,00020,0005,0000148,383118,70729,6770Re gionProjectPhaseProgramRouteTownDescriptionTot al C ost $ (0 0 0 )Federal Cost $(000)State Cost $ (0 0 0 )Local Cost $(000)72, 730015-0375OTHNHPPVARIOUSVARIOUSSTAFF BRIDGEPORT OPS. CTR. (8/1/16 – 7/31/18)2,6332,369263005, 070084-0114PENHPPCT 34MONROE/OX FORDNHS – REPLACE BR 01843 O/ STEVENSON DAM & HOUSATONIC RIVER (PD)1,2001,2000005, 100171-0305OTHCMAQCTFASTRAKNEW BRITAIN/HARTFORDCTFASTRAK OPERATING – FUNDS TRANSFER TO FTA15,00012,0003,000005, 10, 110171-0417PESTPAVARIOUSDISTRICT 1OSTA TRAFFIC SIGNAL S IN DISTRICT 1 (P D)4364360005, 060174-0380CONNHPPCT 8DISTRICT 4UPGRADE SIGNING, FROM SHELTON TO I-84 IN WATERBURY1,0001,0000005, 060174-0380CONNHPPCT 8DISTRICT 4UPGRADE SIGNING, FROM SHELTON TO I-84 IN WATERBURY4,4844,4840002, 05, 100174-0403CONNHBRVARIOUSDISTRICT 4PRESERVATION WORK ON VARIOUS NHS BRIDGES IN DISTRICT 414,76511,8122,953002, 03, 05, 100174-0418PESTPAVARIOUSDISTRICT 4REPLACE TRAFFIC SIGNALS AT 12 LOCATIONS (PD)4954950040,01333,7976,2160Greater Connecticut Moderate Non-Attainment Area (District 76)CT transit (District 79)Multi-Regional Project ListingCTDOT Maintenance and Construction District 3CTDOT Maintenance and Construction District 4NY-NJ -CT M ode rate Non-A ttainme nt A re a (Distric t 7 5 )

Unified Planning Work Programs (UPWP) for the Naugatuck Valley Planning Region FY 2018-2019

| P a g e FY 201 8 – 2019 Unified Planning Work Program for the Naugatuck Valley Planning Region Prepared by the : Naugatuck Valley Council of Governments June 2017 Revised November 2017 Amended May 2018 i | P a g e ii | P a g e Table of Contents Adoption FY 2018 -2019 Unified Planning Work Program Resolution 2017 -18 Urban Transportation Planning Certification Resolution 2017 -20 Amendment to the FY 2018 -2019 Unified Planning Work Program Statement of Cooperative MPO/State/Transit Operators’ Planning Roles & Responsibilities Resolution 2018 -09 iv v vii I. Statement of Cooperative MPO/State/Transit Operators Planning Roles and Responsibilities Naugatuck Valley Planning Region 1 Purpose General Roles and Responsibilities Long Range Transportation Plan Transportation Improvement Program (TIP) Air Quality Planning Public Participation Program Public Transportation Planning Fiscal/Financial Planning Congestion Management Process (CMP) Program Intelligent Transportation Systems (ITS) Program Performance Bas ed Planning and Programming Amendment Effective Date No Limitation on Statutory Authority 1 1 2 2 3 3 4 4 5 5 5 8 8 8 II. Naugatuck Valley Planning Region Regional Transportation Planning Process 8 Introduction M etropolitan Planning Transportation Systems Transportation Planning Issues and Goals UPWP Program Objectives 8 9 14 17 19 III. Naugatuck Valley Planning Region Regional Tra nsportation Work Program FY 201 6-2017 22 Unified Planning Work Program (UPWP) – Outline Unified Planning Work Program (UPWP) – Budget Task 1: Data Collection/Analysis Task 2A: Transportation Planning – Regional Task 2B: Transportation Planning – Transit 22 23 25 30 36 iii | P a g e Task 2C : Transportation Planning – Non -motorized Trans por tation Modes Task 3 : Program Management , Implementation and Administration Task 4 : Other Technical Assistance 42 47 52 IV . Naugatuck Valley Planning Region Task and Staff Allocation Budgets and Regional Transportation Program Schedules FY 2016 -2017 60 FY 201 8 Task Allocation by Funding Sources and Revenues FY 2019 Task Allocation by Funding Sources and Revenues FY 2018 Task Allocation Budget FY 2019 Task Allocation Budget FY 2018 and FY 2019 Other Direct Budget FY 201 8 Staff Allocation Budget FY 2019 Staff Allocation Budget FY 2018 Regional Transportation Program Schedule Central Naugatuck Valley Region MPO FY 2019 Regional Transportation Program Schedule Central Naugatuck Valley Region MPO Job Classifications by Title Maximum Hourly Rates 60 60 61 62 62 63 64 65 66 67 73 iv | P a g e v | P a g e vi | P a g e vii | P a g e 1 | P a g e I. Statement of Cooperative MPO/State/Transit Operators Planning Roles and Responsibilities Naugatuck Valley Planning Region Purpose The purpose of this statement is to outline the roles and responsibilities of the State, the Central Naugatuck Valley Metropolitan Planning Organization (CNV MPO) and appropriate providers of public transportation, as required by 23 CFR Sec. 450.314(a) and (h) ”Metropolitan Planning Agreements”. General Roles & Responsibilities The CNV MPO will perform the transportation planning process fo r their region and develop procedures to coordinate transportation planning activities in accordance with applicable federal regulations and guidance. The transportation process will, at a minimum, consist of: 1. Preparation of a two -year Unified Planning Wo rk Program that lists and describes all transportation planning studies and tasks to be completed during this two -year period. 2. Preparation and update of a long range, multi -modal metropolitan transportation plan. 3. Preparation and maintenance of a short -rang e transportation improvement program (TIP). 4. Financial planning to ensure plan and program are financially constrained and within anticipated funding levels. 5. Conduct of planning studies and system performance monitoring, including highway corridor and inter section studies, transit system studies, application of advanced computer techniques, and transportation data collection and archiving. 6. Public outreach, including survey of affected populations, electronic dissemination of reports and information (website) , and consideration of public comments. 7. Ensuring the transportation planning process evaluates the benefits and burdens of transportation projects and/or investments to ensure significant or disproportionate impacts on low income and minority populations a re avoided and/or mitigated. This will be accomplished using traditional and non -traditional outreach to Title VI populations, including outreach to LEP populations. t 8. Development and implementation of a Congestion Management Process as appropriate. 9. Ensur ing plans, projects and programs are consistent with and conform to air quality goals of reducing transportation -related emissions and attaining National Ambient Air Quality Standards. Long Range Transportation Plan 1. The CNV MPO will be responsible for pr eparing and developing the long range (20 –25 years) metropolitan transportation plans for its respective region. 2. The CNV MPO may develop a consolidated transportation plan summary report for the planning region that includes the key issues facing the are a and priority programs and projects. 2 | P a g e 3. CT DOT will provide the following information and data in support of developing the transportation plan: a. Financial information – estimate of anticipated federal funds over the 20 -25 year time frame of the plan for the highway and transit programs. b. Trip tables – for each analysis year, including base year and the horizon year of the plan by trip purpose and mode. (CT DOT will provide this only if requested since the CNV MPO may maintains its own travel forecast model.) c. Traffic count data for state roads in the CNV MPO region, and transit statistics as available. d. List of projects of statewide significance by mode, with descriptions, so that they can be incorporated into the long range metropolitan transportation plans. e. Assess air quality impacts and conduct the regional emissions assessment of the plan. Will provide the results of the assessment in a timely manner to allow inclusion in the plan and to be made available to the public at public information meetings. (Ref er to air quality tasks.) 4. The CNV MPO may conduct transportation modeling for the area. 5. The CNV MPO will consult with the appropriate providers of public transportation on local bus capital projects to include in the transportation plan, and will work toge ther to develop local bus improvements for the plan from the 10 -year capital program. Through consultation, they will identify future local bus needs and services, including new routes, service expansion, rolling stock needs beyond replacement, and operati ng financial needs. Transportation Improvement Program (TIP) 1. The TIP will be prepared and compiled through a consultative process between CT DOT, CNV MPO , and the appropriate provider(s) of public transportation. 2. CT DOT will send a draft proposed 5 -ye ar Capital Plan to the CNV MPO for review and comment. The draft list will reflect input that the CT DOT received from the CNV MPO during the consultation process on the previous year’s plan. 3. CT DOT will prepare an initial list of projects to include in the new TIP. This list will be based on the current TIP that is about to expire and the 5 – year Capital Plan. 4. CT DOT will consult with and solicit comments from CNV MPO and transit providers on the TIP and incorporate where practicable. 5. CT DOT will pro vide detailed project descriptions, cost estimates and program schedules. The project descriptions will provide sufficient detail to allow the CNV MPO to explain the projects to the policy board and the general public. 6. CT DOT will provide a list of project s obligated during each of the federal fiscal years covered by the expiring TIP/STIP. The annual listing of obligated projects should include both highway and transit projects. 7. The CNV MPO will compile the TIP for the Region, including preparing a narrati ve. Projects will be categorized by federal aid program and listed in summary tables. The TIP will be converted into a format that will allow it to be dow nloaded to the Region’s website. The CNV MPO will maintain the TIP by tracking amendments and change s to 3 | P a g e projects (schedule, scope and cost) made through the TIP/STIP Administrative Action/Amendment/Notification process. 8. CT DOT will develop the STIP based on the MPOs’ TIPs and projects located in the rural regions of the State. 9. CT DOT will include one ST IP entry each for the Bridge program and the Highway Safety Improvement program. This entry will list the total funds needed for these programs for each fiscal year. All Regions will receive back up lists in the form of the Bridge Report and the Safety R eport monthly . The one line entry will reduce the number of entries needed in the STIP. Any projects listed in the Bridge and or Safety Report that are over $5m and on the NHS, will be transferred directly into the STIP as its own entry per the TIP/STIP Administrative Action/Amendment/Notification process . 10. CT DOT will provide proposed amendments to the CNV MPO for consideration. The amendment will include a project description that provides sufficient detail to allow the CNV MPO to explain the propose d changes to the CNV MPO board. It will also provide a clear reason and justification for the amendment. If it involves a new project, CT DOT will provide a clear explanation of the reasons and rationale for adding it to the TIP/STIP. 11. When an amendment to the TIP/STIP is being proposed by the CNV MPO , the project sponsor will consult with CT DOT to obtain concurrence with the proposed amendment, to obtain Air Quality review and consistency with Air Quality Conformity regulations and ensure financial co nsistency. 12. CT DOT will provide a financial assessment of the STIP with each update. The CNV MPO should prepare a TIP summary table listing all projects by funding program sorted by year based on CT DOT’s financial assessment. Air Quality Planning 1. CT DOT and the CNV MPO should meet at least once per year to discuss the air quality conformity process, the regional emissions analysis and air quality modeling. 2. CT DOT will conduct the regional emissions analysis, which includes the CNV MPO area and provide the results to the CNV MPO. The regional emissions analyses for the build or future years will include the proposed transportation improvements included in th e regional long -range metropolitan transportation plans and TIP. 3. The CNV MPO will prepare a summary report of the conformity process and regional emissions analysis for the Region. It will contain a table showing the estimated emissions from the transpor tation system for each criteria pollutant and analysis year. 4. The summary report on the regional emissions analyses will be inserted into the long – range transportation plan and TIP. 5. The CNV MPO will make the regional emissions analysis available to the publ ic. Public Participation Program 1. The CNV MPO will annually review and evaluate its public participation program. 2. The CNV MPO will update and prepare a list of neighborhood and local organizations and groups that will receive notices of MPO plans, program s and projects. 3. The CNV MPO will work to ensure that low -income, minority and transit dependent areas are afforded an adequate opportunity to participate in the transportation planning 4 | P a g e process, receive a fair share of the transportation improvement benefit s and do not endure a disproportionate transportation burden. The CNV MPO will comply with federal legislation on these issues. 4. The CNV MPO’s process for developing plans, projects, and programs will include consultation with state and local agencies resp onsible for land use and growth management, natural resources, environmental protection, conservation and historic preservation. 5. The CNV MPO will maintain their website to provide clear and concise information on the transportation planning process and pro vide an opportunity to download reports and documents. This will include developing project and study summaries, converting reports into a pdf or text format, and maintaining a list of available documents. The website will provide links to other associat ed organizations and agencies. Public Transportation Planning 1. The CNV MPO will allow for, to the extent feasible, the participation of transit providers at all transportation committee and policy board meetings to provide advice, information and consultation on transportation programs within the planning region. 2. The CNV MPO will provide the opportunity for the transit providers to review and comment on planning products relating to transit issues within the region. 3. The CNV MPO will allow for trans it provider(s) to participate in UPWP, long -range plan, and TIP development to insure the consideration of any appropriate comments. 4. The CNV MPO and CT DOT will assist the transit provider(s), to the extent feasible, with planning for transit -related activ ities. Fiscal/Financial Planning 1. The CT DOT will provide the CNV MPO with up -to -date fiscal and financial information on the statewide and regional transportation improvement programs to the extent practicable. This will include: a. Anticipated federal funding resources by federal aid category for the upcoming federal fiscal year, as shown in the TIP financial chart. b. Will hold annual meetings to discuss authorized funds for the STP -Urban and LOTCIP accounts . c. Annual authorized/programmed funds for the F TA Section 5307 Program as contained in the STIP and the annual UZA split agreements. d. Monthly updates of STP -Urban Program showing current estimated cost & scheduled obligation dates. 2. The CT DOT will notify the CNV MPO when the anticipated cost of a projec t, regardless of funding category, has changed in accordance with the agreed upon TIP/STIP Administrative Action/Amendment/Notification process . 5 | P a g e 3. The CNV MPO will prepare summary tables and charts that display financial information for presentation to the policy board. Congestion Management Process (CMP) Program 1. The CNV MPO, if located in a TMA, will conduct a highway performance monitoring program that includes the collection of traffic counts, conduct of travel time surveys, and determination of travel speeds and delay. 2. The CNV MPO will conduct congestion strategies studies for critical corridors and identify possible improvements to reduce congestion and delay. 3. The CNV MPO will work with CT DOT on programming possible congestion -reducing projects. 4. The C NV MPO will, upon implementation of a congestion reduction improvement, assess post -improvement operations and determine level of congestion relief. 5. Intelligent Transportation Systems (ITS) Program 1. 1. The CT DOT will maintain the statewide ITS architectu re and ensure consistency with the Regional ITS Architecture for the CNV MPO. 2. The CNV MPO will maintain and update the Regional ITS Architecture for the CNV MPO, where appropriate. Performance Based Planning and Programming A. Collection of Performance Data 1. All data collected for performance measure goals will be collected by the CTDOT and will meet the MAP21/FAST ACT provisions and requirements. 2. All data collected for goals for Federal Transit Administration’s (FTA’s) State of Good Repair performance me asures will include data provided by the Transit Districts through CTDOT, in accordance with the Transit Asset Management Rule. 3. CTDOT will make the compiled data collected for each performance measure available on the CTDOT MAP21 website. 4. CTDOT will devel op a Measures and Deliverables tracking spreadsheet outlining each Performance Measure, the deliverables required, the submittal dates and the CTDOT contact. B. Selection of Performance Targets CTDOT will draft statewide performance targets for each of the FA ST Act performance measures and coordinate with the MPOs and Transit Representatives, as required by 23 CFR Parts 450 and 771, as well as 49 CFR Part 613 as outlined below: 1. The CTDOT will discuss performance measures at each of its regularly scheduled mont hly meetings (via teleconference or in person meeting). 6 | P a g e 2. The CTDOT will present data collected for each performance measure and collaborate with the CNV MPO and Transit Representatives on assumptions. 3. The CTDOT will provide the CNV MPO and Transit Represe ntative with 30 days to provide feedback on the data received and the assumptions provided. 4. The feedback received will be discussed at the next scheduled monthly meeting. 5. CTDOT will set targets for each performance measure based on feedback received. C. Repor ting of Performance Targets 1. CTDOT will notify the CNV MPO and Transit Representatives by email when final statewide targets are established. 2. CTDOT will send the targets that have been set, the backup information and a PowerPoint presentation to the CNV MPO for their use in educating the MPO Policy Board. CTDOT will provide region level data summaries, if available. 3. The CNV MPO has 180 days after the CTDOT establishes and reports its targets to FHWA/FTA to establish its own targets or endorse the State’s tar gets and agree to plan and program projects so that they contribute toward the accomplishment of the performance targets. 4. If the CNV MPO is establishing its own targets, the CNV MPO will report those targets to the CTDOT by email no later than the 180 day timeframe. 5. The CNV MPO will share this information with the Policy Board and will require Policy Board resolution to support the targets set by CTDOT or endorse their own targets. 6. The CNV MPO will forward the Policy Board resolution to the Performance Meas ures Unit at the CTDOT before the 180 day limitation for FHWA performance measures. 7. For FTA performance measures, it is noted that the CNV MPO provided a resolution of support for the initial transit State of Good Repair performance targets on July 1, 201 7. Thereafter, in accordance with FTA, transit providers will continue to share their targets annually with the CNV MPO. However, the CNV MPO targets are not to be updated annually, only revisited whenever the CNV MPO updates its MTP and/or TIP on or after October 1, 2018. 8. The CNV MPO set initial SGR targets as required by FTA on 7/1/17. Thereafter, the CNV MPO needs to set SGR targets for the first time when the TIP or MTP is amended or updated on or after October 1, 2018. Following this date, targets shou ld be updated upon the development of future TIPs and MTPs. D. Reporting of progress toward achieving goal 1. CTDOT will document progress towards achieving statewide performance targets and report that information to the CNV MPO and transit representatives in the Long Range Transportation Plan, the Statewide Transportation Improvement Program, the CTDOT TAM Plans and the FTA Annual report by email after the biannual reports are issued to Federal Agencies. 2. CTDOT will share the TAM Plans with the CNV MPO in a timely manner, and the MPOs will incorporate them into their planning process. 3. The CNV MPO will document pr ogress towards achieving performance targets and report that information to CTDOT in the Metropolitan Transportation Plan and the 7 | P a g e Transportation Improvement Plan as outlined in the Measures and Deliverables tracking spreadsheet vial email. The CTDOT will c ollect this information and file until requested from FHWA. E. The collection of data for the State asset management plan for the NHS 1. CTDOT will collect all asset management data required for all NHS routes, regardless of ownership. 23 Performance Measures Highway Safety Number of Fatalities – 5-Year Rolling Average Highway Safety Rate of Fatalities per 100 million VMT – 5-Year Rolling Average Highway Safety Number of Serious Injuries – 5-Year Rolling Average Highway Safety Rate of Serious Injuries per 100 million VMT – 5-Year Rolling Average Highway Safety Number of Non -Motorized Fatalities and Non -Motorized Serious Injuries – 5-Year Rolling Average Bridges & Pavements Percentage of Pavements of the Interstate System in Good Condition Bridges & Pavements Percentage of Pavements of the Interstate System in in Poor Condition Bridges & Pavements Percentage of Pavements of the Non -Interstate NHS in Good Condition Bridges & Pavements Percentage of Pavements of the Non -Interstate NHS in Poor Conditio n Bridges & Pavements Percentage of NHS Bridges classified in Good Condition (by deck area) Bridges & Pavements Percentage of NHS Bridges classified in Poor Condition (by deck area) System Performance Percent of the Person -Miles Traveled on the Interstate That Are Reliable System Performance Percent of the Person -Miles Traveled on the Non -Interstate NHS That Are Reliable Freight Percent of the Interstate System mileage providing for reliable truck travel times Congestion and Air Quality Annual Hours of Peak -Hour Excessive Delay (PHED) Congestion and Air Quality Percent of Non -SOV Travel 8 | P a g e Congestion and Air Quality Total Emissions Reduction Transit Asset Management Percentage of Service (non -revenue) Vehicles that have met or exceeded their Useful Life Benchmark (ULB) Transit Asset Management Percentage of Facilities with an asset class rated below condition 3 on the TERM scale. Transit Asset Management Infrastructure (rail, fixed guideway, track, signals, and systems) – Percentage of track segments with performance restrictions Transit Asset Management Percentage of Revenue Vehicles within a particular asset class that have met or exceeded their ULB FTA C 5010.1E Number of fatalities per ‘‘vehicle revenue miles.’’ by mode. FTA C 5010.1E Number of serious injuries per ‘‘vehicle revenue miles.’’ by mode. Amendment This Statement on Transportation Planning may be amended from time to time or to coincide with annual UPWP approval as jointly deemed necessary or in the best interests of all parties, including Federal transportation agencies. Effective Date This Statement will be effective after it has been endorsed by the CNV MPO as part of the UPWP, and as soon as the UPWP has been approved by the relevant Federal transportation agencies. No Limitation on Statutory Authority Nothing contained in this Statement is intended to or shall limit the authority or responsibilities assigned to signatory organizations under Connecticut law, federal law, local ordinance, or charter. II. Naugatuck Valley Planning Region Regional Transportation Planning Process Introduction The Naugatuck Valley Council of Governments ( NVCOG) wa s formed on January 1, 2015, by the merger of the Council of Governments of the Central Naugatuck Valley (COGCNV) and the Valley Council of Governments (VCOG) . The City of Bristol and Town of Plymouth, formerly of the Central Connecticut Regional Planning Agency, elected to join the new organization. 9 | P a g e The Naugatuck Valley planning region encompasses 19 municipalities in west -central Connecticut covering approximately 422 square miles. The City of Waterbury is the largest city and serves as the region’s central city. Based on the most recent American Community Survey (ACS) , the region has a total population of 448,180 people . The Naugatuck Valley planning region includes almost the entire Census -defined Waterbury urbanized area, and parts of the Bridgeport -Stamford urbanized area, New Haven urbanized area and Hartford urbani zed area.  Ansonia   Naugatuck   Southbury   Beacon Falls   Oxford   Thomaston   Bethlehem   Plymouth   Waterbury   Bristol   Prospect   Watertown   Cheshire   Seymour   Wolcott   Derby   Shelton   Woodbury   Middlebury  The NVCOG coordinates planning activities and provides technic al and support services to the region’s transportation policy and decision -making boards and member municipalities. While the consolidation of C OGCNV and VCOG combined planning in the region, the jurisdiction of the metropolitan planning organizations (MPOs) was not adjusted to correspond to the new regional planning area boundaries . The NVCOG conducts the federal transportation planning process in accordance with federal regulations, and as provided in M AP-21 and FAST Act for the Central Naugatuck Valley Region MPO ( CNV MPO). Four regional municipalities remain members of the Greater Bridgeport and Valley MPO – Ansonia, Derby, Se ymour and Shelton . Federal transportation planning funds attributable to these four communities ha ve been allocated to the Greater Bridgeport -Valley Metropolitan Planning Organization (GBVMPO) and the responsibility for conducting the transportation planning process for those communities remain s with the NVCOG, as the co -host of the GBVMPO. A separate UPWP has been prepared . The Unified Planning Work Program for the Naugatuck Valley COG is prepared in accordance with Title 23 CFR Part 420 and Part 4 50 Section 308. The metropolitan transportation planning activities documented in the UPWP will be performed using funds provided by the U.S. Department of Transportation (Federal Highway Administration and Federal Transit Administration), under Title 23 U .S.C. and Title 49 U.S.C. Chapter 53. The planning tasks for the CNV MPO are described in the UPWP . Funding to perform UPWP tasks is also provided by the Connecticut Department of Transportation (CTDOT) and member municipalities of t he NVC OG. Metropolitan Planning 10 | P a g e The Naugatuck Valley planning region is located in west -central Connecticut and lies primarily in New Haven County. Several of the region’s northern communities are located in Litchfield County . T he City of Bristol is in Hartford Cou nty and the City of Shelton lies in Fairfield County. The region’s center city is Waterbury, which is mid -way between Hartford to the east, New Haven to the south, Bridgeport to the southwest and Danbury to the west. The urbanized areas within the Naugatuc k Valley planning region are shown on the map on page 7. With the merger of the COGCNV with the VCOG, metropolitan planning, as required by the US Department of Transportation, is conducted by the Naugatuck Valley Council of Governments (NVCOG) for Central Naugatuck Valley Region Metropolitan Planning Organization ( CNV MPO). The CNV MPO is primarily responsible for providing policy direction on all aspects of the transportation planning process, as specified in federal transportation act s, including the MAP – 21 , FAST Act and federal tr ansportation policies and rules. R esponsibilities include : 1. Adopting a comprehensive and multi -modal long -range regional transportation plan (LRTP) for the CNV MPO metropolitan planning area. 2. Developing, main taining and, as necessary, amending a short -range transportation improvement program (TIP). 3. Ensuring its transportation plan, program and projects conform to air quality goals. The membership of the CNV MPO co nsists of the chief elected official of each municipality in the metropolitan planning area:  Beacon Falls   Prospect   Bethlehem   Southbury   Brist ol   Thomaston   Cheshire   Waterbury   Middlebury   Watertown   Naugatuck   Wolcott   Oxford   Woodbury   Plymouth  The CNV MPO policy board oversees the regional transportation planning and capital programs for the planning area , and prepares and maintains an LRTP and annual UPWP . The NVCOG is also the designated FTA grant recipient for the Valley Transit District (VTD). The NVCOG adopted a proactive public involvement program and policy that provides an opportunity for the public to review and comment on CNV MPO plans, program and projects. The policy was updated and revised during 2016 and endorsed on March 10, 2017. It encourage s participation in the metropolitan transportation planning process by residents and interested groups to ensure they have the opportunity to provide v aluable insight in planning 11 | P a g e decisions and programming activities . It includes notification of CNV MPO meetings and actions, opportunities to review, comment and influence the transportation planning process. Reports and documents prepared by the CNV MPO are made available to the public in an electronic form and summaries of the on -going planning activities are posted on the NVCOG website The CNV MPO is not designated as a Transportation Management Area; therefore, Federal Certification of its transportati on planning process is not required. However, the CNV MPO conducts its transportation planning process in conformity with applicable US Department of Transportation metropolitan planning requirements and self certifies that its planning process conforms to the Metropolitan Planning Rule, 23 CFR Part 450 Subpart C and 49 CFR Part 613 . It also participates in the federal certification process as several member municipalities are located in urbanized areas that are designated as a TMA. The existing MPOs in Co nnecticut are depicted on the map following the urbanized area map. 12 | P a g e Census Defined Urbanized Areas Naugatuck Valley Planning Region 13 | P a g e A number of transportation agreements and memoranda of understanding have been executed to guide the collaborative process. The GBV MPO replaced the Tri -State Regional Planning Commission in June of 1981. A Memorandum of Understanding for Transportation Planning in the Greater Bridgeport and Valley Planni ng Regions was adopted in 1981 that established membership in the GBVMPO . The MOU designated the Greater Bridgeport Regional Planning Agency and the Valley Regional Planning Agency as the co -hosts of the GBVMPO and responsible for the transportation planni ng process in their respective planning regions, including separate regional transportation plans, unified planning work programs and agreements. The MOU was reaffirmed in FY 1996 Metropolitan Planning Organizations in Connecticut 14 | P a g e and rewritten in 2006 to reflect new federal transportation planning guideli nes and requirements , as well as the conversion of the co -hosts from “regional planning agencies” to “councils of governments .” The operati ons of GBVMPO and individual roles and responsibilities of the two C OGs are described in the Memorandum of Understanding Regarding Transportation Planning Responsibility and Federal Transportation Funding in the GBVMPO . The GBVMPO also has an agreement in place regarding transportation planning and funding in the entire Bridgeport -Stamford urbanized area. The contents and articles of the new MOU: 1. Define the method for distributing transportation planning funds within the Bridgeport – Stamford urbanized area to the member RPOs through the Connecticut De partment of Transportation (CT DOT) from the Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) and Federal Transit Administration (FTA). 2. Define the method for distributing funds from the FHWA Surface Transportation Program (STP): Urban Area Account attributable to the Bridgeport -Stamford urbanized area and FTA Section 5307 Capi tal Grant Program funds earmarked to the Bridgeport – Stamford urbanized area. 3. Define the roles and responsibilities of member RPOs and transit operators in performing, conducting and coordinating the transportation planning process in the Bridgeport -Stamfor d urbanized area. 4. Define how the MPOs and transportation planning agencies in the Bridgeport -Stamford urbanized area will coordinate planning activities relating to the long range regional transportation plans, transportation improvement program and annual work programs. An agreement has been executed between the GBVMPO, the South Western Region MPO, the Housatonic Valley Council of Elected Officials, the New York Metropolitan Transportation Council and the North Jersey Transportation Planning Authority th at covers the coordination of transportation planning within the federally designated New York Metropolitan Transportation Management Area. As part of this MOU, the transportation planning organizations exchange planning documents and meet one -to -two times each year to discuss transportation projects and programs affecting the entire area. The MOU was adopted in 2008 and is currently being revised to reflect the merger of RPOs in Connecticut and addition of new partners . Transportation Systems Th e transportation system of the Naugatuck Valley r egion is diverse and offers its residents an integrated range of options. The region’s transportation system is oriented toward two limited access highways: Interstate 84, which runs in an east -west direction, and Route 8, extending in a north -south direction from Bridgeport to Winchester. Interstate 691 also passes through the region, connecting I -84 to Interstate 91 and Route 15 between Cheshire and Meriden. The region is also served by commuter rail operat ed by the Metro -North Railroad. Six stations are located along the Waterbury branch rail line (WBL) : Derby -Shelton, Ansonia , Seymour , Beacon Falls, Naugatuck and Waterbury . The WBL is single -track and currently defined as “dark 15 | P a g e territory” because of the ab sence of signalization. The state is designing a full signalization system and Positive Train Control, as well as constructing by -pass sidings. While s ervice is currently limited, there is potential for increased ridership in response to these infrastructu re improvements . Key transportation facilities in the region include:  Interstate 84 from the New York state line at Danbury to the Massachusetts state line – passes through Southbury, Middlebury, Waterbury, and Cheshire.  Interstate 691 an interstate conn ector between I -91 and I -84.  Route 8 Expressway – General Samuel Jaskilka Highway .  Several principal arterials:  US Route 6 – Bristol, Plymouth, Thomaston, Watertown, Woodbury and Southbury  Route 10 – Cheshire  Route 34 – Derby, Seymour and Oxford  Route 63 – Naugatuck, Middlebury and Watertown  Route 64 – Waterbury, Middlebury and Woodbury  Route 68 – Cheshire, Prospect and Naugatuck  Route 69 – Prospect, Waterbury, Wolcott and Bristol  Route 72 – Bristol and Plymouth  Route 73 – Waterbury and Watertown  Route 11 5 – Derby, Ansonia and Seymour  Route 229 – Bristol  SR 727 – Derby and Ansonia  SR 84 7 – Waterbury  An interconnected network of minor arterials.  Local fixed -route bus services provided by the Greater Bridgeport Transit and Connecticut Transit (New Haven, Bristol -New Britain and Waterbury divisions) .  Specialized paratransit services for the elderly and disabled – Valley Transit District and Greater Waterbury Transit District .  Commuter rail service along the Waterbury branch line – Metro North R ailroad.  Freight and goods movement – motor carriers, freight rail (Central Connecticut rail line, Housatonic rail line) , and multi -modal shipments.  Regional shared -use trail – Naugatuck River Greenway (Derby Greenway, Ansonia River Walk , Naugatuck Greenw ay, and Beacon Falls River Walk), Middlebury Greenway, Shelton Riverwalk , Steele Brook Greenway, and Farmington Canal Heritage Trail . The principal transportation systems in the Naugatuck Valley planning region are depicted in the following map. 16 | P a g e 17 | P a g e Tran sportation Planning Issues and Goals Through the transportation planning process , transportation concerns and issues facing the region have been identified (“Central Naugatuck Valley Long Range Transportation Plan: 2015 – 2040,” March 2015) . The region is geographically constrained in opportunities for highway expansion and capacity increase. The Route 8 c orridor, which serves as the major north -south commuter option, is severely over capacity and congested at peak travel times. Additionally, the Route 34 corridor, a major commuter corridor connect ing the lower region to New Haven , experiences substantial congestion and a high frequency of accidents. These two corridors are confined between residential developments making lane expansion unlikel y due to the number of affected properties. Interstate 84 defines the major east -west transportation corridor and connects the region to Hartford and I -90 in Massachusetts to the east and Danbury and the New York Metropolitan area to the west. Congestion recurs daily during peak commuting periods and operations are constrained by the current two -lane section in Waterbury and road geometry. A construction project is underway to widen the section through the east side of Waterbury and eliminate curves that contribute to safety concerns. There is also a need to replace the I -84 and Route 8 interchange , commonly known as the “mix -master.” This i nterchange is one worst freight bottlenecks, not only in New England but also the country. A planning study is underway to assess alternatives and determine the preferred action for rehabilitating or replacing the interchange. Commuter rail service can pr ovide a transportation alternative to travel on Route 8 or Route 34; however, infrastructure deficiencies constrain operations along the Waterbury branch rail line (WBL). Currently, the service is limited to one -way operations because of the lack of signal ization, passing sidings, and double tracking. To improve the infrastructure, a full signalization system is being designed and will be installed as part of Positive Train Control. By – pass sidings are under construction in two locations. The rail stations along the WBL offer an opportunity to function as transit oriented centers, with a mix of commercial and residential activities. However, these urban centers cannot realize their full potential until infrastructure improvements are implemented along the WB L. An expansion of service and the provision of frequent and convenient connections to the New Haven main rail line would act as a catalyst for major redevelopment and revitalization of the downtown area s of towns along the WBL . The constraints of the re gion’s physical and socio -economic resources influence its transporta – tion systems and performance. It is important to preserve and maintain essential infrastructure and services, while making the system operate as efficiently as possible. It is also equal ly critical to enhance the mobility of people and goods by increasing choice, access and convenience, as well as selectively and strategically expanding transportation capacity. Although the highway system dominates movement, non -highway components are equ ally important and provide alternative transportation services. A “balanced” transportation system is the primary goal of the transportation planning process. 18 | P a g e The transportation issues and goals for the Naugatuck Valley planning r egion are discussed in detailed in the long range transportation plan . The LRTP provide s the framework for the transportation planning process and for making transportation investment decisions. The objectives listed in the LRTP include : • Preserve, Maintain and Enhance Highway System – To develop and maintain an efficient transportation system that will provide the public with a high level of mobility, safety, and choice, while also addressing social, economic, and environmental needs and concerns ; and maintain t he principal expressway and highway system in a state -of- good repair through lane continuity, minor widening, rehabilitation and reconstruction, as necessary to improve safety and operating efficiency and to selectively and strategically expand the capacit y of key highways to reduce delay and congestion. • Congestion Management – To alleviate congestion through the implementation of intersection improvements (turn lanes), traffic signal modernization and coordination, and TDM actions (ridesharing, telecommuting and alternate work schedules). • Safety – To improve safety and efficie ncy of the highway network and for both motorized and non -motorized users of the transportation system, with appropriate transportation improvement projects. • Security – To improve and expand overall security of transportation infrastructure for persons u sing – while on -board or waiting – transportation modes and services. • Advanced Technology – To better manage transportation operations, enhance safety and mobility, ensure greater reliability in travel times and/or reduced travel delay, and provide more detailed and up -to -the -minute information to travelers and system opera – tors through the application of various ITS actions. • Preserve and Enhance Public Transportation Services – To maintain essential local bus, commuter rail and paratransit services by providing full funding for operations, replacing capital equipment on a life -cycle cost basis, and renovat ing and rehabilitat ing facilities and infrastructure to a state -of-good -rep air , and enhanc ing services by optimizing how resources are allocated and coordinating the delivery of paratransit service. • Multi -modal Opportunities – To expand and enhance opportunities for linking and connecting multiple modes and facilitating the mov ement between various transportation modes by constructing new multi -modal facilities and coordinating transit services. • Bicycle and Pedestrian Activities – To encourage and promote the increased use of bicycling and walking as a mode of transportation w hile enhancing safety by developing a network of shared -use trails and providing pedestrian walkways and features. 19 | P a g e • Environmental Mitigation – To implement actions to mitigate and alleviate natural and cultural environmental impacts of transportation proj ects. • Sustainability – To develop a long range plan consistent with the Regional Plan of Conservation and Development and state Plan of Conservation and Development that links local land use management, transportation improvements , sustainability and livability initiatives ; to provide “walkable communities,” especially in town centers and the urban core , connecting these areas with transit oriented developments and transit stations . • Economic Development – To improve transportation infrastructure critical to the eco nomic revitalization of the cities of Waterbury and Bristol and urban core areas of the Naugatuck Valley planning region and expand employment opportunities as well as access to jobs . Connecticut is divided into two non -attainment area s for the Ozone National Ambient Air Quality Standard and one non -attainment area for fine particulate matter (PM 2.5 ). The Ozone non -attainment areas are designated as “ Moderate ” with an attainment deadline of December 31, 2018 . Fairfield, New Haven and Middlesex counties are included as part of the New York – Northern New Jersey -Long Island non -attainment area. The remainder of the state is designated as the Greater Connecticut non -attainment area. The Connecticut portion of the larger New York -New Jersey -Connecticut PM 2.5 non -attainment area was re -designated as an “attainment/ maintenance” area in 2013. It encompasses Fairfield and New Haven Counties. The Naugatuck Valley planning region straddles the air quality non -attainment areas, with the municipalit ies in Fairfield and New Haven Counties in the NY -NJ -LI Ozone non -attainment area and the PM 2.5 non -attainment area, and the northern tier communities located in Hartford and Litchfield Counties included only in the Greater Connecticut Ozone non -attainment area. The UPWP includes tasks to monitor air quality emissions and ensure the MPOs’ plans, programs and projects conform to air quality goals. UPWP Program Objectives The principle objective of the CNV MPO’s UPWP is to c onduct comprehensive regional transportation planning process, consistent with federal regulations , and intended to develop and advance the implementation of plans , programs and projects to enhance, preserve and improve local transportation facilities and services, as well as address problems and deficiencies identified in the LRTP . FY 201 8 and 2019 program objectives are to: 20 | P a g e 1. Prepare an u pdate of the LRTP for the Naugatuck Valley planning region to achieve improved mobility, efficiency, and ef fectiveness of existing systems, provide congestion relief and cleaner air . 2. Ensure conformity of the NVCOG’s plans, program and projects with the State Implementation Plan (SIP) for Air Quality and national air quality goals and standards. 3. M onitor and analyze transportation systems performance and work with CT DOT in identifying transportation system perf ormance measures . 4. Promote safety, livable communities , sustainability , and transportation choice . 5. Collaborate with NYMTC, W est COG , MetroCOG , CRCOG and SCRCO G on Sustainable Communities Initiative and Mega -Regional planning. 6. Assess opportunities for effectuating Transit -Oriented Development in the town center s of the Central Naugatuck Valley planning region. 7. Implement , develop and use the NVCOG ’s Geographic Information System (GIS) to support the transportation planning process and assess transportation performance. 8. Develop transportation policies that address major issues and are consistent with regional land use, housing, and urban development plans including socioeconomic and environmental goals. 9. Coordinate energy conservation and air quality planning associated with CMAQ through the consideration of congestion relief strategies in all transportation improvement projects and plans. 10. Continue transit development planning, including developing a 10 -year capital plan , assess ing potential for inter -district services, and coordinatin g paratransit servic es for the elderly and disabled . 11. Update, revise, and maintain the Transportation Impro vement Program (TIP) and review and process amendments to the TIP . 12. Incorporate the updated and approved affirmative action plan pursuant to the Departments Contract Compliance Section guidelines. 13. Consult with appropriate land use management, environmen tal resource conservation, social service, historic, and freight stakeholder agencies through the transportation planning process. 21 | P a g e 14. Provide guidance for appropriate programming of both state and local transportation improvements . 15. Coordinate and collaborat e with CTDOT on project selection, scoping and development under various federal transportation programs. 16. Administer and operate the newly enacted Local Transportation Capital Improvement Program (LOTCIP). 17. Coordinate and administer the preliminary engine ering, design and encourage progress for Route 8 Corridor improvements in conjunctio n with CT DOT. 18. Carry out a proact ive public involvement process that promote s region wide citizen participation, minority involvement and equal employment opportunity , and provide s timely public notice , effective public involvement in the develop ment to the LRTP and TIP , maintenance and enhancement of the NVCOG’s website , and reports and documents in an electronic format . 19. Organize meetings of the CNV MPO . 20. Administer the Regional Transportation Program including preparation of the Unified Planning Work Program , grant applications and work programs in conjunction with federal, state and local agencies. 21. Coordinate Long -Range Transportation Plan development with the Regional Plan of Conservation and Development. 22. Convene a technical monitoring/status review committee (TTAC) to meet as necessary. Monitor progress and overall project schedule. 23. Incorporate revisions to the Strategic Highway Safety Plan into the long range transportation plan. 24. Conduct Freight Movement Planning through the compilation of data, outreach to stakeholders, and analysis of existing and future freight movement in the region , including coordination with the CTDOT on the statewide freight plan and N YMTC on the New York Metropolitan planning area freight plan . 22 | P a g e III. Central Naugatuck Valley Region MPO Regional Transportation Work Program FY 201 8 – 201 9 Unified Planning Work Program (UPWP) – Outline The UPWP has four main tasks:  Task 1 : Data Collection and Analysis: This task monitors transportation performance and uses performance measures to assess and analyze how effective transportation improvements have been in addressing issues and deficiencies. The use of the NVCOG’s Geographic Informat ion System (GIS) is a key element of transportation performance monitoring and provides support to the transportation planning process.  Task 2 : Transportation Planning: This task covers both short -range and long -range planning activities and includes thr ee sub -tasks: regional planning , transit planning and planning for non -motorized modes . Short -range planning involves conducting traffic operations, environmental mitigation, providing technical assistance to member communities and project scoping and deve lopment, including managing and operating the Local Transportat ion Capital Improvement Program (LOTCIP) . Non -motorized tran sportation studies focus on enhancing bicycle and pedestrian facilities , promoting complete streets, and ensuring safety of pedestrians and bicyclists. Long -range planning activities include undertaking corridor studies and focus on preparation of the Long Range Transportation Plan (LRTP), sustainable development planning efforts, developing a 10 -year tr ansit capital plan, and TOD and livable communities initiatives. Implementation -related efforts are included in each sub -task, as appropriate, and involve overseeing progress in advancing highway and transit capital improvement programs.  Task 3: Program Management and Administration : Under this task , the NVCOG perform s the management and administrative functions related to conducting the regional transportation planning process and includes development of work programs, preparation of grant applications and work programs and work related to the consultant selection process. Program management tasks will also involve administering work related to the possible re -designation of MP O boundaries, as may be necessary. Work under this task also supports efforts to provide a proactive public involvement process and ensure timely public notice, full public access, and early and continuing public involvement , including facilitation of publ ic outreach in the region for the CTDOT’s strategic transportation plan and update of the statewide long -range transportation plan. A major emphasis is complying with federal requirements regarding Title VI, Environmental Justice and Limited English Profic iency, identifying innovative ways to encourage greater public participation and creating electronic versions of plans and 23 | P a g e reports. The purpose of Public Participation in the Naugatuck Valley planning region is to provide fair and balanced planning.  Task 4: Other Technical Assistance and Program Implementation : Under this task the NVCOG supports and provides technical assistance relating to major corridor studies, project development and delivery, participation in special studies and proj ects under the sponsorship of CT DOT , FHWA and FTA , and services carried out on behalf of member towns. Project implementation activities consist of developing and maint aining the Transportation Improvement Program (TIP) , project development, regional review and prioritiz ation of projects and oversight and project management of active transportation improvement projects. Unified Planning Work Program (UPWP) – Budget The NVCOG conducts the regional transportation planning process for the Central Naugatuck Valley Region MPO. The following table indicates the federal, state and local funds available to the NVCOG from all sources to conduct the metropolitan transportation planning program . The funding sources are identified. Based on unofficial audit s, carryover funds have been allocated to FY 201 8 and 2019 . FY 201 8 an d FY 201 9 Unified Planning Work Program Naugatuck Valley Planning Region Program Funding Sources and Revenues Funding Program Regional Sponsor Federal FHWA Federal FTA State Local Total FY 201 8 PL + FTA 5303 Funds [1] NVC OG $474,429 $114 ,247 $55 ,924 $91 ,245 $7 35 ,845 FY 201 5 Carryover Funds [2] NV CO G $191 ,531 $0 $0 $47 ,883 $239 ,414 Total: $665 ,960 $114 ,247 $5 5,9 24 $139 ,128 $9 75 ,259 Funding Program Regional Sponsor Federal FHWA Federal FTA State Local Total FY 201 9 PL + FTA 5303 Funds [1] NVC OG $474,429 $114 ,247 $55,924 $91 ,245 $7 35 ,845 FY 201 5 Carryover Funds [2] NV CO G $191 ,531 $0 $0 $47 ,883 $239 ,414 24 | P a g e Total: $665 ,960 $114 ,247 $5 5,924 $139 ,128 $9 75 ,259 [1] Federal funding amount available from FHWA and FTA under the consolidated planning grant. Does not include possible future rescissions. State providing 7.6% match. [2] FY 2015 Carryover attributable to the NVCOG based on unofficial audit; allocated equally between FY 2018 and FY 2019 . State providing 0% match of carryover funds. FY 201 8 an d FY 2019 Unified Planning Work Program Naugatuck Valley Planning Region Other Project Funding Sources and Revenues Funding Program Regional Sponsor Federal FHWA Federal FTA State Local Total State Project No. 0036 -0184 [1] NVC OG $91 ,520 $0 $22 ,880 $0 $114 ,400 State Project No. 0124 -0165 [2] NV CO G $80 ,000 $0 $20 ,000 $0 $100 ,000 State Project No. 0126 -0174 [3] NV CO G $0 $0 $100,00 $0 $100 ,000 Route 8 Alt Modes Corridor Study [4 ] NVC OG $0 $80 ,000 $20 ,000 $0 $7 35 ,845 Total: $171 ,520 $80 ,000 $162 ,880 $0 $414 ,409 [1] Based on 3 rd Supplemental NVCOG -State Agreement . NVCOG allocation for administration and technical assistance estimated at $114,400. [2] NVCOG -State Agreement pending . NVCOG allocation for administration and technical assistance estimated at $100,000. [3] Based on NVCOG -State Agreement . NVCOG allocat ion for administration and technical assistance estimated at $100,000. 100% state funding. [4] Federal funding FTA Section 5339 and 5307 grants; state match provided under the TOD Pilot Program . 25 | P a g e TASK 1: D ATA COLLECTION / ANALYSIS Issues: System Preservation and Maintenance System Enhancement Performance Measures Congestion Management Preserve and Maintain Public Transportation Services Multimodal Opportunities Regional GIS Environmental Planning Safety – Vehicular and Pedestrian High Accident L ocations Capital Expenditures on Local Roads Objectives : To monitor, analyze and report transportation systems use, performance, congestion, change and safety and to enhance GIS capabilities ; explore the possibility of using mega -data to assess and determine system performance; and develop a regional travel demand model capability. Tasks: Performance monitoring and analysis tasks will continue to focus on highway and transit systems to i dentify transportation network deficiencies . The NVCOG conduct s traffic volume counts for member municipalities and extract s count data from CTDOT database. Crash data from the University of Connecticut’s Crash Data Repository is also extracted and used to maintain a regional safety profile and crash database. Pedest rian and bicycle counts along the Naugatuck River Greenway and other regional multi -use trails are also conducted. The NVCOG’s GIS program will be used to complement transportation planning by creating system and project -level maps . A travel demand model w ill be set -up and made operational to assess macro travel patterns as part of the development of the Long Range Transportation Plan (LRTP). Regional and economic data profiles of the Naugatuck Valley Planning Region will be updated. Specific tasks are: Task 1.1: Transportation Database  Maintain and update the regional traffic count database.  Extract traffic count data from CTDOT traffic locator program.  Maintain a bicycle and pedestrian count database – use passive Infrared trail counters and National Bicycle Pedestrian Document methodologies to extrapolate raw counts to annual measures .  Maintain transit ridership database – for both bus and rail systems ; obtain ridership and performance data from Nort h East Transportation on the operations in the Greater Waterbury area . 26 | P a g e  Survey ridership of the CT transit Waterbury system to Identify important destinations.  Link transportation data , traffic count locations and transit assets (bus shelters, bus stops) , to GIS and develop interactive maps.  Develop , maintain and periodically update bus system mapping and geodatabase with bus routes, stops and signage for CT Transit (Waterbury).  Maintain crash data inventory for the region . Task 1.2 : Performance Monitoring and Me trics  Coordinate with CTDOT in setting p erformance measures and targets and on MAP 21 and FAST Act transition to performance based planning and programming .  Explore the opportunity of acquiring “big data” from a third party vendor to deve lop transportation metrics.  Monitor highway performance including delay , speed and travel time using virtual techniques and outside vendors on the expressway network:  I-84  Route 8 Expressway  I-84/Route 8 Interchange – “Mixmaster”  Monitor operations and congestion along the region’s principle highway system, using the NVCO G’s Congestion Management System :  State Routes 10, 63, 68, 69, 70 and 188  US Highway 6  Monitor the operating characteristics of the region’s transit services. Including commuter rail, local bus and paratransit/dial -a-ride service s – expenditures, fares, revenues, deficits, ridership, frequency and bus route performance.  North East Transportation – CT Transit (Waterbury Division)  Monitor the operating characteristics of passenger and freight rail service, with emphasis on the interface between rail and other modes, including parking, transit, bicycle, pedestrian facilities, and truck freight  Waterbury Branch Line .  Monitor usage at the Region’s commuter parking lots and rail stations an d assess need for improvement.  Identify transportation systems connectivity gaps.  Work with CTDOT and neighboring MPOs to develop and implement a performance management approach to transportation planning and programming , and link investment priorities to achieve performance targets .  Evaluate the condition and performance of the transportation systems  Link transportation data – traffic count locations ; transit assets (bus shelters, bus stops) –to GIS and develop interactive maps.  Retrieve and extract accident data from C TDOT accident database. 27 | P a g e Task 1.3 : Travel Demand Modelling Program  Set -up and calibrate a regional travel demand model (TDM) to determine and assess regional travel patterns.  Determine the feasibility and cost of obtaining “Big” data from an outside vendor to provide input into the regional TDM.  Participate in training, as necessary . Task 1. 4: Regional GIS Program  Maintain the Regional GIS database and produce maps and conduct geographic analysis to support transportation plann ing projects and develop “intelligent maps” that provide information such as where people live and work, where growth and development occur, locations of utilities and public facilities, and much more.  Assist municipalities in acquiring basic planimetric data (edge of road, buildings, and infrastructure) using the shared state -wide aerial photography and LiDAR fly -over conducted in the spring 2016.  Develop a regional trails GIS data layer and share it online through an interactive map.  Maintain a spatiall y accurate employer database to use for transportation planning and economic development.  Develop and maintain a centralize d Geospatial Data Warehouse.  Attend and participate in the Statewide GIS Coordinating Committee meetings to stay up -to -date on GIS issues related to state, regional, and local governments, and participate in the statewide initiative to institute ongoing triennial aerial flights of the entire state.  Use GIS to assess traffic operations and transportation system performance .  Assess and project land uses in the region to identify major growth corridors and analyze related transportation improvements .  Create a geoportal (location on the web) where GIS dat a can be downloaded, making up -to -date GIS data readily available to facilitate transportation planning and making it easier for consultants to gain access to key datasets (e. g. parcels, zoning, land use, infrastructure) that help determine suitability of land for different development purposes.  Use GIS to locate low income and min ority population s to assess compliance with Environmental Justice and Title VI requirements Task 1. 5: Regional Demographic and Economic Profiles  Extract 2010 Census and American Community Survey (ACS) demographic data for various transportation planning activities, including analysis of Environmental Justice.  Continue to update GIS databases with the most up -to -date 2010 Census and ACS data , as the data become available . 28 | P a g e  Update the Profile of the Naugatuck Valley Plann ing Region , incorporating regional and local demographic, economic, and housing trends and characteristics.  Review municipal and traffic zone projections of population and employment for CTDOT’s statewide travel demand forecasting model, as needed.  Provide technical assistance to Census data users, as necessary. Deliverable s:  Transportation Database – Local bus, paratransit/dial -a-ride and commuter rail technical memoranda and performance monitoring reports  Traffic count and crash data technical memoranda, as necessary  Bi-annual commuter and rail station parking lot surveys and annual memorandum  Regional base map and infrastructure map  Regional trail and greenway maps  Congestion maps and data reports  NVCOG Regional Profile 2016  NVCOG Economic Profile 2015 Task 1: Data Collection and Analysis Budget FY 2018 FY 2019 Total Direct Labor $89,885 $89,885 $179,770 BFO @1.17 $105,165 $105,165 $210,330 Other Direct $0 $0 $0 Total $195,050 $195,050 $390,100 Staff Allocation: FY 2018 Direct Labor BFO Total Hours Exec. Director $0 $0 $0 0.0 Dir. Of Planning $0 $0 $0 0.0 Reg. Trans. Eng. $0 $0 $0 0.0 Sr. Planners [1] $31,460 $36,808 $68,268 1,048 .7 Planners [2] $35,954 $42,066 $78,020 1,198 .5 Planning Assistant $17,977 $21,033 $39,010 898.9 Administration [3] $4,494 $5,258 $9,752 99.9 Financial Man. [4] $0 $0 $0 0.0 Total $89,885 $105,165 $195,050 3,2 45.8 FY 2019 Direct Labor BFO Total Hours 29 | P a g e Exec. Director $0 $0 $0 0.0 Dir. Of Planning $0 $0 $0 0.0 Reg. Traffic Eng. $0 $0 $0 0.0 Sr. Planners [1] $31,460 $36,808 $68,268 1,048.7 Planners [2] $35,954 $42,066 $78,020 1,198 .5 Planning Intern $17,977 $21,033 $39,010 898.9 Administration [3] $4,494 $5,258 $9,752 99.9 Financial Man. [4] $0 $0 $0 0.0 Total $89,885 $105,165 $195,050 3,2 45.8 Financial Responsibility: FY 2018 NVCOG Federal $156,041 State $1 1,18 5 Local $27 ,826 Total $195,051 FY 2019 NVCOG Federal $156,041 State $1 1,18 5 Local $27,826 Total $195,051 Functional Responsibility: Naugatuck Valley Council of Governments [1] Includes Senior Transportation Planner, Supervising Transportation Planner and Senior Regional Planner [2] Includes Regional Planners, Transportation Planners I & II, and GIS Coordinator & Specialist [3] Includes Municipal Shared Services Director and Administrative Assistant [4] Includes Finance Director and Finance Manager 30 | P a g e TASK 2A: TRANSPORTATION PLANNING – REGIONAL Issues: System Preservation and Maintenance System Enhancement Performance Measures Congestion Management Advanced Technologies Environmental Mitigation and Planning Safety – Vehicular and Pedestrian Transportation Security – Emergency Management Freight Movement Regional Planning Objectives : To conduct t ransportation planning studies on transportation system deficiencies and needs, congestion management, traffic and operations, vehicular, and integrating transportation and freight planning. To maintain and update the LRTP for the Naugatuck Valley Region to achieve improved mobility, eff iciency, and effectiveness of existing systems, address transportation deficiencies, and provide congestion relief and cleaner air . To e nsure conformity of the CNV MP O’s plans, program s and projects with the State Implementation Plan (SIP) for Air Qualit y and national air quality goals and standards. To d evelop transportation policies that address major issues and are consistent with regional land use, housing, and urban development plans including socioeconomic and environmental goals. To p rovide gui dance for appropriate programming of both state and lo cal transportation improvements and c oor dinate and collaborate with CT DOT on project selection, scoping and development under various federal transportation programs. To a dminister and operate the Lo cal Transportation Capital Improvement Program (LOTCIP). To i ncorporate revisions to the Strategic Highway Safety Plan into the long range transportation plan. Tasks: Regional highway planning efforts will focus on assessing the highway network, identifying reasonable and effective improvements, providing technical assistance to member municipalities and considering operational and management strategies to improve performance of the exi sting transportation 31 | P a g e facilities. The NVCOG will continue to administer the LOTCIP program for the Naugatuck Valley planning region and work with the towns in advancing projects. Freight planning efforts will continue with continued support of the CTDOT’s e fforts to develop a statewide freight plan and coordination with NYMTC in the development of its freight plan. A major update of th e long range transportation plan (adopted in FY 201 5) will be completed and endorsed by May 2019 . Specific tasks are: Tas k 2A .1: Long Range Transportation Plan  Develop and endorse a new LRTP for the Naugatuck Valley Region :  Determine and assess regional travel patterns and travel characteristics  Identify deficiencies, congestions and constraints  Develop travel forecasts including development, land use , and demographics  Identify transportation improvement projects by mode including vehicle, bus, rail, pedestrian and bicycle  Develop cost estimates and financial plan  Consider planning factors  Incorporate revisions to the Str ategic Highway Safety Plan into the LRTP .  Coordinate with CDOT on state highway plan and i ncorporate projects of statewide significance and priority into the LRTP.  Prepare a financial assessment of proposed projects to ensure fiscal constraints.  Assess the LRTP for impacts to low income and minority areas to ensure compliance with Environmental Justice requirements.  Include congestion management strategies in the LRTP.  Promote transportation improvements and land uses consistent with the LRTP and coordinate the LRTP with local, regional, and state plans of conservation and development (POCDs) .  Develop a regional Plan of Conservation and Development for the Naugatuck Valley planning r egion consistent with the long range transportation plan and provide a framework and guide for regional sustainable land use patterns that are supported by and coordinated with the region’s transportation infrastructure, and a model for future local planning efforts . The Naugatuck Valley planning r egion ha s demonstr ated a commitment to planning that is supportive of transit oriented development, a range of housing and transportation opportunities, protection of the natural environment and environmental assets, access to jobs, education and services, equitable develop ment, a vibrant economy and public safety is essential. (Note: Consultant Services may be used to prepare the Regional POCD). 32 | P a g e Task 2A. 2: Traffic Operations and Technical Assistance  Convene the regional Transportation Technical Advisory Committee ( TTAC ) to guide the development of transportation improvements .  Provide technical assistance to member municipalities, as necessary on the local road network .  Assess traffic and highway operations on key corridors and i dentify capital improvement projects t o preserve and enhance highway system on the state arterial network:  State Routes 10, 63, 68, 69, 70 and 188  US Highway 6  Route 69 between Bristol and Waterbury Task 2A. 3: Regional Safety Prog ra m  Analyze crash data and determine regional safety trends  Create metrics to i dentify and assess high hazard accident locations by tabulat ing crash data and contributing factors. Establish base line performance and update regularly to evaluate safety improvements.  Identify, evaluate, and seek funding to imp rove hazardous locations (hot spots) on local roads under the Local Road Accident Reduction Program.  Develop a regional safety improvement program and identify low cost, effective measures to reduce crash frequency and severity. Task 2A. 4: Cong estion M an agement Program  Develop operational and management strategies to alleviate congestion and make the transportation systems operate more efficiently .  Assess and evaluate identified congested corridors  Collect delay and travel time data  Use computer modeling to simulate travel patterns and sc reen congested corridors .  Use and access NPMRDS data to develop performance measures and trends.  Develop performance measures to establish base line performance and update regularly to evaluate progress.  Coordinate CMP and collaborate with the CT Metro Council of Governments (Metro COG ), Capitol Region Council of Governments (CRCOG) and Western Council of Governments (W est COG) . Task 2A. 5: Transportation Security and Emergency Management  Conduct e vacuation planning and route assessment . 33 | P a g e  Increase the security of transportation system by participating on the Region 2 Emergency Planning Team and collaborating with local municipal and private emergency service providers and CT DEHMS in emergency operations plan ning and emergency support functions (ESF), related to ESF -1 (Transportation).  Assess and p romote the security at various regional transportation centers including but not limited to the Waterbury rail station . Task 2A. 6: Environmental Mitigation  Determine air quality conformity of the CNV MP O’s transportation plans, programs and pro jects and continue coordinat ion with C TDOT and Department of Energy and Environmental Protection.  Conduct environmental assessments of transportation improvements  Storm water management; run -off .  Coordinate major planning studies and consider environmental impacts of transportation projects as part of NEPA and CEPA processes.  Prepare the A ir Quality Conformity S tatement for CNV MPO transportation projects, plans an d programs.  Assist municipalities with local emergency planning, including the identification of critical facilities and transportation systems in local pre -disaster mitigation plans and maps. Update local pre -disaster mitigation plans, if needed. Task 2A .7: LOTCIP  Administer the state -funded LOTCIP program for the NVCOG planning region .  Solicit project proposals from member communities for the NVCOG area .  Assist municipalities in pre -screening project proposals .  Review applications for eligibility and completeness .  Prioritize projects and forward applications to C TDOT .  Assist municipalities in conducting the p ublic review process and participate in LOTCIP meetings, as needed .  Project scope development and review (LOTCIP funded) .  Coordinate and particip ate in third party review of design plans (LOTCIP funded).  Process final design plans and submittals to CTDOT for project obligation (LOTCIP funded). Task 2A.8 : Freight Planning  Develop a regional freight profile  Collect and inventory freight and goods movement data in the Naugatuck Valley region;  Identify commodity flows, modes, type of freight moved ;  Locat e warehouses and intermodal facilities . 34 | P a g e  Identify areas with deficient freight infrastructure and areas of freight demand.  Identify infrastructure constraints  Low clearance and weight restricted bridges .  Develop performance measures using available data sources to establish base line performance and update regularly to evaluate progress  Coordinate and work with CTDOT on the statewide freight plan  Identify critical freight routes .  Determine freight issues and needs . Deliverable s:  FFY 2019 -2044 Long Ran ge Regional Transportation Plan  Regional Plan of Conservation and Development  Congestion Management Process Report  Regional Highway Safety Plan  Air Quality Conformity Statements for Ozone for the NY -NJ -LI Non -attainment area  Air Quality Conformity Statements for Ozone for the Greater Connecticut Non – attainment area  Air Quality Con formity Statements for PM2.5 for the NY -NJ -CT Non -attainment area  LOTCIP project applications  LOTCIP program quarterly reports  Regional Freight Inventory and Profile Task 2A: Transportation Planning — Regional Budget FY 2018 FY 2019 Total Direct Labor $89,885 $89,885 $179,770 BFO @1.17 $105,165 $105,165 $210,330 Other Direct $0 $0 $0 Total $195,050 $195,050 $390,100 Staff Allocation: FY 2018 Direct Labor BFO Total Hours Exec. Director $3,595 $4,207 $7,802 51.4 Dir. of Planning $17,977 $21,033 $39,010 299.6 Reg. Trans. Eng. $10,786 $12,620 $23,406 215.7 Sr. Planners [1] $22,471 $26,291 $48,762 749. 1 Planners [2] $31,460 $36,808 $68,268 1,048 .7 Planning Assistant $0 $0 $0 0.0 Administration [3] $3,595 $4,207 $7,802 79.9 35 | P a g e Financial Man. [4] $0 $0 $0 0.0 Total $89,885 $105,166 $195,050 2,444 .3 FY 2019 Direct Labor BFO Total Hours Exec. Director $3,595 $4,207 $7,802 51.4 Dir. of Planning $17,977 $21,033 $39,010 299.6 Reg. Trans. Eng. $10,786 $12,620 $23,406 215.7 Sr. Planners [1] $22,471 $26,291 $48,762 74 9.1 Planners [2] $31,460 $36,808 $68,268 1,048 .7 Planning Intern $0 $0 $0 0.0 Administration [3] $3,595 $4,207 $7,802 79.9 Financial Man. [4] $0 $0 $0 0.0 Total $89,885 $105,166 $195,050 2,444 .3 Financial Responsibility: FY 2018 NVCOG Federal $156,041 State $1 1,18 5 Local $27 ,826 Total $195,051 FY 2019 NVCOG Federal $156,041 State $11 ,18 5 Local $27 ,826 Total $195,051 Functional Responsibility: Naugatuck Valley Council of Governments [1] Includes Senior Transportation Planner, Supervising Transportation Planner and Senior Regional Planner [2] Includes Regional Planners, Transportation Planners I & II, and GIS Coordinator & Specialist [3] Includes Municipal Shared Services Director and Administrative Assistant [4] Includes Finance Director and Finance Manager 36 | P a g e TASK 2B: TRANSPORTATION PLANNING – TRANSIT Issues: System Preservation and Maintenance System Enhancement Performance Measures Congestion Management Advanced Technologies Environmental Mitigation and Planning Safety – Vehicular and Pedestrian Transportation Security – Emergency Management Freight Movement Regional Planning Objectives : To promote a balanced transportation system by working with public transit operators i n evaluating regional and local transit system deficiencies, capital and operating needs, multi -modal opportunities , and the coordina tion of inter – district and intra -district bus services . To provide technical and planning assistance in conduct ing transit planning studies, assess ing and determ ining transit capital priorities to update the 10 -year capital plan, and identifying facility capital needs. To maintain a coordination plan for human service transportation (LOCHSTP ). To assess long term bus, commuter rail and multi -modal facility need s, including actions and strategies to incentivize and promote transit -oriented districts and corridors, assess opportunities for alternate trans it services and modes , improve bus stops, signage and shelters, and enhance transit security and safety. To incorporate proposed transit capital, service and operations plans into the long range transportation plan (LRTP) . Tasks: Transit planning tasks focus on local bus, commuter rail, and paratransit services in the Naugatuck Valley Region. The NVCOG will complete work on the Waterbury Area Transit Study and promote implementation of low cost short term adjustments of the bus route network. Transit planning tasks also provide coordinated assessment of human service transportation services and assistance in planning near term and future local bus services and facilities. Included in this activity will be oversight of services provided by the Greater Waterbury Transit District. The NVCOG also works with area transit providers on short and long term capital needs. In its capacity as the designated recipient of FTA funds, the NVCOG will provide planning assistance to the Valley Transit District, including development and update of the 10 -year capital plan and assessment of trans it capital and operational needs. Planning efforts focus on alternative 37 | P a g e transportation modes to promote transit oriented and supportive districts. Rail station capital and parking needs are identified and evaluated, as well as improving access via local bu s services. Transit planning tasks also focus on improved coordination o f inter -regional bus operations . Specific tasks are: Task 2B .1: 10 -Year Plan  Work with North East Transportation and the CT Transit -Waterbury Division to develop and updat e the 10 -year capital improvement program : fleet replacement, facility improvements and rehabilitation, and bus shelter program .  Incorporate capital improvement plan into the LRTP .  Coordinate with the CT DOT on amending the TIP/STIP to incorporate bus capital pri orities as reflected in the 10 -year capital plan . Task 2B .2: Local Bus System Planning  Evaluate local, fixed -route system needs for the Greater Waterbury area, determine service gaps and opportunities, and identify operational improvements – bus stop s, shelter s and sign amenities, internet trip planning, and vehicle location systems.  Review projects funded under the FTA Sections 5307 capital programs, including transit enhancements and include in the TIP .  Conduct bus system TOD buildout study.  Develop p riority shelter replacement recommendations based on current and previous analysis. Task 2B .3: Local Human Service Transportation Coordinating Planning  Provide technical assistance to regional municipalities and the Greater Waterbury Transit District in coordinating priorities and projects for special transportation services funded under the State M unicipal Grant program (C.G.S. 13b -38bb) for senior and disabled demand responsive transportation .  Develop regional priorities for the FTA Section 5310 pro gram to fund vehicle purchases for private non -profit and public organizations and other transportation services for people with disabilities, and c oordinate grant applications and c ontinue to work closely with CTDOT, paratransit operators and municipal human service transportation providers on formula funding for elderly persons and persons with disabilities .  Work with local agencies and stakeholders, neighboring RPOs, and CTDOT in developing and updating the Locally Coordinated Human Services Transporta tion Plan (LOCHSTP) , identifying gaps and setting project priorities .  Participate on advisory committees and planning meetings relating to the job s access program and the Regional Mobility Manager program. 38 | P a g e Task 2B .4: Commuter Rail  Inventory and evaluate Waterbury Branch Line stations and infrastructure including passenger amenities, information kiosks, platforms, shelters, parking , and canopies .  Identify rail parking needs utiliz ing parking counts, parking supply , and the condition at commuter rail stations along the Waterbury Branch Line .  Work with CTDOT in advancing proposed Waterbury Branch Line improvements and enhancements , specifically the planned positive train control, signal system design and passing sidings.  Work with CTDOT in programming long term improvements to and rehabilitation of the Waterbury Branch Line.  Evaluate proposed recommendations from the Central Connecticut Rail Study and assess opportunities to extend passenger rail services between Waterbury and Berlin wi th commuter rail stops at Plymouth, Bristol, Plainville and New Britain.  Monitor and review Tier 1 Final EIS documents and recommendations for the NEC Future planning program and provide comments, as needed. Task 2B .5: Alternative Transportation Mode s Assessment  Investigate alternative modes to harness public transit and create livable communities .  Promote safety, livable communities, and environmental sustainability in planning activities.  Determine the strategies and actions to enhance and facilit ate north -south travel along the Route 8 corridor and the Waterbury Branch Line and link commuter rail stations and associated transit oriented and supportive districts in the region.  Encourage and assist municipalities with adopting trans it-supportive lan d use policies and developing plans and strategies to create transit -oriented districts in the vicinity of the commuter rail stations.  Encourage greater integration and connectivity between rail and bus.  Coordinate and supplement work on the Route 8 and Waterbury Branch Line alternative modes assessment study funded under FTA Section s 5339 and 5307 and the State TOD pilot project . Task 2B .6: Waterbury Area Transit Study (WATS)  Oversee consultant work for the ongoing Waterbury Area Transit Study funded under FTA Section 5307 .  Complete the WATS study, hold public outreach meetings and publish final report .  Initiate and conduct a Phase 2 WATS study to i dentify and assess possible locations for a new bus terminal and investigate the economic developm ent impacts of relocating the pulse point in downtown Waterbury . This task may involve the use consultant services to assist and perform the economic impact assessment . 39 | P a g e Task 2B .7 Naugatuck Valley Transit Governance Study The Greater Waterbury Transit District oversees and administers the paratransit services in the eight -town area operated by North East Transportation, under contract with the CTDOT. The GWTD has approached the NVCOG with a n inquiry about t he possible disso lution of the current Board and the ramifications of such an action . This planning study will evaluate the current governance of the GWTD, assess alternative governance structures, including the feasibility of merging GWTD with VTD and creating a single tr ansit district for the Naugatuck Valley planning region. This task may involve the use consultant serv ices to assist and perform the merging and consolidation assessment .  Evaluate the current governance structure of the Greater Waterbury Transit District and conduct a SWOT analysis.  Review state statutes relating to the formation, operation and dissolution of transit districts.  Convene stakeholder / advisory committee to evaluate issues and the need for alternative methods to deliver paratransit services.  Identify the gaps in human service transportation in the Naugatuck Valley planning region .  Conduct a study to determine the feasibility of consolidating and merging the Greater Waterbury Transit District and the Valley Transit District.  Develop a governan ce plan for paratransit services in the Naugatuck Valley planning region cov er ing the financial plan, district management, administration and oversight, and governing board make -up.  Develop an implementation plan for integrating operating services, informa tion and customer service.  Review current services and operating statistics , including demographics, description of services, governance, inventory of rolling stock, vehicles and physical infrastructure, operating statistics, and financial data .  Coordinati on with CTDOT.  If needed, select consultant to conduct governance study and oversee and administer contract and scope of work. Deliverable s:  10 -Year local bus capital improvement plan – CT Transit -Waterbury Division  FTA Section 5307 regional priorit y list – CT Transit -Waterbury Division  Waterbury Area Transit Study (final report)  FTA Section 5310 regional priority list – NVCOG Region  Municipal Grant Program applications – NVCOG Region  Waterbury Branch Rail Line improvement program  Alternative Transpo rtation Modes Plan 40 | P a g e  TOD Plans – station area plans  WATS Bus Operations Plan for Downtown Waterbury and Downtown New Bus Terminal  Naugatuck Valley Transit Governance Plan Task 2B: Transportation Planning — Transit Budget FY 2018 FY 2019 Total Direct Labor $67,414 $67,414 $134,828 BFO @1.17 $78,874 $78,874 $157,748 Other Direct $0 $0 $0 Total $146,288 $146,288 $292,576 Staff Allocation: FY 2018 Direct Labor BFO Total Hours Exec. Director $2,697 $3,155 $5,852 38.5 Dir. of Planning $14,831 $17,352 $32,183 247.2 Reg. Trans. Eng. $0 $0 $0 0.0 Sr. Planners [1] $23,595 $27,606 $51,201 786 .5 Planners [2] $23,595 $27,606 $51,201 786.5 Planning Assistant $0 $0 $0 0.0 Administration [3] $2,697 $3,155 $5,852 59.9 Financial Man. [4] $0 $0 $0 0.0 Total $67,414 $78,874 $146,289 1,918.6 FY 2019 Direct Labor BFO Total Hours Exec. Director $2,697 $3,155 $5,852 38.5 Dir. of Planning $14,831 $17,352 $32,183 247.2 Reg. Trans. Eng. $0 $0 $0 0.0 Sr. Planners [1] $23,595 $27,606 $51,201 786 .5 Planners [2] $23,595 $27,606 $51,201 786.5 Planning Intern $0 $0 $0 0.0 Administration [3] $2,697 $3,155 $5,852 59.9 Financial Man. [4] $0 $0 $0 0.0 Total $67,414 $78,874 $146,289 1,918.6 Financial Responsibility: FY 2018 NVCOG Federal $117,031 State $8,38 9 41 | P a g e Local $20 ,869 Total $146,289 FY 201 9 NVCOG Federal $117,031 State $8 ,38 9 Local $20 ,869 Total $146,289 Functional Responsibility: Naugatuck Valley Council of Governments [1] Includes Senior Transportation Planner, Supervising Transportation Planner and Senior Regional Planner [2] Includes Regional Planners, Transportation Planners I & II, and GIS Coordinator & Specialist [3] Includes Municipal Shared Services Director and Administrative Assistant [4] Includes Finance Director and Finance Manager 42 | P a g e TASK 2C: TRANSPORTATION PLANNING – N ON -M OTORIZED TRANSPORTATION M ODES Issues: System Preservation and Maintenance System Enhancement Bicycle Planning Activities Pedestrian Planning Activities Safety – Bicycle and Pedestrian Regional Trail Network Multi -modal Oppor tunities Alternative Transportation Modes TOD Opportunities Regional Planning Objectives : To promote a balanced transportation system to create safe, livable communities and environmental sustainability through enhanced access to transportation alternatives and efficient, effective and convenient non – motorized modes of transpo rtation and active transportation facilities . A focus will be placed on the identification of deficiencies in pedestrian and bicycle system connectivity in an effort to establish a contiguous network. The key objectives of this planning task are to:  Decrease per -capita VMT and transportation -related emissions for the corrid or;  Increase the miles of constructed multi -use trails;  Promote the economic benefits of constructing the Naugatuck River Greenway; and • Promote public health and safety through enhancements to the bicycle and pedestrian facilities and networks. Tasks: Under this task, the NVCOG will coordinate multiple and inter -related planning tasks to create an interconnected network of multi -use trails, ensure pedestrian safety and promote livable and sustainable commu nities, including continued involvement in the design and construction of the Naugatuck River Greenway . The NVCOG will promote the findings of the NRG economic impact study and implementation of uniform signage design. The NVCOG will use its participation on Sustainable CT Working Groups to info rm the update of the long range transportation plan. Specific tasks are: 43 | P a g e Task 2C .1: Route 8 Corridor TOD & Alternate Modes Project The NVCOG initiated a planning study to assess and identify opportunities for implementing alternative transportation modes within the Route 8 and Waterbury branch line corridors . The project is being funded under two FTA grants ( Section 5339 and 5307) with match funds provided under the state TOD Pilot Program . The project was initiated in FY 2017.  Administer and oversee Consultant services related to conducting the study.  Assist in the alternative transportation modes assessment and in the d evelop ment of alternative services and modes plans .  Collect data and generate maps, as needed, to supplement work. Task 2 C.2: Regional Multi -use Trail Plan ning  Work on enhancing regional trail and greenway systems including the Naugatuck River Greenway , Middlebury Greenway, the Steele Brook Greenway and Farmington Heritage Canal Trail .  Participate in the Waterbury Naugatuck River Greenway Design Project (Phase 1) and assist Waterbury in advancing the project through the city .  Provide technical assistance to member communities on respective greenw ay and multi – use tra il projects.  Provide administrative support to the Naugatuck River Greenway steering committee , including acting as staff to the NRGSC, prepar ing meeting agendas, post ing meeting minutes, and providing website content .  Oversee the Connecticut Trail Census project for the CT Greenways Council , including administer ing project s, conduct ing trail counts, prepar ing survey tool , and tabulat ing and analyzing data. Task 2 C.3: Naugatuck River Greenway Economic Impact Study The economic impact study for the Naugatuck River Greenway was completed and published in FY 2017. The NVCOG will:  Develop community/municipal level summary sheets.  Participate in a community outreach and education process and present study findings to municipal boards and commiss ions.  Promote the economic benefits from NRG construction.  Prepare an economic development guide for municipalities on how to best capitalize on the construction of the regional trail and greenway systems . Task 2 C.4: Regional Bicycle Plan  Develop and update the regional bicycle plan . 44 | P a g e  Assess and address bicycle and vehicular needs, and determine opportunities for expanding bicycle facilities in a regional bicycle plan.  Work with and provide technical assistance to the municipalities in the NVCOG plannin g region on implementing a bicycle route network , including assessment and evaluation of proposed routes, project scoping, and project design approach, and ensur ing consistency with guidelines and standards .  Conduct a s tudy on a possible e ast -west bike rou te from Forestville to Thomaston . Task 2 C.5: Regional Pedestrian Safety Plan The NVCOG developed a draft pedestrian plan in FY 2017 that looked at current conditions and opportunities for enhancing pedestrian study. The NVCOG will:  Finalize the regional pedestrian safety plan .  Assess and address pedestrian needs, and determine opportunities for expanding pedestrian facilities and providing pedestrian amenities .  Reach out to member municipalities and present findings from the safety plan and promote measu res to improve safety.  Extract and analyze pedestrian -related crash data and publish findings and performance in an annual update .  Continue developing a Safe Routes to Scho ol program, as necessary , and assist member communities in developing SRTS plans. Task 2 C.6: Livability and Sustainability Program  Develop a complete streets and green infrastructure policy and plan for the N augatuck Valley planning region .  Identify green infrastructure elements that can be incorporated in transportation improvement pr ojects .  Assess potential impacts to the region’s t ransportation systems due to c limate change and natural hazards, and develop strategies to minimize and mitigate impacts and make the systems more resilient .  Develop web page on the NVCOG website that focus es on climate change and livability to promote safety, livable communities and environmental sustainability .  Participate on Sustainable CT working groups.  Incorporate livability and sustainability principles into the LRTP. Deliverable s:  Route 8 and Waterbury Branch Line Corridor TOD and Alternative Modes Assessment reports  Regional Bicycle Plan 45 | P a g e  Regional Pedestrian Safety Plan (final)  CT Trails Census reports  Trail User Surveys  Economic Impact Study of the Naugatuck River Greenway – Municipal Summary Sheets  Regional Complete Streets Policy and Plan  Climate Change Resiliency assessment Task 2C: Transportation Planning — Non -Motorized Transportation Modes Budget FY 2018 FY 2019 Total Direct Labor $44,943 $44,943 $89,886 BFO @1.17 $52,583 $52,583 $105,166 Other Direct $0 $0 $0 Total $97,526 $97,526 $195,052 Staff Allocation: FY 201 8 Direct Labor BFO Total Hours Exec. Director $1,798 $2,103 $3,901 25.7 Dir. of Planning $8,989 $10,517 $19,505 149.8 Reg. Trans. Eng. $0 $0 $0 0.0 Sr. Planners [1] $18,876 $22,085 $40,961 62 9.2 Planners [2] $13,483 $15,775 $29,258 449.4 Planning Assistant $0 $0 $0 0.0 Administration [3] $1,798 $2,103 $3,901 39.9 Financial Man. [4] $0 $0 $0 0.0 Total $44,943 $52,583 $97,526 1,294 .1 FY 2019 Direct Labor BFO Total Hours Exec. Director $1,798 $2,103 $3,901 25.7 Dir. of Planning $8,989 $10,517 $19,505 149.8 Reg. Trans. Eng. $0 $0 $0 0.0 Sr. Planners [1] $18,876 $22,085 $40,961 62 9.2 Planners [2] $13,483 $15,775 $29,258 449.4 Planning Intern $0 $0 $0 0.0 Administration [3] $1,798 $2,103 $3,901 39.9 Financial Man. [4] $0 $0 $0 0.0 Total $44,943 $52,583 $97,526 1,294 .1 46 | P a g e Financial Responsibility: FY 2018 NVCOG Federal $78,021 State $5 ,592 Local $13 ,91 3 Total $97,527 FY 2019 NVCOG Federal $78,021 State $5,592 Local $13 ,91 3 Total $97,527 Functional Responsibility: Naugatuck Valley Council of Governments [1] Includes Senior Transportation Planner, Supervising Transportation Planner and Senior Regional Planner [2] Includes Regional Planners, Transportation Planners I & II, and GIS Coordinator & Specialist [3] Includes Municipal Shared Services Director and Administrative Assistant [4] Includes Finance Director and Finance Manager 47 | P a g e TASK 3: PROGRAM M ANAGEMENT AND ADMINISTRATION Issues: Highway System Enhancement Highway System Preservation Safety – Vehicular and Pedestrian Congestion Management Process Advanced Technologies (ITS) Preserve and Maintain Public Transportation Services Multimodal Opportunities Bicycle and Pedestrian Activities Transportation Security Flexibility in Highway Design Freight Movement Environmental Planning and Mitigation Public Involvement Environmental Justice Economic Development Regional Planning Objectives : To conduct administration and program management functions necessary to carry -out the planning tasks included in the UPWP, including amending the UPWP, as needed, and preparing and submitting quarterly progress and financial reports . To c oordinate transportation and transit planning activities and tasks. To develop, select, scope and evaluate projects for funding under the FHWA’s Surface Transportation Block Grant Program: Urban (ST BG Waterbury Urban Area ), Transportation A lternatives Program Set -aside funds (TAP), and Congestion Mitigation and Air Quality . To ad vise and inform participating agencies of program substance and expenditures. To participate in and provide administrative support to study advisory committees, as necessary. To assist member municipalities and regional transit operators with the preparation of applications for state and federal funds. Tasks: Administer the transportation planning program in the Central Naugatuck Valley planning region , as detailed in the FY 2018 and 2019 Unified Planning Work Program and manage the transportation planning program . The NVCOG will 48 | P a g e conduct a proactive public involvement process in accordance with its adopted public participation policy. Specific tasks are: Task 3.1: UPWP  Amend the FY 201 8-2019 UPWP, as needed .  Prepare and submit quarterly progress and financial reports.  Prepare the FY 20 20 -20 21 UPWP . Task 3.2 : CT DOT Coordination  Coordinate on developing and implementing Performance Measures .  Coordinate on travel demand modeling .  Coordinate with revisions to land use forecasts .  Participate in the l ocal road accident reduction program .  Revise , as necessary, the functional classification system to reflect changes in the urbanized area .  Co ordinate work on regional transportation, transit and engineering programs, projects and stu dies to maximize efficiency.  Coordinate and work with CTDOT and adjacent MPO’s on the future re -designation of MPO boundaries Task 3 .3: Administration  Administer the regional transportation planning program s, as detailed in the FY 201 8 and 201 9 Unified Planning Work Program.  Prepare the annual audit of the UPWP . Task 3 .4: Grant Application s  Prepare grant applications and work programs for special studies, as needed.  Assist member communities and regional transit operators in preparing project applications under various federal transportation funding programs, as needed.  Assist member communities in preparing project applications under LOTCIP program. Task 3. 5: Highway Project Development  Identify new project proposals for funding under various federal aid programs and work with the municipalities and CTDOT in determining project eligibility, developing project scopes, preparing applications and evaluating proposals.  Monitor the ST BG urban program. 49 | P a g e  Participate in CT DOT Project Concept Development process and coordinate with the CTDOT Office of Highway Design on state and local road improvement projects .  Review and comment on the CTDOT five -year capital.  Work with CT DOT and member municipalities on identifying possible pr ojects for funding under the STBG Transportation Alternatives Set -aside Program and Conges tion Mitigation and Air Quality and monitor project development and implementation .  Work with the municipalities and provide technical assistan ce in determining project eligibility, developing project scopes, preparing applications and evaluating proposals relating to these programs.  Establish and refine regional highway priorities. Task 3 .6: Transit Programming  Work with CT Transit to program bus capital projects in the TIP and incorporate local bus transit needs into the TIP/STIP under the FTA Section 5307, 5309, and 5310 programs.  Work with CT Transit in determining project scopes, preparing applications and evaluating proposals.  Establish and refine regional transit capital priorities to be funded by FTA Section 5307, 5309, 5310, 5316 and 5317 , and help municipalities establish and fund operational priorities for the elderly and disabled under the Municipal Grant Program. Task 3 .7: Policy  Monitor and review federal Notices of Proposed Rulemaking (NPRM) related to the transportation planning process and offer comments and recommendations, as appropriate , including but not limited to MPO coordination , performance measures , transit planning , and transportation performance management rules.  Establish and refine regional trans portation po licies. Task 3. 8: Public Participation Program The NVCOG updated its Public Outreach Policy and Environmental Justice Policy in FY 2017. Both policies provide structure to federal and state requirements to involve and inform the public at all stages in the planning process and were made available in English and in Spanish . The NVCOG will:  Adhere to the Public Outreach and Environmental Justice polices and ensure a proactive engagement with the public.  Participate in meetings of the CNV MPO .  Make presentations at CNV MPO and NVCOG meetings on transpor tation plans, programs and projects. 50 | P a g e  Convene and hold meetings of the Transportation Technical Advisory Committee (TTAC) to provide face -to -face opportunities to discuss and exchange ideas regarding transportation issues, deficiencies and solutions.  Period ically assess effectiveness of the public involvement process.  Provide reports, documents, plans and summaries in user -friendly format and post on NVCOG website.  Hold public information meetings on plans, program and projects at convenient and accessible p laces and times, including utilizing a “go to them” strategy, provide community outreach to inform and involve community groups, and offer assistance to the hearing impaired and persons with limited English proficiency.  Maintain the NVCOG website and post transportation documents, summaries, actions, plans and programs . Deliverable s:  Quarterly progress reports  FY 2018 -2019 UPWP  Grant applications  Highway Project programming  Transit programming  Transportation Policies  Public Outreach Policy  Environmental Justice Pol icy  Public information sessions  NVCOG website Task 3: Program Management, Implementation and Administration Budget FY 2018 FY 2019 Total Direct Labor $33,422 $33,422 $66,844 BFO @1.17 $39,104 $39,104 $78,208 Other Direct $25,000 $25,000 $50,000 Total $97,526 $97,526 $195,052 Staff Allocation: FY 2018 Direct Labor BFO Total Hours Exec. Director $5,013 $5,866 $10,879 71.6 Dir. of Planning $11,698 $13,686 $25,384 195.0 Reg. Trans. Eng. $1,671 $1,955 $3,626 33.4 Sr. Planners [1] $1,671 $1,955 $3,626 55.7 Planners [2] $3,342 $3,910 $7,252 111.4 51 | P a g e Planning Assistant $0 $0 $0 0.0 Administration [3] $5,013 $5,866 $10,879 111.4 Financial Man. [4] $5,013 $5,866 $10,879 111.4 Total $33,422 $39,104 $72,525 689.9 FY 2019 Direct Labor BFO Total Hours Exec. Director $5,013 $5,866 $10,879 71.6 Dir. of Planning $11,698 $13,686 $25,384 195.0 Reg. Trans. Eng. $1,671 $1,955 $3,626 33.4 Sr. Planners [1] $1,671 $1,955 $3,626 55.7 Planners [2] $3,342 $3,910 $7,252 111.4 Planning Intern $0 $0 $0 0.0 Administration [3] $5,013 $5,866 $10,879 111.4 Financial Man. [4] $5,013 $5,866 $10,879 111.4 Total $33,422 $39,104 $72,525 689.9 Financial Responsibility: FY 2018 NVCOG Federal $78 ,021 State $5 ,592 Local $13,913 Total $97,526 FY 2019 NVCOG Federal $78 ,021 State $5 ,592 Local $13,913 Total $97,526 Functional Responsibility: Naugatuck Valley Council of Governments [1] Includes Senior Transportation Planner, Supervising Transportation Planner and Senior Regional Planner [2] Includes Regional Planners, Transportation Planners I & II, and GIS Coordinator & Specialist [3] Includes Municipal Shared Services Director and Administrative Assistant [4] Includes Finance Director and Finance Manager 52 | P a g e TASK 4: O THER TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE AND PROGRAM IMPLEMENTATION Issues: Regional Planning System Enhancement System Efficiency System Preservation Multi -Modal Opportunities Alternative Transportation Modes TOD Opportunities Objectives : To provide technical assistance to member communities , conduct, administer, manage and carry -out major corridor studies and projects on behalf of member municipalities and funded primarily under specific project funding programs. To engage and support member municipalities in advancing and implementing tran sportation investment to enhance the management and operation of the region’ transportation system, increase system efficiency and preserve system components. To develop, amend and maintain a short -range Transportation Improvement Program (TIP) that is financially constrained and consistent with the long range Regional Transportation Plan . Tasks: Administer and manage specific transportation planning, program and design grants obtained by and on behalf of Naugatuck Valley planning region municipalitie s, and provide technical assistance to member municipalities ; hold monthly meetings of the CNV MPO; and develop and maintain the metropolitan transportation improvement program . Specific tasks are: Task 4.1: Transportation Improvement Program – TIP/STIP  Develop and maintain the short range transportation improvement program (TIP).  Amend TIP/STIP, as necessary , and coordinate the endorsement of amendments and administrative actions to the TIP in cooperation with CTDOT .  Review and approve Admin istrative Actions and keep track of changes .  Develop project scopes and applications for funding unde r various federal aid programs .  Establish transportation project priorities and work with municipalities in setting implementation schedules .  Revise financ ial plans, prepare amendment summary reports, and make presentations at meetings of the MPO to inform members of proposed amendments and changes to the TIP/STIP. 53 | P a g e  Maintain the TIP/STIP in a database format – MS Access .  Maintain and update an interactive ma p o n the website , including project descriptions and inform ation that would pop -up when clicked .  Administer and monitor the FHWA Surface Transportation Block Grant Program , including soliciting and evaluating project proposals, setting priorities, and main taining a financial plan , as needed .  Administer the NVCOG’s Local Transportation Capital Improvement Program (LOTCIP), including soliciting and evaluating project proposals, setting priorities, and maintaining a financial plan .  Coordinate MPO correspondenc es, project selection, and project solicitation for various state and federal aid transportation programs . Task 4.2: Metropolitan Planning Organization  Serve as the transportation planning staff for the CNV MPO.  Prepare meeting agendas and technical material, including plan and project summaries, technical memoranda, and policy papers CTDOT .  Make presentations at M PO meetings , regarding the TIP/STIP, LRTP s, air quality conformity, project priorities, and amendments/actions for CTDOT .  Provide technical advice and guidance on plan, policy, program and project issues to the CTDOT . Task 4.3: Transportation Technical Advisory Committees  Convene the Naugatuck Valley Transportation Technical Advisory Committee . Tasks include:  Provide input on projects, plans and programs  Review amendments to the TIP /STIP and offer recommendations  Review projects funded under the LOTCIP Program  Provide technical advice on public works best practices through guest speakers  Provide technical advice and guidance on emergency planning activities related the Regional Emergency Planning Teams including Region 5 (Beacon Falls, Bethlehem, Cheshire, Middlebury, Naugatuck, Oxford, Plymouth, Prospect, Southbury, Thomaston, Waterbury, Watertown, Wolcott, and Woodbury) . Task 4 .4: Naugatuck River Greenway Project  Provide technical assistance to the City of Waterbury and CTDOT on the Waterbury Naugatuck River Greenway Design Project – State Project No. 0151 -0321 .  Assist the Naugatuck River Greenway Steering Committee :  M aintain and h ost the NRG website / webpage on the NVCOG website  Prepare meeting agendas and material and host bi -monthly meetings of NRGSC  Prepare and update interactive maps of the NRG, including proposed alignment s 54 | P a g e  The NVCOG received a grant award under the OPM’s Responsible Growth and TOD Grant Program to conduct a routing study for the Naugatuck River Greenway between Thomaston and Torrington. The grant is in the amount of $110,000. While it was a joint application with NHCOG, the NVCOG has assumed the role of fi duciary and will administer the project and provide technical support under its US DOT metropolitan planning program. In addition, the NVCOG proposes to allocate US DOT planning funds, not to exceed $2,100 to supplement the OPM Responsible Growth grant. Th ese funds will be allocated to pay for and reimburse Other Direct Costs incurred by the selected consultant during the conduct of the routing study. These Other Direct Expenses include:  Out -of-pocket Expenses during Field Work: $1,250  Printing – Color Rep orts & Photos: $500  Postage & Shipping: $100  Field Consumables: $250  Total: $2,100 A QBS process was completed to request qualifications from prospective consultants and select the preferred consultant. The BSC Group was selected after an interview process of short -listed consultants. These Other Direct Costs will be paid based on actual costs incurred; therefore, the actual allocation of PL funds may be less than listed above.  Administer and provide technical assistance / support on the Watertown and Thomaston NRG design project funded under the Recreational Trails Program Task 4 .5: TIGER VI Program – WATER Project  Work with the City of Waterbury on the TIGER VI project for the Waterbury Active Transportation and Economic Resurgence (WATER) and provide technical assistance , as needed . Task 4.6 : Route 34 Reconstruction Project – State Project No. 0036 -0184*  Administer the design of the widening and reconstruction of Route 34 in Derby from Ausonio Drive to Bridge Street :  Participate in public information meetings on project design plans and coordinate public comments and suggestions into the design plans  Review plans  Serve as the liaison between the City of Derby, CTDOT and consultant engineer  Maintain financial records of the design phase  Monitor progress 55 | P a g e *Funding for task provided under State Project No. 0036 -0184 Task 4.7 : Route 67 Spot Improvements and Minor Widening Project – State Project No. 0124 -0165*  Administer the design of spot improvements and minor widening along Route 67 in Seymour:  Participate in public information meetings on project design plans and coordinate public comments and suggestions into the design plans  Review plans  Serve as the liaison between the Town of Seymour, CTDOT and consultant engineer  Maintain financial records of the design phase  Monitor progress of preliminary and final design activities *Funding for task provided under State Project No. 0124 -0165 Task 4. 8: Derby -Shelton Bridge Renovation Project – State Project No. 0126 -0174*  Administer the design of renovation and pedestrian / bicycle improvements on the Derby -Shelton Bri dge over the Housatonic River between Derby and Shelton:  Participate in public information meetings on project design plans and coordinate public comments and suggestions into the design plans  Review plans  Serve as the liaison between the cities of Derby and Shelton, CTDOT and consultant engineer  Maintain financial records of the design phase  Monitor progress of preliminary and final design activities *Funding for task provided under State Project No. 0126 -0174 Task 4.9 : Route 8 Corridor Improvements – State Project No. 0036 -0179* The Valley Council of Governments, subsequently the NVCOG, administers design contract for improvements along the Route 8 corridor in the lower Naugatuck Valley planning region. State Project No. 0036 -0179 provided funds to c onduct the preliminary design of improvements to interchanges 15 through 18. Project breakouts include the improvements at Interchange 18 (constructed in FY 2017) and the major widening and reconstruction of Route 34 (State Project No. 0036 -0184 – referenc e Task 4.3). The realignment and consolidation of interchanges 16 and 17 remains a regional priority, but the project has been removed from the CTDOT’s five -year capital plan. 56 | P a g e  Work to add the proposed Route 8 Interchange 16 and 17 realignment and consolidation project to the CTDOT five -year capital plan and identify short and long range actions. *Funding for task provided under State Project No. 0036 -0179 Task 4.10 : TOD Pilot Project*  Administer the conduct of the NVCOG TOD Pilot Project and Alternate Transportation Modes project .  Manage consultant agreement and scope of work for Task 3 activities including the Route 8 Alternate Modes Project .  Provide technical assistance to the project consultant, as needed including data collection, mapping and public outreach.  Prepare and submit quarterly progress and financial reports.  Monitor progress on the project. *Funding for task provided under FTA Grant CT -39 -000 2-00 and CT -95 -X014 -00 Task 4. 11 : I-84 / Route 8 Interchange Project The CTDOT is working on a preliminary engineering study to recommend options for replacing the I -84 / Route 8 interchange.  Work with and provide technical assistance to the design team and city of Waterbury, as needed. Task 4. 12 : Regional Coordination and Consultation  Coordinate multi -state and mega -regional planning by p articipate in and attend bi – annual meetings of the Metropolitan Area Planning (MAP) Forum to ensure that metropolitan transportation planning products and documents of each respective MPO consider and take into account the impacts of the plans and programs developed by the other MPOs.  Coordinate and consult with Connecticut Metropolitan Planning Organizations on various projects, plans and programs – CRCOG, WestCOG, MetroCOG, SCRCOG, and NHCOG . Task 4.1 3: Technical Capacity Building  Increase the technical capacity of the NVCOG through staff attendance and participation at workshops , seminars, webinars and conferences sponsored and held by the CTDOT, FHWA Resource Center, and National Highway Institute (NHI). 57 | P a g e  Procure technical resourc es, as necessary.  Technical training, as needed. Task 4. 14 : Transportation Program Technical Assistance  Provide technical assistance and monitor federal aid transportation programs including but not limited to STBG; CMAQ and the TAP Set -aside .  Coordinate with CTDOT on the selection and implementation of TAP Set -aside projects .  Provide technical assistance to member towns, as needed. Task 4. 15: Technical Assistance to Regional Planning Commission  Provide assistance to the NVCOG RPC in reviewing the transportation and traffic impacts of proposed land use actions and assess the conformity of zoning, subdivision, and planning proposals with regional and state plans .  Provide assistance to the NVCOG RPC in preparing the regional plan of conservation and development and ensure consistency with the long range transportation plan .  Provide assistance to the member municipalities in preparing the local plans of conservation and development and ensur ing consistency with the long range trans portation plan . Deliverable s:  Monthly CNV MPO meetings  Bi-monthly TTAC meetings  Bi-annual MAP Forum meetings  NRG S teering Committee  Route 34 Reconstruction Project – Design Administration (State Project No. 0036 -0184)  Route 67 Spot Improvements Project – Design Administration (State Project No. 0124 – 0165)  Derby -Shelton Bridge Project – Design Administration (State Project No. 0126 -0174)  Route 8 and Waterbury Branch Line Corridor TOD and Alternative Transportation Modes Assessment Project – FTA Section 5307 and 5339 Grants 58 | P a g e Task 4: Other Technical Assistance Budget FY 2018 FY 2019 Total Direct Labor $111,389 $112,357 $223,746 BFO @1.17 $130,325 $131,458 $261,783 Other Direct $2,100 $0 $2,100 Total $243,814 $243,815 $487,629 Staff Allocation: FY 2016 Direct Labor BFO Total Hours Exec. Director $16,708 $19,549 $36,257 238.7 Dir. of Planning $38,986 $45,614 $84,600 649.8 Reg. Trans. Eng. $11,139 $13,033 $24,171 222.8 Sr. Planners [1] $16,708 $19,549 $36,257 556.9 Planners [2] $5,569 $6,516 $12,085 185.6 Planning Assistant $0 $0 $0 0.0 Administration [3] $5,569 $6,516 $12,085 123.8 Financial Man. [4] $16,708 $19,549 $36,257 371.3 Total $111,389 $130,325 $241,712 2,348.9 FY 2017 Direct Labor BFO Total Hours Exec. Director $16,854 $19,719 $36,572 240.8 Dir. of Planning $39,325 $46,010 $85,335 655.4 Reg. Trans. Eng. $11,236 $13,146 $24,381 224.7 Sr. Planners [1] $16,854 $19,719 $36,573 561.8 Planners [2] $5,618 $6,573 $12,191 187.3 Planning Intern $0 $0 $0 0.0 Administration [3] $5,618 $6,573 $12,191 124.8 Financial Man. [4] $16,854 $19,719 $36,573 374.5 Total $112,357 $131,459 $243,817 2,369.3 Financial Responsibility: FY 201 8 NVCOG Federal $195,052 State $13,981 Local $34,782 Total $243,815 59 | P a g e FY 2019 NVCOG Federal $195,052 State $13,981 Local $34,782 Total $243,815 Functional Responsibility: Naugatuck Valley Council of Governments [1] Includes Senior Transportation Planner, Supervising Transportation Planner and Senior Regional Planner [2] Includes Regional Planners, Transportation Planners I & II, and GIS Coordinator & Specialist [3] Includes Municipal Shared Services Director and Administrative Assistant [4] Includes Finance Director and Finance Manager 60 | P a g e IV. Naugatuck Valley Planning Region Ta sk and Sta ff Alloca tion Budgets and Regional Transportation Program Schedules FY 201 8 – 201 9 FY 2018 and FY 2019 Unified Planning Work Program Naugatuck Valley Council of Governments FY 201 8 Task Allocation by Funding Sources and Revenues Tasks Federal State Local Total Task 1: Data Collection/Analysis $156,041 $11,185 $27,826 $195,052 Task 2A: Transportation Planning — Regional $156,041 $11,185 $27,826 $195,052 Task 2B: Transportation Planning — Transit $117,031 $8,389 $20,869 $146,289 Task 2C: Transportation Planning — Non -Motorized Transportation Modes $78,021 $5,592 $13,913 $97,526 Task 3: Program Management, Implementation and Administration $78,021 $5,592 $13,913 $97,526 Task 4: Other Technical Assistance $195,052 $13,981 $34,782 $243,815 Total: $780,207 $55,924 $139,129 $975,260 FY 2018 and FY 2019 Unified Planning Work Program Naugatuck Valley Council of Governments FY 201 9 Task Allocation by Funding Sources and Revenues Tasks Federal State Local Total Task 1: Data Collection/Analysis $156,041 $11,185 $27,826 $195,052 Task 2A: Transportation Planning – Regional $156,041 $11,185 $27,826 $195,052 Task 2B: Transportation Planning — Transit $117,031 $8,389 $20,869 $146,289 61 | P a g e Task 2C: Transportation Planning — Non -Motorized Transportation Modes $78,021 $5,592 $13,913 $97,526 Task 3: Program Management, Implementation and Administration $78,021 $5,592 $13,913 $97,526 Task 4: Other Technical Assistance $195,052 $13,981 $34,782 $243,815 Total: $780,207 $55,924 $139,129 $975,260 FY 2018 and FY 2019 Unified Planning Work Program Naugatuck Valley Council of Governments FY 2018 Task Allocation Budget Direct Labor Indirect Other Direct [1] Total Task 1: Data Collection/Analysis $89,886 $105,167 $0 $195,053 Task 2A: Transportation Planning — Highways $89,886 $105,167 $0 $195,053 Task 2B: Transportation Planning — Transit $67,414 $78,874 $0 $146,288 Task 2C: Transportation Planning — Non – Motorized Transportation Modes $44,943 $52,583 $0 $97,526 Task 3: Program Management, Implementation and Administration $33,422 $39,104 $25,000 $97,526 Task 4: Other Technical Assistance $111,389 $130,325 $2,100 $243,814 Total: $436,940 $511,220 $27,100 $975,260 [1] Other Direct Costs listed in the following table. 62 | P a g e FY 2018 and FY 2019 Unified Planning Work Program Naugatuck Valley Council of Governments FY 2019 Task Allocation Budget Direct Labor Indirect Other Direct Total Task 1: Data Collection/Analysis $89,886 $105,167 $0 $195,053 Task 2A: Transportation Planning — Highways $89,886 $105,167 $0 $195,053 Task 2B: Transportation Planning — Transit $67,414 $78,874 $0 $146,288 Task 2C: Transportation Planning — Non – Motorized Transportation Modes $44,943 $52,583 $0 $97,526 Task 3: Program Management, Implementation and Administration $33,422 $39,104 $25,000 $97,526 Task 4: Other Technical Assistance $112,357 $131,458 $0 $243,815 Total: $437,908 $512,353 $25,000 $975,261 [1] Other Direct Costs listed in the following t able. FY 2018 and FY 2019 Unified Planning Work Program Naugatuck Valley Council of Governments FY 2018 an d FY2019 Other Direct Budget Other Direct FY 2018 FY 2019 Arc GIS Maintenance $9,000 $9,000 TDM $1,500 $1,500 Travel $1,500 $1,500 Training $3,000 $3,000 Computer/IT $2,500 $2,500 Translation $3,000 $3,000 Data Acquisition $4,000 $4,000 Reproduction $500 $500 63 | P a g e Other Direct Costs Related to NRG Routing Study $2,100 $0 Total $2 7,100 $25,000 FY 2018 and FY 2019 Unified Planning Work Program Naugatuck Valley Council of Governments FY 2018 Staff Allocation Budget FY 2018 Direct Labor Indirect Total Hours Executive Director $29,811 $34,879 $64,691 425.9 Direct or of Planning/Assistant Direct or $90,810 $106,247 $197,057 1,513.5 Regional Tr ansportation Engineer $25,267 $29,563 $54,830 505.3 Senior Transportation Planners , Senior Regional Planner & Supervising Transportation Planner $116,453 $136,250 $252,703 3,881.8 Regional Planners, Transportation Planners I & II, Transit Planner and GIS Coordinator & Specialist $113,404 $132,682 $246,085 3,780.1 Planning Intern/Planning Assistant $17,977 $21,033 $39,010 898.9 Administration Assistant & Municipal Shared Services $21,496 $25,149 $46,644 477.7 Finance Director & Financial Manager $21,722 $25,415 $47,136 482.7 Total $436,940 $511,218 $948,156 11,965.9 64 | P a g e FY 2018 and FY 2019 Unified Planning Work Program Naugatuck Valley Council of Governments FY 2019 Staff Allocation Budget FY 2018 Direct Labor Indirect Total Hours Executive Director $29,957 $35,049 $65,006 428.0 Direct or of Planning/Assistant Direct or $91,148 $106,644 $197,792 1,519.1 Regional Tr ansportation Engineer $25,364 $29,676 $55,040 507.3 Senior Transportation Planners , Senior Regional Planner & Supervising Transportation Planner $116,598 $136,420 $253,019 3,886.6 Regional Planners, Transportation Planners I & II, Transit Planner and GIS Coordinator & Specialist $113,452 $132,739 $246,191 3,781.7 Planning Intern/Planning Assistant $17,977 $21,033 $39,010 898.9 Administration Assistant & Municipal Shared Services $21,544 $25,206 $46,750 478.8 Finance Director & Financial Manager $21,867 $25,585 $47,452 485.9 Total $437,908 $512,352 $950,260 11,986.3 65 | P a g e Tasks Activity July August Sept Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb March April May June 1.1 Transportation Database ▲ ▲ 1.2 Performance Monitoring ▲ ▲ 1.3 Travel Demand Model ▲ ▲ 1.4 Regional GIS Program 1.5 Regional Profiles ▲ 2A.1 Transportation Plan ▲ ▲ 2A.2 Tech Assistance 2A.3 Safety Program ▲ ▲ ▲ 2A.4 Congestion Management ▲ ▲ 2A.5 Emergency Management ▲ ▲ ▲ ▲ 2A.6 Environmental Mitigation ▲ ▲ 2A.7 LOTCIP ▲ ▲ ▲ ▲ 2A.8 Freight Planning ▲ ▲ ▲ 2B.1 10-Year Capital Plan ▲ ▲ 2B.2 Local Bus Planning 2B.3 LOCHSTP 2B.4 Commuter Rail 2B.5 Alt Modes Study ▲ ▲ 2B.6 W ATS ▲ ▲ 2B.7 Transit Governance ▲ ▲ 2C.1 Route 8 Alt Modes ▲ ▲ 2C.2 Reg Trail Planning 2C.3 NRG Economic Study ▲ ▲ 2C.4 Reg Bicycle Plan ▲ ▲ ▲ 2C.5 Reg Pedestrian Safety ▲ ▲ 2C.6 Sustainability Program 3.1 UPW P ▲ ▲ 3.2 CTDOT Coordination 3.3 Administration 3.4 Grant Applications As necessary 3.5 Highway Program Dev 3.6 Transit Programming 3.7 Policy 3.8 Public Participation Prog. 4.1 TIP/STIP ▲ ▲ ▲ 4.2 MPO ▲ ▲ ▲ ▲ ▲ ▲ ▲ ▲ ▲ ▲ ▲ ▲ 4.3 TTAC ▲ ▲ ▲ ▲ ▲ ▲ 4.4 NRG Project 4.5 TIGER VI — W ATER 4.6 Route 34 Reconstruction 4.7 Route 67 Project 4.8 Derby-Shelton Bridge 4.9 Route 8 Corridor Project 4.10 TOD Project 4.11 I-84/Rte 8 Assessment 4.12 Regional Coordination As necessary 4.13 Tech Capacity Building As necessary 4.14 Tech Assistance 4.15 Tech Assistance–RPC Program Planning Project Planning Meetings, Draft Report, Final Report ▲ FY 2018 Unified Planning W ork Program Regional Transportation Program Schedule Naugatuck Valley Council of Gov ernments — CNV MPO 66 | P a g e Tasks Activity July August Sept Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb March April May June 1.1 Transportation Database ▲ ▲ 1.2 Performance Monitoring ▲ ▲ 1.3 Travel Demand Model ▲ ▲ 1.4 Regional GIS Program 1.5 Regional Profiles ▲ 2A.1 Transportation Plan ▲ ▲ 2A.2 Tech Assistance 2A.3 Safety Program ▲ ▲ ▲ 2A.4 Congestion Management ▲ ▲ 2A.5 Emergency Management ▲ ▲ ▲ ▲ 2A.6 Environmental Mitigation ▲ ▲ 2A.7 LOTCIP ▲ ▲ ▲ ▲ 2A.8 Freight Planning ▲ ▲ ▲ 2B.1 10-Year Capital Plan ▲ ▲ 2B.2 Local Bus Planning 2B.3 LOCHSTP 2B.4 Commuter Rail 2B.5 Alt Modes Study ▲ ▲ 2B.6 W ATS P ro ject expected to be co m pleted in F Y 201 8 2B.7 Transit Governance ▲ ▲ 2C.1 Route 8 Alt Modes ▲ ▲ 2C.2 Reg Trail Planning 2C.3 NRG Economic Study P ro ject expected to be co m pleted in F Y 201 8 2C.4 Reg Bicycle Plan ▲ 2C.5 Reg Pedestrian Safety ▲ ▲ 2C.6 Sustainability Program 3.1 UPW P ▲ ▲ 3.2 CTDOT Coordination 3.3 Administration 3.4 Grant Applications As necessary 3.8 Tech Capacity Building As necessary 3.5 Highway Program Dev 3.6 Transit Programming 3.7 Policy 3.8 Public Participation Prog. 4.1 TIP/STIP ▲ ▲ ▲ 4.2 MPO ▲ ▲ ▲ ▲ ▲ ▲ ▲ ▲ ▲ ▲ ▲ ▲ 4.3 TTAC ▲ ▲ ▲ ▲ ▲ ▲ 4.4 NRG Project 4.5 TIGER VI — W ATER 4.6 Route 34 Reconstruction 4.7 Route 67 Project 4.8 Derby-Shelton Bridge 4.9 Route 8 Corridor Project 4.10 TOD Project 4.11 I-84/Rte 8 Assessment 4.12 Regional Coordination As necessary 4.13 Tech Capacity Building As necessary 4.14 Tech Assistance 4.15 Tech Assistance–RPC Program Planning Project Planning Meetings, Draft Report, Final Report ▲ FY 2019 Unified Planning W ork Program Regional Transportation Program Schedule Naugatuck Valley Council of Gov ernments — CNV MPO 67 | P a g e JOB CLASSIFICATIONS BY TITLE Executive Director : Directs the operations of the Naugatuck Valley Council of Governments (NVCOG) and supervises the transportation and regional planning staff. The Executive Director formulates policies, manages daily operations of the NVCOG and plans and coordinates use of resources for sustainability. The Executive Director serves as the Co -Secretary of the Greater Bridgeport and Valley MPO and Director of the Central Naugatuck Valley Region MPO, assists in formulating policy board actions and implementing recommendations, and facilitates the on – going interaction and relationships between the NVCOG and state, federal, non -profit and private sector partners. The Executive Director w orks with the New York -Connecticut Sustainable Communities Initiative Consortium in developing a regional plan for sustainability and with the Regional Plan Associations , CCM, and others to encourage more TOD s in the state and region. Coordinates mega -regional planning efforts as a member of the Metropolitan Area Planning Forum with directors of the New York Metropolitan Transportation Council (NYMTC) and Northern New Jersey Transportation Planning Authority (NJTPA). Director of Planning /Assistant Director : Responsible for the implementation of the NVCOG’s regional, environmental and transportation planning, and support of its mission as the Metropolitan Planning Organization for the Greater Bridgeport and Valley portions of the Bridgeport -Stamford urbanized area and the Central Naugatuck Valley Region of the Waterbury urbanized area . The Director o f Planning is responsible for coordinating and collaborating with other regional organizations and MPOs in Connecticut and state and federal agencies, including the Connecticut Department of Transportation, Department of Energy and Environmental Protection , Office of Policy and Management and Department of Emergency Services and Public Protection. The Director of Planning is also responsible for NVCOG ’s interactions with the Air Quality Conformity Interagency Consultation Committee and Connecticut Bicycle a nd Pedestrian Advisory Board . Works with the Executive Director in providing analysis and recommendation s regarding key planning issues and c oordinat ing all planning policies in order to create complementary and not contradictory policies . The Director of Planning coordinates with the FHWA and FTA on highway and transit c apital program s and planning and l eads the region’s Transit -Oriented Development efforts. Works with and assists the Executive Director in coordinating mega -regional planning efforts as a m ember of the Metropolitan Area Planning Forum with directors of the New York Metropolitan Transportation Council (NYMTC) and Northern New Jersey Transportation Planning Authority (NJTPA). Regional Tra nsportation Engineer : Under general direction of Executive Director and Director of Planning , manages all technical aspects of roadway, street, highway, and interstate design, modeling, and improvement. Provide s transportation 68 | P a g e and traffic engineering technical assistance to the municipalities of the Naugatuck Valley Council of Governments, assess es traffic and highway operations on key corridors and intersections , d evelop s highway capital improvement project concepts , develop s preliminary engineering and design activities for project scoping and devel opment , c onduct s and manage s traffic engineering corridor and intersection studies , and r esponsible for NVCOG’s travel demand forecasting and traffic simulation modeling activities . Administer s the state -funded LOTCIP for NVCOG and assist s in developing pr oject scopes and preparing concept drawings . R esponsible for project selection, scheduling, cost control and contract administration and c onsult s with town s regarding LOTCIP, STP, TAP and CMAQ projects. Tra nsportation Engineer : Under general direction of Executive Director, Director of Planning, and Senior/Principle Traffic Engineer , provide s transportation and traffic engineering technical assistance to the municipalities of the Naugatuck Valley Council of Governments, assess es traffic and highway ope rations on key corridors and intersections , d evelop s highway capital improvement project concepts , develop s preliminary engineering and design activities for project scoping and development , c onduct s and manage s traffic engineering corridor and intersectio n studies , and works on the NVCOG’s travel demand forecasting and traffic simulation modeling activities . Assists in a dministr ating the state -funded LOTCIP for NVCOG and developing project scopes and preparing concept drawings . R esponsible for project sele ction, scheduling, cost control and contract administration , and c onsult s with town s regarding LOTCI P, STP, TAP and CMAQ projects. M anages all technical aspects of roadway, street, highway, and interstate design, modeling, and improvement. Senior Transportation Planner : Supervises the r egional transportation planning staff in the conduct of the regional transportation planning process and helps the Director of Planning in coordinating the development of the short -range Transportation Improvement P rogram (TIP), the Long Range Regional Transportation Plan, the Unified Planning Work Program and oversees the modifications to the TIP, either through the Administrative Action process or Amendments. The Senior Transportation Planner assists the Director o f Planning in special projects, program coordination and the development and analysis of their respective policy impacts upon the agency. The Senior Transportation Planner establish es and conducts the meeting schedule, agendas and business of the Transport ation Technical Advisory Committee (TTAC) and supervise s special projects recommended and approved by the TTAC . Senior Regional Planner : Works under the general supervision of the Director of Planning and the Senior Transportation Planner, d etermines the methods f or conducting technical studies , and p repares technical studies and writes reports. Serves as project manager on selected plans and studies ; coordinates and oversees development of the UPWP and tasks assigned to staff. Provides techni cal assistance on transportation matters to municipalities. May supervise others assigned to assist in work for which responsibility has been delegated. 69 | P a g e Supervising Transportation Planner : Supervises the r egional transportation planning staff in the conduct of the regional transportation planning process and assists the Director of Planning in coordinating the development of the short -range Transportation Improvement Program (TIP), the Long Range Regional Transportation Plan, the Unified Planning Work Program and oversees the modifications to the TIP, either through the Administrative Action process or Amendments. The Senior Transportation Planner assists the Director of Planning in special projects, program coordination and the d evelopment and analysis of their respective policy impacts upon the agency. The Supervising Transportation Planner establish es and conducts the meeting schedule, agendas and business of the Transportation Technical Advisory Committee (TTAC) and supervise s special projects recommended and approved by the TTAC . Transportation Planner II : Assist the Senior Transportation Planner and Supervising Transportation Planner in the conduct of various transportation planning studies and tasks as outlined and contain ed in the Unified Planning Work Program. The Transportation Planner II works under the direction and supervision of the Senior Transportation Planner and Director of Planning, as appropriate and necessary. Transportation Planner I : Assist the Senior Tran sportation Planner and Supervising Transportation Planner in the conduct of various transportation planning studies and tasks as outlined and contained in the Unified Planning Work Program. The Transportation Planner I works under the direction and supervi sion of the Senior Transportation Planner and Director of Planning, as appropriate and necessary. Senior Transit Planner : Supervises the transit planning staff and oversees the development, coordination and implementation of regional transit priorities and leads the NVCOG’s long -range and short -term transit planning efforts in order to enhance the transit system s in the Naugatuck Valley planning r egion to better link land us e, housing, employment and new bus rapid t ransit and rail opportunities. The Senior Transit Planner works with the Director of Planning and Senior Transportation Planner in working with the GBV MPO, CNV MPO, CCMPO, CT DOT, CT Transit, VTD and the municipalit ies to identify funding sources and strategies to implement plan recommendations and coordinates plan ning efforts with the VTD, GBT and CT Transit related to special transportation needs , including jobs access , elderly and handicapped transportation grant programs (LOCHSTP and Municipal Grant Program) . 70 | P a g e Transit Planner : Assists the Senior Transit Planner with the development, coordination and implementation of regional transit priorities and works on the NVCOG’s long -range and short -term transit planning efforts in order to enhance the transit system s in the Naugatuck Valley planning r egion to better link land use, housing, employment and new bus rapid t ransit and rail opportunities. The Transit Planner works with the transportation planning staff in working with the GBV MPO, CNV MPO, CCMPO, CT DOT, CT Transit, VTD and the municipalities to identify funding sources and strategies to implement plan recommendations and coordinates plan ning efforts with the VTD, GBT and CT Transit related to special tra nsportation needs , including jobs access , elderly and handicapped transportation grant programs (LOCHSTP and Municipal Grant Program) . The Transit Planner also serves as the NVCO’s Disadvanatged Business Enterprise Liaison Officer (DBELO). Duties include review of third party contracts and purchase requisitions for compliance with this program and w ork s with transportation planning staff on prorgam requirements. Manages large and/or broad in scope projects for DBE compliance, establishes annual DBE goals, compiles statistical data, completes and submits required reports and participates in annual site reviews . Environmental Planner : Under general supervision of the Executive Director, provides expertise i n environmental planning, research, and policy analysis for the Regional Brownfield Partnership in the areas of brownfields assessment, cleanup and redevelopment related to transportation oriented development, smart growth, in fill development, community o utreach, green remediation, regulatory liaison outreach, project development and funding. Regional Planner : Works directly under the Director of Planning and Senior Regional Planner and is primarily responsible for implementing all aspects of the regional land use planning program and coordinates the link ages with the transportation planning activities and provides analysis and recommendations regarding key planning issues. The Regional Planner also support s a wide range of regional environmental a ctivities and planning studies, such as natural hazard mitigation, Brownfields reclamation, trails and greenways development, conservation and watershed management, sustainability planning, and climate resiliency planning. Provides support planning for ass essing environmental mitigation efforts related to the long range transportation plan, transportation improvement program, and projects, including air quality conformity; and assesses the environmental impacts of STP funded projects. The Regional Planner a lso w ork s with the operation and implementation of the r egion’s Brownfields Partnership, organizing project bids, scheduling meetings and conferences, drafting articles, reports, and correspondence, and creating presentations , and is the Staff Director of the 71 | P a g e Regional Planning Commission and primary regional contact with all municipal planning departments. The Regional Planner c onducts research in support of and drafts updates to municipal and r egional plan s of conservation and development and c oordinates with the state Office of Policy & Management (OPM). GIS Program Coordinator: Creates and maintains GIS databases and maps related to NV COG’s planning work and programs; assists planning staff in their work as it relates to GIS and data gathering and analysis; prepares maps and other graphics for NV COG documents and presentations; provides GIS technical assistance to member municipalities, prepares data documentation (metadata) for GIS files. The GIS Program Coordinator w orks under the general supervision of the Executive Director and the Director of Planning and supervises other GIS staff. Regional Planner – GIS Specialist: Creates and mai ntains GIS databases and maps related to NV COG’s planning work and programs; assists planning staff in their work as it relates to GIS and data gathering and analysis; prepares maps and other graphics for NV COG documents and presentations; provides GIS tec hnical assistance to member municipalities, prepares data documentation (metadata) for GIS files; performs quantitative analysis of regional planning data; prepares reports on planning analyses and studies; makes oral presentations of study results. GIS Pl anning Assistant : Works under the direction of the GIS Program Coordinator. Duties include but are not limited to assisting in the creation and maintenance of databases for the NVCOG’s ge ographic information systems. Municipal Shared Services Coordinator : Works under the general supervision and direction of the Executive Director and provides Municipal Shared Service program development and management, research, analysis, and technical assistance work for the Naugatuck Valley region in the area of multi -jurisdictional delivery of grant writing, cooperative purchasing, local government services, budget and finance, contract management and training. Policy Coordinator/Special Projects : Works under the general supervision and direction of the Executive Direct or and in cooperation with all transportation and regional planning staff. The Policy Coordinator assists the Executive Director in preparing and disseminating analyses of state and federal policies and program requirements, and, as directed, arranges and organizes program and policy level meetings. Works in concert with the Director of Planning , Finance Director and administrative staff to research, draft, review, interpret, and oversee the implementation of organizational policy. The 72 | P a g e Policy Coordinator co nducts technical work for planning and administrative staff, and manages and administers special projects being under taken by the NVCOG . Finance Director : Works under the general supervision of the Executive Director and m aintains general ledger, journals and all other fiscal records and reports , including all NVCOG checking and savings accounts , in accordance with federal and state accounting and auditing standards. The Financial Officer p repares project financial reports , requests contract reimb ursements , prepares quarterly finacial reports ( FICA, FWT and unemployment ), prepares monthly balance sheets , analysis of staff timesheets and financial reports, and makes out all checks including payroll. The Financial Officer processes invoices received from consulting firms under NVCOG contract. Financial Manager : Maintains general ledger, journals and all other fiscal records and reports in accordance with federal and state bookkeeping and auditing standards. Prepares project financial reports; contra ct reimbursements; quarterly FICA, FWT and unemployment reports; monthly balance sheets; monthly analysis of staff timesheets; makes out all checks including payroll. Maintains Council checking and savings accounts. Makes all deposits, withdrawals, and f und transfers. Orders office supplies. Maintains an inventory of office equipment and furniture. Uses personal computer for fiscal applications. Assists with general clerical functions as needed. Works under the general supervision of the Finance Directo r. Supervises clerical staff and others as assigned. Administrative Assistant : Works under the general supervision and direction of the Executive Director and w orks in cooperation with the Financ e Director and all transportation and regional planning staff. The Administrative Assistant assists planning staff in preparing and disseminating correspondence s, notices and other documents , and, as directed, arranging meetings and maintaining the NVCOG calendar. The Administrative Assistant conducts technical work for the planning staff, as needed . Planning Intern/Planning Assistant : Is a durational position that c arries out specific planning and program tasks under the direction and supervision of the Director of Planning, Senior Transportation Planner or a designated staff member and assists the transportation and regional planning staff in the conduct of a wide variety of planning tasks , including the preparation of planning documents , data collection and analysis, and GIS support and maintenance . 73 | P a g e Nauga tuck Valley Council of Governments FY 201 8 and 201 9 Planning Staff Maximum Hourly Rates Title Max Rate Executive Director $75 .00 Director of Planning /Assistant Director $60 .00 Regional Transportation Engineer $60.00 Transportation Engineer $50.00 Senior Transportation Planner $50.00 Senior Regional Planner $45.00 Supervising Transportation Planner $45.00 Transportation Planner II $35.00 Transportation Planner I $30 .00 Transit C apital Administrator $50 .00 Senior Transit Planner $55 .00 Transit Planner $45 .00 Environmental Planner $75.00 Regional Planner $45.00 GIS Program Coordinator $40 .00 Regional Planner – GIS Specialist $35 .00 GIS Planning Assistant $30.00 Municipal Shared Services Coordinator $50.00 Policy Coordinator /Special Projects $50.00 Finance Director $50 .00 Financial Manager $40 .00 Administrative Assistant $35 .00 Planning Intern/Planning Assistant $20 .00

Unified Planning Work Programs (UPWP) for the Greater Bridgeport & Valley MPO FY 2018-2019

Unified Planning Work Program for the Greater Bridgeport & Valley Planning Region: 2018 & 2019 June 15, 2017 Shelto n Ea sto n Fair fi eld M onro e Tru m bu ll Stratfo rd Se ym our B rid gep o rt D erb y A nso nia 2 MetroCOG Staff Connecticut Metropolitan Council of Governments Patrick Carleton, Deputy Director Lawrence Ciccarelli, Administrative Services Director Matt Fulda, Acting Executive Director Mark Goetz, Senior Transportation Planner/GIS Director Mark Hoover, GIS Specialist Colleen Kelleher, Deputy Finance Director George B. Obeng, GIS Specialist Michael Pavia, Deputy Director Meghan A. Sloan, Planning Director Table of Contents Introduction …………………………….. 1 Task I: Data Collection, Analysis & Applications .. 10 Task II: Multi-Modal Transportation Planning …. 15 Task III: Other Technical Assistance ………… 25 Task IV: Public Participation ……………….. 29 Task V: Administration ……………………… 32 Task VI: Special Planning Studies …………. 35 Financials ……………………………… 38 Employee Tasks …………………… 44 Statement: Cooperative MPO/State/Transit Operators Planning Roles & Responsibilities ………. 48 Resolutions ……………………………. 52 3 Abstract The FY 2018 and 2019 Unified Planning Work Program (UPWP) for the Greater Bridgeport and Valley Metropoli – tan Planning Organization (GBVMPO) describes all urban transportation and transportation-related planning activities anticipated between the state fiscal years July 1, 2017 to June 30, 2019. It contains a discussion of the major trans – portation issues, goals and objectives in the Region. Federal funding resources and budget summaries are included. Effective Date The UPWP will be effective after it has been endorsed by the GBVMPO and upon approval by the relevant Federal transportation agencies. Acknowledgements The Greater Bridgeport and Valley Metropolitan Planning Organization (GBVMPO), in cooperation with the member municipalities, the Connecticut Department of Transporta – tion, the US Department of Transportation (Federal Highway Administration and Federal Transit Administration), and public transit operators in the Greater Bridgeport and Valley Metropolitan Planning Region developed this UPWP. The opinions, findings and conclusions expressed in this publica – tion are those of the GBVMPO and do not necessarily reflect the official views or policies of the CTDOT or USDOT. Amendment This Statement on Transportation Planning may be amend – ed from time to time or to coincide with annual UPWP ap – proval as jointly deemed necessary or in the best interests of all parties, including Federal transportation agencies. Non–Limitation of Statutory Authority Nothing contained in this Statement is intended to or shall limit the authority or responsibilities assigned to signatory organizations under Connecticut law, federal law, local ordinance or charter. Contact: Connecticut Metropolitan Council of Governments 1000 Lafayette Boulevard, Suite 925, Bridgeport, Connecticut 06604 Phone: (203) 366-5405 Fax: (203) 366-8437 E-mail: mfulda@ctmetro.org Website: www. ctmetro.org Introduction 4 Overview The Greater Bridgeport Valley Metropolitan Planning Orga – nization’s (GBVMPO) FY 2018 – FY 2019 Unified Planning Work Program (UPWP) describes all urban transportation and transportation-related planning activities anticipated to be initiated and completed over a two-year period begin – ning July 1, 2017 and ending June 30, 2019. The UPWP is prepared in accordance with Title 23 CFR Part 420 and Part 450 Section 308. The metropolitan transportation planning activities documented in the UPWP will be performed using funds provided under Title 23 U.S.C. and Title 49 U.S.C. Chapter 53. The UPWP will be updated in June, 2019 to reflect accomplishments during the 2018 and 2019 fiscal years and identify those planning activities to be completed and undertaken in FY 2020. The UPWP contains: • A description of GBVMPO’s transportation planning process; • A description of the Region’s transportation systems, major issues and deficiencies; • A description of planning tasks to address the Region’s major transportation issues. The responsible agency, party performing the work, a schedule, work products and costs are identified for each task. • The status and progress of on-going transportation plan – ning studies and activities initiated during the previous program year and continuing into the current UPWP • A financial summary that breaks out federal, non-federal matching funds and carryover funds by each task. • General duties for each employee classification and maximum hourly rates The Greater Bridgeport & Valley Metropolitan Planning Region & Transportation Systems The Greater Bridgeport & Valley Metropolitan Planning Organization is located in the southwestern part of Con – necticut and part of Fairfield and New Haven Counties. It is comprised of the Cities of Ansonia, Bridgeport, Derby and Shelton and the Towns of Easton, Fairfield, Monroe, Sey – mour, Stratford and Trumbull. Some of these municipalities are located along the Interstate 95 and the Northeast Rail Corridor which provides rail access to New York City and Boston, Massachusetts. Four expressways, five rail stations along Metro North’s New Haven line and three stations along Metro North’s Waterbury line provide access to areas throughout Connecticut. These rail lines are owned by the State of Connecticut and operated by Metro North. With a population of about 408,000 people and a land area of about 196 square miles, the Region has a population density (approx. 2,081 persons per square mile) that is the highest of any region in the state. This density and intensive development patterns are reflected in the high proportion of the region that lies within the Census-defined Bridge – port-Stamford Urbanized Area with over 95% of the popu – lation living in the urban area and a significant percentage of the land area within designated federal-aid urban bound – aries. Roughly 35% of the Region’s approximately 408,000 residents live in the City of Bridgeport. Each day, more than one million trips are made to, from and within the Region. This travel reflects the daily activities of its residents, and, in a broader perspective, the Region’s econ – omy. The efficiency of this travel is an important measure of economic vitality in the Region. The transportation system of the Region is diverse and offers its residents an integrated range of options. Key trans – portation facilities are listed on the next page and mapped in Figure 1. Organization & Management The Region’s transportation planning process is carried out by the consolidated Greater Bridgeport and Valley Metropol – itan Planning Organization (GBVMPO). The MPO replaced the Tri-State Regional Planning Commission and a separate Greater Bridgeport Transportation Endorsement Board in June of 1981. A Memorandum of Understanding for Transportation Plan – ning in the Greater Bridgeport and Valley Planning Regions was adopted in 1981 that established membership in the GBVMPO member towns and “a unified, comprehensive, cooperative, officially coordinated, continuing process for transportation planning.” As of January 1, 1982, a con – solidated MPO was designated in the July 7, 1981 MOU, 5 consisting of Chief Elected Officials of 10 communities within the combined boundary of the Greater Bridgeport and Valley Planning Regions. A combined “Technical Coordination Group (TCG)” was to be developed consist – ing of representatives from GBRPA, Valley RPA, CTDOT, GB Transit District, Valley Transit District, each Town/City (10), FHWA, FTA. The MPO was responsible for Urban Transportation Planning, developing a UPWP (currently 2), 1 Transportation Plan (currently 2), 1 TIP (currently 1). In 2016, FHWA requested that the MPO begin developing a single set of planning products. The MOU was reaffirmed in FY 1996 and rewritten in 2006 to reflect new federal transportation planning guidelines and requirements from the Safe, Accountable, Flexible Efficient Transportation Equity Act: A Legacy for Users (SAFETEA-LU). The new MOU was adopted by the MPO at its July 26, 2006, meeting and subsequently signed by all involved organizations. An agreement was also executed between the GBVMPO, the South Western Region MPO, the Housatonic Valley Council of Elected Officials, the New York Metropolitan Key Transportation Facilities Interstate Route 95 – Governor John Davis Lodge Turnpike. State Route 15 – Merritt Parkway. State Route 8 and State Route 25 Expressways. Principal Arterials – US Route 1, State Route 25, State Route 34, State Route 58, State Route 113, State Route 115, Main Street in Bridgeport and Pershing Drive in Ansonia. Interconnected Minor Arterials and Collector Roads – State Route 59, State Route 67, State Route 108, State Route 110, State Route 111, State Route 113, State Route 115, State Route 127, State Route 135, State Route 188, State Route 243, State Route 313, State Route 334, Bridgeport Avenue, Broadbridge Avenue, Constitution Boulevard, Daniels Farm Road, Fairfield Woods Road, Huntington Road, Huntington Street, Madison Avenue, and Park Avenue. GBT & Connecticut Transit – Local fixed-route bus services. GBT & Valley Transit District (VTD) – Specialized para – transit services for the elderly and disabled. Metro North Railroad Commuter Rail Service – New Haven Main Rail Line and Waterbury Branch Line Amtrak -Intercity and interstate passenger rail service. Bridgeport-Port Jefferson Steamship Company – Pas – senger and Auto Ferry Service. Bridgeport Harbor – Deepwater port. Sikorsky Memorial Airport – General aviation and charter operations Pequonnock River Trail, Naugatuck River Greenway, Derby Greenway, Ansonia Riverwalk and Shelton Riverwalk – Regional shared-use trail. Freight and goods movement – motor carriers, freight rail, waterborne shippers, air cargo and multi- modal shipments. Commuter Parking Lots – Located at limited access highway interchanges – I-95, State Route 8/25 & State Route 15, etc. I 2 I 2 I 2 I 2 I 2 I 2 I 2 I 2 I 2 I 2 I 2 I 2 I 2 I 2 ! ¿ ®q S helt o n E asto n F air fi eld M onro e T ru m bull Str atfo rd S eym our B rid gep o rt A nso nia D erb y ¯ Fa cilitie s ®q Airport ! ¿ F err y I 2 Tra in St atio n Com mute r Lot W ate rb ury Bra nchN ew H ave n R ail Lin eGBT Bu s R oute F ig ure I I-4 : T ra nsp ort atio n Sy ste m s, G re ate r Br id ge po rt R eg io n ¬ «5 8 ¬ «59 ¬ «136 ¬ «11 0 ¬ «25 ¬ «59 ¬ «11 1 ¬ «3 4 ¬ «188 ¬ «334 ¬ «313 ¬ «67 ¬ «8 ¬ «243 ¬ «11 5 ¬ «108 ¬ «15 ¬ «8 ¬ «11 1 ¬ «1 27 ¬ «15 ¬ «108 ¬ «127 ¬ «25 ¬ «8¬ «25 ¬ «59 ¬ «135 ¬ «130 ¬ «130 ¬ «11 3 ¬ «58 ¬ «15 £ ¤1 § ¨ ¦95 § ¨ ¦95 £ ¤1 § ¨ ¦95 F airf ie ld R ail St atio n F airf ie ld M etro R ail St atio n Bri dge po rt R ail St atio n W ate r St reet D ock F err y T e rm in a l St ratfo rd R ail St atio n Si ko rs ky M em oria l Ai rp ort So uth po rt R ail St atio n D erb y-S hle to n R ail St atio n An so n ia R ail St atio n Se ym ou r R ail St atio n Figure 1: Transportation Systems, GBVMPO 6 Transportation Council and the North Jersey Transportation Planning Authority that covers the voluntary coordination of transportation planning within the federally designated New York Metropolitan Transportation Management Area. As part of this MOU, these agencies exchange planning documents and meet to discuss transportation projects and programs affecting the entire area. The MOU was adopted in 2008. The Connecticut Department of Energy and Environmental Protection (CTDEEP) is the designated air quality planning agency in Connecticut. The GBVMPO and DEEP have an agreement in place that describes the respective roles and responsibilities for air quality related transportation planning in the Bridgeport-Stamford Urbanized Area. The GBVMPO is primarily responsible for providing policy di – rection on all aspects of the transportation planning process, as specified in federal transportation acts policies, rules and guidelines. These responsibilities include adopting and maintaining a LRTP and TIP. The TIP must be consistent with the goals and objectives of the LRTP. Both the LRTP and TIP must conform to air quality goals and advance the attainment of National Ambient Air Quality Standards for Ozone and fine particulate matter (PM2.5). The GBVMPO has adopted a proactive Public Participation Plan that provides an opportunity for the public to review and comment on MPO plans, programs and projects. We ensure that the transportation planning process is consis – tent with and conforms to Executive and US Department of Transportation orders on Environmental Justice, including identifying disadvantaged areas and households with limited English proficiency. Transportation Planning Process As the federally designated transportation planning agency for the Greater Bridgeport & Valley Metropolitan Planning Regions, GBVMPO conducts the transportation planning process in accordance with the “3-C Planning Process:” Continuing, Cooperative and Comprehensive. A “Continuing” process enables changes in the transportation system to be assessed, monitored and considered. A “Cooperative” process involves local, state and federal agencies, as well as the general public, in the development of transportation alternatives, soliciting input, achieving mutual support and considering community concerns. A “Comprehensive” pro – cess ensures that all transportation modes are considered, system impacts are assessed and recommended trans – portation projects relate to the surrounding environment. The process is guided by other federal regulations, such as MAP-21 and the FAST Act. The primary tasks of GBVMPO’s Transportation Planning Process are: • Prepare and update the Long Range Transportation Plan (LRTP) for the Region that reflects at least a 25- year horizon; • Develop, maintain and amend the short-term Transporta – tion Improvement Program (TIP) that allocates reasonably expected federal aid transportation funds for the next five years and work with CTDOT in implementing the E-STIP; • Monitor and assess highway system performance, including collection and analysis of transportation data; • Develop and maintain a regional Geographic Infor – mation System (GIS) and utilize advanced analytical techniques to support the planning process. • Maintain and mainstream the Regional ITS Architecture. • Implement a Congestion Management Process (CMP) Program. • Assess, evaluate and recommend opportunities for a multi-modal transportation system, including public transit, waterborne transportation, pedestrian safety and facilities, bicycle facilities and freight. • Identify and assess transportation options that promote environmental sustainability, safety and livable commu – nities. • Consult with various land use, zoning, environmental, conservation, and historic preservation agencies, airport operators and freight movement stakeholders. Greater Bridgeport & Valley Metropolitan Planning Organization: Greater Bridgeport Transit (GBT) Valley Transit District (VTD) Ansonia Bridgeport Derby Easton Fairfield Monroe Seymour Shelton Stratford Trumbull 7 • Provide technical assistance in coordinating human service transportation services and projects. • Provide technical assistance to member municipalities in assessing traffic operations and safety. • Assist GBT and VTD with development of the 10-year capital program, programming TIP projects, and in the planning, assessment and analysis of short-term and long term local bus service needs and operations. • Assist our municipalities in identifying, scoping and developing projects under the Surface Transporta – tion Program, Congestion Mitigation and Air Quality (CMAQ), Transportation Alternative Program (TAP) and other programs, as needed. • Assess and evaluate transportation security issues and needs, identify critical transportation infrastructure and participate in emergency planning and incident manage – ment activities. Transportation Planning Issues & Goals The transportation planning process will identify the Re – gion’s transportation concerns and issues. Many of the issues facing the Greater Bridgeport & Valley Metropolitan Planning Region are typical of other northeast corridor areas, that is, older facilities in need of repair or replace – ment, reducing peak hour congestion, increasing system capacity and addressing levels of service limitations and resource constraints for new or expanded transit services. The constraints of the Region’s physical and socio-eco – nomic resources influence its transportation systems and performance. However, it is important to preserve and maintain essential infrastructure and services, while mak – ing the system operate as efficiently as possible. It is also equally critical to enhance the mobility of people and goods by increasing choice, access and convenience, as well as selectively and strategically expanding transportation ca – pacity. Although the highway system dominates movement, non-highway components are equally important and provide alternative transportation services. A “balanced” transporta – tion system is the primary goal of the transportation planning process. The tasks, objectives and activities within the UPWP reflect the ten planning factors that federal legislation requires MPOs to consider. They are detailed in the box on the next page. The FHWA and FTA have also requested MPOs to address four emphasis areas in the UPWP: Climate Change and Resiliency: Work in cooperation with CTDOT and other state and local agencies to improve transportation system resiliency in the face of climate change, sea level rise, and severe storm events, and support the Department’s climate change and resiliency planning efforts. MAP-21 & FAST Act: Transition to Performance-based Planning and Programming: Develop and implement a performance management approach to transportation planning and programming that supports the achievement of transportation system performance outcomes. Models of Regional Planning: Promote cooperation and coordination across MPO boundaries and State bound – aries where appropriate to ensure a regional approach to transportation planning. Ladders of Opportunity: Access to Essential Services: As part of the transportation pla nning process, identify transportation connectivity gaps in accessing essential ser – vices. Essential services include employment, health care, schools/education, and recreation. These planning factors and emphasis areas provide a framework for the transportation planning process and for making transportation investment decisions. The following are goals and objectives in the Greater Bridgeport & Valley Metropolitan Planning Region: Preserve, Maintain and Enhance the Highway System – Maintain principal expressways and highway system in a state-of-good repair through lane continuity, minor widening, rehabilitation and reconstruction, as neces – sary to improve safety and operating efficiency and to selec – tively and strategically expand the capacity of key highways to reduce delay and congestion. Congestion Management – Alleviate congestion through the implementation of intersection improvements (turn lanes), traffic signal modernization and coordination, and Travel Demand Management (TDM) actions such as ridesharing, telecommuting and alternate work schedules. Safety – Improve the safety and efficiency of the highway network for both motorized and non-motorized users of the transportation system with appropriate transportation improvement projects. Security – Improve and expand overall security of trans – portation infrastructure for people using, on-board and/or waiting for transportation modes and services. 8 Advanced Technology – Improve the management of transportation operations, enhance safety and mobility, ensure greater reliability in travel times, and provide de – tailed, up-to-the-minute information to travelers and system operators through the application of various ITS actions. Preserve and Enhance Public Transportation Services – Maintain essential local bus, commuter rail and paratransit services by fully funding operations, replacing capital equipment on a life-cycle cost basis, renovating facilities and infrastructure to a state-of-good-repair, and enhancing services by optimizing the allocation of resources and coordinating the delivery of paratransit service. Multi-modal Opportunities – Expand and enhance opportunities for linking and connecting multiple modes and facilitate the movement between various transportation modes by constructing new multi-modal facilities and coordi – nating transit services. Bicycle and Pedestrian Activities – Encourage and promote the increased use of bicycling and walking as a mode of transportation while enhancing safety by develop – ing a network of shared-use trails and providing pedestrian walkways and features. Flexibility in Highway Design – Balance the needs for improving roads within the context of the surrounding area, develop transportation facilities that fit their physical setting and preserve scenic, aesthetic, historic and environ – mental resources, while improving safety and mobility. Environmental Mitigation – Implement actions that will mitigate and alleviate impacts to natural, cultural and environmental resources. Freight Movement – Implement actions and projects that diversify and improve how goods and freight are moved to, from and through the region. Aviation – Upgrade regional airports, such as Sikorsky Memorial Airport to a high quality, regional facility capable of supporting commuter airline services and meeting corporate needs, while enhancing safety. Sustainability – Develop a long range plan consistent with the Regional Plans of Conservation and Development (POCD), the state POCD, and local POCDs. Link local land use management, transportation improvements and livability initiatives. Economic Development – Improve transportation infra – structure critical to the economic revitalization of the Greater Bridgeport and Naugatuck Valley Regions. Air Quality Conformity – Support achieving the National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS), avoid adverse impacts on air quality, implement transportation control measures, reduce volatile organic compounds (VOC) and fine particulate material (PM2.5) emissions, and avoid increases to the frequency or severity of existing violations. The Planning Process & Program of Projects The LRTP reflects future transportation needs and identi – fies strategies to accommodate existing travel, improve the efficiency of the current transportation system, meet growing Planning Factors 1. Support the economic vitality of the metropolitan area, especially by enabling global competitive – ness, productivity, and efficiency. 2. Increase the safety of the transportation system for motorized and nonmotorized users. 3. Increase the security of the transportation system for motorized and nonmotorized users. 4. Protect and enhance the environment, promote energy conservation, improve the quality of life, and promote consistency between transportation improvements and State and local planned growth and economic development patterns. 5. Enhance the integration and connectivity of the transportation system, across and between modes, for people and freight. 6. Increase the accessibility and mobility of people and freight. 7. Promote efficient system management and oper – ation. 8. Emphasize the preservation of the existing trans – portation system. 9. Improve the resiliency and reliability of the trans – portation system and reduce or mitigate stormwa – ter impacts of surface transportation. 10. Enhance travel and tourism. 9 travel requirements and improve mobility. The LRTP is con – sistent with anticipated funding levels for both highway and transit improvements. Programs that are critical to the Region over the next five to ten years include: Commuter Rail: Enhance passenger amenities and parking availability at the MPO’s commuter rail stations. Continue to support improvements to Regional transporta – tion centers and expanded parking options in station areas, including improvements to the Waterbury Branch Line. Local Fixed-Route Bus Services: Focus on capital programming needs over the short term (TIP/STIP) and long term (10-year capital plan). Assess bus stop safety, ame – nities and accessibility. Enhance the transit layers in GIS. Support implementation of the long range transit plan. Paratransit Service Coordination: Assist Greater Bridge – port Transit and Valley Transit District and other public and private paratransit service operators to coordinate human service transportation services Multi-Modal Transportation Opportunities: Strengthen the connectivity and integration of the transpor – tation system by assessing alternative transportation modes along the New Haven and Waterbury rail lines, evaluating land parcels in the station vicinities, promoting mixed use development and updating the regional bicycle plan. Congestion Management Systems (CMS) Pro – cess: Monitor highway performance, identify the points and causes of congestion, determine travel speed and delay, and select priority corridors for detailed study. Recommend – ed improvement projects emphasize operational changes to better manage traffic flow, such as traffic signal revisions, left turn lanes and access management. Intelligent Transportation Systems (ITS): The regional ITS architecture provides a framework for deploying advanced technologies and projects. MetroCOG will contin – ue to work with GBVMPO municipalities to enhance traffic operations and install various advanced systems as needed. Multi-use Trails: Continue the development of the Pequonnock River Trail (PRT), Housatonic Greenway, Naugatuck River Greenway, Derby Greenway and the An – sonia and Shelton Riverwalk(s). The GBVMPO will continue to oversee expansion of the systems and identifying trail connections. Complete Streets: GBVMPO will continue to assist mu – nicipalities with preparing and implementing local complete streets plans, as well as a regional active transportation plan. These efforts continue the recent focus on imple – menting facilities for non-motorized transportation modes and promoting bicycle and pedestrian safety. GBVMPO will provide assistance in planning Safe Routes to School and with developing grant applications. Sustainability: Continue sustainable development planning efforts from past participation in the New York-Con – necticut Sustainable Communities Consortium and other efforts with a sustainability component, as well as planning related to the Sustainable CT program. Transportation Security: Assess transportation securi – ty issues and identify possible critical transportation infra – structure. Focus on transportation security and emergency management related to the DEMHS Emergency Planning Team(s). Freight Planning: Continue to integrate freight and goods movement into the transportation planning process and work with other transportation stakeholders in develop – ing better freight models and data. Continue to assess the possibility of a short sea container barge service between Bridgeport and the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey. Flexible Highway Design: Continue to promote the use of flexible highway design concepts (Context Sensitive Solutions) and principles in the design of highway projects. Encourage communities to implement access management to reduce conflicts and traffic calming strategies to reduce travel speeds. Environmental Mitigation: Assist project sponsors with assessing the potential environmental impacts of transportation improvement projects and encourage the implementation of measures to mitigate the impacts. The Conservation Technical Advisory Committee oversees environmental and conservation issues in the region and provides guidance on their relationship to the transportation system, including impacts due to coastal flooding, climate change and storm water management. Public Participation, Title VI, LEP & Environ – mental Justice: Continue utilizing inclusive public out – reach and participation strategies to ensure that no person is excluded from participation, denied benefits, or otherwise subjected to discrimination under any program or activity, on the basis of race, color, or national origin. 10 Task I: Data Collection, Analysis & Applications 1.1: Regional GIS Coordinate the maintenance of the Regional GIS Planimet – ric Basemap (planimetrics) developed through the 2012 Office of Policy and Managements Regional Performance Incentive Program grant award. Work with member munic – ipalities to develop funding mechanisms for this set of GIS data that is the basis for numerous transportation datasets. Continue to maintain and update parcel, right-of-ways, zon – ing, land cover (planimetrics) and land-use data to support parcel-level analyses, network analyses and the devel – opment of an activity based, land use and transportation model. Coordinate with CT DOT Central Surveys with the maintenance of GIS right-of-way datasets. Coordinate with member municipalities with the maintenance of local GIS parcel, right-of-way and zoning datasets. Develop parcel based land-use standardization process to develop regional land-use dataset. Develop an improved Regional municipal boundary dataset. Coordinate with member municipalities and CT DOT Central Surveys in mapping municipal boundaries. Municipal boundaries with improved accuracy are critical to numerous design, construction and safety programs. Create and maintain inundation features derived from 2016 CT LiDAR elevation dataset to support a resilient and reliable transportation system and to assess future vulnera – bilities/impacts; integrate real-time tidal gauge data into the regional GIS web application for emergency preparedness and evacuation monitoring. Maintain data on significant conservation areas, sensitive habitats and protected open space to identify opportunities Objectives: • Continue to maintain and enhance the Regional GIS program and GIS capabilities to support integrated land use and transportation models. • Support comprehensive transportation planning by including demographic, land use, economic development, conservation, public safety, envi – ronmental, natural hazard data and other base – mapping in the Regional GIS. • Maintain and update transportation assets and transportation data, across all modes (vehic – ular, bus, rail, pedestrian, bicycle, freight, etc) into a standardized, regional GIS; utilize data to enhance the integration and connectivity of the transportation system and to analyze and report on transportation systems use, mobility and safety. • Support performance-based planning and main – tain performance measures and target data. • Serve municipalities, the region, state agencies and other COGs by acting as a clearinghouse for GIS best practices and data (Models of Regional Planning). Work within state professional GIS and related organizations to develop and main – tain data standards relevant to Regional and Transportation GIS programs. • Develop and maintain a travel demand model; use advanced traffic modeling software in con – junction with GIS to assess projected land uses in the region, identify major growth corridors and analyze related transportation improvements. • Maintain a GIS database of all local, regional, state, and federal transportation and transit infra – structure projects. • Inform the public by presenting data and spatial analyses through maps, online and mobile map – ping applications, Story Maps, infographics and other innovative visualization methods. 11 to reduce or mitigate the stormwater impacts of surface transportation and potential trail linkages. Coordinate with member municipalities and CT DOT Envi – ronmental Planning with the mapping elements of the CT DEEP MS4 permit. Stormwater infrastructure, system interconnections, directly connected impervious areas and outfall catchment areas are included in the mapping ele – ments. Integrate census data and other Federally developed GIS data to inform the transportation planning process. 1.2: Transportation GIS Maintain roadway geometry, roadway assets and travel data as part of the Regional GIS: • Coordinate with CT DOT planning in the maintenance of the statewide roadway network. Work with the Depart – ment of Public Safety to align the 911 road database with the CT DOT roadway network. • Maintain and incorporate Rights-of-Way data into local parcel data. • Continue to develop intersection database for intersec – tions not included in the already migrated Traffic Signal Evaluation and Management Study. • Link CTDOT bridge safety reports within CT DOT ProjectWise system into the bridge features within the Regional GIS. • Identify capital expenditures on local roads and integrate data into the regional GIS. • Use the 2013 and 2016 aerial imagery to continue to develop and maintain the parking GIS dataset. • Utilize CTDOT’s Congestion Management Process, transportation datasets and ITS to assess and report on safety and congestion management issues. • Increase the security of the transportation system by integrating critical facilities, security plans and state and federal traffic diversion plans (in consultation with CTDOT and local EOC and Law Enforcement). Develop GIS datasets to support the Regional Transporta – tion Safety Plan: • Integrate detailed traffic data to analyze transporta – tion system usage and assess opportunities for safety improvements. • Utilize accident data from the CT Crash Data Repository to identify hotpots and high risk areas. Continue to support and compile transit data and assets into the Regional GIS: • Maintain and update route alignments, service areas, stop locations, amenities and ADA facilities. • Integrate census, employment and business data to support GBT’s Title VI Program and Ladders of Oppor – tunity. • Develop a transit demand model to evaluate existing local bus route performance and assess future service improvements. • Develop and utilize a transit needs assessment model; integrate ridership data to spatially identify attractors, generators, barriers and constraints to transit services and to identity gaps in access to essential services. • Leverage GIS for advanced analysis during the imple – mentation of regional transit ITS infrastructure develop – ment. Continue to support and compile active transportation data and assets into the Regional GIS: • Maintain the location of trails, routes and facilities. • Integrate pedestrian and bicyclist counts. • Conduct a pedestrian and bicycle suitability analysis by identifying existing data to represent attractors, genera – tors and barriers. • Maintain the multimodal network, with a focus on transit and other high traffic facilities. Incorporate ADA Ramps, other ADA compliant features and various pedestrian infrastructure. Continue to utilize the Regional GIS for freight planning: • Work with CTDOT and other stakeholders to compile a freight inventory, including an inventory of existing conditions, barriers, connections (or needed connec – tions) between various modes of freight and redundancy routes. • Integrate as a layer in the Regional GIS to support anal – ysis, identification of improvements and performance measures. • Use GIS to inform current and potential future freight movement within the region. Develop any GIS data necessary to accomplish this. • Work with CTDOT, NYDOT, NJDOT and TRANSCOM to monitor and assess the movement of freight and to improve analyses tools and models. Develop a regional Travel Demand Model to assess system performance, determine highway operations and congestion, forecast trip patterns based on existing and future land uses, 12 analyze transportation impacts from TOD scenarios and assess the effectiveness of alternate transportation modes. Integrate travel data (counts and turning movements) into the regional GIS; update with data generated from local, regional and state managed transportation planning projects and corridor studies. Integrate parcel level data, land use, and census data to support activity based modeling. Assess traffic operations, performance and patterns to determine existing and future operating conditions. Coordinate with regional businesses to refine commuting data. Work with CTDOT to assess highway performance and include statewide travel assumptions. Coordinate with Councils of Governments, transit agencies and the New York Metropolitan Transportation Council for compatibility among travel demand models. 1.3: Data Collection Roadway and Vehicular data collection: • Collect traffic count, turning movements, speed and vehi – cle classification data as needed for program and project studies and incorporate into transportation GIS dataset). • Monitor highway performance and operations, includ – ing delay and travel time using virtual techniques and outside vendors, consistent with CTDOT congestion management procedures and as needed. Incorporate and compile monthly NPMRDS data from HERE into GIS data layers, analysis and reporting. Utilize accident data from the Connecticut Crash Data Re – pository and local police departments to inform the Regional Transportation Safety Plan and other plans and projects as needed. Provide CT DOT with local and regional travel data to assist with developing VMT’s. Transit data collection: • Continue to coordinate transit data collection and analysis with Greater Bridgeport Transit, including bus ridership data from GBT’s CAD/AVL system – daily, monthly by route; develop enhanced access queries for reporting and assessment of operations. • Conduct field surveys and inventory of bus stops and transit amenities. • Inventory and survey New Haven mainline stations and structures. Active Transportation data collection: • Monitor bicycle and pedestrian activity on trails. • Survey the condition of the sidewalk network and other active transportation facilities (locations to be deter – mined) • Monitor usage of various active transportation facilities (locations to be determined). Freight data collection: • Work with CTDOT and other stakeholders to identify data collection needs. • Work with CTDOT, outside vendors and stakeholders to identify sources of freight data, monitoring freight perfor – mance and data collection procedures. • Conduct regional inventory of freight assets, including but not limited to road system, rail, major freight gen – erators, and origin/destination of regional freight, as recommended in the 2014 Federal recertification review. • Obtain and compile basic data on freight movement and facilities in the Region through CTDOT’s statewide dataset and other secondary sources. Parking Counts: • At locations specified by CTDOT and on a quarterly basis, collect commuter parking lot usage data within ArcGIS Online. • Assist municipalities with collecting parking patterns and behaviors, as needed. • Track rail commuter lot usage, parking patterns and permit usage in local transportation centers. • As necessary, collect parking counts around trail areas. Collect performance measure data, as required by the FAST Act, MAP-21 and CTDOT. Refine data collection processes: • Create a standardization system and manuals that out – line data collection methods for the region that address classifications, collection systems, and other elements like metadata formatting; provide databases to all mem – ber municipalities. • Develop automated tools for data collection to support seamless upload into the Regional GIS. • Continue to require consulting firms to provide GIS data collected through studies and projects in a standard format for upload into the Regional GIS. 13 1.4: Intelligent Transportation Systems (ITS) Update and maintain the regional ITS architecture for the Greater Bridgeport Region. Continue development of an Archived Database Manage – ment system and ITS Data Warehouse and link to Regional GIS; provide opportunities for public access and interaction. Provide technical assistance to adjacent regions and transit districts, as requested, in the development of a multi-region ITS architecture. Coordinate and collaborate with TRANSCOM on the imple – mentation of region specific ITS notifications. 1.6: Performance Monitoring & Metrics Evaluate the condition and performance of the transporta – tion system. Coordinate with CTDOT in setting performance measures and targets and on MAP 21 and FAST Act transition to per – formance based planning and programming. Explore the opportunity of acquiring “big data” from a third party vendor to develop transportation metrics. Monitor the operating characteristics of the region’s transit services. Including local bus and paratransit/dial-a-ride services – expenditures, fares, revenues, deficits, ridership, frequency and bus route performance. Monitor the operating characteristics of passenger and freight rail service, with emphasis on the interface between rail and other modes, including parking, transit, bicycle, pedestrian facilities, and truck freight Identify transportation systems connectivity gaps. Link investment priorities to achieve performance targets. 1.7: Data Clearinghouse, Sharing & Coordination Collaborate with state agencies, MPOs, transit agencies and TransCOM on data collection, storage, analysis, analytical tools, performance monitoring and measures and the devel – opment of a data sharing platform. Establish Open Data Portal on ArcGIS Online to facilitate the sharing of MetroCOG Regional and Transportation GIS datasets. Continue ongoing regional GIS consortium services where cities and member agencies share costs, leverage econo – mies of scale, optimize resources, and develop standardized data collection methods. Provide FHWA, FRA and FTA with more accurate locations of bridges, railroad crossings and other GIS elements to update the National Transportation Atlas Database. CTDOT Coordination: • Assist CTDOT in obtaining information from local munic – ipalities to complete the 536 Reports on capital expendi – tures on local roads. Products: • Regional base map • Regional, multi-modal transportation GIS • Interactive maps on website (Story Maps, Web Maps, & Web Applications) • Traffic Counts, turning movements, data summa – ry reports, traffic volume and travel time profiles as part of the Transportation GIS dataset • Transportation system data clearinghouse • Travel demand model • Performance measures • Freight inventory • Regional Economic Development Database • Brownfields Inventory • Congestion Management Process • 536 Report on local road improvements • Coordinated MS4 Mapping elements 14 Fiscal Year 2018 Fiscal Year 2019 Task 1 Q1 Jul-Sept Q2 Oct-Dec Q3 Jan-Mar Q4 Apr-Jun Q1 Jul-Sept Q2 Oct-Dec Q3 Jan-Mar Q4 Apr-Jun Regional GIS Transpotation GIS Data Collection Intelligent Transportation System (ITS) Data Clearinghouse, Sharing & Coordination Geospatial Technical Advisory Committee (GTAC) Data Collection, Analysis & Applications Schedule • Provide all transportation data collected through projects and planning studies to CTDOT’s Bureau of Policy and Planning. • Assist CTDOT with revisions to and updates of its Land Use Forecast files and major new development file. • Coordinate with CTDOT to integrate all transportation improvements projects into regional GIS database. • Coordinate with CTDOT to integrate Right-of-Way data into local parcel datasets. • Coordinate with Municipalities and CTDOT regarding the MS4 Program. 1.7: Geospatial Technical Advisory Committee (GTAC) Convene and hold quarterly meetings of the Geospatial Technical Advisory Committee (GTAC) to guide development and expansion of the Regional GIS Program. Provide coordination, support services and technical assis – tance, as necessary, to the GTAC. Involve various interested stakeholder groups. 15 2.1: Multi-Modal Transportation System Investment & Project Development Establish and refine transportation system priorities (across all modes) that align with major growth corridors and project – ed, sustainable land uses. Conduct a Regional Growth Analysis to assess the perfor – mance of the existing and future transportation network. Serve as the liaison between CTDOT and member munici – palities to identify capital and operational improvements and priority projects that will preserve and improve the existing transportation system. Develop, select, scope and evaluate projects for funding under the FHWA’s Surface Transportation Program for the Bridgeport-Stamford Urbanized Area (STP-BS), Transporta – tion Alternatives Program (TAP), and Congestion Mitigation and Air Quality (CMAQ) program, as well as funding under the state’s Local Transportation Capital Improvement Pro – gram (LOTCIP) and temporary programs. Assist member municipalities with determining project eligibility, project development, regional review, prioritization and monitoring local project schedules for state and federal programs. Coordinate with municipalities, GBT, VTD and other stake – holders to develop strategies that focus on mobility, safety and connectivity within the multi-modal transportation system. Identify opportunities to leverage funding streams in support of regionally significant projects. Once projects are selected for funding, work with the spon – sors, as necessary, to ensure continued advancement of the projects. 2.2: Transportation Safety Develop a Regional Transportation Safety Plan that ad – dresses all transportation modes: • Incorporate recommendations from CTDOT’s State Highway Safety Plan into the Regional Transportation – Safety Plan. • Maintain consistency with the Long Range Transporta – tion Plan and other regional plans that address transpor – tation safety. • Analyze crash data and utilize GIS to locate hotspot areas to determine regional safety trends and issues. • Create metrics to identify and assess high hazard acci – dent locations by tabulating crash data and contributing factors. Establish base line performance and update regularly to evaluate safety improvements. • Utilize the Regional Transportation Safety Plan to initiate a regional safety improvement program and identify low cost, effective measures to reduce crash frequency and severity. As recommended in the 2014 Federal recertification review, assist member municipalities with the identification of safety needs and safety improvement projects on local roads in the region. Continue to distribute information about state and federal funding opportunities for transportation safety improve – ments, training, technical assistance, and data analysis, such as the Community Connectivity, Local Road Accident Reduction and Safe Routes to School Programs. Provide application and project development assistance as needed. Task II: Multi-Modal Transportation Planning 16 2.3: Roadways & Congestion Management Process Assess the highway network, evaluate operational and man – agement strategies and identify reasonable improvements to improve the performance of the existing transportation system. Use and follow the Congestion Management Process (CMP) developed in FFY 2007 to monitor congestion and highway system performance. The CMP reflects the six congestion management process elements: • Determine the CMP network in the region for both the highway and transit networks; • Define congestion – parameters and thresholds; • Identify congestion trends and congested links in the region using CTDOT’s congestion screening report; • Develop geometric, operational and travel demand-re – lated strategies to address congested links. • Identify short and long term strategies in the LRTP and TIP; implement as opportunities and funding are made available. Objectives: • Preserve the existing transportation system, maintain a state of good repair and improve access to and connec – tivity between all modes of transportation. • Identify and encourage strategies that will improve the safety, security and resiliency of the transportation system through the development of a Regional Transportation Safety Plan. • Identify transportation system improvements and investments that could reduce roadway congestion, vehicle miles travelled and emissions, and freight delays, especially along I-95, Routes 15, 8 and 25, and other major corridors. • Support the public transit system and further livable communities by advancing context sensitive projects to improve safety, reliability, efficiency, accessibility and integration with the overall transportation network. • Support ladders of opportunity and assess connectivity gaps in the transportation systems, especially as it may impact access to essential services and employment opportunities. • Promote active transportation plans, policies and projects that improve livability, public health and the walkability and bikeability of the Region’s urban and suburban areas. • Foster compact development patterns and leverage key transit nodes in ex isting city and town centers to create walkable, mixed-use/mixed income districts that serve as “transit oriented development nodes.” • Align land use and transportation planning: promote consistency between transportation improvements, employ – ment, major growth corridors, projected land use, brownfields revitalization and historic preservation. • Mitigate transportation system impacts on stormwater management, natural resources and air quality by inte – grating NEPA/CEPA, conservation considerations and low impact development in the transpo rtation planning process. • Strengthen the resiliency of the transportation system to natural hazards. • Identify context-sensitive non-motorized linkages within and between communities, greenways and trails, parks, recreation areas, open space and the region’s waterfront. • Develop and maintain short and long term transportation plans, including the Long Range Transportation Plan, Transportation Improvement Program, and POCD. • Develop and implement a performance management approach to the transportation planning and programming process that supports the achievement of performance targets. 17 • Monitor the highway and transit networks and assess data to determine if any implemented improvements have resulted in reductions in congestion. Assess congestion management performance measures and coordinate with CTDOT to develop targets. Encourage and support strategic circulation improvements that can reduce local roadway inefficiencies, such as pro – viding cross access points, sharing parking lots, adding bus turnouts, implementing traffic circles, and adding/consolidat – ing turn lanes. Continue to cooperate with CTDOT on various congestion management systems, such as evaluating the need for high – way widening, congestion pricing, and/or the establishment HOV lanes to encourage carpooling. Prepare CMP strategy reports that include regional and multimodal options. As recommended in the 2014 Federal recertification review, continue to coordinate CMP activities with all MPOs in the Bridgeport-Stamford Urbanized Area and CTDOT in order to produce a united, TMA-wide effort in congestion manage – ment, including data-sharing and development of mutual objectives and performance measures. 2.4: Local Bus Technical Assistance Provide technical assistance to GBT and VTD to plan for system wide and paratransit services, seamless connections between all modes of transportation and operational and capital improvements. Assist GBT and VTD with revising and updating its various capital financial plans and 10-year capital improvement program; assist with securing funding to implement priority projects and incorporate projects into the TIP/STIP. Work with GBT and VTD to establish and refine region – al transit priorities that will be used to determine project scopes, prepare applications and evaluate proposals. Once projects are selected for funding, work to ensure continued advancement of the projects. Evaluate bus connections to rail services, intermodal facili – ties, intercity bus service and commuter van pools. Assist with maintaining, updating and measuring the prog – ress of GBT’s Long Range Transit Plan and Alternative Modes Assessment. Integrate priority recommendations into the LRTP. The purpose of the plan is to: • Support system-wide planning and to assess the needs and opportunities for service expansion options beyond GBT’s base service levels, long term fleet requirements and long range capital needs. • Determine and identify alternative approaches to deliver improved public transit services. • Assess land use projections and major growth corridors when considering bus service adjustments. • Coordinate implementation and maintenance of the two plans. Assess service gaps, identify opportunities to enhance service and improve the coordination of inter-regional and intra-regional transit services. Work with GBT, VTD, NVCOG and communities along the Waterbury Branch line to enhance coordination between local bus services and rail schedules, ensure adequate service access and improve the transit experience along the Route 8 corridor. Work with GBT, CTDOT and adjacent transit districts in programming and implementing recommendations from the Coastal Corridor bus study and the Route 1 Bus Rapid Transit study. In support of “Ladders of Opportunity”, identify connectivity gaps in access to essential services and plan for short and long term solutions. Essential services include housing, employment, health care, education and recreation. Provide technical assistance, support and coordination ser – vices, as needed, for local and regional transit advisory com – mittees, public officials and non-profit transportation providers. Provide technical and planning assistance to the VTD to evaluate system needs, assess bus stop, shelter and sign amenities, and determine service gaps and opportunities; and coordinate bus maintenance needs by assisting in proj – ect scoping, development and evaluation. 2.5: Bus Stop Safety, Amenities & Accessibility Assess the safety of bus passengers throughout the system: at bus stop locations before they board a bus and after they exit. Identify physical features that pose safety concerns and 18 physical impediments to accessibility. Evaluate pedestrian paths to and from the bus stop. Identify bus stops that are not properly served by sidewalks and crosswalks, and work to fill gaps in the network. Assess ADA facilities, bus stop amenities, assets and fea – tures, including curbs, wheelchair ramps, signs, shelter and condition. Identify needed improvements and changes, as well as sources of funding to support improvements. These include reconstruction of the curb and bus stop area, relocation of the bus stop, removal of on-street parking spaces, sidewalk enhancements and removal of obstructions. Assess opportunities for satellite transfer centers. Through the Transit Design Guidelines project, develop model bus stop parameters that can be applied to locations throughout the system. Improve non-motorized mobility between bus stops and rail stations to ensure seamless connections between all modes of transportation. 2.6: Human Service Transportation Coordination Planning Provide technical assistance to municipalities, GBT, VTD and other stakeholders with coordinating elderly and dis – abled transit services and programs and planning for human services transportation. Continue to work closely with CTDOT, GBT, VTD, SCRCOG, WestCOG, other transit districts and municipal human service transportation providers on updating and maintaining the LOCHSTP plan for the Bridgeport-Stamford urban area: • Funding for elderly persons and persons with disabilities and grants to provide specialized transportation services for getting disabled persons to jobs; • Transit enhancements to better serve suburban employ – ment centers; • Identify gaps in human service transportation; • Enhance existing services and propose new strategies to fill in gaps. Continue to participate on the human service transportation coordination subcommittee (LOCHSTP). Coordinate grant applications from the Region’s municipal – ities and paratransit providers to the FTA’s Section 5310 program. Coordinate grant applications to the state’s Municipal Match – ing Grant program for senior and disabled demand respon – sive transportation. 2.7: Commuter Rail Facilities Evaluate Waterbury branch line and New Haven main line structures, amenities, information kiosks, parking and station platforms to determine future improvements and identify funding mechanisms. Assist the City of Bridgeport on the Intermodal Transpor – tation Center project and the development of a second rail station in Bridgeport’s East Side (Barnum Station). Assess bicycle and pedestrian linkages and facilities in station areas; develop strategies to improve the safety and accessibility of local non-motorized connections to rail sta – tions, especially from bus stops. Identify and secure funds necessary for improvements. Monitor, evaluate and develop strategies to address com – muter rail parking needs. Develop plans to implement station-area parking enhancements, such as shared parking and commuter van service from “park and ride” lots. Monitor and review Tier 1 Final EIS documents and rec – ommendations for the NEC Future planning program and provide comments, as needed. Work with CTDOT in advancing and programming long term Waterbury Branch Line improvements and enhancements, specifically the planned positive train control, signal system design and passing sidings. 2.8: Transit Oriented Development Partner with the State, municipalities and transit providers to leverage rail stations in Bridgeport, Fairfield, and Stratford to drive new transit-oriented residential development targeted at commuters. Target major transportation corridors and key transit nodes in existing regional and town centers to create livable, mixed-use 19 developments at a density that can be accommodated by the existing transit system (or in the short to mid-term). Assess opportunities for the construction of affordable hous – ing units within TOD target areas. Encourage pedestrian oriented, complimentary building design and streetscape improvements by identifying best practices for zoning regulations and design guidelines. The Regional Model TOD guidelines can be utilized as a frame – work. Identify transportation improvements that will support physical, social and economic linkages between educational institutions, employers, businesses, innovation districts and incubators. Identify resources, such as federal and state funding, grants and public private partnership opportunities to incentivize and/or stimulate mixed-use transit-oriented development in suitable locations. Investigate alternative transportation modes to harness public transit and create livable communities, promote safe, livable communities, and environmental sustainability, and determine the strategies and actions to enhance and facilitate north- south travel along the Route 8 corridor and the Waterbury Branch Line and link commuter rail stations and associated transit oriented and supportive districts in the region. 2.9: Active Transportation Planning Continue to assist in developing a comprehensive, coordi – nated regional trail network, including the Pequonnock River Trail, Housatonic River Greenway and the Naugatuck River Greenway, with future linkages to the East Coast Greenway and Merritt Parkway Trail. Continue to provide technical assistance to municipalities on implementing bicycle route networks (on and off-road), including assessing and evaluating proposed routes, project scoping, project design approach and ensuring consistency with guidelines and standards. Continue to work with partnering communities in the estab – lishment of local “complete streets” policies to safely and equitably accommodate motorists, pedestrians, and bicy – clists on appropriate roadways: • Fill gaps in the sidewalk network. • Connect neighborhoods to parks, civic uses, commercial areas, and schools. Work with the City of Bridgeport and Towns of Monroe and Trumbull in implementing and connecting an uninterrupted, primarily off-road, Pequonnock River Trail. • Public engagement, including the PRT website. • Coordination with CTDOT, municipalities and advisory committees. • Assisting with CMAQ fund administration, and other funding sources, as needed. • Implementing the signage plan. • Identify possible locations for off-street parking and opportunities for shared parking. • Coordinate with the Town of Trumbull on implementing PRT Visitors Center. Assist CTDOT and municipalities in developing, implement – ing and maintaining plans for active transportation and Com – plete Streets, including the State Bicycle Plan, Fairfield’s Bicycle and Pedestrian Plan and Bridgeport’s Complete Streets Plan. Link local parks and open spaces by expanding local trail systems that connect to the regional trail network. Integrate low impact development best practices in active transportation facilities. Assess how regional and long-distance trails connect to multi-modal transportation facilities. Update the Regional Bicycle Plan to include pedestrian and trail planning for a “Regional Active Transportation Plan.” Work with the Cities of Derby and Ansonia and the Town of Seymour in implementing and connecting an uninterrupted, primarily off-road, Naugatuck River Greenway. • Public engagement, including the NRG website. • Coordination with municipalities and the NRG Steering Committee. • Implement and install signage in accordance to the Uniform Signage Design Manual. 2.10: Freight Planning Work with CTDOT in the development of a statewide freight plan, as recommended in the 2014 Federal recertification review. Identify major freight issues and data collection needs. Consider all modes of freight (vehicular, rail, air and mar – itime) in the transportation planning process and identify opportunities for intermodal connections. 20 2.11: Aviation, Maritime & Traditional & High Speed Ferry Planning Support and help identify funding for investments for Sikorsky Airport and Bridgeport Harbor to increase utilization and enhance the economic competitiveness of the region. Assist Sikorsky Airport in planning for and identifying improvements and funding to support commuter airline services, meet corporate needs, and enhance safety, as requested. Continue to work with the Connecticut and Bridgeport Port Authorities, as needed, on implementing high-speed ser – vices from Bridgeport and other points in Connecticut to New York City. 2.12: Environmental Protection Air Quality Conformity: • Submit Long Range Transportation Plan and Transpor – tation Improvement Plan project lists to CTDOT for con – formity determination; respond to comments as needed. • Attend the Interagency Consultation Group meeting and submit concurrence form. • Review and assess the results and findings of regional emissions analyses performed by CTDOT. • Facilitate the 30-day public review by publishing CT – DOT’s analyses to the website, providing copies upon request and addressing any public comments. • Approve and adopt (GBVMPO) the CTDOT air quality conformity determinations for Ozone and PM2.5 and forward determinations to CTDOT. • For TIP/STIP amendments found to be non-exempt, follow the transportation conformity process. Identify actions to mitigate the potential environmental im – pacts of transportation projects, including stormwater man – agement and climate change, per MAP-21 and FAST Act. Link the transportation planning and the NEPA processes. Identify the purpose and need for the action, assess alterna – tives, and eliminate actions that are not feasible. Coordinate and undertake planning activities necessary to address critical environmental issues, including air and water quality, flooding, and contaminated brownfield sites. Identify green infrastructure elements that can be incorporat – ed into transportation projects to reduce and manage storm water runoff and reduce pollution. Target brownfield assessment and cleanup funding to sites along transportation corridors with the greatest potential for redevelopment and reuse. Assess the impact of future transportation system improve – ments on the redevelopment and reuse potential of brown – field properties. Perform a greenhouse gas inventory to assess the environ – mental impacts of the transportation system. Throughout the transportation planning process, identify sensitive natural areas and protect regional assets, such as local watersheds, riparian zones, pollinators, regional water supplies, and wetlands, while promoting an integrated network of park and recreation areas throughout the Region. 2.13: Intelligent Transportation System (ITS) Planning As recommended in the 2014 Federal recertification re – view, maintain and update the regional ITS architecture, as necessary. Utilize the ITS architecture to assess performance, effective – ness and the need for future improvements. Utilize ITS infrastructure as a tool for disseminating emer – gency management information throughout the region. Identify and assess ITS to support real time notifications to transit users and to enhance passenger security. Consider real-time integration with the GBT’s CAD/AVL system to pro – vide arrival and departure times and available connections between providers. Work with the city of Bridgeport, GBT, CTDOT and other agencies on scoping and implementing advanced ITS concepts and early deployment actions, such as regional commuter rail station parking and event operations in Down – town Bridgeport. ITS Coordination: • Provide technical assistance to adjacent regions and transit districts, as requested, in the development of a 21 multi-region ITS architecture. • Work with GBT to identify ITS infrastructure improve – ments, funding sources and opportunities to integrate the ITS of other transit providers. • Work with the Federal DOT, CTDOT, NYS DOT, Metro North and transit agencies to implement transit and transportation linked ITS infrastructure, especially coor – dination between the highway system and Metro-North railroad. • Coordinate and collaborate with TransCOM on the implementation of ITS notifications. 2.14: Performance Measures & Modeling Coordinate with CTDOT in developing policies, performance measures and performance targets for the multi-modal transportation system, that align with the goals of MAP-21 and the FAST Act. Utilize travel demand modeling and high quality GIS data to assess transportation system performance. Collect required performance metric data and identify perfor – mance targets that relate to this data. 2.15: Long Range Transportation Plan A major update of the Long Range Transportation Plan will occur in FY 2019. The current LRTP, adopted in 2015, will expire in May 2019. Plan development will be guided by the MPO, TTAC, NVCOG and MetroCOG’s public involvement procedures and will be consistent with federal requirements. MetroCOG will coordinate with NVCOG to consolidate the proposed transportation improvements for the Valley com – munities into the GBVMPO LRTP. The LRTP update will incorporate: • Long and short range strategies for an integrated, multi-modal transportation system • Current and projected travel demand over a 20 year planning horizon • Existing and proposed transportation facilities that func – tion as an integrated metropolitan transportation system. • Performance measures, performance targets, a system performance report and progress in meeting perfor – mance targets. • Operational and management strategies • Congestion management process • Assessment of strategies to preserve the transportation infrastructure • Transportation and transit enhancement activities • Environmental mitigation • Descriptions of all existing and proposed transportation facilities • Pedestrian and bicycle facilities • Projects of regional and statewide significance. • GBT’s capital improvement plan. • The Strategic Highway Safety Plan • An assessment of the vulnerability of the transportation system to natural hazards, and strategies to increase resiliency. • “Illustrative projects” that can be implemented if excess revenues are available. • Financial resources and funding sources to implement recommendations. Maintain the LRTP and utilize performance measures to assess transportation system improvements. As recommended in the 2014 Federal recertification review and in order to maintain and enhance the 3C joint planning process in the Bridgeport-Stamford urbanized area, consider evaluating the possibility of jointly developing and integrating the LRTP across the TMA region. 2.16: Transportation Improvement Program (TIP) Develop, amend and maintain a short range Transportation Improvement Program (TIP) that is financially constrained and consistent with the Long Range Transportation Plan and State Transportation Improvement Program (STIP). The 2018-2021 TIP must be approved by October of 2017. Review, approve and record Administrative Actions. Develop a database format to maintain projects, amend – ments and actions, preferably based on CTDOT’s E-STIP framework. Link the database to GIS and maintain an inter – active map for website. 22 Revise financial plans and prepare reports to inform GBVM – PO members of proposed amendments and changes to the TIP/STIP. As recommended in the 2014 Federal recertification review and in order to maintain and enhance the 3C joint planning process in the Bridgeport-Stamford urbanized area, consider evaluating the possibility of jointly developing and integrating the TIP across the TMA region. 2.17: Transportation Technical Advisory Committee (TTAC) Expand the TTAC to include all member towns within the GBVMPO. Hold quarterly meetings of the Transportation Technical Advisory Committee to provide face-to-face opportunities for local engineers and planners to discuss and exchange ideas regarding transportation issues, deficiencies and solutions. Meetings are held prior to GBVMPO/COG meetings or as necessary. Review amendments to the federal Transportation Improve – ment and state Local Transportation Capital Improvement programs and offer prioritization and advisory recommenda – tions to the GBVMPO member towns. Provide coordination, support services and technical assis – tance to the TTAC. 2.18: Models of Regional Planning & CTDOT Coordination Ensure a regional approach to transportation planning by promoting cooperation and coordination across MPO bound – aries and across state boundaries, where appropriate. Increase cooperation between state, regional, and local governments in identifying, funding, and implementing major infrastructure investments. Coordinate with CTDOT, adjacent MPOs, CTDEEP, OPM, DECD and other stakeholder agencies, as necessary, on various transportation plans, programs, initiatives, corridor studies and projects. Coordinate transportation planning activities in the Con – necticut, New York, New Jersey Metropolitan Area through participation in the MAP Forum. As recommended in the 2014 Federal recertification review, work with SWRMPO to maintain a 3C joint planning process for the Bridgeport-Stamford urbanized area. Continue to strengthen the 3C planning process by considering the coor – dination of data collection, analysis, and planning assump – tions across the TMA, and by identifying regional planning documents that are appropriate for joint development and integration across the TMA region. Understand local, regional and state concerns among a range of stakeholders through consultation with various eco – nomic development, land use management, environmental resources, environmental protection, conservation, security, emergency management and historic preservation agencies, airport operators and freight stakeholders. Products: • Long Range Transportation Plan • Regional Transportation Safety Plan • Transportation Improvement Program, amend – ments and actions • Congestion Management Process • Multimodal Planning • Regional Plan of Conservation and Development • Regional Active Transportation Plan • Local Complete Streets Plans • Transit Oriented Development Plans • Natural Hazard Mitigation Plan • Performance Measures • Air Quality Conformity • Transportation and Land Use Model/Growth Management Strategy • Capital Needs Planning • Intelligent Transit Systems • Ladders of Opportunity • Coordinated Public Transit Human Services Transportation Plans 23 2.19: Staff Development Maintain and enhance the professional and technical capabil – ities of staff through attendance in CTDOT/FHWA sponsored courses and local, regional and national conferences regard – ing transportation, land use, conservation, natural hazard mitigation, economic development and brownfields planning. Maintain and increase proficiency in GIS, transportation and traffic engineering software and analytical applications. 2.20: Policy Monitor and review federal Notices of Proposed Rulemak – ing (NPRM) related to the transportation planning process and offer comments and recommendations, as appropriate, including but not limited to MPO coordination, performance – measures, transit planning, and transportation performance – management rules. Establish and refine regional transportation policies. 24 Fiscal Year 2018 Fiscal Year 2019 Task 2 Q1 Jul-Sept Q2 Oct-Dec Q3 Jan-Mar Q4 Apr-Jun Q1 Jul-Sept Q2 Oct-Dec Q3 Jan-Mar Q4 Apr-Jun Multi-Modal Transportation System Investment & Project Development Transportation Safety Roadways & Congestion Management Process Local Bus Technical Assistance Bus Stop Safety, Amenities & Accessibility Human Service Transportation Coordination Planning Commuter Rail Facilities Transit Oriented Development Active Transportation Planning Freight Planning Aviation, Maritime and Traditional and High Speed Ferry Planning Environmental Protection Intelligent Transportation System (ITS) Planning Performance Measures & Modeling Long Range Transportation Plan Transportation Improvement Program Transportation Technical Advisory Committee Models of Regional Planning & CTDOT Coordination Policy Staff Development Multi-Modal Transportation Planning Schedule 25 Task III: Technical Assistance 3.1: Local Technical Assistance Program Assist member municipalities with the STP-Urban, CMAQ, TAP, TIGER, LOTCIP and other transportation related fund – ing programs. • Ensure project consistency with regional priorities, local goals and the congestion management process. • Develop capital and operating plans consistent with available funding levels. • Solicit new project proposals for funding and provide technical assistance in determining project eligibility, preparing applications and evaluating proposals. • Prepare and revise financial plans. • Review CTDOT’s obligation plans and commitment letters. • Recommend changes in program schedules to ensure financially constrained programs and assess regional fairshares. • Participate in the CTDOT Project Concept Review pro – cess and Capital planning meetings. • Work with sponsors to ensure continued advancement of projects and to monitor schedules. • Monitor announcements and updates for various funding programs. • Identify regionally beneficial projects and opportunities to leverage funding streams. • As recommended in the 2014 Federal recertification review, evaluate the coordination of regional priorities under the STP-Urban program with all MPOs in the TMA. Identify and develop local strategies and capital and op – erational improvements to preserve the existing highway system and local transportation assets. Assist municipalities with assessing, evaluating and optimiz – ing local parking facilities. Provide transportation planning technical assistance, data and advanced GIS capabilities to municipalities with updates to the local Plans of Conservation and Development and other planning studies/documents, if needed. Review and assess the regional impacts of changes to local zoning regulations. 3.2: Plan & Project Implementation Assist municipalities with maintaining and implementing rec – ommendations from the Regional and local Plans of Conser – vation and Development, neighborhood plans and other past planning products, including but not limited to: Bridgeport: • Barnum Station Feasibility Study • Bridgeport Complete Streets Plan • East Bridgeport – Seaview Avenue Development Corri – dor Alternative Transportation Assessment • Feasibility and Concept Plan for the Realignment of Lafayette Circle • Feasibility Study for the Construction of a Pedestrian Bridge over Ash Creek Fairfield: • Engineering Planning Study for Black Rock Turnpike • Fairfield Bicycle and Pedestrian Plan Objectives: • Provide context sensitive, technical assistance to member municipalities for transportation planning and other planning areas that have major impacts on the transportation system. • Establish project priorities and assist with imple – menting federally and state funded transportation projects. • Provide support and coordination, as needed, to develop, update and maintain local and regional planning products. • Align local planning goals with the regional plan – ning program. 26 Stratford: • Route 110 Engineering Planning Study • Stratford Center Revitalization Plan • Stratford Complete Streets Improvement Plan Regional • Alternative Transportation Modes (GBT) • Coastal Corridor Bus Study • Engineering Planning Study for Routes 25 & 111 Plan – ning Study (Monroe and Trumbull) • Long Range Transit Plan (GBT) • Model Transit Oriented Development guidelines • Pequonnock River Trail Project • Regional Plan of Conservation and Development • Route 1 Bus Rapid Transit Study • Sustainable Communities Initiative Plans 3.3: Regional Plan of Conservation & Development Maintain the Regional Plan of Conservation and Develop – ment (RPOCD), which was adopted in 2015. Use the RPOCD to guide the transportation planning pro – cess and to inform the LRTP, future plans and local POCDs throughout the region. Coordinate transportation planning and improvements with major growth corridors, regional transportation nodes and major developments that have the potential for regional impact. Utilize the RPOCD to assess the impacts of future land use management, economic development, conservation and natural hazards scenarios on the transportation system. Coordinate with OPM to ensure that the RPOCD and State POCD update align. The State POCD update began in 2016. Support, in part, the preparation of the Regional Plan of Conservation and Development for the Naugatuck Valley Planning Region related to the Cities or Ansonia, Derby and Shelton and the Town of Seymour. 3.4: Economic Development & Infrastructure Needs Evaluate the links between commuting patterns and the regional economy to support targeted transportation and transit infrastructure improvements that will support econom – ic growth in urban and town centers and major employment corridors. Assess the transportation system’s performance in sup – porting economic growth and providing equitable, efficient access to economic opportunities. Support and plan for transportation infrastructure upgrades that could increase the economic viability of the Region. Support and help identify funding for freight, air (Sikorsky Airport) and water-borne modes (Bridgeport Harbor) of transportation to increase the economic competitiveness of the region and the smooth, efficient movement of goods. Convene meetings of the Economic Development and Tour – ism Advisory Committee and collaborate with the Bridgeport Regional Business Council and local chambers of com – merce to inform the transportation planning process. Secure funding for the Comprehensive Economic Develop – ment Strategy (CEDS) and begin the process of drafting a CEDS for the Greater Bridgeport Region. Continue assistance to the Bridgeport Innovation Places Working Group, formed in response to the State of Con – necticut’s Innovation Places initiative by providing technical assistance, guidance and GIS data related to transportation infrastructure, economic development and land use/zoning. Continue to align brownfields planning and reuse strategies with transportation infrastructure projects and mixed use/ transit oriented developments. Maintain inventory and mon – itor progress with the Economic Development Site Selector (GIS brownfields inventory). Support economic vitality by utilizing ESRI’s Business Analyst for location specific employment, consumer be – havior and business data, as well as economic and market analyses. Maintain the brownfield inventory and engage the business/development community in identifying areas prime for redevelopment. Plan for transportation system improvements that will en – hance travel and tourism in the region. 27 Identify opportunities to coordinate infrastructure invest – ments such as access to broadband with economic develop – ment throughout the region. Collaborate with the Shelton Economic Development Corpo – ration in maintain and updating the CEDS for the Naugatuck Valley EDD. 3.5: Natural Hazard Mitigation Track implementation of strategies identified in the Region’s Natural Hazard Mitigation Plan and maintain the plan per FEMA’s requirements. The plan was last updated in 2014; an updated FEMA-approved plan is required by 2019. Assess potential impacts to transportation systems from flooding and other natural hazards. Work with CTDOT and other state and local agencies to identify vulnerable infrastructure and improve the resiliency of the system to natural hazard impacts such as climate change, sea level rise, and severe storm events. Through the NHMP and LRTP, develop a regional priority program list of infrastructure needs related to flood manage – ment and natural hazard mitigation. Foster inter-agency cooperation and natural disaster contingency planning between local governments, public safety providers, state and federal agencies, and residents to ensure coordinated and efficient responses to natural disasters. 3.6: Transportation Security & Emergency Preparedness Planning Link the transportation planning process to emergency planning, including the state evacuation plan and diversion routes. Coordinate with state, regional and local stakeholders to identify critical facilities, functions and transportation sys – tem components in emergency, security and transportation plans. Continue transportation system security planning and incor – porate findings and recommendations into the Long Range Transportation Plan and Regional Transportation Safety Plan. Act as Voting Member in Region 1 Emergency Planning Team (R1EPT) and as Co-Chair of RESF-1 (Transportation) and provide guidance and technical assistance to RESF-3 (Public Works) and various other ESFs on SWOT assess – ments, resource typing, and project needs. Participate in the ESF-5 Emergency Management Data Working Group of the DEMHS State-wide Emergency and Management and Homeland Security Advisory Council. Coordinate with state and federal DOT on emergency opera – tions and response, planning exercises, best practices and performance measures and targets. Participate in the Region 2 Emergency Planning Team (R2EPT). 3.7: Safe Routes to School Program Provide technical assistance to municipalities and/or schools/school districts with the preparation, development and implementation of Safe Routes to School master plans. Assist interested municipalities in selecting candidate school(s). Provide technical assistance to towns and schools in iden – tifying issues and infrastructure safety hazards that hinder bicycling and walking to school. Develop an outline of the steps and actions to be completed by the SRTS Team to address identified issues. Work with the SRTS Team in identifying barriers to walk – ing and bicycling to school that can be addressed by law enforcement agencies. 3.8: Advisory Committees Conservation Technical Advisory Committee (CTAC): • Hold quarterly meetings of the Conservation Technical Advisory Committee (CTAC). • Through the CTAC, provide face-to-face opportunities to discuss, coordinate, administer and undertake planning activities deemed necessary and appropriate to ad – 28 dress critical environmental and conservation issues, concerns and problems related to coastal resiliency, climate change, brownfield remediation and storm water management. • Involve various interested stakeholder groups. • Provide coordination, support services and technical assistance, as necessary, to the CTAC. Economic Development and Tourism Advisory Committee (EDTAC)/Brownfields Working Group: • Convene meetings of the Economic Development and Tourism Advisory Committee and collaborate with the Bridgeport Regional Business Council and local cham – bers of commerce to inform integrated land use, freight, and transportation planning. • Involve various interested groups representing private freight developers, operators, environmental groups, transit providers, and members of the business commu – nity. • Through the Brownfields Working Group, align local economic development and brownfields reuse strategies in transportation infrastructure projects. • Provide coordination, support services and technical assistance, as necessary, to the EDTAC. Products: 1. Regional Plan of Conservation and Development 2. Local Plans of Conservation and Development 3. Economic Development Site Selector/Brownfields Inventory 4. Natural Hazard Mitigation Plan 5. Comprehensive Economic Development Strategy (CEDS) Products: • Regional Plan of Conservation and Development • Local Plans of Conservation and Development • Economic Development Site Selector/Brownfields Inventory • Natural Hazard Mitigation Plan • Comprehensive Economic Development Strategy (CEDS) Fiscal Year 2018 Fiscal Year 2019 Task 3 Q1 Jul-Sept Q2 Oct-Dec Q3 Jan-Mar Q4 Apr-Jun Q1 Jul-Sept Q2 Oct-Dec Q3 Jan-Mar Q4 Apr-Jun Local Technical Assistance Program Plan & Project Implementation Regional Plan of Conservation & Development Economic Development & Infrastructure Needs Natural Hazard Mitigation Transportation Security & Emergency Preparedness Planning Safe Routes to School Program Advisory Committees Technical Assistance Schedule 29 4.1: Public Involvement Program Maintain, publicize and adhere to the Public Participation Plan to ensure consistency with MAP-21, the FAST Act and new Title VI, Environmental Justice, and Limited English Proficiency considerations as needed. The Plan was adopt – ed by the GBVMPO in 2008. Notify the public of COG and MPO meetings, proposed TIP amendments and meeting agendas and minutes via the MetroCOG and NVCOG websites and through municipal coordination. Promote, maintain and optimize the performance of the MetroCOG and NVCOG websites: • Publish notices of Board Meetings (COG & MPO), Advi – sory Committees, Working Groups and public meetings. • Provide project updates through project specific web – pages with a means for public comment. Regularly update project webpages to reflect progress and share documents via an information repository. • Enhance the public’s experience by integrating interac – tive databases, maps and applications for visioning. • Maintain links to member municipalities, GBT, data sources and sites about transportation planning to inform the public. • Utilize google analytics to assess usage of the website and topics of interest. Work with regional partners to engage the public in the transportation planning process, including GBT, VTD, member municipalities, community leaders, educational institutions, libraries and senior centers. Hold public information meetings, workshops and open houses for projects, plans and studies at convenient and transit and ADA accessible places and times. Develop and distribute electronic versions of presentations, informational brochures, project summaries and/or news – letters with used-friendly content customized for the target audience(s). Periodically assess the effectiveness of the Public Participa – tion Plan, engagement with underserved communities and Task IV: Public Participation Objectives: • Maintain a proactive public involvement process consistent with state and federal guidelines that provides accurate and complete information, timely public notice, full public access to key decisions and responds to public comments and inquiries. • Provide opportunities for citizens to meaningfully engage with elected officials, local municipal staff, and key stakeholders throughout the transpor – tation planning process, especially in the devel – opment of key planning products such as the Transportation Improvement Program (TIP), Long Range Transportation Plan (LRTP) and major transportation studies. • Provide engaging information to the public about the transportation planning process and projects via a variety of media, especially to populations and neighborhoods that have traditionally been marginalized during the planning process. • Ensure that the transportation planning process and the public involvement process are inclusive and consistent with state and federal Environ – mental Justice, Title VI and Limited English Proficiency requirements. • Proactively improve the effectiveness of current public involvement activities, by utilizing demo – graphic data to identify populations that have traditionally been underserved by existing trans – portation systems and implement innovative and inclusive techniques of engagement. 30 identify innovative strategies to promote public involvement and awareness, such as through social media. Make presentations to member municipalities and attend stakeholder events to explain the transportation planning process, projects and studies. As recommended in the 2014 Federal recertification review, ensure that any comments received at public hearings and/ or received in writing are recorded in the appropriate plan itself to document the public participation process and its results. Support models of regional planning by utilizing Metro – COG’s public outreach processes to increase public aware – ness of CTDOT, GBT, MAP Forum, local/regional organiza – tions and other MPO plans and events. 4.2: Title VI, Environmental Justice, & Limited English Proficiency Planning Ensure that all significant language groups are identified and incorporated into the public participation process through the Title VI, Environmental Justice and LEP policy. Conduct outreach to ensure that traditionally underserved individuals and communities, including Environmental Justice communities and low income, minority, and Limited English Proficiency (LEP) persons are involved in the trans – portation planning process. Continue to translate documents and outreach materials in languages where the need exists. Continue to provide language assistance at no cost to the public, if language assistance is requested. Hold public information meetings on plans, program and projects at convenient and accessible places and times, including utilizing a “go to them” strategy, provide community outreach to inform and involve community groups, and offer assistance to the hearing impaired and persons with limited English proficiency. As recommended in the 2014 Federal recertification review, develop a process to assess impacts of projects on the TIP that utilize quantitative analysis strategies. Continue to de – termine and assess the distribution of benefits and burdens of transportation investments included in the TIP and RTP on “at-risk” areas and groups using spatial analysis (GIS). Expand the distribution of transportation planning notices to include not only major media outlets, but also any communi – ty and minority newspapers, newsletters, or similar publica – tions. Assist GBT and VTD in preparing base mapping for GBT’s FTA Title VI Plan, including spatial display of GBT routes and census data relating to minorities, residents with Limited English Proficiency (LEP) and household income. Assist and GBT and VTD in evaluating possible service changes and preparing the Title VI Service Equity Analysis, including preparation of mapping and census data needed for this analysis. Products: • MetroCOG website (www.ctmetro.org) • User-friendly, electronic versions of presenta – tions, informational brochures, plan summaries and project updates; translations determined by target audience. • Public information sessions, workshops and open houses; translation services determined by target audience. • Agendas and minutes for COG and MPO meetings • Agendas for TTAC, CTAC, EDTAC and GTAC meetings (meetings are scheduled quarterly or as needed). • News releases and legal notices; translations determined by target audience. • Annual report • Revised Public Involvement Procedures • Title VI, Public Participation and Environmental Justice/Limited English Proficiency (LEP) Plans; summary translated to Spanish • Spatial Assessment of Transportation System, TIP and Plan projects • Develop interactive databases, maps and vision – ing platforms for the website. 31 Fiscal Year 2018 Fiscal Year 2019 Task 400 Q1 Jul-Sept Q2 Oct-Dec Q3 Jan-Mar Q4 Apr-Jun Q1 Jul-Sept Q2 Oct-Dec Q3 Jan-Mar Q4 Apr-Jun Annual report Revised Public Involvement Procedures Title VI, EJ & LEP Plans Summary translated to Spanish Spatial Assessment of TIP & projects Public Participation Schedule 32 5.1: Council of Governments Schedule quarterly meetings of the Council. Prepare meeting agendas, resolutions, staff reports, financials and updates on the Local Transportation Capital Improvement Program (LOTCIP), GIS and other programs, as necessary. Prepare meeting minutes and maintain past meeting minutes. Prepare, process and maintain MetroCOG member resolu – tions. Notify public about MetroCOG meetings and actions by submitting agendas to town clerks and posting member meeting agendas, minutes and adopted resolutions on the MetroCOG website. Provide staff support to the Board of the Connecticut Metro – politan Council of Governments. 5.2: Metropolitan Planning Organization Schedule quarterly meetings of the GBVMPO member towns. Prepare meeting agendas and technical material, in – cluding plan and project summaries, technical memorandum and policy papers, as necessary. Prepare GBVMPO member towns meeting minutes and maintain records of previous meetings. Prepare and process GBVMPO member towns-endorsed resolutions. Notify public about GBVMPO meetings and actions by sub – mitting agendas to town clerks and posting member meeting agendas, minutes and adopted resolutions on MetroCOG and NVCOG website. Publish planning products such as the UPWP, LRTP and TIP to the MetroCOG and NVCOG websites for the required public review period. Serve as the transportation planning staff to the Greater Bridgeport and Valley MPO. As recommended in the 2014 Federal recertification review, consider an evaluation of adding an official representative of bicycle and pedestrian interests, as well as a CTDOT representative, to the MPO board. As recommended in the 2014 Federal recertification review and in accordance with Metropolitan Planning requirements of MAP-21 and in accordance with any future MPO redes – ignations, revise the written agreement to be in compliance with regulations, and maximize coordination and coopera – tion with all MPOs and Transit Districts in the entire Bridge – port-Stamford Urbanized Area and New York Metropolitan Area (MAP Forum). 5.3: Unified Planning Work Program (UPWP) Prepare and adopt the UPWP for FY 2020 & 2021. Amend and/or update the 2018-2019 UPWP if necessary and/or upon CTDOT’s request Prepare all Programmatic and Financial Reports/Statements on planning activities completed under the UPWP. Submit progress reports within 10 days of the close of each quarter. Coordinate work across tasks and functions to avoid dupli – cation of effort and maximize efficiency. As recommended in the 2014 Federal recertification review and in order to maintain and enhance the 3C joint planning process in the Bridgeport-Stamford urbanized area, consider evaluating the possibility of jointly developing and integrating the UPWP across the TMA region. Task V: Administration Objectives: • Allocate staff resources to effectively carry out the planning tasks included as detailed in this Unified Planning Work Program (UPWP). • Advise and inform participating agencies of pro – gram expenditures and activity. 33 5.4: Administration Maintain financial records and develop reports in accor – dance with USDOT and CTDOT regulations and guidance. Integrate UPWP budget with overall agency budget. If necessary, administer any work connected with potential MPO redesignation. Participate on and provide administrative support to various advisory committees. Expand the Transportation Technical Advisory Committee to include all member towns within the GBVMPO. Adhere to all CTDOT and USDOT procurement procedures and consultant selection requirements. Form and participate on consultant selection committees. 5.5: Certification The GBVMPO re-certification process was completed in FY 2015 (September, 2014). MetroCOG will continue to work with CTDOT, FHWA and FTA to document compliance with applicable federal standards and recertification require – ments. For FY 2017 and FY 2018, annual self-certification will occur at MPO meetings, with a resolution that states that the planning process is consistent with applicable federal regulations. MetroCOG will begin preparing for the FY 2019 re-certifica – tion. 5.6: Annual Audit For each fiscal year, (2017 and 2018), prepare an annual audit of revenue, expenditures and internal management practices. 5.7: Grant Applications Prepare application packages for various federal-aid trans – portation programs, work programs and/or special studies, as needed. Assist member municipalities and regional transit operators with the preparation of applications for state and federal funds. Prepare highway improvement projects applications under the STP: BS TAP, CMAQ, and other temporary programs, as needed. Administer and manage federal grants. 5.8: DBE/WBE Program Continue efforts to expand the opportunities for DBE/WBE/ MBE firms in contracting of special studies and the purchase of equipment. Prepare and submit quarterly and yearly reports to the Con – necticut Commission on Human Rights and Opportunities. 5.9: Documentation Requirements Document EEO, Affirmative Action, DBE/WBE, citizen partic – ipation, self-certification, procurement and other activities as needed. Products: • Meeting minutes. • Resolutions and amendments. • Certification report. • Annual audit. • Grant applications. • Unified Planning Work Program (UPWP) • DBE/WBE Reports 34 Fiscal Year 2018 Fiscal Year 2019 Task 5 Q1 Jul-Sept Q2 Oct-Dec Q3 Jan-Mar Q4 Apr-Jun Q1 Jul-Sept Q2 Oct-Dec Q3 Jan-Mar Q4 Apr-Jun Council of Governments Metropolitan Planning Organization Unified Planning Work Program Administration Certification Annual Audit Grant Applications DBE/WBE Program Documentation Requirements Administration Schedule 35 Black Rock Turnpike Planning & Engineering Study, Fairfield MetroCOG is serving as the project manager for this study. A consulting firm has been selected to conduct a planning and engineering study that will analyze and select preferred alternatives for road, bicycle/pedestrian, and safety improve – ments. The recommendations identified by the study will increase safety for vehicles, bicyclists and pedestrians and will link the commercial district to adjacent residential neigh – borhoods. The study area extent consists mainly of the commercial district starting at the intersection of Route 58 (Tunxis Hill Cut Off) and Knapps Highway, continuing north onto Black Rock Turnpike and ending at the intersection with Tahmore Drive. Engineering Planning Study for Routes 25 & 111, Monroe & Trumbull MetroCOG is serving as the project manager, and a con – sulting firm is conducting the study. The Routes 25 and 111 Study will identify strategies to improve traffic operations along the Route 25 and 111 corridors in northern Trumbull and Monroe, especially during peak commuting hours. Routes 25 and 111 are regionally significant corridors that serve local businesses, employers, schools, medical facilities and retailers located in Trumbull, Monroe and Newtown. The corridors provide connections to the Merritt Parkway, the Route 8/25 Expressway, Route 34, Interstate 84 and intersecting local and collector roads. In addition to improving traffic operations, the study will also identify safety measures, bicycle, pedestrians and transit accommodations, future development, and environmental mitigation strategies. Transportation Planning for Ansonia, Derby, Seymour & Shelton MetroCOG intends to contract with the NVCOG to conduct the metropolitan planning program, as described in the pre – vious sections, for the Cities of Ansonia, Derby and Shelton and the Town of Seymour. To ensure that the transportation planning process is conducted at the highest level of quality and that the UPWP is inclusive of all members, this section provides an addendum of sub-tasks that address transporta – tion assets, issues and concerns in these four municipalities. Task I: Data Collection, Analysis & Applications Maintain a Transportation Database – traffic counts, bicycle counts, rail and bus ridership; link the database to GIS. Coordinate with CTDOT in setting performance measures and metrics and transition to a performance based assess – ment. Explore the opportunity of acquiring “big data” from a third-party vendor to develop transportation metrics. Set-up a regional Travel Demand Modeling program to determine and assess regional travel patterns. Maintain the Regional GIS Program and conduct geographic analyses to support transportation planning programs and projects. Update and prepare the Regional Demographic and Economic Profiles. Task VI: Special Planning Studies 36 Conceptual Studies: • Regional Transportation Safety Plan. • Old Town Road Planning Study, Bridgeport, Fair – field, Stratford and Trumbull • Route 1/Route 130 Rotary Planning and Engi – neering Study, Fairfield • Mill Plain Road, Fairfield • White Plains Road, Trumbull • Active Transportation Plan • Transit Design Guidelines • Transit Origin Destination Study • Bicycle and Pedestrian Plan, Trumbull Task II: Multi-Modal Transportation Planning Develop a Long Range Transportation Plan focused on the transportation system needs of the Cities of Ansonia, Derby and Shelton and the Town of Seymour, and consolidate plan needs and program of projects into the GBVMPO LRTP. Develop a regional Plan of Conservation and Development for the Naugatuck Valley planning region consistent with the long range transportation plan and provide a framework and guide for regional sustainable land use patterns that are supported by and coordinated with the region’s transpor – tation infrastructure, and a model for future local planning efforts. • Assess traffic and highway operations on key corridors and identify capital improvement projects to preserve and enhance highway system on the state arterial network: • Administer the state-funded LOTCIP program for the Cities of Ansonia, Derby and Shelton and the Town of Seymour as part of the NVCOG planning region LOT – CIP program. • Work with the Valley Transit District to develop and update the 10-year capital improvement program: fleet replacement, facility improvements and rehabilitation, and bus shelter program. The NVCOG is the designated recipient and grantee of FTA capital funds and FTA grant funds awarded to NVCOG are used to purchase capital equipment including rolling stock assigned to VTD, to ensure the state-of-good repair of the capital equipment and rolling stock, and to study and develop new services and transit facilities within the grantee area. • Provide technical assistance to VTD related to local bus system planning, including capital grant administration and programming. • Work with CTDOT in programming and advancing proposed Waterbury Branch Line improvements and en – hancements, including the planned positive train control, signal system design, passing sidings and overall long term rehabilitation. • Conduct the Naugatuck Valley Transit Governance Study to evaluate the current governance of the GWTD, assess alternative governance structures, including the feasibility of merging GWTD with VTD and creating a single transit district for the Naugatuck Valley planning region. Coordinate multiple and inter-related planning tasks to create an interconnected network of multi-use trails, ensure pedestrian safety and promote livable and sustainable communities, including continued involve – ment in the design and construction of the Naugatuck River Greenway. • Work on enhancing regional trail and greenway systems including the Naugatuck River Greenway – Derby Gre – enway, Seymour Greenway and Linear Park and access to Ansonia downtown from the Riverwalk. • Develop and update the Regional Bicycle Plan for the Cities of Ansonia, Derby and Shelton and the Town of Seymour and consolidate the needs and program of projects into a GBVMPO bicycle plan. • Develop and update the Regional Pedestrian Safety Plan for the Cities of Ansonia, Derby and Shelton and the Town of Seymour and consolidate the needs and program of projects into a GBVMPO pedestrian plan: Task III: Other Technical Assistance Assist the Cities of Ansonia, Derby and Shelton and the Town of Seymour with maintaining and implementing recommendations of the Regional Plan of Conservation and Development 37 Participate on various technical advisory committees, as necessary. Administer the Naugatuck River Greenway Project and assist the Naugatuck River Greenway Steering Committee by maintaining and hosting the NRG website / webpage on the NVCOG website, preparing interactive maps and hosting meetings of the NRG Steering Committee. Assist municipalities with on-going transportation projects and planning studies, including but not limited to: • Route 34 Reconstruction Project – State Project No. 0036-0184 • Route 67 Spot Improvements and Minor Widening Proj – ect – State Project No. 0124-0165 • Derby-Shelton Bridge Renovation Project – State Proj – ect No. 0126-0174 • Route 8 Corridor Improvements – State Project No. 0036-0179 • TOD Pilot Project Task IV: Public Involvement Program The NVCOG updated its Public Outreach Policy and Envi – ronmental Justice Policy in FY 2017. Both policies provide structure to federal and state requirements to involve and inform the public at all stages in the planning process and were made available in English and in Spanish. The NVCOG will: • Adhere to the Public Outreach and Environmental Justice polices and ensure a proactive engagement with the public. • Participate in meetings of the GBVMPO. • Make presentations at GBVMPO and NVCOG meetings on transportation plans, programs and projects. • Convene and hold meetings of the Transportation Tech – nical Advisory Committee (TTAC) to provide face-to-face opportunities to discuss and exchange ideas regarding transportation issues, deficiencies and solutions. • Periodically assess effectiveness of the public involve – ment process. • Provide reports, documents, plans and summaries in user-friendly format and post on NVCOG website. • Hold public information meetings on plans, program and projects at convenient and accessible places and times, including utilizing a “go to them” strategy, provide community outreach to inform and involve community groups, and offer assistance to the hearing impaired and persons with limited English proficiency. • Maintain the NVCOG website and post transportation documents, summaries, actions, plans and programs. Task V: Administration Coordinate and work with MetroCOG in scheduling meetings of the GBVMPO and preparing meeting agenda, material and documents. Coordinate and work with MetroCOG in preparing and updating the UPWP. Prepare grant applications. Maintain financial documents and records. Task VI: Special Planning Studies The NVCOG is serving as the project manager for the Route 8 & Waterbury Branch Line Corridor Transit Oriented De – velopment & Alternate Transit Modes Assessment Project. A consulting firm has been engaged to conduct the project. The project will: • Identify new, enhanced and alternate public transit facilities and services, including local bus service, bus rapid transit routes and commuter rail, to transform town centers into vibrant, high-density communities that have access to efficient and high quality transit services. • Provide built environment densities that meet transit supportive standards for land uses and walkability, in order to facilitate and encourage the use of enhanced transit services. • Enhance transit connectivity, reliability and attractive – ness. • Develop an implementation plan for incentivizing transit oriented and supported developments in the lower Nau – gatuck Valley Region. • Advance HUD’s livability principles and extend sustain – able communities. The NVCOG is administering the project and providing tech – nical assistance to the project as needed. 38 Funding Sources FY2018 + FY2019 Anticipated Revenue Funding Program Regional Sponsor Federal State Local To t a l Regional Transportation Planning: FY 2018 PL + FTA 5303 Funds GBVMPO $759,626 $72,165 $117,742 $949,533 Regional Transportation Planning: FY 2019 PL + FTA 5303 Funds GBVMPO $759,625 $72,165 $117,742 $949,533 FY 2015 Carryover $43,799 $0 $10,950 $54,749 Total $1,563,051 $144,329 $246,434 $1,953,814 [1] Local match calculated at 12.4% [2] State match calculated at 7.6% FY2018 + FY2019 GVBMPO Anticipated Revenue Funding Program Regional Sponsor Federal State Local To t a l Regional Transportation Planning: FY 2018 PL + FTA 5303 Funds MetroCOG $531,340 $50,477 $82,358 $664,175 Regional Transportation Planning: FY 2019 PL + FTA 5303 Funds MetroCOG $531,339 $50,477 $82,358 $664,175 FY 2015 Carryover MetroCOG $22,826 $0 $5,707 $28,533 Regional Transportation Planning: FY 2018 PL + FTA 5303 Funds Valley $228,286 $21,687 $35,384 $285,358 Regional Transportation Planning: FY 2019 PL + FTA 5303 Funds Valley $228,285 $21,687 $35,384 $285,358 FY 2015 Carryover Valley $20,973 $0 $5,243 $26,216 [1] Local match calculated at 12.4% [2] State match calculated at 7.6% 39 FY2018 + FY2019 Anticipated Revenue Funding Program Regional Sponsor Federal State Local To t a l Regional Transportation Planning: FY 2018 PL + FTA 5303 Funds GBVMPO $759,626 $72,165 $117,742 $949,533 Regional Transportation Planning: FY 2019 PL + FTA 5303 Funds GBVMPO $759,625 $72,165 $117,742 $949,533 FY 2015 Carryover $43,799 $0 $10,950 $54,749 Total $1,563,051 $144,329 $246,434 $1,953,814 [1] Local match calculated at 12.4% [2] State match calculated at 7.6% FY2018 + FY2019 GVBMPO Anticipated Revenue Funding Program Regional Sponsor Federal State Local To t a l Regional Transportation Planning: FY 2018 PL + FTA 5303 Funds MetroCOG $531,340 $50,477 $82,358 $664,175 Regional Transportation Planning: FY 2019 PL + FTA 5303 Funds MetroCOG $531,339 $50,477 $82,358 $664,175 FY 2015 Carryover MetroCOG $22,826 $0 $5,707 $28,533 Regional Transportation Planning: FY 2018 PL + FTA 5303 Funds Valley $228,286 $21,687 $35,384 $285,358 Regional Transportation Planning: FY 2019 PL + FTA 5303 Funds Valley $228,285 $21,687 $35,384 $285,358 FY 2015 Carryover Valley $20,973 $0 $5,243 $26,216 [1] Local match calculated at 12.4% [2] State match calculated at 7.6% Hourly Rates Planning Staff Maximum Hourly Rates FY 2018 FY 2019 Executive Director 85 85 Deputy Director 70 70 Administrative Services Director 75 75 Planning Director 62 62 Finance Director 53 53 Deputy Finance Director 45 45 Senior Transportation Planner/ Engineer 60 60 Transportation Planner 37 37 Regional Transportation Engineer 60 60 GIS Specialist/ Planning Assistant 37 37 Regional Planner 49 49 GIS Director 62 62 Administrative Services Manager 37 37 Administrative Assistant 35 35 Intern/ Planning Assistant 22 22 40 FY 2018 Labor by Task FY 2018 MetroCOG Direct Salaries by Task Including Overhead Task I: Data Collec – tion & Analysis Task II: Multi-mod – al Transportation Planning Task III: Other Technical Assis – tance Task IV: Public Participation Task V: Adminis – tration Cost Cost Cost Cost Cost Executive Director 0 20,913 9,411 6,274 15,684 Deputy Director 1,722 34,444 15,500 4,306 8,611 Administrative Services Director 0 0 0 3,690 18,452 Planning Director 3,051 49,575 19,067 7,627 0 Finance Director 0 0 0 0 2,706 Deputy Finance Director 0 8,304 0 2,768 13,839 Senior Transportation Planner 4,429 22,143 18,452 6,643 0 Transportation Planner 3,641 31,861 18,206 4,096 0 Regional Transportation Engineer 0 29,524 11,071 0 0 GIS Specialist/ Planning Assistant 36,412 18,206 27,309 4,552 0 Regional Planner 0 18,083 45,208 6,028 0 GIS Director 45,762 15,254 15,254 3,813 0 Administrative Services Manager 0 4,552 0 2,276 4,552 Administrative Assistant 0 0 0 0 0 Intern 1749 3518 3700 1203 0 Total Budget 96,766 256,376 183,179 53,275 63,844 [1] Audited FY2015 BF&O rate at 1.4603% 41 FY 2018 MetroCOG Direct Salaries by Task Including Overhead Task I: Data Collec – tion & Analysis Task II: Multi-mod – al Transportation Planning Task III: Other Technical Assis – tance Task IV: Public Participation Task V: Adminis – tration Cost Cost Cost Cost Cost Executive Director 0 20,913 9,411 6,274 15,684 Deputy Director 1,722 34,444 15,500 4,306 8,611 Administrative Services Director 0 0 0 3,690 18,452 Planning Director 3,051 49,575 19,067 7,627 0 Finance Director 0 0 0 0 2,706 Deputy Finance Director 0 8,304 0 2,768 13,839 Senior Transportation Planner 4,429 22,143 18,452 6,643 0 Transportation Planner 3,641 31,861 18,206 4,096 0 Regional Transportation Engineer 0 29,524 11,071 0 0 GIS Specialist/ Planning Assistant 36,412 18,206 27,309 4,552 0 Regional Planner 0 18,083 45,208 6,028 0 GIS Director 45,762 15,254 15,254 3,813 0 Administrative Services Manager 0 4,552 0 2,276 4,552 Administrative Assistant 0 0 0 0 0 Intern 1749 3518 3700 1203 0 Total Budget 96,766 256,376 183,179 53,275 63,844 [1] Audited FY2015 BF&O rate at 1.4603% FY 2019 Labor by Task FY 2019 MetroCOG Direct Salaries by Task Including Overhead Task I: Data Collec – tion & Analysis Task II: Multi-mod – al Transportation Planning Task III: Other Technical Assis – tance Task IV: Public Participation Task V: Adminis – tration Cost Cost Cost Cost Cost Executive Director 0 20,913 9,411 6,274 15,684 Deputy Director 1,722 34,444 15,500 4,306 8,611 Administrative Services Director 0 0 0 3,690 18,452 Planning Director 3,051 49,575 19,067 7,627 0 Finance Director 0 0 0 0 2,706 Deputy Finance Director 0 8,304 0 2,768 13,839 Senior Transportation Planner 4,429 22,143 18,452 6,643 0 Transportation Planner 3,641 31,861 18,206 4,096 0 Regional Transportation Engineer 0 29,524 11,071 0 0 GIS Specialist/ Planning Assistant 36,412 18,206 27,309 4,552 0 Regional Planner 0 18,083 45,208 6,028 0 GIS Director 45,762 15,254 15,254 3,813 0 Administrative Services Manager 0 4,552 0 2,276 4,552 Administrative Assistant 0 0 0 0 0 Intern 1749 3518 3700 1203 0 Total Budget 96,766 256,376 183,179 53,275 63,844 [1] Audited FY2015 BF&O rate at 1.4603% 42 Funding by Task FY2018 MetroCOG Planning Costs by Task Ta s k FHWA+FTA State Local To t a l 100: Data Collection & Analysis $81,413 $7,517 $12,836 $101,766 200: Planning $217,101 $20,408 $33,868 $271,376 300: Other Technical Assistance $146,543 $13,705 $22,931 $183,179 400: Public Participa – tion $43,420 $3,908 $6,947 $54,275 500: Administration $54,275 $4,939 $8,630 $67,844 Total $542,753 $50,477 $85,212 $678,441 [1] Local match calculated at 12.6% [2] State match calculated at 7.4% [3] Local match for FY2015 carryover funds calculated at 20%, State match calculated at 0% FY2019 MetroCOG Planning Costs by Task Ta s k FHWA+FTA State Local To t a l 100: Data Collection & Analysis $81,413 $7,517 $12,836 $101,766 200: Planning $217,101 $20,408 $33,868 $271,376 300: Other Technical Assistance $146,543 $13,705 $22,931 $183,179 400: Public Participa – tion $43,420 $3,908 $6,947 $54,275 500: Administration $54,275 $4,940 $8,629 $67,844 Total $542,753 $50,478 $85,211 $678,441 [1] Local match calculated at 12.4% [2] State match calculated at 7.6% [3] Local match for FY2015 carryover funds calculated at 20%, State match calculated at 0% 43 FY2018 MetroCOG Planning Costs by Task Ta s k FHWA+FTA State Local To t a l 100: Data Collection & Analysis $81,413 $7,517 $12,836 $101,766 200: Planning $217,101 $20,408 $33,868 $271,376 300: Other Technical Assistance $146,543 $13,705 $22,931 $183,179 400: Public Participa – tion $43,420 $3,908 $6,947 $54,275 500: Administration $54,275 $4,939 $8,630 $67,844 Total $542,753 $50,477 $85,212 $678,441 [1] Local match calculated at 12.6% [2] State match calculated at 7.4% [3] Local match for FY2015 carryover funds calculated at 20%, State match calculated at 0% Direct Expenses by Task FY2018 MetroCOG Direct Expense by Task Ta s k s Print Equipment Meeting Expenses Tr a v e l Misc. Contractor To t a l Task I: Data Collec – tion & Analysis 2,000 3,000 5,000 Task II: Multi-mod – al Transportation Planning 3,000 10,000 2,000 15,000 Task III: Other Technical Assistance 0 Task IV: Public Participation 200 800 1,000 Task V: Administra – tion 1,500 2,000 500 4,000 Task VI: Special Planning Studies 298,465 298,465 Total 200 6,500 800 15,000 2,500 298,465 323,465 FY2019 MetroCOG Direct Expense by Task Ta s k s Print Equipment Meeting Expenses Tr a v e l Misc. Contractor To t a l Task I: Data Collec – tion & Analysis 2,000 3,000 5,000 Task II: Multi-mod – al Transportation Planning 3,000 10,000 2,000 15,000 Task III: Other Technical Assistance 0 Task IV: Public Participation 200 800 1,000 Task V: Administra – tion 1,500 2,000 500 4,000 Task VI:Special Planning Studies 298,466 298,466 Total 200 6,500 800 15,000 2,500 298,466 323,466 44 Executive Director • Work with the Board of Directors to oversee the com – prehensive planning process for the Greater Bridgeport Region. • Coordinate the functions necessary to carry-out the planning tasks included in the UPWP • Administer the transportation planning process. • Identify opportunities for and coordinate technical assis – tance to member communities. • Maintain and enhance the professional and technical capabilities of the planning, GIS and support staff. • Collaborate with the adjacent RPOs and MPOs as needed. Deputy Director • Assist the Executive Director in implementing the overall Council program, including needs identification, short and long term planning, policies and procedures, program development, and local, State and Federal coordination. • Assist in providing technical informational and planning assistance to member municipalities regarding land use, transportation, economic and environmental planning. • Manage specific projects, including procurement devel – opment of work programs, project-specific supervision of staff and consultants, reporting, project evaluation, contract administration, etc. • Research various sources (websites, periodicals, etc.) for grant opportunities and coordinate the preparation of grant applications. In this capacity, provide notice and technical assistance to member municipalities on poten – tial grant funding opportunities available to them. • Interface as necessary with member municipalities, ad – jacent MPOs/ RPOs, state/federal agencies, community groups and citizens. • Attend Council Meetings, and Council-related municipal, State or Federal meetings. • Assist the Executive Director in the management of the Council’s administrative operations. • Assist with development of work programs • Assist with the coordination of the MPO, the Council and Regional Advisory Committees. • Administration, advanced research and analysis, and presentation of information and recommendations on long-range land-use planning, regional planning, trans – portation planning, urban design and economic develop – ment issues. • Support a proactive public involvement process. • Attend meetings, conferences, workshops, and training sessions as necessary Administrative Services Director • Advise and inform the Council and participating agen – cies of program substance and expenditures. • Overall responsibility for Administrative side of organiza – tion including but not limited to; finance, Human Re – sources, insurances (medical and liability and employ – ment) and contractual. • Reports directly to Executive Director. Can sign con – tracts in his stead. • Assist in developing business plans to enhance organi – zations funding sources. Planning Director • Oversee the coordination of transportation, land use, economic development, emergency and conservation planning. • Assess the potential for and feasibility of creating Transit Oriented Developments (TOD). • Support all Regional Sustainability, active transportation and TOD Planning. • Assist with the coordination of the MPO, the Council and Regional Advisory Committees. • Collaborate with adjacent RPOs and MPOs as needed. • Identify opportunities for and coordinate technical assis – tance to member communities • Develop short- and long-range work plans, procedures, and schedules. Employee Tasks 45 • Review local project proposals, designs, and plan docu – mentation. • Project management and contract administration. • Assist with development of work programs. • Develop project work scopes, schedules, and budgets. • Administration, advanced research and analysis, and presentation of information and recommendations on long-range land-use planning, regional planning, trans – portation planning, urban design and economic develop – ment issues. • Support a proactive public involvement process. • Attend meetings, conferences, workshops, and training sessions determined by supervisor. • Assist with other tasks as necessary. • Maintain and enhance the professional and technical capabilities of the planning staff. Finance Director • Advise and inform the Council and participating agen – cies of program substance and expenditures. • Provide financial data for state and federal reporting requirements. • Coordinate yearly auditing activities. • Support a proactive public involvement process. • Assist the Executive Director with tasks as needed. Deputy Finance Director • Provide financial data for state and federal reporting requirements. • Provide bookkeeping functions. • Prepare financials for quarterly reports. • Coordinate yearly auditing activities. • Support a proactive public involvement process. • Assist the Executive Director with tasks as needed. • Monitor grant budgets. • Maintains general ledger, journals and all other fiscal records and reports in accordance with federal and state bookkeeping and auditing standards. Prepares project financial reports; contract reimbursements; quarterly FICA, FWT and unemployment reports; monthly balance sheets; monthly analysis of staff timesheets; makes out all checks including payroll. Maintains Council checking and savings accounts. Makes all deposits, withdrawals, and fund transfers. Orders office supplies. Maintains an inventory of office equipment and furniture. Uses personal computer for fiscal applications. Assists with general clerical functions as needed. Senior Transportation Planner/Engineer • Support the development and maintenance of the Long Range Transportation Plan and Transportation Improve – ment Program (TIP). • Support the CTDOT Air Quality Conformity process. • Develop short- and long-range work plans, procedures, and schedules. • Review local project proposals, designs, and plan docu – mentation. • Project management and contract administration. • Coordinate technical assistance to member communi – ties and conduct transportation planning studies. • Assist with development of work programs. • Develop project work scopes, schedules, and budgets. • Hold meetings of the Transportation Technical Advisory Committee. • Link the transportation planning process with the NEPA process, other environmental and conservation issues, land use planning and emergency planning. • Assess the potential for and feasibility of creating Transit Oriented Developments (TOD) districts and corridors. • Support a proactive public involvement process. • Collaborate with adjacent RPOs and MPOs as needed. • Attend meetings, conferences, workshops, and training sessions determined by supervisor. • Provide technical assistance to member communities and conduct transportation planning studies; assist with active transportation planning • Assist with other tasks as necessary. Transportation Planner • Support the development and maintenance of the Long Range Transportation Plan and Transportation Improve – ment Program (TIP). • Support the CTDOT Air Quality Conformity process. • Provide technical assistance to member communities and conduct transportation planning studies; assist with active transportation planning 46 • Use computer-based modeling and application software to facilitate the transportation planning process. • Monitor, analyze and report transportation systems use, performance, congestion, changes and safety issues. • Monitor highway performance consistent with CTDOT procedures and as needed. • Link the transportation planning process with the NEPA process, other environmental and conservation issues, land use planning and emergency planning. • Evaluate transportation systems to provide economic and social opportunities and benefits. • Collaborate with the adjacent RPOs and MPOs as needed. • Assist CTDOT with data coordination. • Support a proactive public involvement process. • Assist GBT with revising and updating the ten year capital improvement program. • Work with public transit operators to evaluate regional and local transit system deficiencies, capital and operat – ing needs, and multi-modal opportunities. • Study bus service initiatives to close gaps and enhance service (long range transit plan). • Maintain a coordination plan for human service trans – portation (LOCHSTP). • Assess opportunities for alternate transit services and modes. • Support planning initiatives for Transit Oriented Devel – opments (TOD) districts and corridors. • Collect, maintain and organize transit data. • Coordinate with GIS Department on all databases relat – ed to transit. • Assist members and transit providers with state and federal grant applications related to transit. • Work with ferry stakeholders as needed. • Attend meetings, conferences, workshops, and training sessions determined by supervisor. • Assist with other tasks as necessary. Regional Transportation Engineer • Provide transportation engineering technical assistance to member communities and conduct transportation planning studies. • Support the CTDOT Air Quality Conformity process. • Use computer-based modeling and application software to facilitate the transportation planning process. • Monitor, analyze and report transportation systems use, performance, congestion, changes and safety issues. • Monitor highway performance consistent with CTDOT procedures and as needed. • Use and follow the Congestion Management Process (CMP) to monitor congestion and highway system performance. • Maintain, mainstream and use the regional ITS architec – ture for the Greater Bridgeport Region. • Support a proactive public involvement process. • Assist CTDOT with data coordination. • Attend meetings, conferences, workshops, and training sessions determined by supervisor. • Assist with other tasks as necessary. • GIS Specialist/Planning Assistant • Maintain regional transportation traffic, transit, commuter parking/permit and bicycle pedestrian count databases. • Organize census and census transportation planning package data. • Develop data reports to support the transportation plan – ning process. • Use GIS to develop maps and spatially illustrate trends, patterns and operating conditions. • Link transportation and transit databases to GIS. • Conduct land parcel analyses, network analyses, freight analyses, business inventories and transportation im – pact assessments. • Develop interactive maps for website that will support the public involvement process. • Participate in meetings of the Geospatial Technical Advisory Committee. • Assist CTDOT with data coordination. • Attend meetings, conferences, workshops, and training sessions determined by supervisor. • Assist with other tasks as necessary. Regional Planner • Assist with the preparation of the Regional Plan of Con – servation and Development and Regional Transit-Ori – ented Development Strategy. • Prepare and manage transportation/corridor plans; transit oriented development; brownfields; etc. • Facilitate public outreach/participation/education for 47 various initiatives. • Develop short- and long-range work plans, procedures, budgets and schedules. • Hold meeting of the Conservation Technical Advisory Committee, Economic Development and Tourism Tech – nical Advisory Committee and Emergency Management Technical Advisory Committee. • Administration, advanced research and analysis, and presentation of information and recommendations on long-range land-use planning, regional planning, multi-modal transportation planning, urban design and economic development issues. • Link the transportation planning process with the NEPA process and other environmental and conservation issues. • Evaluate transportation systems to provide economic and social opportunities and benefits. • Support a proactive public involvement process. • Attend meetings, conferences, workshops, and training sessions determined by supervisor. • Assist with other tasks as necessary. GIS Director • Enhance regional GIS program and mapping capabili – ties. • Develop GIS based land use and transportation models to support economic development and vitality • Oversee GIS and database linkages • Oversee publication of GIS data on website that will support the public involvement process. • Coordinate meetings of the Geospatial Technical Advi – sory Committee. • Develop short- and long-range work plans, procedures, and schedules. • Review local project proposals, designs, and plan docu – mentation. • Project management and contract administration. • Coordinate technical assistance to member communi – ties and conduct transportation planning studies. • Assist with development of work programs. • Develop project work scopes, schedules, and budgets. • Maintain and enhance the professional and technical capabilities of the GIS staff. • Attend meetings, conferences, workshops, and training sessions determined by supervisor. • Assist with other tasks as necessary. Administrative Services Manager • Assist the Director with scheduling • All administrative tasks in regards to planning events and booking venues • Schedules and coordinates meetings with towns, CEO, regional committees and economic development depart – ments as needed. • Create flyers for events. • Organize and maintain resolutions endorsed by the GBVMPO member towns and Council. • Take and maintain meeting minutes. • Support a proactive public involvement process. • Attend meetings, conferences, workshops, and training sessions determined by supervisor. • Assist with other tasks as necessary. Administrative Assistant • Assist the Director with scheduling • All administrative tasks in regards to planning events and booking venues • Support a proactive public involvement process. • Organize and maintain resolutions endorsed by the GBVMPO member towns and Council. • Take and maintain meeting minutes. • Attend meetings, conferences, workshops, and training sessions determined by supervisor. • Assist with other tasks as necessary. Intern • Assist with data gathering. • Assist with the collection of traffic data (volume, speed, vehicle class) and travel time. • Assist with duties related to the proactive public involve – ment process. • Attend meetings, conferences, workshops, and training sessions determined by supervisor. • Assist with other tasks as necessary. 48 Statement of Cooperative MPO/State/Transit Operators Planning Roles & Responsibilities Appendix Statement of Cooperative MPO/State/Transit Operators ’Planning Roles & Responsibilities Purpose The purpose of this statement is to outline the roles and responsibilities of the State, the GBVMPO and appropriate providers of public transportation as required by 23 CFR Sec. 450.314(a)”Metropolitan Planning Agreements”. General Roles & Responsibilities The GBVMPO will perform the transportation planning process for their region and develop procedures to coordinate transportation planning activities in accordance with applicable federal regulations and guidance. The transportation process will, at a minimum, consist of: 1. Preparation of a two-year Unified Planning Work Program that lists and describes all transportation planning studies and tasks to be completed during th is two-year period. 2. Preparation and update of a long range, multi -modal metropolitan transportation plan. 3. Preparation and maintenance of a short -range transportation improvement program (TIP). 4. Financia l planning to ensure plan and program are financially constrained and within anticipated funding levels. 5. Conduct of planning studies and system performance monitoring, including highway corridor and intersection studies, transit system studies, application of advanced computer techniques, and transportation data collection and archiving. 6. Public outreach, including survey of affected populations, electronic dissemination of reports and information (website), and consideration of public comments . 7. Ensuring the transportation planning process does not have a significant or disproportionate impact on low income, minority and transit dependent Title VI populations. 8. Development and implementation of a Congestion Management Process as appropriate. 9. Ensuring plans, pr ojects and programs are consistent with and conform to air quality goals of reducing transportation -related emissions and attaining National Ambient Air Quality Standards. Long Range Metropolitan Transportation Plan 1.GBVMPO will be responsible for preparing and developing the long range (20 –25 years) metropolitan transportation plans for itsrespective region. 2. GBVMPO may develop a consolidated transportation plan summary report for the planning region that includes the key issues facing the area and priority programs andprojects. 3. CT DOT will provide the following information and data in support of developing the transportation plan: a. Financial information – estimate of anticipated federal funds over the 20 -25 year time frame of the plan for the highway and transit programs. b. Trip tables – for each analysis year, including base year and the horizon year of the plan by trip purpose and mode. ( CT DOT will provide this only if requested since GBVMPO may maintains its own travel forecast model.) c. Traffic count data for state roads in the GBVMPO region, and transit statistics as available. d. List of projects of statewide significance by mode, with descriptions, so that they can be incorporated into the long range m etropolitantransportation plans. 49 e.Assess air quality impacts and conduct the regional emissions assessment of the plan. Will provide the results of the assessment in a timely manner to allow inclusion in the plan and to be made available to the public at public information meetings. (Refer to air quality tasks.) 4. GBVMPO may conduct transportation modeling for the area. 5. GBVMPO will consult with the appropriate providers of public transportation on local bus capital projects to include in the transportation plan, and will work together to develop local bus improvement sfor the plan from the 10 -year capital program. Through consultation, they will identify future local bus needs and services, including new routes, service expansion, rolling stock needs beyond replacement, and operating financial needs. Transportation Improvement Program (TIP) 1. The TIP will be prepared and compiled through a consultative process between CT DOT ,GBVMPO , and the appropriate provider(s) of public transportation. 2. CT DOT will prepare an initial list of projects to include in the new TIP. This list will be based on the current TIP that is about to expire and an assessment of which projects will be obligated for funding before the end of the current federal fiscal year. 3. CT D OT,MPO and transit provider(s) – CT DOTwill solicit comments on the TIP and incorporate where practicable. 4. CT DOT will provide detailed project descriptions, cost estimates and program schedules. The project descriptions will provide sufficient detail to allow the GBVMPO to explain the projects to the policy board and the general public. 5. CT DOT will provide a list of projects obligated during each of the federal fiscal years covered by the expiring TIP/STIP. The annual listing of obligated proj ects should include both highway and transit projects. 6. GBVMPO will compile the TIP for the Region, including preparing a narrative. Projects will be categorized by federal aid program and listed in summary tables. The TIP will be converted into a format that will allow it to be downloaded to the Region’s website .GBVMPO will maintain the TIP by tracking amendments and changes to projects (schedule, scope and cost) made through the TIP/STIP Administrative Action/Amendment/Notification p rocess. 7. CT DOT will develop the STIP based on the MPOs’ TIPs and projects located in the rural regions of the State. 8. CT DOT will include one STIP entry each for the Bridge program andthe Highway Safety Improvement program. This entry will list the total funds needed for these programs for each fiscal year. All Regions will receive back up lists in the form of the Bridge Report and the Safety Report monthly . The one line entry will reduce the number of entries needed in the STIP. Any projects listed in the Bridge and or Safety Report that are over $5m and on the NHS, will be transferred directly into the STIP as its own entry per the TIP/STIP Administrative Action/Amendment/Notification process . 9. CT DOT will provide proposed amendments to the GBVMPO for consideration. The amendment will include a project description that provides sufficient detail to allow the GBVMPO to explain the proposed changes to the GBVMPO board. It will also provide a clear reason and justification for the amendment. If it involves a new project, CT DOT will provide a clear explanation of the reasons and rationale for adding it to the TIP/STIP. 10. When an amendment to the TIP/STIP is being proposed by the GBVMPO , the project sponsor will consult with CTDOT to obtain concurrence with the proposed amendment , to obtain Air Quality review and consistency with Air Quality Conformity regulations and ensure financial consistency. 11. CT DOT will provide a financial assessment of the STIP with each update. GBVMPO should prepare a TIP summary table listing all projects by funding program sorted by year based on CT DOT ’s financial assessment. 50 Air Quality Planning 1.CT DOT andGBVMPO may meet at least once per year to discuss the air quality conformity process, the regional emissions analysis and air quality modeling. 2. CT DOT will conduct the regional emissions analysis, which includes the GBVMPO area and provide the results to the GBVMPO . The regional emissions analyses for the build or future years will include the proposed transportation improvements included in the regional long -range metropolitan transportation plans and TIP. 3. GBVMPO will prepare a summary report of the conformity process and regional emissions analysis for the Region. It will contain a table showing the estimated emissions from the transportation system for each criteria pollutant and analysis year. 4. The summary report on the regional emissions analyses will be inserted into the long -range tran sportation plan and TIP. 5. GBVMPO will make the regional emissions analysis available to the public. Public Participation Program 1.The GBVMPO will annually review and evaluate its public participation program. 2. The GBVMPO will update and prepare a list of neighborhood and local organizations and groups that will receive notices of MPO plans, programs and projects. 3. The GBVMPO will work to ensure that low -income, minority and transit dependent areas are afforded an adequate op portunity to participate in the transportation planning process, receive a fair share of the transportation improvement benefits and do not endure a disproportionate transportation burden. They will comply with federal legislation on these issues. 4. The GBVMPO ’s process for developing plans, projects, and programs will include consultation with state and local agencies responsible for land use and growth management, natural resources, environmental protection, conservation and historic preservation . 5. The GBVMPO will maintain their website to provide clear and concise information on the transportation planning process and provide an opportunity to download reports and documents. This will include developing project and study summaries, converting reports into a pdf or text format, and maintaining a list of available documents. The website will provide links to other associated organizations and agencies. Public Transportation Planning 1. The GBVMPO will allow for, to the extent feasible, the participation of transit providers at all transportation committee and policy board meetings to provide advice, information and consultation on transportation programs within the planning region. 2. The GBVMPO will provide the opportunity for the transit providers to review and comment on planning products relating to transit issues within the region. 3. The GBVMPO will allow for transit provider(s) to participate in UPWP, long -range plan, and TIP development to insure the consideration o f any appropriate comments. 4. The GBVMPO and CT DOT will assist the transit provider(s) ,to the extent feasible ,with planning for transit- related activities. Fiscal/Financial Planning 1.The CT DOT will provide the GBVMPO with up-to -date fisc al and financial information on the statewide and regional transportation improvement programs to the extent practicable. This will include: 51 a.Anticipated federal funding resources by federal aid category for the upcoming federal fiscal year, as shown in the TIP financial chart. b. Will hold annual meetings to discuss authorized funds for the STP -Urban and LOTCIP accounts. c. Annual authorized /programmedfunds for the FTA Section 5307 Program as contained in the STIP and the annual UZA split agreements . d. Monthly updates of STP -Urban Program showing current estimated cost & scheduled obligation dates. 2. The CT DOT will notify the GBVMPO when the anticipated cost of a project, regardless of funding category, has changed in accordance with the agreed upon TIP/STIP Administrative Action/Amendment/Notification process . 3. The GBVMPO will prepare summary tables and charts that display financial information for presentation to the policy board. Congestion Management Process (CMP) Program 1. The GBVMPO will conduct a highway performance monitoring programthat includes the collection of traffic counts, conduct of travel time surveys, and determination of travel speeds and delay. 2. The GBVMPO will conduct congestion strategies studies for critical c orridors and identify possible improvements to reduce congestion and delay. 3. The GBVMPO will work with CT DOT on programming possible congestion -reducing projects. 4. The GBVMPO will, upon implementation of a congestion reduction improvement, assess post-improvement operations and determine level of congestion relief. Intelligent Transportation Systems (ITS) Program 1. The CT DOT will maintain the statewide ITS architecture and ensure consistency with the Regional ITS Architecture for the GBVMPO . 2. The GBVMPO will maintain and update the Regional ITS Architecture for the GBVMPO , where appropriate. Amendment This Statement on Transportation Planning may be amended from time to time or to coincide with annual UPWP app roval as jointly deemed necessary or in the best interests of all parties, including Federal transportation agencies. Effective Date This Statement will be effective after it has been endorsed by the GBVMPO as part of the UPWP, and as soon as the UPWP has been approved by the relevant Federal transportation agencies. No Limitation on Statutory Authority Nothing contained in this Statement is intended to or shall limit the authority or responsibilities assigned to signatory organizations under Conne cticut law, federal law, local ordinance, or charter. 52 Resolution GREATER BRIDGEPORT AND VALLEY METROPOLITAN PLANNING ORGANIZATION Ansonia ●Bridgeport ●Derby ●Easton ●Fairfield ●Monroe ●Seymour ●Shelton ●Stratford ●Trumbull Responsible Metropolitan Transportation Planning Agencies CONNECTICUT METROPOLITAN COUNCIL OF GOVERNMENTS NAUGATUCK VALLEY COUNCIL OF GOVERNMENTS 1000 Lafayette Boulevard, Suite 925 49 Leavenworth Street, Suite 301 Bridgeport, Connecticut 06604 -4902 Waterbury, Connecticut 06702 Phon e: (203) 366 -5405 Fax: 366 -8437 Phone: (203) 757 -0535 Fax: 756 -7688 E-mail: mfulda @ctmetro.org E-mail: rdunne@nvcogct.org RESOLUTION 2017-14 ADOPTION : FY 2018 AND 2019 UNIFIED PLANNING WORK PROGRAM GREATER BRIDGEPORT AND VALLEY METROPOLITAN PLANNING ORGANIZATION WHEREAS , the Greater Bridgeport and Valley MPO (GBVMPO) is the federally designated transportation planning agency for the Greater Bridgeport and Valley planning region and receives metropolitan transportation planning funds from the US Department of Transportation to conduct the transportation planning process in conformity with federal planning guidelines; WHEREAS , the GBVMPO is required to prepare a Unified Planning Work Program (UPWP) that describes the tasks it will undertake over the next two years; WHEREAS , the GBVMPO has prepared the Unified Planning Work Program for FY 2018 and FY 2019 . NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the Greater Bridgeport and Valley MPO has reviewed the draft UPWP for the GBVMPO and adopts it as the UPWP for the MPO. BE I T FURT HER RESOLVED that the Greater Bridgeport and Valley MPO authorizes the Executive Director of the Connecticut Metropolitan Council of Governments to negotiate and execute any and all planning agreements with the Connecticut Department of Transportation rela ting to Unified Planning Work Program . This resolution shall become effective as of June 15 th, 2017. I do hereby certify that the resolution adopted by the GBV MPO at a public meeting held on June 15th, 2017 , at which a quorum was present and that the same is a correct and true transcript from the original thereof. Respectfully submitted, Matt Fulda, Executive Director Richard T. Dunne, Executive Director MetroCOG – MPO Co-Secretary NVCOG – MPO Co- Secretary Date: June 15 th, 2017

Central CT MPO Long Range Regional Transportation Plan 2015-2040

CCMPO-LRTP-2015-final-adopted-1.jpg

EdZ>KEEd/hd DdZKWK>/dEW>EE/E ‘KZ’E/d/KE ???  D]v^?U ,??(}?Ud?? ?? ? KWdWZ/>??U?? ?? ????D]v}?h?? ?  }( ??? ]?o]u? dZ]???}??Z?v??????Zv??o}vv??? D??}?}o]?vWovv]vPK?Pv]??}v ]v}}???}v?]?Z?ZhX^ X???uv? }(d?v??}???}vU ]vo? ]vP]?????]??vPPv]?U  v?Z}vv??????uv?}(d?v??}???}vXdZ}?]v]}v?U.v]vP?Uv }vo??]}v??????]v?Z]???o]?}v? ?Z}?}(?Zv??o}vv??? D??}?}o]?vWovv]vPK?Pv]??}v  v}v}?v?r ??]o??G??Z }8]o ?]??}??}o]]?}(?Z ^??}(}vv???X ????D]v}?h?? ?  }( ??? Contents KEdEd^ ………………………….. ………………………….. ………………. ? &KZtKZ ………………………….. ………………………….. …………….. ? ????D]v}?h?? ………………………….. ………………………….. ………… ? s/^/KE ………………………….. ………………………….. ……………………. ? E?}vo??(}?uvP }o? ………………………….. …………………………. ? D:KZ/DWZKsDEd^ ………………………….. ………………………. ?? ‘v?o ………………………….. ………………………….. ……………………….. ?? W???]v?v?o ]??? ………………………….. ………………………….. … ?? W?o]d?v?]? ………………………….. ………………………….. ……………….. ?? W?]???Z]o? ………………………….. ………………………….. ……………. ?? &?]PZ? ………………………….. ………………………….. ………………………… ?? WZ^Zsd/KE?hW’Z ^ ………………………….. …………………. ?? &/EE^ ………………………….. ………………………….. ……………… ?? &?o(?v]vP ………………………….. ………………………….. ……………. ?? ^??vo}o(?v]vP ………………………….. ………………………….. …. ?? Z?v????u??}v?v??u?? ………………………….. …………… ?? WKW> ………………………….. ………………………….. …………………. ?? W}??o?}v ………………………….. ………………………….. …………………… ?? }v}u]? ………………………….. ………………………….. …………………… ?? Pv]?]o]?? ………………………….. ………………………….. …………. ?? Zv?Zv]]?? ………………………….. ………………………….. ………… ?? ,}??]vPvZ}??Z}o?Z]o? ………………………….. …………………. ?? ^z^dD^ ………………………….. ………………………….. ……………… ??? W???]v?v?o]??? ………………………….. ………………………….. .. ??? W?o]??v?]? ………………………….. ………………………….. ……………… ??? W?]???Z] o? ………………………….. ………………………….. ………….. ??? &?]PZ? ………………………….. ………………………….. ………………………. ??? }vPZvPd?v??}???}v Wov~>ZdW(}?v??o }vv???U ?Z?}?PZ ????Uo??}???}?]?]}v}(?Z(}?uv (?v?}v?  }(?Z ? P]}v[?  ??v??}???}v ????uv}?v?]? ?]oo(}????o  ????}}uX  ,}???U?Z]??]?]}v]?v}????X  dZWov]?G?]o v  u???]??} ???} ZvP?]v?P]}vov?X  Z?o??}vv  ??]?]}v?  }(?Z Wov }??  ?u?G??Z????}?}(?Z(?u? ??}l??Z  Wov?o?v?X dZ WovP]?? ?v??Z}?}(??v??}???}v ]v ?Z ?P]}v?]?Z  ?]? ?}??  ?Z  (????X  W?}i?vP (???? vv??u]v]vP  Z}??}u??Z?v ]?  }oo}???  ??}??X  d Zvl? ? ??v?}?Z ??+ ?Z}  ??Z}??ZWov v ?} ?Z  }vv???  ???uv?}(d?v??}???}v  (}?]??Zo? X  /v???(?}u?Z Pv? }?U ??+}( uu?  u? v]]?o]??U  v?Z ??o] ]?u?Z  ???]?X ????D]v}?h?? ?  }( ??? ????D]v}?h?? WhZWK^K&d,/^ D/EKZ hWd dZ??]u??????}?}(?Z]?  ???]??}}u?o??]?Zv??r ??]?uv???Z??????}(?ZD}?]vPZ(}?W?}P?u]v ?Z?? ??  v????~DW r ??oP]?o?}vXDW r ??]v??}?v? ouv???Z?u???}v?]??DWK??Zv????]vP ?Z]???v??}???}v?ov?X DWK ]?}]vP  u]v}????U]v??}((?oo???U(}? v?u? }(??}v?X dZ .?????}v ]??Z? DW r ?????]?? DWK??}}}?]v??]?Z?Z]????[????uv?}(??v??}?r ??}v?}?o}???(}?uvu??]??}??]v?ovv]vP +}???XDWK[?o}vP r ?vP? ?v??}???}v?ov~??oo??Z >ZdW?}(}?Z?DWK?]v}vv??????(}?v???r (}??Z}?u??]?????X ?}v??}v(}?}]vPu]v}????]v??}((?oo??r ?]??Z?DWK}?v?]?]v}vv????ZvP]vPX/v ????U?Z  ^??}(}vv???]v]????}???}?}?Pv]? ]???P]}vo?ovv]vP}?Pv]??}v?~ ZWK?U ?Z}Z???]?}vr oo?v?ZZ}???}(?Z???[?DWK?Xd Z]???}??  ???o?   ]v ?Zv??o}vv???ZP]}voWovv]vPPv? ]vP]?r ?}o? X &}?? } ( ?Z u?v]]?o]?? i}]v ?Z ?]?}o ZP]}v }?v]o }( ‘}??vuv??  ~ZK’ U ??} i}]v?Z E?P??l soo?}?v]o}(’}??vuv??  ~EsK’ Uv}vi}]v?Z E}??Z???,]oo?}?v]o}(’}??vuv??  ~E,K’ X  ^????v? ?}?Z]??}?Pv]??}vU ?Z?}?v? o?o?]v]??Z]??]? ?}ZvP  ?ZDWK}?v?]??}u?ZZWK}?v?]?X  tZ]o?ZZWK? r ?]Pv?}v??}????}u?o?]v:v??? ????U?ZDWK??}??]??l]vPo}vP?XdZDWK? r ?]Pvr ?}v??}?????]???Z?u?v]]?o]??  v?ZP} ??v}?  ?r ??}?}(?Z}?v??ZvPX?}(?Z]???]?vPU?Zu?v]]?or ]??o}vP]vP?}DWKUZK’UEsK’UvE,K’Z?oo }8]oo?v}???ZZvPX/v&???????? ?ZZK’v EsK’U????}???oo?Z???]?]?u?v]]?ovDWK??r }o ??}v?U?v?o???}?Z  ‘}??v}?[?}8?????vP?r ??}?o}(?Z}?v??ZvPXdZ????}?o]???oo?v]vPX DWKv?]????Z? ?Z]???}???]oov}?}u?o??v?o :?v????X Eyd^dW^ Kv?Z}?v?]??}8]oo?ZvPUDWK?]oo? ?}?]?? v?Zvo?PDWK??]oo??]??Z]??ov??}]v}?r ?}???Zv?u?v]]?o]?? X  ???v?DWKu?v]]?o]??  vv}?]v}??}????]vP?Z]?u]v}??????Z?? v}?}8]o o?uu??}(?Z]?????uv?DWK?X /v:?o?U????U}vv???[DWK??]oo}u?o?(?oo???}( ?Z]?>ZdW?X??Z]??uU](?Z DWK??]Pv?}v??}??]? }u?o? UZ}(?ZDWK??]?]vPu?v]]?o]??(?}u?Z  v??o }vv??? DWK ?]oo ]vo? ?Z? u?v]]?o]?? ]v ????D]v}?h?? ?  }( ??? ?Z]?????????? X Z?P]}v[???]??ov??]oo]vo? (?oo????Z??]oo ]v}??}??   ?Zv?U??]}? ]??Uv??}r i??(?}u?Zoo}(?ZDWK[?uu?  u?v]]?o]??X  /v?Z  uv?uU?Z]?}?uv??]oo?????Zo}vP r ?vP??v??}?r ??}v?ov(}??Z??vu?v]]?o]??}(?Zv??o}vv?r ]??ZP]}vX t,d[^Et tZ]o v}?  }u??Zv?]? ]v v???U ?Z]? ??? ]vo??  v?u?}(ZvP?XdZ?]vo?W x v??ov?}v }(?ZDWK????????]vP??}???Z?]? }vP}]vP]v}vv???  ~?}? x Z(?v??}?Z}vP}]vP??}??}(??o]?Z]vP??r (}?uvu??]?(}?DWK?]v}vv???  ~??Z Er ?}vo??(}?uvP}o?  ??}v}v?P ?  x v??v]????]}v}((?]PZ??ovv]vP  +}???  ~? ?Z &?]PZ?  ??}v}v?P ??  x dZ]vo??]}v}(v?  }????   o}vP r ??u??}i???} }??u]? u?v]]?o ?Z]o ?}???  ~? ?P ??  U r ?o}??P]}vo]l??Zv??}?l  ~??P ??  U?v?r ?l}u??Zv?]???]?}(??v?]??}???  ~??P ??  U????}(?ZZ}???l???} ??]}?]vE??]?]v v?o]v  ~??P ??  Uv????} (Du}?]o}?or ??]v?]??}o  ~??P ??  x h????}??}i???Z???v???  ~??Z Di}? ]u??}?uv??  ??}v}v?P ??  x h?? .vv]o ?  ~? ?Z &]vv?  ??}v }v ?P ??  x h?? K?}v ]? Y?o]?? }v(}?u]?? Z?}?? ~? ov]??vuvuv??  ??}v  }v?P ???  dZ?}?PZ}???Z]??ovU??}v??Z??v?}??Z?]vo??]Pr v].v???]?]}v?U?]??o?]v}?vPX ?v}?}?U L??ZDWK}?v?]?????v ?Z? ZvP?? ]oo]v?P??]v?}?Z?ov?}(?Zv?o?vo?P ?]?}oZP]}v}?v]o}(’}??vuv??vE?P??lsoo? }?v]o}(’}??vuv??X ????D]v}?h?? ?  }( ??? V ision dZv??o}vv??? D??}?}o]?vWovv]vPK?Pv]??}v  ?]oo?}?l ?}P?Z??]?Z]?? uu?? ?o]vU?]??} oU??o]vP ?}vU E?  ?]?]vU Wo]v?]ooUWo?u}??Zv^}??Z]vP?}v?}v????Z???v??}???}v ]v???uv??]v?Z?P]}vu}??Z?]?]}vUZ]??ZP}o?Uv }u?o??Z??}i??v}????Z]??ovX  &}??}???]v]?o?]v(}?u?Z]?WovXdlv ]v}v??U?Z???]v]?o? ???]?]}v(}??Z(????}(??v??}???}v]v?Z?P]}vX/?]??Z ]v?v?}(? Z]?Wovv?Z?}o]?}(DWK U?Z?]v???uv?]v?Z?P]}vU ?Z?Z?}vv???}i??}???P??}(?]??vP(]o]??U?G???Z? ?? ]v]?o?XdZ??]v]?o???(}oo}??}v?Zv???PX ????D]v}?h?? ?  }( ??? WZ/E/W>^ ?X ^(?? X/v???uv??Z}?o???v?]v??v??o]??X’]?v?Z Z]PZ  }v}u]vZ?uv }??}(  ]?]o]??  v  ?ZUu]v?]v]vPv ]u??}?]vP?(??]v?Z??v??}???}v  ?? ??u]??r ?v?o X ?X E??? X /v???uv? ?Z}?o ??}?? vU ?Z? ?}??]oU vZv ?Z v?]?}vuv?X v ]v?? v?]?}vuv ?]?l??}ooZ?uv??]??X d}u]v?]v?Z?P]}v[? ?oo]vP U  ?Z??v??}???}v  ????uu????????Zv?]?}vuv?X ?X ??X  /v? ??uv??Z}?oZo??}?oP??Z??Z?v?}XZ?]v??U?}?l??Uv?]?]?}?? ?}?Z?P]}vo]?U?}?lUo?vUv?o?]v]????o?Xd}Zo??ZuP??Z?U?Z??v??}??r ?}v????uu?????}?]?Zu?]?ZZ]PZo?o}(??}?]u]??vU?Z?  ?Z?(]o?Uu}]o]??X ?X WoX / v???uv??Z}?oul?]?v??o?X >]?o?}?v?}?v?v?]ooPv????]v?P?o ?}?Z?}]oU  }v}u]U  vv?]?}vuv?oZo?Z}(?Z?P]}vX  Dv?}(?Z???Z?(oov }vZ??u?U]v???? ?}?}}?]v???uv?? X  d}?????Z]?U?Z??v??}???}v????uu??? }v??]???}ul]vP?Z??o??v]??U?]?v??o?X E?}vo??(}?uvP}o? ?  }( ??? E?}vo??(}?uvP}o? D}?]vPZ(}?W?}P???]v?Z?? ??  v????~DW r ??]??Z ???v????(??v??}???}v(?v]vPo?U]v??}? v?  ??(}?u v r  v }??}u r ? ??}P?u ???]?uv? (}? DWK?v????XDW r ????(}??Zv?}vo?}o]?]v????}?? }(??(}?uvuvPuv??Z????W ^W?(}?uvuvPuv??]oo??v?(}?u?Z&?o r ]Z]PZr ????}P?uv??}?]uv??}?Zu}??8]v? ]v???r uv?}(&?o??v??}???}v(?v???(}??]vP}vv?}vo ??v??}???}vP}o?U]v??]vP?Z}?v?]o]??v??v?r ??v? }( ?Z &?o r ] Z]PZ?? ??}P?uU v ]u??}?]vP ??}i?]?]}v r ul]vP?Z?}?PZ_ r ?????V??h^???~ E?}vo ??( }?uv P}o? ? ??o]?Z ]v ??v ??X d Z}?P}o??o]??]v do ? X do ? XE?}vo??(}?uvP}o? ‘}o? E?}voP}o ^ (?? d}Z]??]Pv].v????}v]v??8(?o]??v??]}??]vi??]?}voo??o]?}? /v(????????}v]?}v d}u]v?]v?ZZ]PZ??]v(??????????? ????u]v???}(P}}??]? }vP??}v???}v d}Z]??]Pv].v????}v]v}vP??}v}v?ZE?}vo,]PZ??^???u ^???u?o]]o]?? d}]u??}??Z8]v?}(?Z???(??v??}???}v????u &?]PZ?u}?uv?v}v}u] ?]r ?o]?? d}]u??}??Zv?}vo(?]PZ?v??}?lU???vP?Zv?Z]o]??}(???o}uu?v]???}r ??v?}vov]v??v?}vo??u?l??Uv????}???P]}vo}v}u]?o}?uv? v?]?}vuv?o????]v]o]?? d}vZv?Z??(}?uv}(?Z??v ??}???}v????u?Z]o??}??vPvvZv]vP ?Zv???ov?]?}vuv? Z???}i?o]???o?? d}????}i?}???U??}u}?i}?v?Z}v}u?Uv??]??Zu}?uv?}( ?}?ovP}}??o??vP??}i?}u?o?}v?Z?}?PZo]u]v ?vPo??]v?Z??}r i??o}?uv?vo]?????}??U]vo?]vP??]vP?P?o?}????v?v]u??}?r ]vPPv]?[?}?l???? E?}vo??( }?uvP}o? ??  }( ??? WZ&KZDED^hZ^ o}vP?]?Z?Z???(}?uvP}o?U DW r ??]??? ?Z^?r ??? }( d?v??}???}v ?} ??o]?Z  ??]? }( ??(}?uv u????  ?}Zo?????vDWK?u????Z]???}P????}r ??u?vP?ZP}o?XdZ??(}?uvu???? u??? ??o]?Z??Z????vDWK?]v?Z(}oo }?]vP??W x W?uv?}v ]?}v}v?Z/v?????^???uv}v?r u]v?}(?ZE?}vo,]PZ??^???u~E,^ x W?(}?uv}(?Z/v?????^???uv?Z?u]vr ?}(?ZE,^ x ?]P}v]?}v}v?ZE,^ x &?o]?? v ??]}?? ]vi??]? v }?Z v?u? v ?? ???Z]ou]o???o  rr }voo??o]?}? x d?8}vP??}v x Kv r ?}u}]o?}??u]??]}v? x &?]PZ?u}?uv?}v?Z/v?????^???u ^ddEDWKdZ’d ^ t]?Z]v}v??}(?ZhX^X???uv?}(d?v??}???}v[??r ?o]?Zuv?}(??(}?uvu????UZ????]oo? o}? ??]?}(??(}?uv??P??XdZ???P???]oo?o}? ]v}v??o??}v?]?Z?ZDWK?]v?Z????X dZ }vv??? ???uv? }( d?v??}???}v ]? ???v?o? ?}?l]vP?]?Z}vv???DWK?U]vo?]vPDWKU?}?o}? ?Z???(}?uv??P? ?XKv?Z ???P?????o]?ZU DWK?]oo????Z]??ov?}  ]vo??ZuX E?}vo??(}?uvP}o? ??  }( ??? Major improvements dZ(}oo}?]vP??}vo]???v??]?oo}(?Z ui}?]u??}?uv??v??P???}u?}?Z ?P]}v[???v??}???}v????u }???Zv???????X dZ???}i????]v?.??]vP?Z>ZdW??}??? }uuv?????]?Zvv????(}??Z?]vuv?}( ?Z?]?]}v??oo}??}v?Z(}?P}]vP?PXW?}i??? P?}???u}V?Z??v}?o]??]v}??}(]u?}??vX E?}vo??(}?uvP}o? ??  }( ??? ‘EZ > ???? W  P  ‘]???]}?]???}u]v?vv}?? ??v?]}v X   }v}? }vr ????? v? (]o]?? ??Z ??v?}( ?]?oU?]??vP ]v(?r ??????? X  /v??U?l?}??]vPu}?8]v?(?}u?Z?]? o???]o?X KdU?}?v?U DWK Z?]?oo ??}i??(}?v?]?}vuv?o]u??X  }v}?????? ??}i???Z?]u?]??Zv?]?}vuv?X KdU?}?v?U  DWK ?]Pv?}?v??????}vZv?Z?]o?v?]?}vuv?X  h ???v??}???}v?}ul?(Uo]?o}uu?v]??U ]v??r ??o? ]v???]?Zv?]??}??}?v?o (} ???o}?uv?? v?]??X KdU?}?v?U  DWK /u??}??}oo?}vX  }oo??P]}v r ?]??8?Xt}?l ?]?Z?}o]?}?}??vo?P}}]v???}???v??8 ?]}o?}v?v??u]??Zuo??}v]oo??} ????]?r ?(}?????u r ?]vo??]?X ^???}o]U ?}?v?UKd ? ? ?o}?Z]PZ r ??}uu?v]?}vv??}?l?X }vv??}?lr ??vu?o}???]v?Z?P]}v?}?Z]v(}?u?}v????Z]PZr ???}P]?o??v????}?Z??]o???o~XPXU?o}uu??r ]vPX &?o P}??XU ^??U?}?v?U?or }u? ? ? E?}vo??(}?uvP}o? ??  }( ??? W?????v]vZ]??}?]}??]}??X  vZv?v]?]?? vZ]??}?]?]???Z?}?PZ??v??}???}v]v???uv???Z???r ???  ?Z?????v??}u}?}u??oov r ?????v?X ^??U?}?v? ? ? W^dZ/E^Ez> /^d^ /u?ouv??Z^??[? Z }u?o?????? [  o? X  oo??}i?? u?????}?](}?????]v?v?o]???X KdU?}?v? ? ? }??v??}?l  }(}v r  v}+ r ?}????]vv?o]?? ?}???X  Z}??? ?Z}?o}vv??}?Z&?u]vP?}v vo,?]?r P d?]ovZK’[?u?o? r ??v??}?lX DWK U?}?v? ? ? }u?o??Z&?u]vP?}vvo ,?]?P d?]oX  Wo?P?ZP??  ??vZKl,]ooZ}]v&?u]vP?}v  v, ??^???]v ^}??Z]vP?}vX d}?v?U  KdUW ? ? }vv?vP?]??]o??}?ZE??]?]v r ,??}???r ????]oX  >]vl?Z??????]o?}^hvt???u?Doo ?]?Z?????X d}?v?U DWK U KdUW ? ? W?}??v??vZ]l]vP??]o?X  W????Uu]v?]vUvU ?Z??}??]oU??v?Z?P]}v[???]o????uU]vo?]vP?Z E?vPovd?]oX d}?v?UW ? ? E?}vo??(}?uvP}o? ??  }( ??? Wh>/dZE^/d }vv??Z?P]}v?} ?Z E?z}?l]??U^?u(}?U?]Pr ?}??Ut?????Uv,??}?  ??X  d ?v?]??Z}?o]v??r ?P]}voX??v?Z ????(?o ?]P?}?? r t???????v?]? }??]}??Z?}?PZ?]??}oUWo]v?]ooUvE??]?]v?},??r (}?X  Z}v.P??o}o???}????}.????]X D??} r E}??ZU ddZE^/d ? ? Z?v}uu????]oo}vP?ZE?,?v r ,??}? r ^??]vP.o }??]}?X Z}v.P??o}o???}????}.????]X u??lUKd ? ? Z?}vo]?o}o???}???X  o]u]v??}???v??v?(?? ?Z??}??]o?}]u??}?????u??(}?uvX ddZE^/dU }vr ???}?? ? ? h?/v??v???]??ovv]vP ?}]u??}???]o]??X  ^?u]? oo ??v?]??}???]v?Z?P]}v (}?]vo??]}vv???X ddZE^/d ? ? ?]PvP?}Z]PZ?v?]?]]o]??X  W}??u??v?Z?o?? ?u?}]v??}?????}??X ddZE^/d ? ? /v?oo]Pv???v?]?????u X  / u??}???v?]?v????v?]? ?]?Z ?Zv}o}P? X  DWK U ddZE^/dU}vr ???}?? ? ? E?}vo??(}?uvP}o? ??  }( ??? WZ/sds,/>^ o??}v]Z]PZ???]Pv??}]v]?o??v??}????} ?}]}vP??}v}?]v]v??X  ^???ouv? ?]??vPv}?.r ?}v????u??]?Z?]Pv??Z?]???]???}v?} o??v? ?}???X Kd ? ? ??o}?}vv?vPo}o??????}????o??v??}??? (}?}vP??}??]}??X  Zo]???8}v???]o??lv]?vP ?}P?Z?  v]????]vP??8}v?}?Z????P?]X DWK U?}?v? ? ? Z?o]v????}v??]?Z?}?v}????Z????}??]?X  o]u]v??vv??????}???}]u??}??(??v??8G}?X d}?v? ? ? /u?ouv???uvPuv?vl}??]Pvo}}?]v?}v ?Z????}??]?X  ???u??8o]PZ??v}v?}o]? ?]????}v}vP???}?U??]oo?}v????Z?}?PZ ?}???U?}]u??}??(??v??8G}?X d}?v?UKd ? ?  ?o]PZ?vl}???u???vP?}??o}?}v?X KdU?}?v? ? ? }v?????Z?P]vPv??}?l?}????}??o??]?Z]o?X &?oP}??XU ^??U?}?v? ? ? E?}vo??(}?uvP}o? ??  }( ??? &Z/’,d D]v?]vv??P? ?Z?P]}v[? ?]o????u?}Zvo (?]PZ???8X  ^Z]L?u?Z(?]PZ??(?]o(?}u ??? Z]PZr ???v?}??}?]oX WvuUKd ? ? ‘v?o ??  }( ??? ‘v?o /DWZKsdK>>d /KE }u??Zv?]???Z}?o}oo?}v??8}v]?}v? v]v]v???P]}v r ?]X ^Z/Wd/KE d}v????Z???v??}???}v(?v????v?]v?Zu}??8r ]v?U }?? r +?? uvv?U P}} ? ? ??v?oX /v ?Z ???U??}??}v???]v??Z??vo?Po]u]??}oor ?}v?}??}???}?U??Z???8}?v??U?lv???]v ?o ???].?uXdZol}(}u??Zv?]??}Lv (}?? ?ovv?? ?} ?o?}v Pv?o]??}v? vv}?o ?]r vvul???}i??o}?uv?U?o??}vUv??]}?]r ???}vZoovPX dZ??}o](??}v}(’W^???v???}o??}v?}?Z]???} ouX Dv?’W^?v]??U??Z??Zu]oo]}v?}(?u???Z}v?]v]??or ?}vU??}??l}v??8}v]?}v?X^????]v?P???Z? ??}???v}?]v?}?v??Z}??}(u}uv???}v]?}v???o?} ]v?}}u??Zv?]?Z]??}?]o????]?Z?}?v r ?Z r o}lU v?}v?]}??PX?}(??]?vPU’}}PoU(}?]v??vUv}? }vo?P]??o]???8u??}voo?}?(?}u????????}?v ?}}oo?}??V]?o?}ul?????? r Z}??o?u??}( ???]o  ??8 ?]ooX dZ ???}?u?}?o }u??Zv?]?v?? }( ?Z? ?}?? ?U?Z]Zvo?}]vo?}?Z?]v(}?u?}v??Z??oo ?u?v???o?}???U??(??Z?}oo?}v?]??}( ?v ?Z o?P?? DWK?vKd?X ???}?Z]? ]v(}?u?}v }?o ??}o??}v]? ??v??}???}v ?ovv]vPX &}? ?Z? ??}vU ?Z]?Wov oo?}voo?o?v??????}ulP}} r (]?Z+}??? ?}??]??Z]?]v(}?u?}vX dZ??o?}}??}???v]??(}?P?Z?]vP?.???ZvX]r v???}???U(}?]v??vU]vo??Zo}?}v}(?Z]v?X dZ?o}?}v??v}?v??]vv???v ?]?(}?uUo? o}vP}}v??o?]v?}????]??XdZ]? ul??}?l]vP?]?Z?Z?????]8?o?v]u?]???Z(r .]v?}(?(??]u??}?uv???}P?u?Xd}?????Z]?U?Z]? Wov?}uuv?}??]?vPoo^?? v  o}o?}o ]?Z??r ??}v?}??8]v]v???]?Z’W^?v]???Z??}?o}?}v v??u]??Z??}v??o]v]v??P]????X K^d W?}i? }???v? }v ?Z ?}?? v ??? }( ?X dZ]? r ????o]v????v(?}u(??}?}?]?v?XdZ}??}(??]u??  ? }oo?}v]( ??}??o? ??? ~?]?Z ???}??]? ??]?r uv?v???]v]vPU?Z}?o?o??o?o}?X ‘v?o ??  }( ??? ^ddh^EEyd^dW ^ ? ???v?U ???} ??Z ]v(}?u?}v ]? u]v]uoX /v ?Z}??U ??}??uv?v}oo?}v}(?Z??}?o}???o??o? ?? ]Lo?X,}???U]u?]uv??}?]??XdZ?]vo??Z?]or ]o]??Uo]v?]vPUv}??}(?Z]? r ?????~?Z]o?}uv?r ??U??Z?’}}PoUZ???}(??v]v????]vul]vP?Z? ? ?]oo ?} ??v??}???}v ?ovv??U v} }uu]?uv?? Z? vu??oo??Zv?}?o}???]u??? }oo?}v ????u ?Z? ]? ?}???U ?o]oU v ?}?lo ~]XXU ?]o?P}}?v}?v}?]u?}?v???v}v]v]v? ???}v??XE???????}(}oo}??W ? Kd U D,^U vl}? DWK  P]v? ?? ?} ?Z]? r ???? ??8?X ^?????}?? r }??}v}(?Z]?Wovv}vo?? ?]?Z]v??}???X ? KdUD,^U^???}o]?o}?v]u?ouv??ov]vr o?]vPZ???U?P]?????}L??Uv??+??]v]vP}ur ?}vv?? ?} }oo? v ??u]? P }} ]v]v? ?X ^?????}?? r }??}v}(?Z]?Wovv}vo???]?Z]v.? ???X ? >}o?}o]}???Z^???}o]?????uX ^?????}?? r ]ur ?ouv??}v}(?Z(}?uv?}v^???ovv}ur ?o??]?Z]v.????X ,/’, r ^WKDDhE/d/KE EdtK Zd^dZd^/DW >DEdd/KE d?v??}???}v ]v???uv??u??? ]v?P?? vPv?]vo? r }uu}?oo????X ^Z/Wd/KE /v????U?Z^?? ???W?o]?E}X?? r ???XdZ]?o?~v}? ??}v ?? r ???(  }(?Z}vv???’v?o^?????U?X ??? U uv??^}u?o?vP?Z?????U_}??Z]v?P??}v}(oo??r ??}(?Z??v??}???}v????uU]vo?]vP?o]???U????]v?U v??v?]??]??]v?}?Z?ovv]vPU?]PvU}v?????}vUv }???}v}(?}???]v?Z^??XdZo?vi}]v?Kdv u?v]]?o]???}??v^??}vou}?v?_}((?v??r ]?(}??Z^}v?????}vU???}??}vU?Z]o]??}v}??o}r ?}v}(Z]PZ???U?}?}??????Y?}v?(]o]??(}?oo????U ]v o?]vPY]l???v?]?ol?X_&?}u.?o??????}vU Kdvu?v]]?o]??u????}??o???9}(?Z?(?v? (}???Z??}i??X 1  dZ]?Wov?}uuv??Z??ZP???}(?9}(??v??}???}v(?v??r ]?(}?P]?vu?v]]?o]??U}??Z?}(oo??Z(?v]vP??v]v P]?vu?v]]?o]????]?ov??}?Z??v?P}(oo?}?l??}uu??vP? (}}?}?]?o?}?}?l]v?Z?  u?v]]?o]??U?Z}?o??v?}v}u?o? o?Z}?PZKdvu?v]]?o]??]v?Z?P]}vu???v}?]v}?r ?}??v}v r u}?}?]?????]v?}?Z]???v??}???}v???? uU ?Z]?Wov???}vPo?v}??P??Zu?}P}}?v?}v?Z ?9u]v]u?uX 1  K^d W?}i? }?? ?v? }v ?Z ??].? }( Z ??}?}? ]ur ??}?uv?}???P?X ^ddh^EEyd^dW ^ dZZ}u?o??????[]oo]?o?X/?]?v}????}?ZKdv u?v]]?o]???}Z??}]?XE???????}(}oo}??W ? Kdvu?v]]?o]??]v?P??oo????]v?}??v??}??r ?}v??}i??X ^???? ]uu]?o?v}v?v??]v.v]?o?X ? d}(]o]??]u?ouv??}v}(?Zo?U DWK  ??]??oo ??}?}???v??}?? ?}v??}i??]v?Z?P]}v(}?}u?o]r v?]?Z?Zo?X ^???? ]uu]?o? v}v?v??]v.r v]?o? X ^????]u?ouv??}vX}?]vP?}o???? r ??????u?]v}uu?r v]??^??????u??~???? r ????U?Z??v?P}(?}?l??]vZu?v]r ]?o]???Z}?ol}?]l?}?}?l]??(}oo}??W?o]vU?X?9V?]??}o U?X?9V??r o]vP?}vU?X?9VE??]?]vU?X?9VWo]v?]ooU?X?9VWo?u}??ZU?X?9V^}??Z]vPr ?}vU?X?9X W???]v?v?o]??? ??  }( ??? ? Kdvu?v]]?o]????v?o???9}(?]?(?v? }vv}v r u}?}?]?????X ^????.?o??????v}v?vr ??]v.v]?o?X ? DWK  ?}P]? ?]PZ??}??}i ???Z?Z}u?o??Z ????? [  ]v]???o??}v?X  o??????  v}v?v??]vr .v]?o?X W^dZ/EEz>/ ^dZKhdEdtKZ< /v???uv??]v]?(]o]???Z}?o(}??}v?P]}vo v??}?l}(?]Pv??}???X ^Z/Wd/KE dZZ}u?o??????[???}Z?v??}???Z?}o?Z??r ???]v?v?o]????o?]v?Z??v??}???}v????uvr }?]vPo?oo?(}??Zu?}}uu}?U?}?Z?oo?}?oU v}?i????]???v?Z]????vP??Uu?????]?Z?(??v 8 ]v?X dZ]? Wov ??}??? ?Z? P}o? ]v ]?? ??]v]?o? }( ^(??  v ?? Xz??ZWovo?}?}Pv]???Z???}??? ?o]u]?X/((?v??v}??}????}?Z]v??}]v?]?]r o???}?]o?vP]ov.??(}??ol??v]l??U?Z]?  ??o]?}vu???}vv???X/v}?Z??}??U]v???uv? ?Z}?o (}?? }v ]u??}?]vP ??v??}???}v (]o]?? ?Z? Z? v??P?U}? ?]Pv? U(}?????]vv?o]????X 2 2  ,}???U?ZWovo?}u?Z?]???Z?oo??v??}???}v(]o]??U??? ?Z??}o?U??Z?]v?Z?}(o]u]? r ??????????U?Z}?o   ?]Pv?}???oo?????]?Z?(??X d}v????Z?]v???uv??]v????]vv?o]??(]o]?? ul(} ?}Z?v?U??oUv?o?u?o?????(?o????uU }u??Zv?]?U?oo r }vv?v??}?l}(u?o? r ???}??? ?? ?o}? (}? ?Z]? WovX &]P?? ?  ~?X ??  ?]?? ?Z? ?}???U ?Z]Z ???o? (?}u ??v?]? ??o] }v??o??}vX dZ ?}????]v? v?}}vv??}??o?}vv???v?}??o? ??v?}v??]?Z???v?v(????????]vv?o]??]vr (?????????]?Z]vv?]?Z}???Z?P]}vX~dZo??]vo? ?Z&?u]vP?}vvo,?]?Pd?]oU]???? o}?  ?]?r ?v???P???}]????]o?]Pv].vU?ZE??]?]v r ,??}? ???? u?o? r ?? ??]oU v ZK’[? u?o? r ?? v?r ?}?lX K^d }??}v}(?]Pv?v??}?lZ ?v}}??XdZ}??}(]ur ?ouv??}v?v?}v?ZZvP???}?}?v??v?(?}u o}?~XPXU?]PvPvov???]?]vP?}?o??o?Z]PZ~?]P? v??vvo?(}?????]vv?o]????X ^ddh^EEyd^dW ^ ?Lv??}?l ]? ]vo?]v?Z]?Wo vU???}v}uuv?? ?]??Z?}?PZ?Z??o]]v?}o?uv???}??X}??}v}( ?ZWov?]oo?]Pv](?}??}v}(?Z]?v??}?lX  W???]v?v?o]??? ??  }( ??? E???????}(}oo}??W ? DWK  ?o}??v}????P]}vo}v r  v}+ r ???? ?}??v??}?lX }u?o??]?Z?Z }??}v}(?Z]?WovX ? DWK?}?l??]?ZZK’?}?.vv]v?P???}??v?r ?}?l?X ^????]v????v}v?v??(}?}v??X ? Kd v u?v]]?o]?? ]v?P?? ?Z v??}?l ]v?} ?Z]? ?ovv]vPv??o]?}?l??}??v?X ^?????}?? r }??}v}( ?Z]?Wov v}vo???]?Z]v}v??X ? D?v]]?o]??]v?P???Zv??}?l]v?}?Z]?Wov?}(}vr ????}v v ?o}?uv?X ^???? ?}?? r }??}v }( ?Z]? Wovv}vo???]?Z]v?v???X ? Kdvu?v]]?o]???]Pvv???}i???}??}?]?r ??}??]?U?? ?(]o]??}v?]Pv??}?X K??? }v??}i??]?U????vP?}?? r }??}v}(?Z]?WovX &ZD/E’dKEE>,Z /d’dZ/> ‘?? ]v  u?o? r ?? ??]o }( ?P]}vo ?]Pv].v ?Z}?o  ?o?PPX ^Z/Wd/KE dZ&?u]vP?}vvo,?]?Pd?]o]??ovvU}v?v?}?? ?? r u]o??]oo}vP(}?u??]o?}?]PZ? r }( r ????vE? ,?vvE}??Zu??}vUD??Z????X/v?v????Uo?P 3  ?}oo??ZK’X 4  ??u???DWKX ??}v?}(?Z??]oZ?v??v}?v?}?Z??o] (}??ol ]vPv]l]vPXdZ???}v?Z???]lo?}u ui}????}vo(]o]??v?}??]?????}vU?]?Z}vP?r ?}v(???v?}vouv???X^?}?}?v?? 3  }(?o]???v?r ???]v???Z?]u????]}v?}??X??u?? 4  ]v]??Z? uv??}]v??o} vP?Z??]ovi}?}?????U????v]???]?]??U ?]?Z?}u?????}???U???}?u}?X??Z?u]v]vP?r ?}v?}(?Z??]o?}u?o?Uvo]vl??}u}?v?o? r ?}?r ?o?????vv??v?????o]?ZU]?]?v?]r ???Z??Z??]o?]oo o?}]v??]vPo????}uu????v ??o]??]l??v?ol??X 5 dZ??]o?????Z?}?PZ??}?}?v?]v?Z?P]}vU^}??Z]vP?}v vWo]v?]ooXdZ??}?v?o?}ul???Zo]}v[??Z?}(?Z ?u]v]vP?v}u?o?u]oP}(?Z??]o]v?Z???X?}(  ?Z]?WovU?Z}vo?????Z??u]v]vP?}}u?o?]v?Z ?????v??vW ?X }?v?oo ?v? ]v Z?Z]? v t?? D]v ^??? ]v Wov???]oo~^}??Z]vP?}v ?X ,??^???]v^}??Z]vP?}vvZKl,]ooZ}]v&?ur ]vP?}v 5  ^h?o]??_]l]vPv?ol]vP]vo?oo}?Z?????}???]?}uu??vP ?}?}?lv???}vU??Z??Z}??]vPU??vv]vP??v?U?]?]?vP(?]v?}? (u]o?u u??U}????o]vP?}??l}?v???]vuv??v?X W???]v?v?o]??? ??  }( ??? &]P?? ? X?]Pv??}?? v??}?l  v??]ou? W???]v?v?o]??? ??  }( ??? ? &]P?? ?  ~?X ?? ]oo??????U?Z?P??????Z??]o?]?? v??U?]?o?}]v?X 6  ???ZU?Z?} v???????]u??]ur ?]uv??}??}(?Z??]oXdZ]?Wov?Z?(}??}uuv? ?Z?Wo]v?]oov^}??Z]vP?}vU?}P?Z??]?Z?Z]?v]PZ}?? &?u]vP?}vvZ?Z]?U?}?l?}.oo?ZP??X K^d }uu?v]??Z?(}?v?Z?vP]v?]vPv?]Pv(}??Z &?u]vP?}v vo ,?]?P d?]o ]v Pv?o ??v? ???U??? ?} ? ???U??? ?? u]oX }v?????}v ?vP? ??v ?}?PZo? ? ???U???v??U???U?????u]oX~?]P?v}?Z??]Pv 6  dZP????]??v??}?UP?vo]v?}v?Zv}??Z r ?}??Z?}???Z? ?}?PZo?]????Zu?X ZoovP?v?]??Z }??????v?oo?XdZ]??]o?v??r u??}?o}????v???v???u]oo]}v?}vP]v?Ur ?]PvUv?]o?Z??X?u]o?}(?Z??]o?Z?Z????} }u?o?~? ^ ????  vv?????? U ?X  ?? X ^ ddh^  EEyd^dW^ D}??}(?Z??]o?]?Z]v}vv???Z?v}u?o?XdZ ?u]v ]vP?v?]o???}v?o]]vU}?v???}U?Z?P]}vX?}( ?Z]?WovU?Z?????}(?Z??]o]v?Z?}uu?v]??]??]v do ? X 7 E??????(}??Z ??]o]vo?W 7  ^?}v??Z???v?}v?????}v?v}?}v?]?^?v?]o?X_D]oP ]????}?]u?X do ? Xd?]o??}?}?v?? >}?}v ?l?u W???]v? ?o]??? d}?o???? ZKl,]ooZXU &?u]vP?}v dZ????U?l??l????? r ?WD ?? ?? ?? ^v,]ooZX  l^Z??l??? U ^]u???? dZ????U?l??l????? r ?WD ?? ?? ?? ^ou}v?}}l?]PU ??’?v? dZ????U?l??l????? r ?WD ? ?? ?? ^Z???U hv]}v?]oo dZ????U?l??l????? r ?WD ?? ?? ?? ^????W?lU ?}v dZ????U?l??l????? r ?WD ?? ?? ?? ^}??Z}(^Z??U^]u???? ^?v?U?l??l?????? r ?WD ?? ??? ??? W???]v?v?o]??? ??  }( ??? ? DWKv }vvKd P?}v?}?(}?  ?Z??}?}? Wo]v?]oo’?????vDWKZ]??}v??o?v??}??r (}?u?Z????X t]?Z]v}v??}(}??}v}(?Z]??ovX ? dZ(}???}?v?vu}?}u?o?vP]v?]vPU?]PvU v}v?????}v}(?Z?u]v]vP?v.v]?Z????}(?Z ??]oX }u?o? ?]?Z]v .? ??? }( ?Z }??}v }( ?Z]? WovX do ? Xd?]ou]oPv???????}?v D?v]]?o]?? hv?]o? u]oP ^???? Z?Z]? ?X? }v r Zo(u]oo]vl??v}?v?oo?v?vt??D]v^???]?.v]?Z]vP ?]Pvv?]oo???}v??}v?????}vX??vt??D]v^???v ?Z^}??Z]vP?}v?}?vo]vU?}?lZ????} }uuvX ^}??Z]vP?}v ?X? DWK]?]v?Z??}??}(]v]??vP  ?????}??u]v??(???}??(}? ?Z? ?]ov}??Z}(t??Y?v^??? X/?]????v?o?]vP?o???}vvKd  (}??Z]????]??}v XDWK?????}]v]???Z????]v&z? ?v}u?o? ]?]v&z??X Wo]v?]oo ?X? dZWo]v?]oo’?v??oo]v??}v???U???P?v??}}u?o??}??vP ????}v?Z??]o]v????X]????]}v???v???VZ}???U??}?Z]8r ?o??}(???]vP???}?Z?]o?}?]PZ? r }( r ??U ?Z??}i??u]v?]v?Z }v???Z?X  DWK]?]v?Z??}??}(]v]??vP  ?????}??u]v??r (?? ?}?? ?Z?}?PZ Wo]v?]oo X /? ]? ???v?o? ]vP ?o?? ? }vvKdX DWK?????}]v]???Z????]v&z??v}u?o?]?]v&z??X &? u]vP?}v ?X? ZW ??o] ]v ???? ?} ?Z ^?? K8 }( W}o]? v DvPuv? (}? ? ???U????}}u?o??ovv]vPUvP]v?]vPUv?]Pv(}??Z]v}u?o??r ?}v}(?Z??]o??vZKl,]ooZ}]v&?u]vP?}vvE}??Z????]? ]vWo]v?]ooX W???]v?v?o]??? ??  }( ??? h^tz^/dZ/>^ ^?????Z}?o}vv??Z????u?o? r ????]o?}ui} ???r v?}v???Z?^hvt???u?X ^Z/Wd/KE dZ?]Pv(}??ZE??]?]v r ,??}?????U?ovv?X? r u]o?? r }vo?Z]PZ???Z??]oo}vv??Z??}]??Uoo?(}?  .? r u]o ??]o (}? ????]v v ?o]?? ?? ??v ?Z ??v?]?v ????Z????[?????v??u]v??]v}?v?}?v E??]?]vvZ}??????E?]vP?}v:?v?}v]v?Z??X 8  dZ]???]o}v???????o}u??v?]}v}(?Z?P]}v[??]???r oo?v}v?]??v?]??}??v??}?lVZ}???U?Z??]o]? ??v?}(oo ?Z}??}(]???}?v?oW??u?]vP??]o????}?? ??Z?o?????}(Z}?????]v??}(,??}?~}?t?? ,??}? 9 U]?]??vo]lo??}????uv????o??o}vP?Z}??]r }??}??]?Z?}]l?XD}?}??U?Z]o?Z??]o?????]?Z]v u]o}?? ?}}(v??o}vv???^??hv]???]??vt??r (?u?DooU]?}vv???}v]?Z?XdZov???Z?????}?v? ?Z? ??v?}v? ~??? ?}?U ??? ??l]vP o}??U v ?Z]l 8  dZv ??}??]PZ? r }( r ????o??(??Z???v?]}v}(?Zu?o? r ????]o ??}(Z}?????X ?}}??v???v?Z??Z}??]??v??v????(}??r ???]v?v?o ]???vul?]?]u??}o?Z?uv??]oo (}?P}?Z]????Zv???o]vP?}~}?(?}u?Z???v?}v?X dZ]? Wov vv}? ?u? ?Z ol }( }vv??]?? ??v Z}?????v,??}? 10 U??]?v.??ZP????v}?vr ?}?vE??]?]vU?Z???? ??]oU^hUvt???u?DooX tZ]o?Z???ui}?]??}(??8?}?Z??]?????v?o???]?? ???]????}u}]oU?Zo????}(]o]??}?ov???o Z}???}??(}??ol]vPv]l]vP ?]?Z?Z??}??]v(???????? X ‘]?v?Z??Z??]o]?? ??}????]?Z]v?Z}??]??v}(^h vt???u?U?Z]?Wov?}uuv??]o]vP(?}u?Z??]o?} }?Z}(?Z?o?P??]?Pv??}??v???}??X/v}???} u?]u]? ?? }( ?Z ??]o ~v u]v]u]? ??}u}]o ??8U ?Z? ?] ??]o? ?Z}?o ?l ?Z (}?u }( ]?U }+ r ?} ??]o??Z??}??]oX &]P?? ?  ~?X ?? u???}?v?o?}???(}? ?Z??????X K^d dZ}??(}??Z??]??]o?]?????} ?]u]o??}?Z?(}? }?Z???]o?]v?Z?P]}v~}v?Z}??}(??u]oo]}v??u]oX 9  ^}??Z????v?]}v}(v]u??}?uv???}t??,??}?[?d?}???}}l d?]o ?}?o ??  ?]?o v ??(?o }vv?}v??v }?v?}?v E??]?]vvt??,? ?}?v??X 10  dZ?o]??]?Z]v?Z????]?}(DWK[??]???Pv?UZK’X W???]v?v?o]??? ??  }( ??? /v?}u??U?Z}??u?Z]PZ???}?Z?v}( ?]oX ^ddh^EEyd^dW ^ d}ul?Z???]o?U?Z]Z?}v???????v?U?o]??U ?Z(}oo} ?]vP?]oov?}}u?o?XE???????}(}oo}? ?W ? d}P?Z? ?]?Z ZK’U KdU v  +? u?v]]?o]??U DWK  ???]?v?o???}???X ^?????}?? r }??}v}( ?Z]?Wovv}vo???]?Z]v??}???X ? Kdvl}?+?u?v]]?o]??}u?o?  vP]v?]vPU ?]PvUv}v?????}v}(Z}?v?]??]o?X }u?o? ?]?Z]v.????}(?Z}??}v}(?Z]?WovX WZKdd/KEEyWE ^/KEK&,/>/’EddZE^/d ^z^dD h??Zv}o}P??}] u??}??Z??(}?uvU8]v?Uv?]r ??Z]?}(??v?]?v????v?]?]v?Z?P]}vX ^Z/Wd/KE D}????v?]?]v?Z?P]}v}?v}???v}v]??]PZ?? r }( r ????????Z??o]?}?U?Z]Z]??Z???]?Z}?Z?u}? }(??v??}???}vU]vo? ]vP???}vo??v??}???}v~??v (?]PZ? ~???l?X tZ]o ??Z ]v(???????? r ?Z?]vP ]? .?oo? ?u??U(}?]vP????}u]??]?Z??8}LvZ?v???]ur ??}v?Z??U?o]]o]??Uv??}(??v?]?????uWv}? }vo?????v?v? o??o?}}??]?Z??8 v ?Z?r o??vo??u}??o}?o??Zv???vP??? v ??U ?vo]l ??U ?Z}? ?]??? v ZvP ]??}v?U ?u]vPU }? ?ov?]v???}v??}??8U?Z?u?????l?}.??}??U?v ](]?uv?Z]?vP??8 iuXdZ]?ul???v?]??v}u???? ?]?Z?]?]vPUvU?}v???vUv?????]??Z]??r u?oo?X dZ?P]}v.v?]??o(]v?Z]??]???}vX}vP??}v~ d?8v }vP??}v U?X ??? U??]oo?}v?Z}??]}???????Z W?o]d?v?]? ??  }( ??? ?P]}v[? ??v?]? ????uU Z? u (}? o}vPU ?o}? ??]?? }v ]?? ??? v?v?XdZ]?Wov(??????}i???Z??Z?P]}v]? ?????]vP ?} ??? ?Z]? ??}ouX dZ? ]vo? /v?P??}v ?]?ZE?z}?l  ~?X ??  E?,?v r ,??}? r ^??]vP.oZ]o  ~?X ?? v?ZE??]?]v r ,??}?????~?X ??? XdZ???}r i???]oovo??v?] ??]???}????}vP??}v???}?]]vP ??]v?v????????]PZ?? r }( r ??X ,}???Uv]?Z??Z?]ov}???????}i???]oo???}vr P??}v}voo}(?Z?P]}v[????}???Xd?v?]??]??v}????r o]vP}v?Z?]o}?????}??]}??~}?? ??o]vP}v?Z}?}?r ?]}?????vo?}???Z}????]????oo????}( }vP??}vX^]v]?]?v}??]?o}??}??]o?}}v???????r ???]PZ?? r }( r ??}v??????}??U?}o??}v??Zv??]? ?Z???P}(???v?v? ]vu]? ??8  ?vX ]??? ??? }( ?Zv]??? Z? v ?o}? ?} } ?Z]?X dZ?]vo?W ? d?v?]??]Pvo??]}?]?? ? ^]Pvo}}?]v?}vl}??u]??}v ? Y??i?u?? ? vZvo??}v??? ? W??]}?]vP ? D?o??o}}?v??? ? W??vP?]v(}?u?}v?? ??u? ? do?Z}vv}vo]v??]?}}l]vP~XPXUKvoolKvo]l v??? ? }v?v?}?? }??u]??}vU ?o r ?u }u???? ?Z?o]vPU v??}u?]???Z]vP(}?]o r  r Z]v????v?]? ? ??}u??Z]oo}?}v ^ddh^EEyd^dW ^ ? DWK  ???]?v ?v?]oo?Zv}o}P]?Uvr ??u]v?(?]o}???}vo]u??}?uv??X ^?????]?Z]v ??}???}(?Z}??}v}(?Z]?Wovv}vo???]?Z]v .????X ? d ??v?]?  v}vvKd?]oo]v??oo]vP??}u??Z]o o}?}v?Zv}o}P?]voo?? ?L??Zo?vZ}(d (?r ??l X ^????]v?????]?Z?Zo?vZ}(d(??lX ? ^o?}???}vo]u??}?uv???]u?ouv?X }vr ?vPv?}v(?v]vPU? ?????]?Z]v?Z?u}v?Z?L????? v?v}vo???]?Z]v ??} ??X W?]???Z]o? ??  }( ??? W?]?? ?Z]o? >dZKE/,/’,tz^ /’E/DWZKsDEd^  o??}v] Z]PZ?? ?]Pv? ?} ]v]? o??v? ?}??? ?} ?}]}vP??}v}?]v]v??X^???ouv??]??vPv}?.?}v ????u??]?Z?]Pv??Z?]???]???}v?}o??v??}???X ^Z/Wd/KE ,]PZ???]v?Z?P]}vZ?Z}l?}]v???Z??P?o?o?}vr P??Xd}u]v]u]?o?vul}??uo??}(?Z?}v?r ?}?lUo??}v]Z]PZ???]Pv?Z?v]v??oo??}u}( ?Z?o}?}v?XdZ??]Pv?P]??]???]v(}?u?}v]v?Z ? }(}vP??}v}?]v]v??X hv(}???v?o?U?Z??o]??}(?Z??]Pv?Z?v?}u?Z?o]ur ]???}?Z]?????v??XD??P?}Lv]v]??]u?o? ?Z?o??]???U}??}^?ovo??v??}???U_?]?Z}????]r (?]vP?Z]Zo??v??}????Z}?o ?lvXdZ]?]?????o? ??}ou(}??]????Z}?v}?]v?u?o?(u]o]??]?Z?Z?r P]}vov??}?lV?v????Z??}P}U?Z?u??]?Zo}vP ]v?}?ZiuU}??o}?}?vo??v??}????]?Z?v????]?]vPX 23  ^]Pv??]oov]v?o????}]??}v?(}????i?v?}v}?] v??r ZvPX??}?Z}u?o?v???}(???oU]vo?]vP?Z}vG?v}(/ r ??vZ}????]v,??}?V/ r ??U/ r ???Uv??]vD?]vV/ r ??U??Uv? /( ?Z? ?]??? Z ?? ]v(}?u? }vU uv? }( ?Zu o]lo? ?}?o(}oo}?]?X d}v????Z(???G}?}(??8U?Z]?Wov?Z?(}??}ur uv??Z]v??oo?}v}(]?}voo??}v]Z]PZ???]Pv?? ????P]?}]v??XdZ??]Pv??Z}?o]v??oou?Zo]l?}?v ?]Pv??}vo}o?} ?U}??]??]Pv?}vZ]PZ???W?Z?]?U?Z? ??}??????ui}?]v????}vo}vP?Z?}??Uv?Z? ??}???o????]]v?v}(??????vo???]?? u]??}?(}?P?]??}vX /v??oo?}v}(?Z??]Pv??]oo???]??Z]v?. ?}v}(???r ?P] o??v? ?}??? v ???}??]? ?]Pv o}?}v?X &}? ]vr ??vU?Z?]??vP?]Pv?]v?Z?P]}v?Z???v}(}vP??}v }v/ r ??]vt??,??}?v?]?o??v??}????Z}?o ????ouv??]?Z??}?]Pv?Z?ooi?v?}v?U] v}?Z]r ??}v?U~???v?}v?Z?}???Z???v??(}oo}??W/ r ?? ?  ?? ? ?E ?  ??? ?  ??E ?  ??X &]P?? ?  ~?X ?? u???Z]??}?? ~?Z]v???oo?}?Z?o??v??}???X  23  dZ.????]Pv ?Z}?oo}??ooZ}(i?v?}vv]v(}?u?]???}( ?Z???v?Z?u???ul?}v??}????}v?Zo? ?v??}??V ]v??,??}?Vv/ r ??v??]vWo]v?]oovE??]?]vUu?o??o?]Pv? u?v?}]v ]?????o?u}?uv?XdZo}?}v}(?Z?oo}? }??]????}?]u?X~??o?]Pvo}?}v?u?]+?v}?o?X W?]???Z]o? ??  }( ??? ?Z?}v?]Pv?Z}?oo}?}??Zi?v?}vv?r ?v?oo?Z?}]v?v??}?[?}?Z?}??X/v?}u??U]?u? ??o?}}u]??]Pv?U??}?]u}?]v(}?u?}vv]?r ?o?}v??vVZ}???U?Z]?WovZ}o??Z??}u o??r v??}???U??Z??Z}?U??}}}u?o?(}?ou}??vr ?}????Z?]????Z}o???l?Zu?}?uu?X ^ddh^EEyd^dW ^ ? Kd v D,^ }u?o?  v ???  ]???]}v ?ov?X Wov???o?????]v????Xh?????v]vPX ? DWK  ???]? }??}???v]?? (}? ]?}vo }? ]u??}? ?]PvPvul??}uuv?}v??}KdX ^?????]?Z]v .????}(?Z}??}v}(?Z]?Wovv}vo???]?Z]v ??}???X ? Kd]v??oo??]PvP??}uuvo}?}v?X }u?o? ?]?Z]v?v???}(? Z}??}v}(?Z]?WovX >K>^dZdZKEE d/KE ??o}?}vv?vPo}o??????}????o??v??}???(}? }vP???Z?}?PZ r }??]}??XZo]???8}v???]o??lv]?r ?vP?}P?Z?v]????]vP??8}v?}?Z????P?]X ^Z/Wd/KE d? 8]vuv?????}(?Z?P]}vU}?ooo}vP]???? r ??? ?]?(?}ud????]oo?Z?}?PZ?]??}oU&}????]ooUvWo]v?]oo?} E??]?]vU]?Z??~??o?}v}??Z r ?}??Z(?}u?]??}o?Z?}?PZ ^}??Z]vP?}v?}D?]vXD}?????]o?v}oo?}??? v?U ?U}?}??]??X}vP??}vvo}vP??]??u????o?X D?Z}(?Z]?}vP??}v}???}?Z?o????]??}(}v?vr ?}??}oo?}??vU??]oo?U???]o?o}vP?Z?}??]}??X tZ]o?Z??v?u?}??o}o?}?U(?}(?Zu}vv?X  dZ]?(}???]????}?}??vu??}v?}?Z(?}oo?}??v ???]o??Z??U?Z??}????v]vP?ZuX/(]v????}v? ???}?u?]v?U?Z?????Z???Z}oo?}??v???]o? }??G}?X ‘]?v ?Z ??}Z]]?? }??U v?]?}vuv?o ?v?]? ]o]??U v ?}o]?o]v(?]]o]??}(}v?????vPui}?v??}??Z?}?PZ ?Z?P]}vU?Z?P]}v?]ooZ??}ul????}(?Z?} v??}?l]?Z?U??]oo????8?}o?uP?}??X~??}?}?r ?o?}v P?}??Z vU ??]oo?U ????oU ??8 ]? ? ?? ?} P?}?X’]?v?Z?uv??}???}?v??]??U?Z]vr ???]v}vP??}vu?v}?o]v?????}vv?oX W?]???Z]o? ??  }( ??? &]P?? ? XW}?v?oo??v??}???v?]Pvo}?}v? W?]???Z]o? ??  }( ??? Kv}??}v?Z?Z?v}?v??o}???  ?Z}?o]??Z?? }(o}o?????XdZ???????vo?P?(?o}??r ]??XdZ?????v????].}??}???v]???}}K}??8(?}u ?Z}oo?}??v???]o?VZ}???(}??Z?v}?Z? ?Z? v }vv?}v?X dZ ??}v ?Z? ? ???? ? ?} ?vr ???o]?]??Z??Z?}v}?i}]v?}P?Z??ooW?Z????v ???v}(?o}?uv?]v?Z?P]}vZ??]ov}???]?}vo ]??o}l?U?Z]Zv]????v+??o?]??]??o?P ?}o?u?}(??8U??U?o r  r ? r ?????? ???Z?]u??r ?Z??Zv??}u}?u}]o]??X’]?v?Z????v?ou]v?vv }?????Z?}????}?Zo}ou?v]]?o]??U]?u]PZ? ]v?Z]?]v?????}o}}l??Zuv? v v?Z?o?}o]?? v.??M dZ?u?o?}X/vuv???U}vo? ?Z}???Puv??}(?r ?Zo??}?ov?}(}?uo}l?}??}(???v?o?]?}vr ?v?}???????XdZ]?Wov?Z?(}??}uuv??Z??Z?}?r ?]]o]??(}?}vv?vP?Z?o}l?Uv?Z???o?v??? ]v}vP??}v~v]v??]v?vv?v.?? ??]}??o? ???]X ^ddh^EEyd^dW ^ ? DWK  ???]?}??}???v]??vul??}uuv?}v? ?}u?v]]?o]??X ^?????]?Z]v.????}(?Z}??}v}( ?Z]?Wovv}vo???]?Z]v??}???X ZKhEKhdZdZK&/d Z?o}vP??o}o ]v????}v??]?Z?}?v}????Z? ???}??]?X ^Z/Wd/KE Dv??}?]v?Z?P]}v?}????X??}?Z??o}?]? P?}??Z }( ??} r ?vv? ????v ?o}?uv?U ??8 ? uv? ]v????}v? ]? ?}v ?Z]? ?]??X dZ o}vP o?? ?Z????o?? ?]oo??ui}?]v????}v??]?Z??8o]PZ?? Z?(}?o} r ov]vPU]XX??]oo}??U?Z??]???}??]vr ???}?lo}o?}?XdZ???o?]??vv????l r ???? uv?]v????}v?U??]oo?(}?? r ????}??~??o?}U?}?}u P?Uu] v}?]v????}v??]?Z??8o]PZ??XdZ]?}vP??}v Z?v?u?}(??]uv?o+??U]vo?]vP????uv (?oUvU??]oo?U?Zv}??Puv?}(?lo??UvP?}?? Z?]}? ? ]u??v? ?]??? ~?}oo]vP ??}??U o??vP ?Z?}?PZ?oo}?  o]PZ??U?X  ?]u?o ?}o??}v ?Z? ???? oo }( ?Z? ??}ou? v ]vr ????]???Z]o???o???]vP?Zv?]?}vuv?o~]vr o?]vP]??}oo??}vUv}]?Uv(?o}v??u??}vv?(?? ]????}(?]Pvo]?]v????}v?]??}?v}???XdZ]?Wo vZ}o? ?Z?uv?]v????}v?]v?Z?P]}v}?oP??o?v.?(?}u }v???]}v ?} ?}?v}??? v }?]vPo? ???}vPo? ?}ur uv??Z??}?v}???}v?]???]}??o?(}?oo]v??r ??}v??}i??XdZWov????}????Z]v??oo?}v}(?}?vr }???  ?Z??????}??]?v(?]oX W?]???Z]o? ??  }( ??? ^ddh^EEyd^dW ^ DWK}u?o?????}(?}?v?o?}?v}??o}?}v?]v ?]??}ovWo]v?]oo]v????X ? Kdvu?v]]?o]??}v?]??}?v}???(}?oo]v??r ??}v??}i??X ^???? ]uu]?o?v}v?v? ?]v.r v]?o?X ? DWK  u}].??Z??}i??o??}v??}???}??]Pv }v?? ?}]v?? (}? ]vv}??? ??}i??X K??? ?]?Z]v ?Z? u}v?Z?}(?Z}??}v}(?Z]?WovX ? DWK  ?o??  ?}?v}?? ??}i? (}? ?Z d/W ?  u}v????}v(}??Z?P]}vX K???  }vv}??}???v]??r ?]?X ^^DE’DEdE ^/’E>KKZ/Ed/K E }v?}o]? ?]???? v ?? ?u o]PZ?? }v }vP?? ?}??}]u??}??(??v??8G}?X ^Z/Wd/KE tZ]o?Z?P]}v[?ui}??Z}?}?PZ(??U??Z?Z}????v ??U}vu]vo?  ??]?Z?}?PZ??8U?]?Z?Zu]P??}v}( ??]o]v?}?}?]?o??v???]??U?Z?v}?o?}??v??}?? o?P?}o?u?}(o}o??8XdZ]?Zuoo??8[U?Z]Zu}??? o}????vul?(???v????v?U}vG]???]?Z?Z???r ?}?v(?v?}v ]vP}(?Z??}???P]}vo?Z?}?PZ r ?}???V ]??u]????v}?}vo??u?oo?????}vP??}vv o???o?}???o??]v?]Pv].v?o?o??]v????X ~^ d?8v}vP??}v  v ^(??v????? U?X ???  v ??? U?????o?U(}??u?o?X ^??]??ov???}o]]??Z??]?? (????  }uu?]o?or }?uv??}}?v?}?v?} ??Zo]l?}?ooo?]??Z]???}ouU ??]v?Z?Z}???}u] r ??u?Z??]oov}?Z?u?Z+?}v ??8U??Z?}v}?????Z ?]??vP  ?o}?uv?Xd}??? ]?v}?Z???W?o}vP??Z??}?]??Z?U?Z???]ool? }u]vPX,}???U?Z?  }?v}?uv?Z??Z?]?v}?}}u(}? ]u??}?uv? v }v?Z}v????U]v?}(?????v???v?v }v??}ooU?Z}vP??}vv?(??Z????}??Zuoo ??8[vu]?P?Xd?}??}?v????}}?Z]???? uvPuv?v?]Pvo}} ?]v?}vX ??uvPuv?}v?}o]???Z]vv?u?o~v}Lv ?}}?o??]??]????v??????Z????](?u}?????]??X ?oo]vP?Z?}]v??}(]vP???vP???v?Z]v?Z}vv??r ?}v}(???v???oo????v?(uv????U??]vP?Z  ?}?v?o(}?}vG]?v??]vP?Z???]v(}?oo??v?r ?}???}v????~]vo?]vP????]v?U?o]???Uv??v?]??]r ??X Z}?? }( ??8 o]PZ?? o?} .v uv? ???]??X d??v]vP u}?r uv?? }Lv ?? (???v? ?]Pvo ZvP?V }vP??}v v ( ??????}v ???o?X ^]Pvo }}?]v?}v v o]u]v? uv? }( ?Z??vv??????}??v?Z??(]o]????G}???ur ]vP??8o]PZ???}?Z?u}??]???}v}?ZZ]?????[U?? ??Z??ZP?v??[??Z?}v?v?}?v?Z?}X W?]???Z]o? ??  }( ??? dZ]?Wo vZ}o??Z???]v?}???]v?Z?P]}v??v?}P]v (?}u?Z??Zv]???V]??Z?(}??]???Z??Z]u?ouvr ??}v}(??uvPuv?v?]Pvo}}?]v?}v?Z??r ??}??]?X ^ddh^EEyd^dW ^ ? DWK  ???]?}??}???v]??vul??}u uv?}v? ?}Kdvu?v]]?o]??X ^?????]?Z]v.????}(?Z }??}v}(?Z]?Wovv}vo???]?Z]v??}???X ? Kdvu?v]]?o]??}v?]???}v??}ov?]Pvo }}?]v?}v?Z??o?v?X ^???? ]uu]?o?v}vr ?v??]v.v]?o? X ? DWK  ?o????}i?(}??Zd/W?u}v????}v(}? ?Z?P]}vX K???}vv}??}???v]???]?X hdKDddZ&&/E &KZDEd ?o]PZ?vl}???u???vP?}??o}?}v?X ^Z/Wd/KE ,]PZ??8?}o?u?v?o???}(?}K??Z?  o?}?]?r ??}v?Z?vP?}????8?]}o?}v?Z?}u?}??vX ??}??}??}v???]v??Uu?v]]?o]??v?Z^??? ?vo?}v(}?????]}o?}vU}??voo???}v?XdZ ???o?v?v?Z?v}?}vo?]u?]???Z??v??}???}v ????u ~? ??]vP o?? v ]v?? ?? o?} vvP?? v ?????o?oo]??v??}????XdZ]?]?Z?P}???}?}]??X dZv}o}P?]?v}??]oo?}??v]?Z?Z?}???}+v???Z} ?]}o???8o??v????Zo]??}(}?Z??]vi}???X dZ? ]vo??Z}??Z}??v?o]PZ??v?]???v?(???Xd} v????(??v??}???}v????uU?Z]?Wov?}uuv??Z? ??}u?v(}?uv??]?]v??oo?Z???o}???U ]v??U?]}o?}v?U}??]?l?Z]PZX ^ddh^EEyd^dW ^ ? DWK  ???]?}??}???v]??(}???}u???8v(}?r uv?vul??}uuv?}v??}Kdvu?v]]?o]r ??X ^?????]?Z]v.????}(?Z}??}v}(?Z]?Wovv }vo???]?Z]v??}???X >dZ/s,/>^hW WKZdEdtKZ< }v?????v??}?l}(  Z?P]vP???}v??}????}???Z??}( o??]?Z]o?X ^Z/Wd/KE dZ?Z??}(o]u?ZvPU?}P?Z??]?Z?]?]vP(?o??]? v P}?}o]?o ]v??]o]??U ? ul]vP o? ?Z? ?Z ???}r o?u r ? ??v??}???}v ????u }v????? }?? ?Z o?? . L????]?v]?Z?v?]?}vuv?oo?v}?}v}u]oo?????]vr oX????o?U}?Z?(}?u?}(u}]o]??v??]]o]??? P?}?]vP]v??}u]vvXdZ?]vo??Z??]?}vo(}?u?}( ?ol]vPU]l]vPUv??v?]?U??oo?v?????}Z???Z ?? o}uu??vPv?v?(}??}vv??Uu?o? r ?? W?]???Z]o? ??  }( ??? }uu?v]??X ~Dv? }( ?Z ??}i?? o]?? }? ????}?? ?Z?X tZ]o?Z????}Z???o?ovU?v?u?}??}u?r ?v]v??v?}vo?u?o????Uv?u?oo??Z?]vl ?Z?vv?}(  ?}]??}v??}u}]o?U]?]??vo]lo??Z? ?Zv(}????]oo??}u?o?o?]????Xd}????Z]? v]vo]u]? r ???}o?uUo]u]? r u]??]}v?(????Uo??vr ??(?o?Z]o??]vP?o}?vU?}(??]?vPU????vP ?}u?l? Xo??]????Zu}????}u]?]vP}(?Z? ?Zv}o}P]?XtZ]o?Z?????(}?uo]lvv?Z??Z ?} ?]?Z }v?v?}vo ?Z]o?U ?Z? Z? ?v]?? (?o]vP v??Z??]v}u??o?]?Z?Z?]??vP(?o]???]??}v v??}?lXdZ?]?}(o ??]?Z]o?v??]????Z??}v }( v? ]???]??}v ????uU v}? }( ?}?] (?o ?vl? v ??u????}(Z?P]vP???}v????]?}?]P]v?v??v?}v?X dZ?Z}o?o}??}v}(o??]??]?o]lo??}v??]?? ?Z]v??oo?}v}(Z?P ]vP???}v?v????}??vP??]?uv? ~XPXU?u??u???XtZ]oZ?P]vP???}v??v}???v?]?U ?Z??Z}(?Z?o}?uv? v ?v?U](v}?Z?v??U}(?Z}?r ?v?}(]v??oo?}v??}???Z?P]}v v ]?o}P]??oZoovP ?vo]lo??}Z]??] ?Z}??P}??vuv?]v?}o?uv?X? v?}?Z??Zo??]?Z]oG?P?}??U?Z]?Wovoo?(}? ]v??oo]vP???}v??ooui}???v?}v?]v?Z?P]}v~ur ?o}???U ?Z}}o?U v ?Z}??]vP v???V ]? o?} ?}uuv? ????}??vP?Z]v??oo?}v}(Z ?P]vP???}v????}u}]o }?v?[?o}?}v?~]XXU?Z??Z]o??l??}??v]PZ?X ^ddh^EEyd^dW ^ }vv???[????uv?}(v?P?vv?]?}vuv?oW?}?r ?}vPvvsZ?P]vP???}vP?v???}P?u]v????Xd?} ?}?v?}(?Z??}P?uZ ?v(?vX ? DWK  ]v?.???]}?]??o}?}v?(}?Z?P]vP???}v]vr ??oo?}vX ^?????]?Z]v}v??}(?Z}??}v}(?Z]?WovX ? KdU u?v]]?o]??U v ?Z]? ???? ]v??oo Z?P]vP ??r ?}v????]}?]??o}?}v?X ^??????} }v?(?v]vP]??]or oX}vo???]?Z]v??}???}(????X  v??o}vv?r ??^??hv]???]??~^h  Z?]v??oo??}Z?P]vP??r ?}v?}vu???v]?o}}l]vP(}?}??}???v]???}]v??oo u}? X &?]PZ? ??  }( ??? &?]PZ? ^dhzK&&Z/’,d^z^ dD }}? ]v??]?Z????]v?P]}vo???v???}????v ?ov(}?]u??}?uv???}?Z?P]}v[?(?]PZ?]v(????????X ^Z/Wd/KE DWK}}?]v???]?Z?Z?]?}oZP]}v}?v]o}(’}??vr uv??}v(?]PZ??ovv]vP+}???X/v????ZK’U]v???v?r ?Z]??] ?Z?Z???v}?Z?DWK?U?o}?v]v]?o]v?vr ? }??}( (?]PZ? r ?o?v?]v(????????XdZ?+}??Z?u}??Z ]v?}}v?v?}??(?]PZ??ovv]vP??}???Z?  ]vo????lr Z}o?}???Z??}P?u??oo?(}??}v}}?]v?}v}( (?]PZ? ?o vv]vP +}??? ?]?Z ??? Pv]? v v]PZ}?]vP ?ovv]vP Pv]?X ? }v ?Z]? }v?v?}?? ?ovv]vP +}??U ?l??}??]v?Z(?]PZ???v??}???}v]v(????????(}?o}oU ?P]}vo v ]v?? r ?P]}vo (?]PZ? u}?uv???]oo  ]v?r .U v ?}uu v?}v? ?]oo  u ?} ]u??}? (?]PZ? ??v??}???}v}v]?}v?X ^ddh^EEyd^dW ^ ? DWK}v???ZK’?}}}?]v?}v(?]PZ??ovv]vP +}???X  }u?o?X ? ZK’ }v?v??  ?]?Z }vP}]vP (?]PZ? ?ovv]vP ??}??X  KvP}]vPX ? DWK?o????}uuv? }v??Z????o?(?}u(?]PZ? ?ovv]vP+}???X  o??????v}v?v??]v.v]?o?X Z/>^z^dDhW’Z^ D]v?]vv??P??]o????u?}Zvo(?]PZ???8X^Z]L ?u?Z(?]PZ??(?]o(?}u???Z]PZ???v?}??}?]oX ^Z/Wd/KE }vv???]?}??o??vv?}v???l?(}?(?]PZ?XdZ]?Z? uv?]oo+??U]vo?]vPv?]?}vuv?o??}ou?~]??}oo??}v v v}]?U ?(?? Z??? ~???l? ?}? }oo]?]}v vP?? ?} }?Z? ?]???U Z]PZ? u]v?vv }??? ~?Z? ???}? ?}r ???X  (}??Z??????l?UZ}???Uu}??(?]PZ?u}? ??Z]?}???]vXdZ?P]}v}?v}?Z?v?????Z]??]vP }??]}??V Z}???U ]? }? }??  ?]o }??]}? o}vP ?Z]Z ]o? }???}v? }v?v?X dZ]? }??]}? }vv?? ?Z?}?? ]v ?]P?}???]?Z  ]v??u}o???v?^??]vP.oX hv(}???v?o?U ?Z }??]}? Z? v oo}? ?} ??]}??U o]u]?vP?Z??U?]PZ?Uv(???v?}(??]v?X????o?U ?]??]????o?}v???]vUv?Zo]v]?v}o}vP?}ur ???? ?]?Z ???l (?]PZ?X d } ???? ?Z]?U ?Z]? Wov ?}ur uv??Z??Zo]v??P?vu]v?]vX &?]PZ? ??  }( ??? ^ddh^EEyd^dW ^ ? DWK  ?l? (?v]vP (}? ?]o o]v ]u??}?uv??X }ur ?o?X DWK  ??u]?,]PZ r W?]}?]??W?}i?????}??]r ?}v??????(}????u]oo]}v?}??]??Z? ]oo]v]v????X dZ?????]?Zo??]v?Z???Z}?]??}v}(?Z??v??}?r ??}v]ooX ? h?P???}?Z?]oo]vU?Z]Z?}?ov.?(?]PZ??? ??ooU?]vP}v?]?????}(?Zv??o}vv?r ]??Z]o^???X dZ????]??v???v  ?Z}?o}ur ?o?]v????X ? DWKv}vvKd?l(?v]vP?}]u?ouv??}ur uv?}v?(?}u?Zv??o}vv???Z]o^???X P]v? }v?Z????]?}u?o?X ? Wvu?]vP??Z??l???}???}(??]???8]v?(}? vZv(?]PZ??]oX ^?? ????}}v?(?v]vP]??]ooX }vo???]?Z]v??}???}(????X W?????}v???P?? &?]PZ? ??  }( ??? Preservation & upgrades /v]?}v?}?Z ui}?  ]u??}?uv??o]??]v?Z??]vP??}vU?Z ?o?o}?o]????].??}i??~??????}vv u]v}?  ]u??}? uv? ??}i??]v?.?}?]vZ}(?Z?}?v?]vv??o}vv???X dZ]?o]??}(??}i??]v(}?u??Z?P]}v[?d?v??}???}v/u??}?uv? W?}P?u~d/WXdZ?o??v}?.vovu??}o?]v???}v? ?}ZvP]vPv?U}v]?}v?Uv(?v ]vPX d??  ]v?Z?o? o}?u? W  ~??????}vU h  ~??P?U}? E  ~v?V d]u  u? ^ U D  }? > (}??Z}?? r Uu]?u r U}?o}vP r ??uX ~D}???Z}?? r  ??u??}i??Uuv?}(?Z]ZZ?u}? ?}v?Z}v???o?Z?Uv(}?v]v?Zd/WX E}??Z? ?]P??}i???v}?]vo?o}?X&}? ]????]}v}(?Z?P]}v[??]P?U? ?]P? U?X ??? X&}? u}?]v(}?u?}v?P?]vP?Zd/WU(?o(?v]vP ??}P?u?Uv?Z?ovv]vP??}??U? lP?}?v U?X ??? X W?????}v???P?? W?????}v???P?? &?]PZ? ??  }( ??? dZ(}oo}?]vP?o?o]?????v?v(??????v??}?? ?}v??}i??]v?.?DWK  vuu?u?v]]?o]??XW?}i??v }v???}(]u ?}??v?}?Z?Z}o?P]}v?o]???v??ZZ]vP ZP]}v r ?] Voo}?Z???}i???P]?v?v??Z????? u?v]]?o]??[?vuXW?}i???v}?o]??]vv?????o?}??X tZ]o??}i??u???]vo?]v?Z]?Wov?}?}?v?oo? o]P]o(}?(?o??v??}???}v(?v?U]vo??]}v]v?Z]?Wov}?v}? P??v??Z???}i??]oo?]?(?o(?v?}?}u?}???XdZ]?o]??]?}v?}??}(??}i??(}??Z?P]}v[?d? v??}???}v /u??}?uv?W?}P?u~d/WXDv?}(?Zo]??  ??}i??Z??}v???v]?U?Z]o??}i??o]??]v?Zd/W??Z?o?} ?]?(?o(?v]vPX??Z]?Wovv?Zd/W????]??}.?oo? r }v???]vUuv?}(?Zo]????}i???}v?]? ?v(?v}v????v?o?Zv? ????o}?uv?v?o??}vZ?v}u?o?XdZ???}i??U?Z]Z?v}??   ?v??Z WZ?  }o?uvU???]?(???Z?o}??}vX^}u}(?Z?u?o?ol}????u??V}?Z??v??v?]?????X  dZ]?Wov ]???i??}ZvP v ?Z?}?PZ uvuv????Z?P]}v v v?Z]?o]??u?????}?G?ZvP?]v??}i?(?]]o]??U}??U v??]}?]??X&}?u}?]v(}?u?}v?P?]vP?Zd/WU? lP?}?v U?X ??? X ??]?}v?(}???}i????~?]v]??v??Z}o?uv tZ? ??v(}??Z(}oo}?]vPW ?oA??}v??}oV]lWA??r ??]vv?o]??]u??}?uv??V?]PA?]P?Z]o]??}v}???ouv?V,??AZ]PZ??V Z]ld?]oAZ]l]vP??]oV ]v?/u?A]v??r ??}v]u??}?uv??VZ}vA?}v?????}vV?v?A?}?v}??V??^?A??????vZvuv?l??.?}vVZ]oA }vr ?v?}vo?]o?}Vd?]oA]?u?o? r ????]oV dA?}??u]vV d r ?A?}  ??u]v~?(??Vt]vA?]v]vP X Z’/KE r t/ tZ? tZ? d?? ??X}?? 24 WZ? d]u /v???P]}vo??v?]?(?}uE?z}?l]??u??}~?]P?}?? r t????? }??]}??Z?}?PZ?]??}ovE??]?]v?},??}? d h v  > ,]PZ r ??l]v??]???]o (?}uE?,?v?}^??]vP.oU ?]?o]v Z]o h v  D E??]?]v r ,??}????? ,?? E ? ???X?u W ^ 24  ?v]vP}v?Z??}i?Uv}?oo}(?Z}??u?}?v??Z?P]}vX W?????}v???P?? &?]PZ? ??  }( ??? ??v?]}v}(?]??}o?Z??o?}Wo?u}??Z ?? E v  D ??????u]u??}?uv?? d W v  ^ W?}??}v}(?ZE?vPovd?]o Z]ld?]o W v  v W?}P?u?}?]vP El Z>/E tZ? tZ? d?? ??X}?? WZ? d]u &?u]vP?}v?v??]P ?]P W ? ? X ? ??u KE ^ &}??Z}ZXU??vZuZX?}E}??}vZX Z}v W v  D Z/^dK> tZ? tZ? d?? ??X}?? WZ? d]u Z?X???U>l?X?}^}??Z]vP?}vd}?v>]v ?o h v  > Z?X?UZ?X????}&?u]vP?}vd}?v>]v ?o h v  > Z?X?UZ?X???U v:?}u?X ]v?/u? h v  > W?????}v???P?? &?]PZ? ??  }( ??? Z?X?UZ?X???}sv?]o?ZX ?o h v  > Z?X??UZ?X????}Du}?]oo?X ]v?/u?U ?]P h ? ? X ? u ZKt D Z??X??v?? d r ? h v  > ^?+}?ZXvDo??^?XVDo??^?XvD]?^?XVD]?^?XU D?o?XUv :?}u?XVD?o?XUWo^?XUv ??o]vP?}v?X ?v? h v  > ^}??Z^?XUZ??Z^?XUvhv]}v^?X ]v?/u? h ? ?X???u  ^ ^}??Z^?XVZ}?????^}??Z^?Xv^}??Z^?X??X ]v?/u? h v  D t}o}?^?X Z}v W v  D t}}ov^?X?/E’dKE tZ? tZ? d?? ??X}?? WZ? d]u ?]P]vP}(P??]v?Zd?v?]?d?]o Z]ld?]o E v  D ??o]vP?}v?}?vv?? ]lWU ??^? E v  > &?u]vP?}vZ]??d?]oU??o]vP?}v?X?}Z?X?l?????l]vPo}? Z}v W ? ?u  KE D D?o? r ????]oUZ?X  ????}??o]vP?}v? X  d?]o E v  > Z??X?v??? d r ? h v  > W? ????}v???P?? &?]PZ? ??  }( ??? EtZ/d/E tZ? tZ? d?? ??X}?? WZ? d]u ?}^?X Z}v W ? ?X???u  D ?]Pvl}v?????}v}(v}vr?}]?ov??}?l ]lW h v  KE D ??^?XU?? D]v^?XUvE?]vP?}v?X ]v?/u? h v  D oo]?^?Xv??]}??~^}??ZD]v^?XV^?vo?^?X ?v? h v  > ‘ov^?X????]v]u??}?uv?? ]lW h ? ?X???u  ^ D?o? r ????]o(?}u??????]o?}^h d?]o h v  D D?o? r ????]o(?}u???? ??]o?}t???u? d?]o h v  > Z?X???v??^?X ]v?/u? h ? ?X???u  D ,??^?X?}v?????}v Z}v W ? ?X???u W ^ Z?X???v}?]v?X ?oU]v?/u? h v  D Z?X ???  v??]}??~^?o^?XVolZ}l?XV >]v}ov^?XUD}v?}^?XUv?? ?ZX ?v? h v  > Z?X???UZ}?????u???}t??D]v^?X d r ? h v  > Z?X??UE}??Z^?XUv^?vo?^?X d r ? h v  > Z?X??UZ}????u???}??]v??? d r ? h v  > Z?X??UZ?X???Uvoov^?X d r ? h v  > W>/Es/>> tZ? tZ? d?? ??X}?? WZ? d]u u?^?Xv??]}??~t?Z]vP?}v^?XV?o?^?X ?v? h v  > W?????}v???P?? &?]PZ? ??  }( ??? &?u]vP?}vvo,?]?Pd?]oU&?u]vP?}v?}^}??Z]vP?}v d?]o E ? ?X???u  D W???]v]u??}?uv??]v}}l?’?vov??????}v}v?Z E?vPovd?]o ]lW h v  D Z?X???vZ?X?? ~}}l^?X Z}vU ]lW h ? ?X? ?? u W D Z?X???U}}l^?X?},}}l?^?X t]v h ? ?X???u  D Z??X??U???Uv???]l]u??}?uv??v?]?ol ]lW h v  D W>zDKhd, tZ? tZ? d?? ??X}?? WZ? d]u ??]?]?}v}(Wo?u}??ZZ???}]?v>u]v?}}l??}????U?r ?}v}(>u]vd?]o Z]ld?]o E ? ?X???u KE ^ oov?}?vZXU&ooD}?v?]vZX?}t}o}?ZX Z}v h ? ?X???u  D Z?X~]vo?]vP?o??? Z}v h ? ?X???u  D u]?^?XUZ?X???},]PZ^?X Z}v h ? ? X ??? u W ^ ??}v}(}?v?}?vu?v]]?o??l]vP W?l]vP E ? ?X???u  D ??Wo?u}??ZZXvD?Z??^?X ]v?/u? W ? ?X???u  D ‘????}vZX Z}v W v  D ,??]v?}v?XUZ?X??}?u?????ZX Z}v h ? ?X???u  D >lWo?u}??Zo?X Z}v h ? ?X???u  D D]v^?X ??^? W ? ?X???u  D Z?X?v,??]v?}v?X ]v?/u? h ? ?X???u  > W?????}v???P?? &?]PZ? ??  }( ??? Z??X?v?? ]v?/u? h ? ?X???u  > ^}?ZXU?}??XZ?}t?Z]vP?}vZX Z}v h ? ?X???u  D ^XD]v^?XUEXD]v^?XUv Pv??X ]v?/u? h ? ?X?? ?u W D ^?u}??ZXUZ?X??},??]v?}v?X Z}v h ? ?X???u  D ^}??ZD]v ^?XUZ?X ??}Z? X Z}v W v  D ^}??ZD]v^?X~?}Lv ?? ???? Z}v h ? ?X???u  ^ d},}oo}?ZXUZ?X??}v Z}v h ? ?X???u  D d????]oov???}Wo?u}??Zv??^]?ol ]lW h ? ?X???u  ^ t}o}?ZX’????}vZX?}t}o}?d}?v>]v Z}v h ? ?X???u  D ^Khd,/E’dKE tZ? tZ? d?? ??X}?? WZ? d]u ??^?XUD?]v?X?}??>vX?}Wo]v?]ood}?v>]v d?]o E ? ?X???u  KE D D?Xs?v}vZXUD?]}v?X?}W?}???^?X Z}v W ? ? X ?? u & D Wov???]oo??]v??]???]???.?}v~Z?X?? ??^? h ? ?X???u  D Z?X??v??]}???}? ]v?}?vv??Uv??^?X?}&ov??^?X ]v?/u? h v  > Z?X??UWo]v?]ood}?v>]v?}>??>vX ?o h v  > Z?X???U/ r ???u???}????o?^X d r ? h v  > ^}??ZvZXUZ?X????}Z?Z]?d}?v>]v Z}v W ? ?X???u  D :?>vXvt?? ^?X ]v?/u? h ? ?X??u  D W?????}v???P?? &?]PZ? ??  }( ??? Finances ^}?v.vv]o?ovv]vP]??]?}?o?}?Z ????}(v???v??}???}v??}i?X dZ]?Wov]????]??(?o ?P?o?}v??}.vv]oo? }v???]vU?Z]Zuv??Z ??u??}?o}??}( oo?ovv??v??}???}v ??v]????U}?Z(}???????}v v??P??Uu?v}???Z ???  ??v??]ooX o?Z}?PZ??}i?}v??Z}?o?lv?]?ZP?]v}(?o? v ?Z????v?oo???P????}?l v ?Z]?Wov???]???} ??}?] u}????}o??u?}(?]oo(?v]vPv??}i?}??? }??]????v?? r .????u??]}X&?v]vP(}?P}??vuv? r ??}v?}???v??}???}v??}i??}u?(?}u?Z?o?o?}(P}??vr uv?W(?oU???Uvo}oXdZ(}oo}?]vP??}v????v?? Z??}???]v???v? r ??~????}oo??X W?????}v???P?? &?o(?v]vP ??  }( ??? &?o(?v]vP dZo?P???}??}((?v]vP]v}vv???]??Z(?oP}?r ?vuv?X~dZ]?]?v}?o??????]v}?Z?????}?}?v??]?U ?Z????l??}?]v]ovo}oP}??vuv??u?}v??]?? o?P??Z?XdZ??]v]?o}?}(o?]??vP?Z]????r uv?  }((?o(?v?(}???v??}???}v]??Z D}?]vPZ (}?W?}P???]v?Z?? ??  v?????  ~DW r ??XdZ]??U??? ]v]v?}o?]v????U????Z ^(U}?v?oU&o?]oU(r .]v?d?v??}???}v??]???W>P?(}?h???  ~^&d r >hUv ]???  ?}??]?]v????X /?Z?v ??v?Z?}?PZ D?}(????X DW r ??]?}u?o?o?U??Z}?]?]vP??]????}P?u??}(?v ??v??}???}v ??}i??X dZ hv]? ^??? ???uv? }( d?v??}???}vZ??Z?ui}?]?]?]}v?U?Z&?o,]PZ?? u ]v]????}v ~&,tU ?Z &?o d?v?]? u]v]????}v ~&dUv?Z&?oZ]o?}u]v]????}v~&ZX r &,tU &dUv&Z(?v]vP??}P?u????]?W ? Z??Wll???X,?X}?XP}?l( ?o]l??}i??X(u ? Z??Wll???XLX}?XP}?lP?v??l?????XZ?uo ? Z??Wll???X(?X}?XP}?lWPlW???? X }v}u]v?}o]?o?v??]v?????Z(????  }(??v??}?r ??}v(?v]vP]v?}}??XdZo}vP r ??u?}o?v?}(?Z??v?r ?}???}v????u]????}???X&]P?????Z}???Z G????}v]v(?oZ]PZ????v]vP}???Z???Zo(vr ????X/v}v????U?Zu?]vZ}???vZ]v???uv? ? ~ZZ}(????U}?Z??u?o???lPU[?v?o?P??Zv?}v[? ??v??}???}v????uv???]v(??]}v}(?]?oXdZ?vr o?Z??]?}v}(uv???v??}???}v??}i??X??]? &]P?? ?? X&?oZ]PZ????v]vP}???u $0 $100,000 $200,000 $300,000 $400,000 $500,000 $600,000 $700,000 $800,000 $900,000 $1,000,000 1957 1960 1963 1966 1969 1972 1975 1978 1981 1984 1987 1990 1993 1996 1999 2002 2005 W?????}v???P?? &?o(?v]vP ??  }( ??? u?]?U?}u}(?Z???}i??ZovP?]?Z}?v???r o?  ?}???}v??}?Z}??oo?V]v}?Z???UZ}???U?Z ?[?o]u]??}v?}^?Z}?o r ??_??}i??o?}?Z?o?l]vP}( o}? r ZvP]vP(??]?~XPXU?}??v?}u]v?vvv??]vP ??}i????Z??Zv??? ]vPu}?}u?o?v?X~&}??Z ????}??}(?ovv]vPU?Z??v?(?}u??u?o??]?}v?]? }v r ?u}???v?Z}?Z](+????}???Z lo}P }( ?]??vP ]v(???????? ??]? v?X do ?  o]??? ZZ(?v??}i??]v?Z?P]}vXoo??}i??Pv]v???? v?v}?}u?o?X/v]?}v?}?Z???}i??U?Z? o?}(?v?Z????(]vP}(??lv?]o}?]v^}??Z]v P?}v v????]]v]????U]vo?]vP?Z???Z?}(v???v?]? ???(}??Z?P]}vX dZ]???]??}v}((?o??v??}???}v(?v?~(?}uoo??}r P?u????]???Z}?v]vdo?(}??Z?v????]} do ? XZZ r (?v??}i??]v?Z?P]}v d}?v ??]??}v d}?o?~??? &X? ~??? ^??? ~??? >}o? ~??? ?o]v Z}v?????}vv??]vPW?]?}?oZX ??? ??? ? ??? ?]??}o Z}v?????}vvv}?uo]??}v}( D]?^?X ]v????}v?]?ZDo??^?X ?U??? ?U??? ? ? ??o]vP?}v >]v???lW&?u]vP?}vZ]??d?]o ??? ??? ? ? E??]?]v W?uv???????}vW}?]v?XU??^?XU^?vo?^?XUvoo]?^?X ?U??? ?U??? ? ?U??? E??]?]v D]oov}??o?W}?]v?X~tXD]v^?X?}K?P}}?XU?? ^?X  ~E?]vPr ?}v?X?}^}??Z^?XU^?vo?^?X~Z??v??^?X?}^}??Z^?X ?U??? ?U??? ? ??? Wo]v?]oo Z}v?????}vv??]vPWu?X^?X ??? ??? ? ? Wo?u}??Z D]oov}??o?W,??]v?}v?XUZ?X??}?u?????ZX ??? ??? ? ? ^}??Z]vP?}v D]oov }??o?U^}??ZvZ~????L XvD}?v?s?v}vZX~????L X ?U??? ?U??? ? ?? ^}??Z]vP?}v >]v???lWWov???]oo?}Z?Z]??}?vo]v ?U??? ?U??? ? ? W?????}v???P?? &?o(?v]vP ??  }( ??? (?}u????  ?}??? ? X  E}??Z??Z]??o}?v}?]vo???}r i??o??].?^????]X_&}??u?oU??o]vP?}vu??r ]?u}v?(}?????]??8?]Pvo??}i????]oov}? ]vo?]vdo?](?Z???}i?]vo???]Pvo?}???]?Z ?P]}vXd?v?]?(?v ]vP]?o?}v}????}(do??Z]Zo?? }???Z?P]}v[?v^??[?o?P????}i?? t  ? ???u]oo]}v(}? d(???l~????]??v?]???}i???vE??]?]vv ,??}? v ???? u]oo]}v (}? ?Z E,,^ Z]o }??]}? ~Z]PZ ???]o??vE?, ?vU,??}?Uv^??]vP.oX/v ]?}vU?Z???]Pv].v?]???v]?]vZ]PZ????vr ]vP??v?Z?}?v?X^}u}(?Z]???]?}vu????o?(?}u ui}??????}i??~XPXU?Z??v?]}v}(Z}????]v?]??}o (?}u?????}????}?o]P]]o ]??????]?}v?~XPXUu?Z}(??r o]vP?}v v}? ]vP }v?]? ??? }( ?Z ,??}? h?v]? ??Z]Z?o??]?(?}u???o(?v]vP??}P?u?U??]? v???Zo??]??}??Z?}(?v?}vU?]?Z?]???]??}vov ??]??]u?o]?}v?X ?(}??Z  ?o?]v?Z]???}v]??}??(?}u}vvKd[? vv?o ??uu?? }( (?o }o]P?}v? ~?Z (?o P}??vr uv?[?oPo}uu]?uv?(}??Z(?o?Z?}(??}i??X dZ^??(d?v??}???}vW?}P?u~^dWU????}(?Z]Z? uvP? DWK U]????]o o??Zo?P??(?v]vP?}??(}? ??v??}???}v??}i??]v?Z?P]}vXo]P]o?}?(}?(?v]vP do ? X&?oZ]PZ??(?v]vP???]??}uu?v]??U???? r ???? d}?v ???? ???? ???? ???? ???? ???? ???? ???? ???? ???? ???? d}?o ?o]v ? ?X?? ? ?X?? ? ?X?? ? ?X?? ? ?X?? ? ?X?? ? ??X?? ? ?X?? ? ?X?? ? ?X?? ? ??X?? ? ???X?? ?]??}o ? ?X?? ? ?X?? ? ??X?? ? ???X?? ? ???X?? ? ???X?? ? ???X?? ? ?X?? ? ??X?? ? ??X?? ? ?X?? ? ?U???X?? ??o]vP?}v ? ?X?? ? ?X?? ? ?X?? ? ?X?? ? ?X?? ? ?X?? ? ??X?? ? ?X?? ? ??X?? ? ?X?? ? ???X?? ? ???X?? E??]?]v ? ?X?? ? ??X?? ? ??X?? ? ?X?? ? ?X?? ? ??X?? ? ??X?? ? ???X?? ? ?X?? ? ?X?? ? ??X?? ? ???X?? Wo]v?]oo ? ?X?? ? ???X?? ? ??X?? ? ??X?? ? ?X?? ? ?X?? ? ??X?? ? ?X?? ? ?X?? ? ???X?? ? ??X?? ? ?U???X?? Wo?u}??Z ? ???X?? ? ???X?? ? ??X?? ? ?X?? ? ?X?? ? ??X?? ? ???X?? ? ?X?? ? ??X?? ? ??X?? ? ??X?? ? ???X?? ^}??Z]vP?}v ? ?X?? ? ??X?? ? ?X?? ? ??X?? ? ?X?? ? ??X?? ? ??X?? ? ??X?? ? ??X?? ? ??X?? ? ??X?? ? ???X?? ZP]}v ? ?X?? ? ??X?? ? ??X?? ? ??X?? ? ??X?? ? ??X?? ? ??X?? ? ??X?? ? ??X?? ? ??X?? ? ??X?? ? ???X?? W?????}v???P?? &?o(?v]vP ??  }( ??? ?????]??}vvKd?}?Z}?o??].?&,t?}or o?}?? }? ???]o?X ~>}o ?}? ? ]vo]P]oX  ^dW v}ur ???????o????}P?u?XK(?Z? U?Z^??(d?v??}??r ?}v W?}P?u t  h?v ~^dW r hU ?Z]Z ]? ? }v ??v]? ?U]??Zu}???]Pv].v?X   DWK  ]????}(?Z,??}???r v]??v?]??}????9}(^dW r h r ,??}?(?v? ~?? u]oo]}v }?? }( ??? u]oo]}v vv?oo?U o?Z}?PZ ?Z ?? u}?v?G?????XtZ]o}vvKdu]v]????u}??(?o ??v??}???}v(?v]vP??}P?u?UuvPuv?}(^dW r h(}??Z ?P]}v?????]?Z DWK X do ?  ~?X ?? u}v??????Z?]Pv].v}(^dW r h]v(?v]vP ?Z?P]}v[???v??}???}v????uX??Z?oul?o?U ^dW r h(?v]vP?(??}v}(  ood/W r o]??(?v?Z?????or ??o?}v??v??]v????U?]?Zv???}v]v????U?Zv }vo?}v??}i???(?v]v?Z?P]}vXvv???}( vl  ]v]r ???Z???v}(?oo? r (?v??v??}???}v??}i??]v ?Z?????u?v]]?o]???Z?  ??X ? do ?  ?Z}??U^dW r h(?v]vP??]??? r ?} r ??v}?? ?u u}vP u?v]]?o]??X E? ?]?]v ?]? ?Z o?P?? ?Z?}(^dW r h(?v?]v  ?Z?P]}vU}??}v r ?????U??v ???? v ????X ?]??}o v Wo?u}??Z u ]v ?}vU ?]?Z ^}??Z]vP?}vo}?(}???ZX Z]??}(^dW r h(?v?o?}??]?}v???]??]?X? do ?  v do ?  ?Z}?U]+?v}(u}??Zv??v?? r (}o??r ????Zu?v]]?o]?? ?]?Z?ZZ]PZ??~Wo?u}??Zvo}?r ??~?o]v???]?(?v]vPo?o??]v????X dZ?????o??}v?(}??Z]???]?}vXdZ?]vo?W ?X W}??o?}vXE??]?]vZ?]PZ??u??uv???]v?? ???o]vP?}vX ?X Z}v??}?l?XdZ?}?ou]oP}(  ?}?o]P]o(}?(r ?o(?v]vP]v?]??}o]??Z??u??Z?}(??o]vP?}vX ?X D?]?XW?(?o?P?o?}vU(?v?u?????}v }u???? v v}? ?? ?]? ?]?X D?v]]?o]?? ?Z? ??u]???}i???Z?}????}v?}?Z}???]v]?o?}( ?Z]?Wovvv.??Zv???P]}v?u}?o]lo??} ??(?v??Zv?Z}??Z?}v}?X ?X Z?}??}v???]v??X??}?ZZ]PZ}??}(??}i??U?Z ?P]}v}Lvv}vo?(?v}v}???}??}i??~vu?v]r ]?o]??????X????o?U?Z?P ]}v[?]??v?}?v? u?v??Z?l]vP???v?X[ &????  ^dW r h??}i??~?]?Z??u?}???v}?]vo?]v?Z }??o???Z}?v]v ??}?JZ(?v?}??v}?(}?vX X Z???}i???]oo?}?Zd/W}v??}i??o}?r uv?Z?}vo?X W?????}v???P?? &?o(?v]vP ??  }( ??? do ? X^dW r h???v?P}(ood/W r o]??(?v? D?v]]?o]?? ???? ???? ???? ???? ???? ???? ???? ???? ???? ???? ???? ?PX ?o]v vl vl vl ?9 vl vl ??9 vl vl vl ?9 ??X?9 ?]??}o vl ???9 ?9 ??9 ?9 ?9 ?9 ?9 ?9 ??9 ?9 ??X?9 ??o]vP?}v vl vl vl vl vl vl ?9 vl ?9 vl ??9 ??X?9 E??]?]v vl ?9 ??9 vl ?9 ??9 ?9 ??9 vl ??9 ??9 ??X?9 Wo]v?]oo vl ?9 ?9 ?9 vl vl ?9 vl ?9 ?9 ?9 ?X?9 Wo?u}??Z ???9 ???9 ?9 ???9 vl ???9 ??9 ?9 ?9 ?9 ?9 ??X?9 ^}??Z]vP?}v vl ?9 vl ?9 ?9 ??9 ?9 ?9 ??9 ??9 ?9 ??X?9 ZP]}v ???9 ??9 ??9 ??9 ?9 ??9 ??9 ??9 ??9 ??9 ??9 ??X?9 do ? XW?v?}(^dW r h?Z? ?]???}?v D?v]]?o]?? ???? ???? ???? ???? ???? ???? ???? ???? ???? ???? ???? ?uX ?o]v ?9 ?9 ?9 ?9 ?9 ?9 ??9 ?9 ?9 ?9 ?9 ?X?9 ?]??}o ?9 ??9 ?9 ??9 ???9 ?9 ??9 ?9 ?9 ??9 ?9 ??X?9 ??o]vP?}v ?9 ?9 ?9 ?9 ?9 ?9 ?9 ?9 ?9 ?9 ??9 ?X?9 E??]?]v ?9 ?9 ???9 ?9 ?9 ??9 ?9 ???9 ?9 ?9 ??9 ??X?9 Wo]v?]oo ?9 ?9 ?9 ?9 ?9 ?9 ?9 ?9 ?9 ?9 ?9 ?X?9 Wo?u}??Z ???9 ??9 ?9 ?9 ?9 ??9 ??9 ?9 ?9 ?9 ?9 ??X?9 ^}??Z]vP?}v ?9 ?9 ?9 ?9 ?9 ??9 ?9 ?9 ???9 ??9 ?9 ??X?9 ZP]}v ???9 ???9 ???9 ???9 ???9 ???9 ???9 ???9 ???9 ???9 ???9 ???X?9 W?? ???}v???P?? &?o(?v]vP ??  }( ??? do ? X^dW r h(?v]vP?u?v]]?o]??~???? D?v]]?o]?? ???? ???? ???? ???? ???? ???? ???? ???? ???? ??? ? ??? ? d}?o ?o]v ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ??? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?? ? ??? ?]??}o ? ? ? ??? ? ? ? ?U??? ? ??? ? ? ? ??? ? ? ? ? ? ?U??? ? ? ? ?U??? ??o]vP?}v ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ??? ? ??? E??]?]v ? ? ? ??? ? ?U??? ? ? ? ? ? ?U??? ? ? ? ?U??? ? ? ? ??? ? ?U??? ? ?U??? Wo]v?]oo ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? Wo?u}??Z ? ?U??? ? ?U??? ? ? ? ??? ? ? ? ??? ? ?U??? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?U??? ^}??Z]vP?}v ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ??? ? ? ? ??? ? ? ? ? ? ?U??? ? ?U??? ? ? ? ?U??? ZP]}v ? ?U??? ? ?U??? ? ?U??? ? ?U??? ? ??? ? ?U??? ? ?U??? ? ?U??? ? ?U??? ? ?U??? ? ?U??? ? ??U??? do ? X^dW r h(?v]vP?u?v]]?o]?????]? D?v]]?o]?? ???? ???? ???? ???? ???? ???? ???? ???? ???? ??? ? ??? ? d}?o ?o]v ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?? ?]??}o ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?? ? ?? ? ? ? ?? ? ? ? ? ? ?? ? ? ? ??? ??o]vP?}v ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?? ? ?? E??]?]v ? ? ? ? ? ?? ? ? ? ? ? ?? ? ? ? ?? ? ? ? ? ? ?? ? ??? Wo]v?]oo ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? Wo?u}??Z ? ??? ? ??? ? ? ? ?? ? ? ? ?? ? ??? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ??? ^}??Z]vP?}v ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?? ? ? ? ? ? ?? ? ?? ? ? ? ??? ZP]}v ? ??? ? ??? ? ?? ? ?? ? ?? ? ?? ? ??? ? ?? ? ?? ? ?? ? ??? ? ??? W?????}v???P?? ^??vo}o(?v]vP ??  }( ??? ^??vo}o(?v]vP }vv????o]?Z?]o?}v(?o(?v]vP(}?]????v??}??r ?}v??}P?u?X  ???v?o?Uv?o???}?Z]?? }( ?Z u}v?(}? ??v??}???}v?]?o??}i?? ]v?Z^?? }u?(?}u?Z&r ?oP}??vu v?X  D}??????U????o?o??Z}?}???]}(?Z E}??Z??U??u?Z  P????}??}v}(???vl}??P]}vo (?v?  ?} ??(}?  ??v??}???}v  ??}i?? X  D}??? ????v??}??r ?}v??}P?u??(?v(?}u?Z^?]od?v??}???}v&?v ~^d&U ?Z]Z }oo ?? ??v?? (?}u ??v??}???}v r ?o? ???U(? U  v??v????oo?(?}u?Z??}?}(^?]o d?Ko]P?}v}v?X  Z}?PZo???}?Z]??}(?Z^d&}u?(?}u ???u}?}?(?o???vu}?}??Z]o?]???Xo?Z}?PZ?r o]v}v?Z??}???  ]??]?o(?}u}?Z}v}u] v  v?]?}vuv?o???????~?Z?(?v?}v?W]P}?]v??U ?Z??v???Z??]vP]v?P]vv]vP?}(oo?Z}??}(?Zo?o v?}??????Z^??[??]??vP??v??}???}v????uU o? o}v ?? (}? ??P?? X dZ ?]v]vP P? ??v ?Z ^??[?uv?v]??v?Z???]}???}}??XdZ?]vo?W ?X o]v]v(?o]X  dZ(?oP?}o]v??Z?v (?}?v? ??X?v????Poo}v  ?]v????XdZol}(v ]v??}]vG?}vuv??Z?(?o??v??~v?}?vr ?o???]Z?(oovv}v?v???}(oo]v?o??u?X ?}v???vUP????Z?}(??v??}???}v}??? u???}?v??Z????X ?X ???}v]v?Z? ??P?}o]v??X  dZ^??u}?}?(?o ?????????v????Poo}vU}???X?9U??v???? v ????X dZ]? ?u?oo? ?? ?Z ?]?? }( ?Z ^???}?v??l??}i??}v]??}?vU}??v?}??}?] ^??u?Z(}?(?oo? r (?v??}i? ?Xol}(]v??} ]vG?}v ]? o?}Z}o]vP ?Z???v?? ~v?Z ^??[? ]o]?? ?} ?l }v ??v??}???}v ??}i?? }?? ?Z o}vP ??uX ?X ‘?}?]vPu]v?vvv?X  D?Z}(?Z^??[???v??}?r ??}v]v(???????????]o????]vP?ZP}ov? ??}( ?Z???v???U}Lv?]?Z?? r ???]Pvo](X????o?U o?P?}??}v}(?Z^??[??}?U?]P?Uu?Uv}?Z? ???????? ? v}? ?? (}? ??ouv? ~}? ?o?vP u]v?vv}???XdZv?}?looo?Z???}i??? }v?u ???v??ZoovPWKdZ???u??Z ?vr (?v  ^??u]v?vv??v]v?Zv?(?????} }v?Z}??}(?? r ?]oo]}vX ?X ????] X?o??o]??}(^d&(?v?~??9]v????]??? ?} ?? ?Z ? }v ??v??}???}v ??}i?? ?] (}? ?]?Z }v? XdZv?}??(}??Z???o??o??u}v??]or o(}??Z???v?v(????X W?????}v???P?? ^??vo}o(?v]vP ??  }( ??? >}oP}??vuv??o?}?o?  ?]?o?}o]v.vv]vP?Z??v?r ?}???}v????uXE?}voo?U?Z]??? r ?]???v?}(???(??v?r ?}???}v(?v]vP}u?(?}uo}oP}??vuv?XdZ]???}?}?r ?}v ]? ??? ?} ?]?]v?Z(???? ?(?ov ^?? .r vv???]}??Xd}?vv]? ?o?}(ZoovP??]u]o? ?}?Z}?}(?Z^???}?Z]v??v??v??v]????W]v uv??o?Uv?~????o?o?(}?u]v?vvv?Z]o]r ??}v?P?}?]vP?Z]o??}???????Uu?v]]?o}v?Uv }?Z??}???}(??v????Pvv?}?  ?Z?]vl]vPX >Kd/W /v????U?Z }vv??? ‘v?o??uo????W?o] ? ?? r ???U?Z]Z??Z}?]??Z????}]???  }v??}(?v??}r P?uoo?Z>}od?v??}???}v?]?o/u??}?uv?W?}r P?u~>Kd/WXdZ]???}P?u]??]Pv?}?l?Z?o }( ^dW r hUv}u?  ?]?Z(?????]vP??ZX}vvKdZ? P??}??}?]?Z]?(?v]vP?}?Z?P]}v?v]v r ???v?l? ?Z?P]}v?  ?}???Z]??Z?}(^dW r h(?v?}v??? r ?o ? ??}i??]v?Z]??P]}v?X do ?? X&????^dW r hW?}i??~????v}v?? d}?v W?}i? WZ? z? &?o ( ?v? ?o]v Z?o?]P????}??D????Z]?? KE ???? ? ?U???U??? ?]??}o uZu}?o KE ????~??X ? ???U?? ? ?]??}o /v????}v/u??}?uv?? d d d ?]??}o Di}?/v????}v/u??}?uv? ZKt ????~??X ?? ?]??}o Di}?/v????}v/u??}?uv? KE ????~??X ?U??? E??]?]v Z}v?????}v}(,??^? & ???? ? ?? ?U??? KE ???? ? ?U??? U??? Wo?u}??Z Z}v????????(}}???}v~?o??^?}v???(?v? KE ???? ? ??? U??? Wo?u}??Z /v????}v/u??}?uv??}vZ}??? KE ????~??X ? ?U? ??U??? W?????}v???P?? ^??vo}o(?v]vP ??  }( ??? Kv ?]Pv].v? ]+?v ??v>Kd/W v^dW r h ]? ?Z? >Kd/WU ?  ??? r (?v ??}P?uU ]? ]vP u]v]??? ? }?v]o? }( ‘}??vuv?? ~K’?U v}? DWK?X /v u}?? }( ?Z ???UDWK?vK’??Z}??]v?Z?u}?Pv]??}vX t]?Z?Z]??}o??}v  }(ZWU?Zv??o}vv???DWK u????v???(?}uv?K’  ~?Z}?PZ]?]?Z}??? ?Z ?]?}o ZP]}v K’ X dZ]? ??vPuv? ]? ?u?}??? ? DWK]?  ?Z?o ?}]??}o?]v:?v???? X dZ???u  ? ??u]oo]}v?]oo????]  ]v&z?? Xv??o }vv???  ~?Z?}?PZ?Zv}?(?v?v??o}vv???Zr P]}voWovv]vPPv?  ?]???X???u]oo]}vX W?}i???r o???Z?P]}v  ??Z}?v]v do ?? X u]v]????}v}(?Z???}i??Z?v??v?(??}???} ?Z?????u?v]]?o]??[?v?K’XDWKv}  o}vP?Z? v?}v??}o}???Z]?(?v]vP?}??XdZ??]U]?]??]Pv].v? ]v???uv???Z???X  do ?? X>Kd/W??}i??(}????? d}?v Z}?? W?}i? >Kd/W(?v? ?]??}o s?]}?? Z?oo}}???}?????]v????}v? ? ? U ??? U ??? E??]?]v oov^? Z}v?????}v}(oov^??? ? ? U ??? U??? Wo]v?]oo }}l^?X W?uv??Z]o]??}v}(}}l^??? ? ??? U??? Wo?u}??Z u]?^?X Z}v?????}v}(u]?^??? ? ?U??? U??? ^}??Z]vP?}v :?ovX /v????}v]u??}?uv? ? ?U???U??? W?????}v???P?? Z?v????u??}v?v??u?? ??  }( ??? Z?v????u??}v?v ??u?? dZKdZ???}i?&?o,]PZ??v^??(?v?(}???}r i???}P?uu]vP(}?oo?ZZWK?]v?Z^???Z?}?PZ?Z?? ????X d}?o???(?v]vP(}?oo?  D WK?]vo?]vP DWK  ]? ?Z}?v]v do ??  ~?X ?? Xv??o}vv???]?(}????}?r ]??X?9}(?Z?}?o^??(?v]vPU]?] ??v?X?9}( ?Z?}?ou(}?????u]u??}?uv??v?X?9}(?Z?(}? ????u ??????}vX dZ ?P]}v ]? ??? ?} ?]? }vo? ?X?9}(?Z(?v??Z??]oou?]oo(}?ui}???}i?? }(????]?]Pv].vUoo}(?Z]Z?]oo] ??}?Z ??}?}?E??]?]v r ,??}?????XdZ?P]}v[?]???}?}?r ?}v?o? ?uooU ?v u]v]uoU oo}?}v? (}? ??}i?? }( ????] ?]Pv].v ]? ??]}?? v P? ??ov?}vU P]?v ?Z?P]}v[??]?o?}??o?}vv}v}u?Uv??oo}?}v ]v?Z^??Uv(?v?}v?}v?]?u}vPui}?]??v u??}??X /v(????????Z(?v]vPoo}??}  DWK?]oo??o]?r ??v?Zv?K’?X ?}v?}?? o?}vUZK’?]oo  ?]? ??X?9}(DWK [?^dW r hoo}?}vUEsK’?]oo  ?]???X?9U vE,K’?}?o?]??X?9X dZ??}}((?v?(}?]u??}?uv???}?Z?(}???????}v ??]??u?oo??}???Z?P]}v?X&}?]v??vU?Z’??? ?]P?}?? ?P]}vZ?v?o???9}(?Z}?(?v?oo}?(}? ]u??}?uv??U ?Z]o >]?Z.o ,]oo? v E}??Z????v }vr v???ZZ???9}(?Z]?(?v???(}???????}vXW?}r i? (?v]vP ]v v??o }vv??? (?}?? ??????}v ? ?}?PZo???} r ?} r }vu?P] vXdZ]?u?i?]]}??u]?UP]?v ?Z ?P]}v[? u???]??U ?Z P }( ]?? ]v(????????U v ?Z ^??[?Z]??}?]o?v?(?v]vP}(??????}v]v(?}?}(]ur ??}?uv??~ &]P?? ?? X do  ??  ~?X ?? ?l??Z]?(?v]vP}???? r ? r ??}???Z ?Z]??? r ???uZ}?]?}v}(?Z(}???X dZ?  ??}i?}v??r ??u ?]?  ??v?vv?o]v??]v(?v]vPv}v??v? &]P?? ?? X^???]??v??}???}v(?v]vP}???u 0 100,000 200,000 300,000 400,000 500,000 600,000 700,000 800,000 900,000 1,000,000 1957 1961 1965 1969 1973 1977 1981 1985 1989 1993 1997 2001 2005 Dollars (000) Improvement Preservation W?????}v???P?? Z?v????u??}v?v??u?? ??  }( ?? ? ]???]??}v??v]u??}?uv??v??????}vX~/v?or ]??U?}?o(?v]vPv?Z ??}??}vuv???}?]oo???(?}u ???}??U???Z]?o]v???}i?}vP]??v]}(??u? (?v]vP?]oo}???Z?u(?u}(?ZWovX W?????}v???P?? Z?v????u??}v?v??u?? ??  }( ??? do ?? XW?}i??]oo??v??}???}v(?v???P]}v  ~?Z?}?PZ???? Wovv]vP?P]}v ^???u  ]u??}?uv?? ^???u  ??????}v Di}???}i??}( ????]?]Pv].v d}?o? ^}??Z????v  ?U???U???U???  ???U???U???  ?U???U???U???  ?U???U???U??? ,}???}v]soo?  ???U???U???  ???U???U???  ??U???U???  ?U???U???U??? E}??Z???  ,]oo?  ???U???U???  ???U???U???  r   ?U???U???U??? v??oE?P??lsoo?  ???U???U???  ???U???U???  ?U???U???U???  ?U???U???U??? soo?  ???U???U???  ???U???U???  ??U???U???  ???U???U??? ‘????]P?}??  ???U???U???  ???U???U???  ???U???U???  ?U???U???U??? ^}??Zv??o  ?U???U???U???  ?U???U???U???  ?U???U???U???  ?U???U???U??? v??o}vv???  ???U???U???  ???U???U???  ??U???U???  ???U???U??? ?]?}o  ?U???U???U???  ?U???U???U???  ???U???U???  ?U???U???U??? D]???  ???U???U???  ???U???U???  ???U???U???  ???U???U??? dZ]???????  ???U???U???  ???U???U???  ???U???U???  ???U???U??? ^}??Z???v  ???U???U???  ?U???U???U???  ???U???U???  ?U???U???U??? E}??Z???v  ??U???U???  ???U???U???  r   ???U???U??? hv.vd}?v?  ???U???U???  ???U???U???  r   ???U???U??? ^???}?o  ?U???U???U???  ?U???U???U???  ?U???U???U???  ??U???U???U??? W?????}v???P?? Z? v????u??}v?v??u?? ??  }( ??? do ?? XW?}i? ?]oo??v??}???}v(?v???? z? v??od  ]u??}? uv? ????? ?}v d}?o ^???] ]u??}?uv? ??????}v d}?o ???? ? ?U???U??? ? ?U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ???? ? ?U???U??? ? ?U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ???? ? ?U???U??? ? ?U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ???? ? ?U???U??? ? ?U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ???? ? ?U???U??? ? ?U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ???? ? ?U???U??? ? ?U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ???? ? ?U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ???? ? ?U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ???? ? ?U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ???? ? ?U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ???? ? ?U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ???? ? ?U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ???? ? ?U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ???? ? ?U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ???? ? ?U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ???? ? ?U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? W?????}v???P?? Z?v????u??}v?v??u?? ??  }( ??? z? v??od  ]u??}? uv? ????? ?}v d}?o ^???] ]u??}?uv? ??????}v d}?o ???? ? ?U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ?U???U???U??? ???? ? ??U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ?U???U???U??? ???? ? ??U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ?U???U???U??? ???? ? ??U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ?U???U???U??? ???? ? ??U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ?U???U???U??? ???? ? ??U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ?U???U???U??? ???? ? ??U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ?U???U???U??? ???? ? ??U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ?U???U???U??? ???? ? ??U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ?U???U???U??? ???? ? ??U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ??U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ?U???U???U??? d}?o ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ???U???U??? ? ??U???U???U??? ? ?U???U???U??? ? ??U???U???U??? W}?o Z?v????u??}v?v??u?? ??  }( ??? People  W}?o Wov?o]l?Z]??v?}(}??}v??}i??v??uv??X dZ??P?}?v?(}??Z?W](?Z?]o]?]v?Z?]o?U ?Z???}?????????o?o???v] X?? ??v??}???}v????u?}v?]??}(u}??Zv ?Z??]?v.vv?X?]??u}??(?vuv?oU ??v??}???}v]?}???}?ov?o?W ?Z}??Z?}?oU?Z?}?Z?v?}U vZ}?}?P??Zu?Z?M ??}(?Z]?Uv?]????]}v}( ??v??}???}v ????u?]?Z}??uv?}v}(?}?o}??o??}?o ]v}u?o?X~hv???v]vP}(}?Z]???v?o]( ??v??}???}v????u]??}??(}?u?ooXd}?Z]?vU ?Z]?Z?????]???ZZ?uv????}?Z]? ????}vV ^???u?  ~?X ??? }????Z?o??]X W}?o W}??o?}v ??  }( ??? W}??o?}v }?]vP?}?Z????v???U???U????}?oo]?]vv??o }vv???XdZ]?}u????}???U????}(?Z????v??? v???U????}(v ???????XdZ?P]}v[??}??o?}v? ?Z}oZ?????u?lo???o}???Zo????v?????X Kv?Z]v?? r ?P]}voo?oUZ}???U?Z?]???}v]?v}????r oX? do ??  ~?X ?? ul?o?U??]??o??o???o ?}?o?}??o?}vU?Z?P]}v]????]v]vPZ]PZP?}(]vr ??vou]P??}vX  /v?Zo????}?U?Z?}??o?}v}(?Z ?P]}v[?v}o??????]??Z???]~]v?Z?}( ?]??}ovWo]v?]oo}??Z??vlv~E??]?]vXZ?]P?}??Z ]v}??o?]vP??U??Z??Z?????}(?o]vv^}??Z]vP?}vU v??]oo? ?Z???}(??o]vP?}vUZ?ov?Z]?o}??X tZ]o ?Z ??]o]?? }( ?Z ?P]}v[? ?}??o?}v u?U ? .??? PovU?uZo?Z?v????]vo v ?Z??u]?}(??]o]?? L?oo?v?o]?????]v]o]?? v ?Z?]v??vo?Z]L???ov v?]?}vuv??Z?]?v??Z]vP??XdZ??Z]L???v}v?????} ?Z??]v]?o?}(?u??P?}??ZV?Z?????v?u??]??}??r o? }vu]P??}vv?]vP?o?}(??}ou?U]vo?]vPo}?? }((}????U.o?U??ov?Uv?Z?]?o}????u???]? ?Z??Z?}?v?????}?]V]?]v???uv?]vv?Z? }(}?v?}?v?v}o?v]PZ}?Z}}?Vo]v]vP?}]o?]?o v  ??o]Zo?ZVvUo????v}?o??Uui}???v??}???}v ZoovP?U??Z???}u}]o?vv?U}vP??}vUv Z]PZ???o}???X W}??o?}vu?]+??]vP(?}u?Z?P]}v[?Z]??}?]}??]v?} ?????v????U???Z]???}??]?v}???} u?o?Xd}?o do ?? XW}??o?}v?u?v]]?o]?? z? ?o]v ?]??}o ??o]vP?}v E??]?]v Wo]v?]oo Wo?u}??Z ^}??Z]vP?}v d}?o ???? ??U??? ??U??? ?U??? ??U??? ??U??? ??U??? ??U??? ???U??? ???? ??U??? ??U??? ?U??? ??U??? ??U??? ??U??? ??U??? ???U??? ?? ?? ??U??? ??U??? ?U??? ??U??? ??U??? ??U??? ??U??? ???U??? ZvP U???? r ???? ? ?X? 9 r ?X?9 ??X?9 r ?X?9 ?X?9 ?X?9 ??X?9 ?X?9 W}?o W}??o?}v ??  }( ??? ?}??o?}vv?}??o?}vv?]??}v?v???}???}v?]?r o??}???Z?P]}v[?u?v]]?o]??U? &]P?? ??  ~?X ?? ?Z}??X ??]?}v?]?o?Z?]vlP]v?v????UE??]?]v?r u]v??Z?P]}v[?o?P??vv???u?v]]?o]??U(}oo}?? ?]??}oX~/(???v???v?}v?v?U?]??} ou??????Z.??? ??o(?}uE??]?]v]v?Z(}??o(????X W ?}i?}v? ??PP??~ &]P?? ?? 25 U?X ?? ?Z?P]}v?]oo?Z?]vl }???Zv???v???Uo]???o}?????Zv,??}? } ?v??Uv?Zv?}?v?]?ZP?}??Z(????Zv?Z}?v?? 25  ???? r ????P?}??Z????]?(?}uv????}??o?}v  }?v??V???? r ???? ??????????}i?}v?(?}u?Z}vv???^???v??X }???Z??]vPXdZv??(}?????Z??Z?r P]}voP?}??Z???]oooP?Zv?}v????]?Z?Z ????????X,}???UP]?v?Z??????}i?}v?(}??Z?r P]}vZ?}L v(]o?}}u?}???U?Z??}}?Z}?o ?lv?]?Zo?PP?]v}(?o?X/??u?u}??o]lo??Z??Z ?}??o?}v}(?Z?P]}v?]oo?u]v??oXtZ?Z??Z??v? }(??vG]PZ?v????v????o?Z?Z?.v?Z?r P]}v?}?Z]??}]v??]o o}v?v?.?(]o?P???U?]?r ?v?}v}u?o?}((?}???Z?]vo???Z??(}?uv}( &]P?? ?? XW}??o?}vP?}??Z? -2.5% -0.5% 1.5% 3.5% 5.5% 7.5% 9.5% 11.5% 13.5% 1990-2000 2000-2010 2010-2020 2020-2030 Region State National Hartford County W} ?o W}??o?}v ??  }( ??? ?Z?P]}voU???Uvv?}vou?} r }v}u]?U?Z?]?v Z???}(?ZZ}??]vPu?l?vvl]vP??}?~]vo?]vP ????[ ??(?v? v ?Z  ?]o]o]?? }( .vv]vPU(?o v????}o]]?Uo}oov???P?o?}v?v?]o]vP}?U ??o}?uv???}i??Uv?Z}??v?]o]o]??}(??v?r ?}???}v}??}v?X Z>sE dZ Z]PZ ??]?}v ]v v?]?? v ?o}?uv? ???v? ?Z?}? PZ}???Z?P]}vZ? ]u?o]?}v? (}? ]????v??}???}v ????uXZ??ov????v???v}?}?]}??o?ZoovP]vP (}???v?]?X/vu}????U}vv???}v v }(}?]P]v?v??r v?}v? v ]?v????~??v}???8]v?}v]?}v(}???r ??(?o??}? ?]o}???}v?X’]?v?Z]??o??o?Z]PZ?}??r o?}v v?]??U ?]??}o vU ??]oo?U E? ?]?]v Z? ?Z P?????}?v?o}(?Z?P]}v[?u?v]]?o]??(}???v?]?X~dZ }vG?v}(ddZE^/d[????v???o]v?]v?Z?]???r G???Z]?X^  >}o U?X ??? U(}??]o?XdZ??]U](?Z???v? ??v}(]????o}v?v??U?]?Z}?]P]v?v??v?}v?u}?r ]vP?}v??v?]?[??ZU?Z????uu??o]?]v?}?]]}???r o}(?]vo]vP?]? ?Z]?v???]???X/(?????v}??lv ?}?????Z]?U?Zo}vP r ??u?]]o]??}(??v?]?]v?Z?P]}vu? oo]v?}????}vX dZ????o??vo?}Z?]u?o]?}v?(}??Z?}?XtZ?]?r ?v??P??U?}?ovv}??ol} ?]lUv?Zv?Z?]? v}??}???]vU?}?ou????]?XZ?o]vP??]???Z??}?o }?Z??]??lv?(}}?U]?oU??U}???]v]v?v?].?}vr P??}vXo?Z}?PZ?}u??Z???8]v??]???}?}? ]?}vo???]?Z}????]}??}v  ]v??v??}???}v????u ??(}?uvUuv?}(?Z?P]}v[?Z]PZ??????Z?l]vP ?}]v?W?Z??v?U?U}?}??]??X~^ d?8v}vr P??}v U?X ??? X??}?Zv}vo]v?]??}(}vP??}vU]v?Z? ???v ?o]PZ?]?}v?v???vZ????8]v?}P?]o}lX &]P?? ?? XW}??o?}vv?]??~???}v??????? u]o Berlin 754 Bristol 2,281 Burlington 312 New Britain 5,488 Plainville 1,815 Plymouth 564 Southington 1,212 0 10,000 20,000 30,000 40,000 50,000 60,000 70,000 80,000 0 10 20 30 40 Population Area (square miles) High density Low density Medium W}?o }v}u]? ??  }( ??? }v}u]? /v ??? ?U ?Z u]v Z}??Z}o ]v}u (}? ?Z ?P]}v ?? ? ??U???X 26  ?????U  ]?Z?]?v?}  ? ??U??? X 27  dZ]?.P???}?o ?u?}]v]??Z??Z?P]}v]?(?]vP?oo}v}u]oo?U? ]?o]?v}?}vo?}??Z ????]u]vZ}??Z}o]v}u }(? ??U?????]?(?oo??9Z]PZ??Zv?Zv?}vou]v Z}??Z}o]v}u}(???U??? X  ,}???U?Z]?.P?? u?l??Z? ]u?}??v?(??W ?X /vG?}vX/v}u?Z?v}?l????]?Z]vG?}vU?}?o ???Z?]vP?}??]?(oo]vPX ?X ,]PZ}??}(o]?]vPXdZ?P]}v[?}??}(o]?]vP]?Z]PZ??Zv ?Zv?}vU?}?v]vP?}v}?P}?(?]vv??o}vv?r ???v ??ou}?v??}?oo??Z?X ?X hv?v ]???]??}vX o?Z}?PZ ]v}u? ? Z]PZU ?Z? ]? ?]??]?}v?]?Z]v?Z?P]}vX ?X K?? r }( r ? ??????X dZ ]v(???v? }( }v}u] ? }oo?}v uv? ?Z?v} o}vP??G? ??o }v]?}v? ~?Z}}u}(?Z??? ????????ZZ’??Z??]}v[?}?X 26  }?]vP?}v???????X 27  Zd}?vW?}.o?X 28  vv?ohX^X ]vG?}v  (?}u ?Z???}(>}?^?????U}v??u?W?] /v? X  Z??Wll???Xo?XP}?l?l]vG?}vzo?o?}?XZ?u X /E&>d/KE o?Z}?PZ?v]vP?Z??]?v]v?Z?P]}vU?Z?o?}(u}v? Z?(oov??Z?u?uX}?]vP?}?Z???}(>}? ^?????U]vG?}v}???Zo???v???Z?v?}Z]PZ??} u}??Zvv? oo](??Z}?]?P]v?Xd }l????]?Z]vGr ?}v(?}u ?????}???? UZ}??Z}o?v]vP? ??U???  ?}?o Z??}?v ? ??U??? ]v ???? X  28  ‘]?v?Z??Z???]vG?}v ?? v ?Z????]v?Z}??Z}o? 29 v ?v??}o?Z}(r .]o??~?Z(?oP}? ?vuv??v??}?v???????]vr G?}v(}??}o]?o??}v?U?Zo}??]v?o?v]vP?u? }?o ?Z ??U??? ]+?v ??v ?Z ??o ]v}u }( Z}??Z}o?]v?Z?P]}vv?Z??Z??}?oZ??vU Z]v}uu?o?l?????]?Z]vG?}vX  dZ??U] v??u?}( ?o ?v]vP?}??Uu]vZ}?? Z}o]v}u]v}???Pv?}?? ?Zo??V]?(oo????]l]vPu?P]v~o]lo?}v?Z}??}( ? ?U???XdZ?P]}v]?U]v}?Z??}??UP?vP?}}?? v vv}r ?o??}X 29  Dv??]Z}??Z}o??v??Z??v?P}vZ???]vG?}v]v?Zo?? ?v???U}?o]vP}?u}?]v??]UXPXZ}??]vPU (?o UZo?Z? Uvr ??}vX W}?o }v}u]? ??  }( ??? K^dK&>/s/E’ ,}??Z}o?]v?Z?P]}vu??l]vu}?u}v??Zv?Z]? v?}vo }?v??????}U ?? ?Z? u??? o?} P]? }?? u}?X v??o}vv???]?v}’}o}??U??u}??}(?Z?P]}v]? u}???v?]? ?o?}o]??Zv?Zv?}v??Z}oX &]P??  ??  ~?X ?? u???Z}??}(o]?]vP]v?Z?P]}v?o???} ?Zv?}vX  30  }?v?}?vE??]?]vU?]?Z  ?}?}(??X?]? ?X?9Z???Zv?Zv?}vo??PV??o]vP?}vU????X?]? v?o???9u}???v?]?XdZ?P]}v[?Z]PZ?o]?]vP??v?? ???oo??}?Z?v?P]??Z]PZ???P]??X,}??Z}o? ]v?Z?P]}v?.vv]oo???}+?Zv ?Z???}(?Zvr ?}vU??v}?(?oo??9?}X hEsE/^dZ/hd/KE /v}u]?v}??vo?]???]???}???Z?P]}vX &]P?? ??  ~?X ??   ?Z}???Z? v???o}lP?}??? 31  ?]?Z?ZZ]PZ??u]v ]v}u? }vv??? ]v ?Zu}?????vv???o????}( ?Z?P]}vU ??o]vP?}vU?o]vv^}??Z]vP?}v X  dZ}??]?Z?Z o}???u]v]v}u? o???? ]vv??oE??]?]vX 30  }??}(o]?]vP(}??Zhv]?^?????Z}o]? ??? X??lv(?}u ^??o]vP[???Wo?U}??}(>]?]vP}u??]?}vX  Z??Wll???X???o?Xv?l}ol X 31  ?}(????U??v???????Xv? ??o}lP?}???????v?v]v??u]r ?U??u?v]]?oo?o}(PP?P?}v??vv???o}l?v????X &]P?? ?? Xvv?o?vu?o}?uv????  0% 2% 4% 6% 8% 10% 12% 14% 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 Berlin Bristol Burlington New Britain Plainville Plymouth Southington W}?o }v}u]? ??  }( ??? &]P?? ?? 32  ~?X ?? u???Z]v???}(?o?ZU?}????XdZ.Pr ?? ??o? ?Z Z]PZ?? }vv???}v }( o}? r ]v}u Z}??r Z}o?~.v?o}????9}(?Z?}????o]v 33 ]v}?vr ?}?v?]??}ovU}?ooUE??]?]vXW}}?Z}??Z}o??]?? ] v}?Z?????}(?Z?P]}vVZ}???U?vo]l]v?Z???}??U ?Z??v}??]?]o?}vv???X  u?o}?uv?]??Z??]u?? ?}?? }( u}?? Z}??Z}o?[ ]v}uX u?o}?uv? ??? ?Z?(}? Z?  o?P ((? }v ?Z }v}u] ?oo r ]vP }( Z}??Z}o? ?Z?}?PZ }?? ?Z ?P]}vX &]P?? ??  ??o? ?Z? ?vu?o}?uv? ??? Z? o]u }?? }?? ?Z o?? ?Z? ???]voo}(?Z?P]}v[?]?]?v?}?v?XdZ]?}????}v??} ?Z}v??}(?ZZ’??Z??]}vX[tZ]o???Z??]?vu}? }?o??]v??ooo?}???Z?P]}vUE??]?]vv U?}o??? ??v?U Wo?u}??ZU ?]??}oU v Wo]v?]oo Pv ?  Z]PZ? ?o]vX ~?v ]v ?Z ?? }( ?]u?U ?vu?o}?uv? ??  ??}ou(}?E??]?]vX????o?U?vu?o}?uv????? ????v?]oo?Z]PZ?]v?Z?}uu?v]?]? v ?}(?Z]?WovU?Z?  ?}???9]voo(}??}uu?v]?]?XdZ]???PP????Z?Z}??Z}o? ]v?Z?(}????u????]v]vP}v?]?o?P??? (]vv]o????X 32  ?}(????U??v???????X Khd r K& r d^dd/^d/^ ? ?Z??? (???? Z? u}v????U ?Z}v}u?v ???v???] r }?v?u]vPo?}??v]PZ?Xz??]?Z?Z???}v }(?vu?o}?uv???????U}v}u]?}Lv??+?(?}u }v?]?ooPX~dZv???]?Zo}v????v???U(}? ]v??vX? }v???vU?Z?P?}?? r }( r ?XdZo?? v?????}v????Z?]u??Z}(?ZP} r P}[???X? }v???vU?Z??}?????Z?}?o??]? ?? r ? ?v?]}  (}??Z}v}u?V?Z?}v}??G??Z?}?? ?o]???Z??]Pv? ?}(?Z]?Wov[???]?vPX??}(?Z]?U?Z }v????????u??}v?Z}?o?Z??Z?]???}v}v?Z P?}?v]??]Pv].v?o??}???Zvu}??}(?Z??????? Z?]v?}?o}?Z??]?o}v?}o]?X Z>sE /v?v????U?Z?P]}vZ ??o}??Z??]oo?U?]?Z(}?r ???v(?u?P]?]vP???}??]?]?]}v?v???]?uoo?XtZ]o ?Z]????o}(?o}?uv??]o??}uv.??U]?o?}}u? ?]?Z???}???U??Z?}vP??}vU?}oo??}vU??vo]PZ?U vo}??}(}????u???]?X Dv?}(?Z???}ou?? ???}v?Z]v}???W?Z]o?Z?}???}]????Z}oU v}}?]v????o????(}??ZuX 33  /v????XKv r v r  r Zo(?u??Z(?o?}????o]v]?Pv?oo?}v?]r ?u}??o]??u???}(?}?? ???Zv?Z?}????o]v]??o(U??} ?Zo??]vP????.]oo?o}?X W}?o }v}u]? ??  }( ??? ,}???Uv}?oo}?????}Z]vXE??]o]vP?}??u}v?U ?}??v?Z(?o?}?]??ZovP?Zv]vP]??v?r ??v  ?ZuU v ?}? ?} o]vl ?ZuX z? ? ?Z ?P]}v Z? P?}?v ?Z??]oo?U ? ?Z (}?P}]vP ]????]}v ??o?U ]? Z? (]o?}}?}}v}u]oo?X/v}uZ???Pv???Z?u ?u?Z??Z}??}(o]?]vPZ???o}X~,}??]vP?}?PZo?}?r o]v??]] v?Zo??VZo?Z?v??}vZ? ???]v?v?Z???Z???]vG?}vX dZ???v?+?Uv?+??U?Z??v??}???}v???r ?uX^?Pvv?}?o]v]vP]v }uZ?oLZ}??Z}o?v}ur u?v]???]?Zo???}??v}v?????]vPUu]v?]v]vPUv]ur ??}?]vP ?Z ??v??}???}v ????uU (?}u ?Z ??]?? }u]v ~??}u}]o?U(?oU?X?}?Z??o]~]v(????????U???]?U ?Xhv(}???v?o?Uo]l]vZ}??]vPU  Zo?Z?Uvuv?}?Z? ?]?ov?U}???Z?o?}?]?v]v??v??}???}vX&?oU]vr ???vUv}v?????}vu??]o?o]u]v??]Xo??vr ????}?]?]vP??Z??ol]vPU]l]vPUv??v?]?Z???? ??o?(?}u?Z]???]????? ?U??]oo?(}?o}? r ]v}u &]P?? ?? Xd??ou}?]v}uP?}?? 70% 75% 80% 85% 90% 95% 100% under $10,000 $10,000-$14,999 $15,000-$24,999 $25,000-$34,999 $35,000-$49,999 $50,000-$64,999 $65,000-$74,999 $75,000 or more Drove alone Carpooled Transit Walked Bicycle, motorcycle, taxi, or other Worked at home W}?o }v}u]? ??  }( ??? Z}??Z}o?X,}???U? &]P?? ??  ?Z}??U?v?Z?}}???}( ?Z?P]}v[??}}? v ?Z}?o??o?}+}?? v Z?r } u??}u}]o r ?vv?X D}?}??U?Z?P]}v[?}v?v?????o]?o]lo??}??? ?Z]? ??}ouU (}?]vP Z}??Z}o? ?} ???o o}vP? ]??v?U ??vu}??u}v?Z?}~???????}???o?Uv}?v u}???U??oo??]?]vPu?v]]?o]??v ?Z^???} ?]??X/v?Z}??U????ov??Pvv?}v}u?Z?P]?v ?]? ?}  ?]???}v ?Z? v? Z? P?}?v ? uv? Z? ?Z??vlX ‘]?v?ZZ]PZ}??}(}?Z??]??v??o]]v???uv?]v ??v??}???}v~}?v]vP?]v?Z?????v?} ?????U??? ????VZ]PZ???v?]o??}???u]oo]}v??ov r u]oU]( ?Z}v}u]?o(?}(Z}??Z}o?vu?v]]?o]??]??} u]v?]v }?? ?Z o}vP r ??uU v ??v??}???}v ]? v}? ?} ?}?}??oo?Z}?Z?U??v?o?o]?}(?Z?]vl]vP? ]U}?? 8]v??Z}?o??]u??}v?vXdZ??o]?]}(?Z ??v??}???}v????u v ??vv]vPoo????(?}u?ovv]vP?} }???}v?Uv?Z]vP]v?}?o?.o???Z?ov?? v ?Z}?o}?]v??}??ul]vP????}(?]??vP]v???uv??  v ?}u]v]u]?]vP Z}??Z}o?[ }???}( vU ?Z??}??]oU v(}???v??}???}vX W}?o }v}u]? ??  }( ??? &]P?? ?? X}??}(o]?]vP?/W}? W}?o }v}u]? ??  }( ??? &]P?? ?? XD]vZ}??Z}o]v}u?v???o}lP?}?? W}?o }v}u]? ??  }( ??? &]P?? ?? X,}??Z}o?o}????9}(?Z?}????o?o?v???o}lP?}?? W}?o Pv]?]o]?? ??  }( ??? Pv]?]o]?? dZP}(?P]}v[?v]?v?]??]?o?}]??}v}u]??(}?r uv??oo?]????v??}???}vv?XZ]o?vv ?Zor ?o??v?}u}??vv?U}v}u]oo???oo?]v ??u?}(u}]o]??~uv?vv}??]?Vu] r vo? r ??ur ?o}???v?}u}??o( r ??8]v?]v}?Z?P??U?Z}?PZ ?o???u?o}????v?]?}v]v?}???uv?U?o]v} v }???]????}??]v???Xz}?vP?o??u?o???o( r ??8r ]v??Zv?Zu]o r P??}+?P}}v? r ??u??}???? (}? ]v}u P?}??Z v ?? v (}? ??v??}???}v }?r ?}v?X do ??  34  ?Z}???Z??o]PZ?o?}??Zo(?Z?}??o?}v}(v??o }vv??? ~??X?9 (oo? ]v Z?}?l(}?[ P ?vPU ?? ?} ?? ???}oXd?}?Z]??}(?Z]?P?}??]?P???}??Xd}P?Z?U ?]??}ovE??]?]v }?v?(}?u}??ZvZo(}(?Z??r ?}v???v??v??]v?Z?P]}vXdZ}ooPP?}??or ?}v~?? r ?????}o]??Z?uoo???}??o?}v?Puv?X/?? uu?? ? u}?? ??}u]vv?o? ????v? ]v E? ?]?]vU u}??o]lo???}?Z???v}(v?? o}vv???^?? hv]???]??]v?Z]??XdZ]??Puv?}(?Z?}??o?}v?v??} ul??o?P?Z?}(??v?]??]??Z]?XdZ?u}??Z 34  ?(?}uZX Z???]???}(?Z}??]?ZZ]PZ??}?v?]???}?]??v?]?W Z]PZv?]??Uo}?]v}uvol}(??}u}] o??X >]l]v}uUP]???]??}v]?v}?}v?]??v??}???Z?P]}vX &]P?? ??  ~?X ?? P??Z??Z?]?}v?}(]??v?}?v?(?}u ?Z?P]}vo??P(}?ZPP?}??X?](?}u?Z???Z }( }ooP r P ???}v? ]v E? ?]?]v ~v ?Z]? ?o?? r ?v o??Z?U ??Z?? ?Z ?}v ???]l]vP ??]? ]? ?Z }??????v??}v}(Z]o?vv?v?????v??}v}(}o ?}?o]v??o]vP?}vXdZ(}?u?u??G??Z??}(?Z ?}?v[???u?Z}}o?U?Z]o?Zo??u?}??}?Z?or ??v?v??v??}u}]o r ?vv?Z???}(u}??r ? o}?uv?]v?}?vX D?Z}(?Z o?o?~P??v }??v]?o?}??o?}v  vv}? ?]?  ???}vo ??}u}]o v ? ?vv? }v }?Z?uv?}(??v??}???}vU??Z???o]??v??}???}vX  }?]vP?}?Z}vv???}v}u]Z?}??v??Ui ? ?? }??  }v]v??v???}v?]v?Z?P]}v ~ ??X? 9 ]?P??}? }o? X  dZ]?]??o]PZ?o?Z]PZ??Zv?Z??X?9?}?]v?Z???? v???(}??Z?P]}vX?}(????U }v?Z]?~??X?9}(?Z u}r ]o]??]u?]??}??o?}v? ?P??v}??X  dZ]?ul?}??  W}?o Pv]?]o]?? ??  }( ??? }v?Z]?}(?Z ?P]}v[?v?? ?}??o?}vo?o?vl}?]?r oX  &]P?? ??  ~?X ?? ?o}???Z o?o?v]?o 35  ?v??? o}l P?}??U ??o]vP  Z]PZ }vv???}v? }( }?Z ]v ?]??}o vU]v????o?U E??]?]vX Z>sE o?Z}?PZv}v r ?]????]??]v???P?l?U?Z?}?vPU}oU v]?o(??]oZoovP??Zv]? }u??}?]?]vPW ?Z?Z?(?}uoPoU?Z??]oUuv?oUv.vv]o}v???]v?? }?(?}uZ}]U?Z??]??u?Zo}??????Zv?ZPv?o ??o]X/vv??o}vv???o}vU??U????}?o?o???Zv ??}??o???????}oXE?o???}]v. ???]v??~??X?9 35  Z ]?o [  ?(???} ?Zv?u?}(]?o ???}v?  ]v?Z]?]o]vv}v r ]v?????}vo]??}?r ?o?}v?o??????}(PX (oo]v?}]?Z?}(?Z???}P?}???XdZ]?.P??]v]???Z?U}( oou}P??Z](?}??UPZ??ZP????]u?o]?}v?(}? ?Z?P]}v[???v??}???}v????uX dZ?vv}(u]v}??U?v]}??Uv]?o???}v?]v?Z ?P] }v v ]XXU}(v}v r ?]??? v ??PP???uvvv(}? (}?u?}(??v??}???}v?]??Z??]??u}?}??X/v?}(?? ??v??}???}v????u???}v??}?Zuv?vv?}( ]??????v?}?v?o????U}????}v]vPo?Z]PZo?o}(]vr ???uv? ] v ????]v v ?o]?? ]v(???????? ? ?oo ? ???v??]v?]?i???.X do ?? XP]???]??}v P ?o]v ?]??}o ??o]vP?}v E? ?]?]v Wo]v?]oo Wo?u}??Z ^}??Z]vP?}v 9  ?}?o ? r ?? ?U??? ??U??? ?U??? ??U??? ?U??? ?U??? ?U??? ??X?9 ?? r ?? ?U??? ?U??? ??? ??U??? ?U??? ?U??? ?U??? ??X?9 ?? r ?? ?U??? ??U??? ?U??? ??U??? ?U??? ?U??? ??U??? ??X?9 ?? r ?? ?U??? ??U??? ?U??? ??U??? ?U??? ?U??? ?U??? ??X?9 ??= ?U??? ?U??? ??? ??U??? ?U??? ?U??? ?U??? ??X?9 oo ??U??? ??U??? ?U??? ??U??? ??U??? ??U??? ??U??? ???X?9 W}?o Pv]?]o]?? ??  }( ??? /v???uv?]v??v??}???}v]v(????????]?v}??Z}vo??? ?}????Z?}?PZo???9}(?Z??o]?Z?}?v}??]?XW}r ?ouv}?v??v??}???}v ??? V?Z ????}?}(??v?r ?}???}v]?v}??}u}??}?o(}?u}]o]??[??lU???}oo}? ?Zu???}?ZP}}?U???]?Uv??]??v?????} o]?(?ooo](XtZ]o??v??}???}vv(]o]????U?}U?}}U v}uu?v]???]PvX&}?]v??vUv ??Uu]? r ???or }?uv?v o]u]v?  ?Zv(}???v??}???}v???}?]]vP (}? oo }( v ]v]?]?o[? v? v Z}u?U ?}?l?o?U ?Z}}o?U }?}??[}8?U?Z}??]vPUv???]vuv??v??Uv??l? v ?]?Z]v?ol]vP]??vXo?Z}?PZ}uu?v]???]Pv Z????r ]oo? v??? ????o? (?}u ??v??}???}v]v(?????r ???U]v?o]???Z??}]vG?vv?]vG?v?Z }?Z???}(}?vo?X ??}(?Z]?U}vu]PZ?????Z}??vo?}?]??}?? ?}????o??Z?}vvo]??]?Z}???U??Z?}?vr ?}?v?v?]ooPv???X??Z??]vPu???Z}?U?Z]?]? ?Z?]vv??o}vv???W?Z}oU]?oUv?}}? o??r ??]v}?v?}?vE??]?]v.???v(}?u}??U(}oo}?? }?v?}?v?]??}ovU??}u]??vUWo]v?]ooUd????]ooU v^}??Z]vP?}vv???X~^ W???]v?v?o]??? U ?X ??? U (}??]oXdZ]???PP????Z?U](}v]??}vZv?Z??o]??}( o](v?}]}}v}u]???]??}v}(?Zu}??v}v r ?]???? &]P?? ?? XP]+?v???v?Z?P]}vv]??u?v]]?o]? ? -8.0% -6.0% -4.0% -2.0% 0.0% 2.0% 4.0% 6.0% Southington Plymouth Plainville New Britain Burlington Bristol Berlin 65+ 50-64 25-49 18-24 0-17 W}?o Pv ]?]o]?? ??  }( ??? ?Zo??}??U(}}?U]?oUv??v?]?]v???uv????oo? }uu?v]???]Pv+}????Z}?o(}??}v?Z???X W}?o Pv]?]o]?? ??  }( ??? &]P?? ?? X]?ovo?o??v???o}lP?}?? W}?o Zv?Zv]]?? ??  }( ??? Zv?Zv]]?? dZ?P]}v]?]???]v??u?}(?XZ}?PZo?}v]v?]?}(]?? ??]v??~??X?9??????]o]v???}(}?Z??ZvZ?Z]? o}vX[ dZ o?P?? u]v}?]???}??o?}v ]v?Z?P]}vU??U??? ???}v??}(  ????U??]?]vE??]?]vX do ?? 36   ?Z}?? ?Z???X?9}(E??]?}v?o]u?}}(v}v r ?Z]?}?u?o??r ]ov????XdZ]?]??ZZ]PZ????]v  ?Z?P]}vX 36  ?(?}u?ZhX^Xv????? ?Uv???????X dZ]???]??}v}(,]??v]??Z]]???]u]o????vU?]?Z?Z o?P???}o??v?o???}??o?}v?o?}(}?v]vE??]?r ]v~??U???U}???X?9}(?Z]??[??}?o?}??o?}vX &]P ?? ?? 37  ~?X ?? Z????Z]v]v}(,]??v]?o( r ]v?.?}v?}?v r ? r ?}?v]v?Z?P]}vXdlv?}P?Z?U??X?9}(v??o}vr v???[???]v??}(oo???????,]??v]?Zv]]vr ???X 37  ?(?}u?ZhX^Xv??????Uv???????X do ?? X ^o( r ]v?.? 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% Southington Plymouth Plainville New Britain Burlington Bristol Berlin White Black American Indian and Alaska Native Asian or Pacific Islander Other Multiracial W}?o ,}??]vPvZ}??Z}o?Z]o? ??  }( ??? &]P ?? ?? X^o( r ]v?.?Zv]]??~E}v r ,]??v]v,]??v]}vo? ,}??]vPvZ}??Z}o?Z]o? >]luv?????v??Uu}??}(v??o}vv???]??}v (}??]vPo r (u]o?Z}??]vPXdZ??]Uu?Z}(?Z?P]} v?or }?(}??Z?v?}(?Z??}u}]oV?Z]?oP?]??]?]o ??Zv?U?olov]PZ}?Z}}?}(?]??}ovE??]?r ]vXdZ?v]PZ}?Z}}?}Lv(???o?Pv?u??}(u?o? r (u]o? ???????? ??Z ? ??o?? v ??]?o r l??X D}? ?Z v??}]v.?~??X?9?oo]vP?v]??]v?Z?P]}v????}( u?o? r (u]o?????????XdZ??v]??o????]v?]??}ovE? 38  ?(?}uZX^^]vPo(u]o? r ?Z_]vo??u}]oZ}u?X ?]?]vX? do ?? 38  ?Z}??U E??]?]v]??Z ?}o u?v]]?o]?? ]v?Z]Zui}?]??~ ??X?9}(?Z?v]??]?  v}??]vPo r (u]o?X ,}??Z}o?]v?Z?P]}v}?vv??P}(??}??X,}???U ?Z?]?}v?]?o??]?}v]v?Z]??????X?]??}ovU]v ????o?UE??]?]vZ? o?P v?u?? }(?o?? Z}??r Z}o?X/vU? &]P?? ??  ~?X ??? ?Z}??U ui}?]??  }(Z}??r Z}o?]v????}(E??]?]v}v}?}?v?X Southington Plymouth Plainville New Britain Burlington Bristol Berlin 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% Non-hispanic Hispanic, any race W}?o ,}??]vPvZ}??Z}o?Z]o? ??  }( ??? Z>sE dZ??}(??}u}]o?]??o??}PU]o]??Uv]v}uX? ]?????v? Pv]?]o]??  ~?X ?? U?Z?}?vPU?Z}oU ?Z]?oUv?Z?}}??o ??o?}}?vv?]??X ??}(?Z]?U?Z????]]v?Z???}v??o]?Z?X,}?r ??U?Z???}(Z}??Z}o?o??v??v?]vPo r ?}?v?r ?Z]??Z}??Z}o?]v??]v????}(?Z?P]}vU??].oo? }?v?}?vE??]?]vU]??vZ]PZ ??Zv}vu]PZ???]? ?}v?Zu}P??Z]v?}]}}v}u]????v? ?Z?XZ?]v??}(?Z?????vo?}??}.?(?}u??} r v??]?o}?uv?V](?Z???}?u]vuv]vP(?oo?]v?r P??]v?}?Z?}]}}v}u]o](}(?Z?P]}vU ?Z?u???]r ?Z???}?]??~vZ?+???}?Z????}??(?o v??o????]vU?o]??Uv??v?]?]v(????????U??oo ????}?Z(?oo?vP}(P}}?U???]?Uv??]???Z? }?Z??]v?Z?P]}vvi}?~]XXUo]?o} uu?v]??X do ?? X,}??]vP??? D?v]]?o]?? ?oo]vP? v]?? ^]vPo r (u]o??Z D?o? r (u]o?l?Z ?o]v ?U??? ?U???~??X?9 ?U???~??X?9 ?]??}o ??U??? ??U???~??X?9 ??U???~??X?9 ??o]vP?}v ?U??? ?U???~??X?9 ???~?X?9 E??]?]v ??U??? ??U???~??X?9 ??U???~??X?9 Wo]v?]oo ?U??? ?U???~??X?9 ?U???~??X?9 Wo?u}??Z ?U??? ?U???~??X?9 ?U???~??X?9 ^}??Z]vP?}v ??U??? ??U???~??X?9 ?U???~??X?9 d}?o ??U??? ??U???~??X?9 ??U???~??X?9 W}?o ,}??]vPvZ}??Z}o?Z]o? ???  }( ??? &]P?? ?? XW?v?P}(Z}??Z}o??Z?]??o?? ^???u? ,}??]vPvZ}??Z}o?Z]o? ???  }( ??? Systems dZ]?Z???o??}??]v?](?Z?P]}v[? ??v??}???}v????u?]?Zv??}??? ]v?(?]vPv???]vP?Z]?????Z ????u???]v? ?}?U?}u}??}?U v]v?Z????}}uX ^???u? ^???u? W???]v?v?o]??? ???  }( ??? W???]v?v?o]??? &/>/d/^ ^/t><^E^dZd  ZK^^/E'^ ?ZW(}?v]v]??????Wov(}?d?v??}???}vvo??vr ??,o?Z~Wd,U?]?ol??}uu}v]v?Zv?????? }( ?Z ?P]}vU ?Z ?]??}o v E? ?]?]v }?v?}?v?X ^]r ?ol?(}?u?o??o?}u?o?v??}?l?]v?Z???X^]r ?ol??o? ?(???v?o??Z?]v?Z?P]}vX/v?Z?]ooP v???}(/d/^ E}v}(?Z?P]}v[???vu?v]]?o]??Z??]Pv??r ???]v}?]?o?}??v??}?l?XdZ^??[?]?ovWr ???]v?]?}??}?Z?]v?.?o????}?}?? r ??? ?}????Z?????Z?}?PZ?Z?P]}vVZ}???U?Z????r o? ?]?Z} ?? }v??o??}v }( o}o ??lZ}o??X tZ? ??Z ]v?.?}v?]oouv]v??u?}(?}o]?v(]o]???u]v? ?}  ?vX dZ? ?}???U ?Z]Z ?? }v]? (}? ??r ?}voUo}vP r ]??v?o]vP~XPXUZv?????]]vP[U?vo?P ?v?Z]???  o}vP}?v????}?V?Z??v?}?l]??}?vr ?}?v?U?v]???]??U}uu?]o??Uv}?Z??}?v?oZ}?r ?}(}uu???v??o]???o]vP??]??X E]?Z??Z^??v}??Z?P]}v[?u?v]]?o]??Z?uv? ?Z??]o}?}???}vo]u??}?uv?? ?}?}????]??Z (}?uv?}v??????]u??}?uv???}i??vu?o? r ????]o?Wv}]?oov?U?Z}?o??U}??Z??}???]??]v?Z ?P]}vXdZ]???v?]v}v?????]?Z]??v?}?v???Z? E?,?vvDv?.oU?Z]ZU?Z?}?PZ?Z]? ??v]vP?r ???]vv]?ov??}?l?UZ?u}v?????Z???Z(r ]o]??vv}?}?l]v}vv???X Kv?Z}?Z?ZvU]v???]?Zo}?????]v??8???]r ?ol?U?Zo??}Lv(?}????]?o??Z?Xo?Z}?PZ ?}u}?v? oP]v???]]vP}v?Z?]?olU]v?o?]?v ???}??]?v?(??Zv?]]vP}v?Z?}U??}?]?Z? u]v]u?u}v]?}v??u?X~^]?ol??Z}?o?o??o? u??? }( ????]v? }? ??8]v?o? ?] ?} }uu}? ???]vPV??????Z}?o ?o?o??}??]ov?}??]vP?U ?u?V?o]????Z}?o???o???}vo???U?]Pvo?r ??}ZUv??]???}v?Zv?}??]vP?}?X ^]?ol? u???  ?oo r u]v?]v v }u?o? ?} v??? ?(?]]vPX/u??(?}v?U??Z??l?v ?u??Uv?Z ?o]??? ?} ?Z P?}?v i??? ? ?Z? ??]? ????]v?X /v uv? ??U?Z]vi??]?]l??????]v}v(oo??Z}???+? ??ol??]v???]??X~?o]???[Z]PZ????U?}P?Z??]?Z ?Z]? (}??Z}??v ??}v ?u? v ?Z P? ?? ]??v ?Z?Z??}(ooU??}ou(}??Zo???]?lX/v]?}v ?}???(}v]?}v?U?]?ol?]???????o?o?+? ? }v?P?]??X^]?ol? ?Z? ???v?}P???}?u?U}??Z? ol ?u??? ???U???v? Z????}?]??X ~dZ?v??]l ?]???}?o]}?}u?}v??????}?v(ooX ,/u]vd?]o[~??X ?? X &]P?? ??  ?]??}?Z}(?Z???}i??U]v]?}v?}oo?]??vPv?}r ?v?oo}vP r ]??v??]o?v??}]?}vv?}??]v?Z?r P]}vX D/EdEEEDE ‘DEd ^]?ol?U]l? ?Z?Uv}?Z?(}?u?}(????]vv?o]?? ]v(????????Uo]l?}?v?]o???U???]?u]v?vvv uvPuv?](?Z???}(?v?}v?(o?v8]v?o?X&}? ?Zu}?????U?Z(]o]???Z??]??]v?Z?P]}v?]v???r (?}??}v]? }vX,}???U]v]?]?o?]??}?Z]]??Z(}or o}?]vP??}ou?W ?X v?]?}vuv?XDv??}????u?}Z?v?]Pv ?]?Z?Z??}u}]o]vu]vU?]?Z????]vv?o]??(r ]o]??vL??Z}?PZ?XdZ???o?]?????????Z?? Z}??o}??v? (?}?Z?????XDv??]?ol?U??]oo? ?Z}?o}vPu?o? r ov}uu?]o???]??Uol(?v?}v]vP ????]v?}??]vP?]Pvo?U??}lv????????~XPX (}??]? r ?Z???Uv?????(?}u?Z?}???v} u}??Zv?Z??X ^???u? W???]v?v?o]??? ???  }( ??? ?X }vv??] ??X Dv? ????]v v ?o]?? (]o]?? Z? v]v??oo?]uoU}Lv}v??o?]?X?}vr ???vU P?? ]v?????? ?Z ?]?ol v??}?lX ^}u }( ?Z?}????]?oo}?}v?U]vo?]vP?}v(?}u?}??r o???v?}v?U??Z??Z}}o?U ??l?Uv?Z}??]vPv u?o}?uv?v???X ?X Z?]?? X (??u]v?vv}v??]o?]v??]v??Z? o?}?Z???v}(?l?UZ?u??Uv}?Z?]u?]r uv??Xd}?}uU?Z?u?vvv}?vU???}?Z}? ?]?Z o]u]? u}]o]??U ?Z (?]oU v ? ??}v? ???o]vP ? Z]PZ???~XPXi}PP??v]l??U?Z?v?}??o }??o}?Z??X ?X ^v}??u}?oXD?v]]?o]??}v}??o}?u}??????]v v?o]??(]o]??]v?Z?P]}vXdZ???l]?oL???}??}?r ???}?v??XtZ]o?Z]????u }v?U]?o?}????????]r v?v?o]?????}v r o??]??v??]? r  r ?]???]???U ?Z}? ?}? u?v]]?o]?? } o?W ?Z]o ?}u }?v?? ?Z}?o???]PZ???U}?Z??????XdZ???o?]???(?vr ?}vov??}?l}(?v?o??o]l?v?v}??]L? ?Z??v? ?]?ol?U?}??]vP?Uv?Zo]l??o??v(}???r ??]v??}?ol]v?Z?????X 43  ^ Z??Wll?o]l.?X}u  dZ???}ou?U?Z]o]?}o?U??l??Z}(o??vP?r ?v?}v?}????]vv?o]??]????XE}}v??+}??? Z?v?lv?}???Z ????]vv?o]?????]v ]v?Z?P]}vXo?Z}?PZZW]]v?(?vu??}u}(?Z }?(]o]??v.]v]?(}?Wd,]v????U?Z?ov }v??????}v r ?u?v??Z}?}(v}v r u}?}?]???v??}??r ?}vvv}?v}vP}]vP??}P?u}(]u ??}?uv?X????u? ???}ZU?]??????Z?P]}v[?u?v]]?o]??v?Z ^???]?Z?P??}(]o]??(}? ??}u}]o? UZ?vol]vPX ,}???? }u?o?^????]u?ouv??}v  ~?X ?? o??}??U ?Z]?]????}ZvPW?]?Z?Zv?uv?}(?Z^??[?Z}ur ?o??????[o?U  ????]v?v?o]?????}]v?P?? ]v?}oo??P?}(u?v]]?o]??[v?Z^??[??}uvPr uv?X&???Z?Z}?(}?]u??}?uv?]?P]?v??Z?v?}( ?Zv}o}P?o]l^o]l&]? 43 U?Z]Z?u?oo??]u?o].??Z ??}??}(P?Z?]vP( l(?}u??v??}???}v????u??r ??U ]vo?]vP ????]v? v ?o]???U ??l]vP ]????U v ??}?]]vP???}v??X o?Z}?PZ ??Z?Zv}o}P?]? v}? ?]o? ?? ]v ?Z ?P]}vU P]?v ]?? ?}??o?]?? v ?o}?uv? ]v v??}uu?v]??U?Z?]???}v?}  ????Z?]?u?]v ?Zv?(????X ^???u? W???]v?v?o]??? ???  }( ??? &]P?? ?? X,]l]vP??]o?]v?Z?P]}v ^???u? W???]v?v?o]??? ???  }( ??? t></E'E/ o?Z}?PZ?Z]?o]??u? ?v?U]?o?}]u?o]??Z?o?o?}(?olr ]vPv]l]vPu??o}(?}???XdZo???}?o?ol}? ]lU?Z(????}????]ooP]?v?}(]o]??(}?????]r v?v?o]???UvU?}v???vU?Zo???}?o?]oo ?ol }? ]lJ dZ]? ??P P??? ?Z? ?Z }??}?]? u?  ???U vuo? ?Z? Z]( ?}? ?]o ]?U ?Z? ?]oo }uX[  o}? ?o]v ?Z}?ov}??????????(}?]v?}vX???}i??(?}u^]vr P?}? ?} }?vZPvU(?}uW}??ov ~K?P}v?}E?z}?l ]??Uv(?}uo?l^????}?Z &?u]vP?}vvo,?]?r Pd?]ou}v????U]v???uv??]v????]vv?o]??(r ]o]??U ?Zv }??o ?]?Z ?oo r ?ovv ov ??U v ul ^???u? W???]v?v?o]??? ???  }( ??? ?ol]vPv]l]vP?]oo??v????}?]?]vPXdZ?vo]??r oo???v?(}?u?Z(}(??v??}???}vX d Z?}?v?o(}??ol]vPv]l]vP]v?Z?P]}v??]?X^}u }uu?v]??U??Z???o]vP?}vvWo?u}??ZUu?v??Z? Z]PZo?o?}(]?Z???]????Z]?ol}(v?]??X~E}?}vo? }?o??o?(??}?oo]??Z?U???Z??v?}v??Z? ? Z}??}?o(???v??v?}o]?}v?ol]vPv]l]vP ]??vXK?Z??U??Z?E??]?]vv?]??}oU?]?Z?Z]?Z]?r ?}?] ??v }?? v Z]PZ?U u]? }vv???}v? }( ??]r v?U?}?l?o?U??}??U?Z}}o?Uv?????}v? v???oo? u}???]??}v?Z??}+?u}??}?v?o(}?v}v r u}?}?]???X ,]??}?]oo?U?Z?????Z?]?Zv}v r u}?}?]???v??}??X K???Zo?????o?U?Z???Z?P?}?v]v??r ]vPo?Z}??o?}???????]v?v?o]??????v??}???} v v?ovv]vPZ?(}??}v?Z??}u}]oX,}???Ur ??]??Z???l?U?]??}ovE??]?]v~vU?}o??? ??v?U }?v?}?v Wo]v?]ooU d????]ooU v ^}??Z]vP?}v ??oo u?(??oP?}?v(}?????]v?v?o]???X? &]P?? ?? 45  45  tol^ }?^o?o???Z?ol]o]??}(v????o}?vPv?? ??}??U ? ????v??U ?Z}}o?U ??l?U ?X_ }?]vP ?} ?ol?}?X}u U ? Z ?Zv]???}?l??^???]vP??}]v???}v?Z]??v?}?Zo}??? uv]??]vZ?P}??X/(?Zo}???uv]??]v?P}??]??]?Z]vX?? u ]o? Y  ?]????]Pv????Zu?]u?uv?u?}(?}]v??XdZv?u?}(?}]v?? o]v? ?  ?Z ]??v ???}Z? ? u]oY v} ?}]v? ? ? ?? (}? uv]??(???Z??Zv?u]oXZ?P}??]??]PZ???oo?v?Z ~?X ??? ?Z}??U}?Z?]??}ovE??]?]v}v?v??}}? ?  Z]PZ }vv???}v }( uv]?? ~o]??]?U ?Z}??U ??l?U ?Z}}o?U?X]v?Z]?}?v?}?v?Xt]?Z??}???ovv]vPv]vr ???uv?U?Z???u?}vP]vvi}?Z]PZ(}}?v?o ??8X ^&dz ??Zu?o??U?ol]vPv]l]vP??o??o??(  ??]??W ?Z?]?l??vo?P}v?]??}(??]??U????Uv?Z}r ?]}vo?}lv}vX,}???U(??}?oZ??Z}??}???v]?? ?}?ol}?]l]v?Z]o r (????uXD}???ol]vPv]lr ]vP}????}?vv]v??v??}???}v????u?Z?Z ?v ?]Pv?}(]o]???Z8]v?]??o?}v}(u}?}??Z]o?X dZP??]???v?]vu??v????vu}?}??Z]r o?v????]v?v?o]????????Zo????]Pv].v? ?]?lX??ZZ?? &]P?? ??  ~?X ??? ?Z}??U}oo]?]}v???? ?Z]Z ? ?]??? v ???vP?? ?}?o ????]? }L v u}? o]lo??Zvv}????o?]v?Z(}???ov?o??????Z??r ???]v?v?o]???X ?}]v?????uu vv}?uo]??}?]o  ?}?XXXX dZv?u?}(v?? uv]??]??Zo]vP??]?}?}(?Z?Z??}?o?olX_ dZ?P}?]?]v ?ZoPv]v &]P?? ??  ?.v?(}oo}??Wtol?? [??]?U^]o??r ?v?}v}????]??_Vs???oloU^D}????v?v}ur ?o]?Z}v(}}?_V^}u?Z??oloU^^}uuv]???]?Z]v?ol]vP]?r ?v_V?]?]vP}vo?U^z}?v?ol(?}u?}??Z}???}?}???X_ ^???u? W???]v?v?o] ??? ???  }( ??? &]P?? ?? Xtol?}?u?}(?]??}ovE??]?]v ^???u? W???]v?v?o]??? ???  }( ??? ?????U}??}v?Z}??v????]v?v?o]????]vr i??}?l]oo]v}vv???X^}u}(?Z?]v??}??]v v??o}vv???X do ??  ~?X ??? ?oo]??ol??v]l?? ]vi??}?l]oo]v?Z?P]}v?u?v]]?o]??}??  ?Z?Z? ????]}(?}u????  ?}?? ?? X? ?]vP?Z]???]}U?}?o}(???  ????}??]vi??}?l]oo?  ???o?}(?}]v??X 46  dZ]?]?v]v??(?}u?Z?????}??]vi??]?v(?o]?? (?}u?Z???]}??>ZdW~??]vP???? r ?????X 46  dZ??ov?u?}(??o??u?Z]PZ???}u]??]vP}?]v}??? ??}???X dZ??}?????o?u}??????]v?v?o]?? r (?]vo?u?v]r ]?o]??]v?Z?P]}vU?]??}ovE??]?]vUZ ??Z?}??? ?(???}??(}???Z????XW??}(?Z]?u??G?Z]PZ? ]v]v}(?ol]vPv]l]vP]v?Z}?]??~v?Z???}?vr ?oo? ??l ?v o}?? ?? r u]o ?ol }? ]l ]v? ???VZ}???U?]v]v]???Z???Z???o v}( ?ol]vPv]l]vPP?}??U?o?? v  ?}o??]v???? ?v?}(ooXtZ????Z????Z}(?Zu??U?Z]?WovZ}o? do ?? Xs?ov?o??? ]vi??]?v?Z? D?v]]?o]?? W???]v?Z??? l]oo ?o]???Z??? l]oo ?o]v ? ? ? ? ?]??}o ?? ? ?? ? ??o]vP?}v ? ? ? ? E??]?]v ?? ? ?? ? Wo]v?]oo ?? ? ?? ? Wo?u}??Z ? ? ? ? ^}??Z]vP?}v ?? ? ?? ? d}?o ??? ? ?? ? ^???u? W???]v?v?o]??? ???  }( ??? ?Z?????}??o??]?vo??U???v?oUvP?}?v? (}??}vX ??Z?o??PP???U??ZZ??ov?o???[ ??o???v}? ????vo??}???Z?P]}vv]???}?X? &]P?? ??  ~?X ??? ?Z}??U?Z]o????]v?v?o]????v?}P?Z???}? l]oo u}?? }Lv }v ??? v hX^X ?}??? ]v ??o]vP?}v v 47  }????Z.? r ????]}(?}u?????}????X>}o?}??v}?]vr o?X&?o]??v]vi??]?}vo]u]? r ??????????~XPXU/v????? ??v}??]?? ?}?Z]???}Z]]?}v}v????]v??X Wo?u}??ZU]v?]??}ov^}??Z]vP?}vUo}o?}???Z??}r ouX dZ]? ??PP??? ?Z? ]+?v? ???}Z ? ?} ???]vP ?Z??(??]????u?vX /v]?}vU?}u??????}Z}???}??Uu}???}v?} }oo]?]}v?v?]?l]??}????]v?v?o]???X &]P?? ?? 47  ~?X &]P?? ?? XW?}]o]??}(?Z?????]u???? 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 Impact speed (mph) &]P?? ?? X }oo]?]}v?]v?}o?]vP? ???]v?l ?o]?????}??? 0 50 100 150 200 Southington Plymouth Plainville New Britain Burlington Bristol Berlin Pedestrians Local Road Pedestrians US/State Route Cyclists Local Road Cyclists US/State Route ^???u? W???]v?v?o]??? ???  }( ??? ??? ?o}???Zo}?}v?}(}oo]?]}v?]v?}o?]vP??Z??ov?o ????}v^???}???~]vo?]vPhX^XZ}?????v}?/v?????? v Z]PZo]PZ?? Z?(?? }??]}??[ ~}vv???}v? }( Z ]PZ ]r v???]??]v?Z?P]}vU?Z?]u??}?uv??]v?Zvu }(?(?????]oo?i???.X 48 ??}?o]u]??}v?U &]P?? ??  }?v}?]+?v???]vr i??????]??v}vo??]??}oo]?]}v?}v^??Z]PZ???XdZ]? uv?]?}vo??oo????}(?Z??}??XD}??]v??]v?}o?]vP ??ov?o????}??}vo}o?}?X??v????v????U ??X?9}(}oo]?]}v?]v?}o?]vP?? ??]v??}}l?o}v?}? ?v?u?v]]?o}v??}oV(}??o]???U?Z?u.P??]???X?9X dZ???Z}?}(?Z]?]??Z?U](?Z?(??}(?ol]vPv]l]vP]? ?}]u??}?Uu?v]]?o]?? v ??]oo??]??}ovE??]?r ]v v ]v]?}v?}?Z^??u???? lv???}oX dZ?(??}??]}??]v?.u?P}}????vP?}]v?X ^]vo}o?}??v}?]vo?U]?u????v??}}vr ?????Z}??]}???}v}u???}vv?vPo}o?}?U?]? u?????u?Z?????]v?v  ?o]??????Z^?? ?}????]????]o}o?}?v?Z??o?}???]?l?Z?X 48  ^(??]u??}?uv??u?o?}i???.}???]?Z?P]}vV??Z?? ?}v?Z????]?}(?Z]?WovU?Zu?}?v}?v}??Z?X ^???u? W???]v?v?o]??? ???  }( ??? &]P?? ?? X}oo]?]}v?}v^??Z]PZ????]?Z????]v???]?u???vv?u? ^???u? W?o]??v?]? ???  }( ??? W?o]??v?]? E}?W?Z]?Wov}v?]? ???]??o? r }?v }?  r }??????]? ??v?]?](?Z]???]u??(?v?}v]??}????v?o?uu?? }( ?Z ??o] ??v u?o??o }?]P]v? v ??v?}v?X dZ]? }u??]?? ???]? ??Z ?  ????v?]?U ]o r  r Z]U v }?Z? ?v?}}o? ? ?oo ? ]?  v ?? ??]?? ??Z ? ‘??r Z}?vX ??]?Z]PZ(?o??]?vv?}vo??v]v(?}?}(??? v??]v?U??v?]??]??Z]?]v?Z?P]}v?}??oou}?]?o}? v??Pvv?U](v}??o]??]vPX?]??}ou?Z?}???lvE? ?]?]v??Zo?P??u ?o}?uv?v??]v?Z?P]}vU??? &]P?? ?? 49  u}v?????U?Zo???u]v??Zu?v]]?o]?? ?]?Z?ZP????v?u?v??}?}??}v}(??v?] ? }uu????U ?v??u??U???  ??v?]??]??}??}(??U ????}?l??U(}? ??}(?X? 9 X &?}u?Z??v?}]v?}(????]vPu?]uo}?P?}?]vPu} ?Z?~]XXUP?vP?uv??]???}??}(?Z]?????}??]oU ?Z??v?]? ????u]v?Z?P]}v}u?  ???Z}??X? &]P?? ??  ~?X 49 >Pvv?u???(??}?Z???????U????Uv????U?????o?X?  (?}u?ZhX^Xv??????U????v???Uv???????Uvu?]v}ur u?v]??^???????? r ????X 50  Edvu???]?XK8]ovu??W ?]P?}?? r ^?u(}? r E}?r ?ol V v??? V ,??}? r t??,??}? r ??,??}?V E?,?v Vv tr ??? ul?o?U  ?v?Zu?v]]?o]???]?Z?ZZ]PZ???]r ??Z]?]v?Z?P]}v?(?UE??]?]vU]?]???}?}??}v?o? ??v?]? r ???X ? &]P?? ?? 50  ~?X ??? U ?Z]Z Z??? ??? }( ??v?]??]??Z]??}????]}??]??v?P]}v?]v?Z???U ? Z}??U  ?]??Z]?u}vP}uu????(?}u?Z ]?? }(E??]?]v ]??vo}???Zvu}vP}uu????(?}u?Z (?oo??v?  }( v?  }(}vv???[?u??}?}o]?v?P]}v?U}?E?vPov]??v ?}?v??~Ed?X 51  dZ]?]?v]u?}??v??}]v?U?]v?Z? ?P]}v?  ??vv}?}vo???v?]? r (?]vo?]????o?}o?P???Z? }( ?oo r ?} r } ????? v ]??v? ???o ??U }uu?v]?? ?Z]Z?ZoovP]vP(}???v?]????]X??}(?Z]?U}v u]PZ?U}v?Z(}(]?U????]??Z]?]v]???}?]?]o? Z]PZ ??Zv]v?Z?P]}v??Z?????}?v?ZuU??]v?Z? }(E??]?]vU?Z????]????Xd?v?]?[?}uu???Z?]v oo}(u??},??}????X?9U???????X?9(}??Z]??}( ,??}?v?X?9(}??Z]??}(E??]?]vXdZ]?v}uo?oo? (}?]v? ??P?}vv??PP????Z??Z?P]}v[???v?]?????u u??v?Z]?]vPX ?????Ud  D??}? }o]?vEdXoo?(?}u?ZhX^Xv??????Uu?r ]v}uu?v]??^????????U???]??}ov^}??Z]vP?}vU?Z]Z??}v ??????? r ????}(?Z?????X 51  E?vPov]??v?}?v??U?.v??ZhX^Xv??????X ^???u? W?o]??v?]? ???  }( ??? hv(}???v?o?U o}vP]??]vo u??}?}o]?v ?P]}v ? ? v}? ?]ooU?}v}}u??]?}v}(??v?]v??v?]??}??o?]??}?? ?u]??}??]oX,}???U?}vu?v]]?oo?o?X &]P?? ??  ?Z}???ZZvP]vu}?Z????v  }uu????r ??v????v????? XdZ????o?Z?U?Z]o??}( ??v?]??E??]?]v}uu????]?u?lo?o}???Zv? ,??}?]??vu??}?}o]?v?P]}v}uu? ???U]?Z? ??r oo?P?}?v?Z]o,??}?[??Z?Z?(oov X dZ???o?]v,??r (}?]??????]?]vP ???Z?????Pv?oo??}Pv]? ?}??]}??]vP?Z]Z??v?]?????Pv?}v?]U?? 52  D??Z}??v??}?l(?}u  ????X o?} ?? ?? }( ??v?]? ? E? ,?v }uu????  ??r P}v??Z?u?uX Z/> &?}u?Zu]o}(?Z?? ?Z  ?}?Zu]o}(?Z?? ?Z  v????U v??o}vv???}vv??}v??????v??vr ?]??]ov??}?lU?]?]v &]P?? ?? 52  ~?X ??? XdZv??}?lU ?Z]Z?v?Z?}?PZ????}?vv]??}(]u?}??]v?Z???U ]vo???}o]v?]v?Z?P]}vU}v??vv]vP?? r ???Uv?Z }?Z?Uv}??Z r ?}??ZX &]P?? ?? Xd?v?]??]??Z]????v?}(oo?}?l????o}(??]v 0% 1% 2% 3% 4% Berlin Bristol Burlington New Britain Plainville Plymouth Southington 1990 2000 2013 ^???u? W?o]??v?]? ???  }( ??? dZ .??? o]v ]??o? }vv ? ?Z ?P]}v ?]?Z t?????U ?]P?}??UE}??olU^?u(}?UvE?z}?l]???}?Z?}??Zr ???v,??}?UDvZ???Ut]oo]uv?Uv}??}v?}?Z v}??Z??X d?]v? }v ?Z]? o]v ??? ???o ???}v? ]v v ?}?v?Z?P]}vXdZ?]vo??? t???]ooUd????]ooU  ?]??}oU &}????]ooU Wo]v?]ooU E? ?]?]vU E?]vP?}vU ou?}}UvW?l?]ooX~^}u??]v?o?}u??}??]v’??r ??}vU,v}lUvd}oo?X dZ,]??}?]od]udo? ~?X ??? P]??u?(}???]???}v (?}u?Z?]??Xd?v?(????o?}?}??]o?}}?Z?v?? ]??U]vo?]vPD]o?}?vUE?,?vU???UE?>}v}vU 53  ,}o]???o?X E}??]ZU W?}?]vU ^??]vP.oU v???U d}??]vP?}vU v  t]v??X o?Z}?PZ}???}v?ZvP}???uU? ]??vi}?Z]PZ o?o}(???]?v?o?Zv}vuv?}(???vP????]}v ?Z]?o]vX&}?]v??vU???D}v??Z?}?PZ^????]v?Z u] r ?????U?}u????]v????o(?}ut??????},??r (}?V????]v?u?Z??????]?X 53  ~dZ]??v?? ]v??v^?vr ??X?v?o???Zu] r ?????U???vP??}?oZ}}? (?}u?]???]v?]vZ]??}v}v?l??~?]?Z(}??}v^?r ??????v}v}v^?v??Xo?Z}?PZ???vP?}???}v? &]P?? ?? XZvP]v??v?]?u}?Z?}???u???v }uu???? -4% -2% 0% 2% 4% 6% 8% 10% 12% 14% 16% Hartford New Haven New Britain &]P?? ?? XW?v?}(}uu??????]vP??v?]?]v?o? ?P]}v?v]?? 0% 5% 10% 15% NECTAs (metro regions) ^???u? W?o]??v?]? ???  }( ??? ??vE?z}?l]??vt?????Z??]v???uv ]v ?v?].?v??ZP]?}(D??} r E}??ZU?Zo?????vP? ??]v?]vv??o}vv?????}????vv]vP]v????X 54  ~&?]PZ? }v?v??}v?Z]?o]vU?Z}?PZ?????v?oo?]u]v]?Z?r ]????}??l??]}??}vX????o?UE??]?]vv?]?r 54 ^??]?}}??}vvL??ZG}}?}(????V???]??vt??r ???v,??}?v]v????X ?}ov}?Z}o?Z]??v?}v}(]vP?Zo?P??]????}??r o?}v]v?Z??] r ????~E?z}?lUE?:???Uv}vv?r ]???]?Z}??(?v?}v]vP??]v???}v?X dZ?}vo]vo]vl?Z?P]}v?]?ZP???E?,?vU?Z &?u]vP?}vsoo?UvD??Z????[W]}v?soo?XW??vr P??}?o??]?Z?}?Z?? r ???o]v]vWo]v?]ooV??]v?}v?Z]? o]v o?} ??}?? ? ?Z? ]?}vo ???}v? ]v ?Z ?P]}v &]P?? ?? X,]??}?]o??]vv??}?l &]P?? ?? X,]??}?]o??uv??}?l ^???u? W?o]??v?]? ???  }( ??? ~v uo?D]oooUWov???]ooUv^}??Z]vP?}vU??oo?E? ,?vUD?X?uoUvZ?Z]??}?Z?}??Zv&?u]vP?}vU ?}vU ^]u????U ‘?v?U }vPu}vU ^}??Z?]lU t??]oU ^}??Zu??}vU ??Zu??}v ~D??Z????U E}??Zu??}vU v t]oo]u???P ?} ?Z  v}??ZX ~&oP ??}?? ?? ?]oo ? ?}}l??ovt?}P?Xd?]v?}v?Z]?o]vv????? ?Z]PZ?]??Z]???Z}???vt?????v,??}?V? }v???vU???vP????]?]v????X&?]PZ??v ?v?o?Z?o??????U?ZvG}} ?uP?Z??l?X^]v ?ZvUu?Z}(?Z?]PZ? r }( r ??Z?v}v???]v?}P?vr ??U?Z&?u]vP?}vvo,?]?Pd?]oU?]?Z?ov??}}v??? ?Z? r ???v]u??}???}v??}?]o??]oX&?]PZ?}???}v? ???]??}vo?o}vP????Puv?}(  ?Zo]v??vZ}??r ?}v]??}??]vWo]v?]oov?Zv}??Z?vv}(^}??Z]vP?}vX /v]?}v?}?ZZ???]ov??}?lU?Z}??? r ]??v??u 55  ????u}vv??Z}uu?v]??}(v??o}vv????]?Z Z}?Z?vP???,??}?U?Z}?v]v &]P?? ?? XdZ??u? vo???o}???Z}???]??v?v??v?(???}?ZZ?? ?]o????u?ui}?v}?U]vo?]vP}?v?}?v?o]vU?]??}oU E?  ?]?]vUvWo]v?]ooXt]?Z?Z?]?}(??o???U?Z]????r ?u??]?uv?o]v?Z?????XE}?Z]vP}(]??u]v?X 55  d?u??o?}lv}?v?Z??????[}?Z??}oo??X[  D??Z}??v??}?l(?}u ????X>]v??}d????]oo??]????v? XZ]oo]v?U?}u}(?Z]Z(}or o}??Z?u}??]}??U?v}??Z}?vX/uP?lv(?}u,??}?}?v?? d?}oo??U??o]?Z??Z}vv???d?}oo?D???u~????X o?Z}?PZ?Z?Z?v???oo?}???Z???(}???r ?}??}v}(???vP??]o?}v??o}vv???U]vo?]vP(?}u ?Z]?Wo v~(}??]o?U? /v?P??}v?]?ZE?z}?l U  ?X  ?? U v}  }uu???}????????]v?????Z?P]}vXdZ?}o}uu?r v]???]?Z???vP??]o]??o]vU??Z}?K> d dZE^/d uvP? ?Z ?P]}v[? o}o ?? ????uU ?Z]Z ????????}(?o]vU?]??}oU,??}?&?u]vP?}vUD?]vU E??]?]vUE?]vP?}vUv Wo]v?]ooXK???}v???o]??Z? ???W  ddZE^/d~,E^ ??v??Z,??}?]?]?]}v  ~}v?}??]v ?Z ?P]}vV  ?Z E? ?]?]v d?v??}???}v }u?v? v ddK ? ?v?}v????}}??? ?Z E?  ?]?]vl?]??}o ]?]?]}v???~??}v?v?}???U??? ??o?X^??]]?v}? }+?]v??o]vP?}vUWo?u}??Z~]vo?]vPd????]ooU}?^}??Zr ]vP?}vX &]P?? ??  ~?X ??? ?]??ddZE^/d?}???]vvv? ?Z?P]}vX  ?????vD}v??Z?}?PZ&?]?(?}u}???D ?}?WDU?]?Z??v???]?}?W??WD]v????}(?o]vU E??]?]vUvWo]v?]ooXdZ? ]?v}^?v?}?Z}o]???r ?]X ^]vPo??v?(????vddZE^/d?}???U]vo?]vP?}v (?}u?ZE??]?]vl?]??}oU,??}?UvD?]vltoo]vPr (}? ]?]?]}v? ? ?}??]o ? v} }??X D?o??o ??v?(?? v ??v?(?? ?} }? (?}u D]o?}?v ? d? v?]? ??? ? o?} ?}??]o?????]??Z???Z?}(]?}vo?l?~?XW?r ?vP??u?o?}}?}?o]PZ?(?}uu??l??]v???Z?r o]v r }o???}??? ^???u? W?o]??v?]? ???  }( ??? do ?? X}uu}v?}???v???o?u?~u]v???? u} ??v?}v (?}u?]??}o ?? ? (?}uE??]?]v ?? ? ?]??}o }?v?}?v v v v W ?? ?? &?u]vP?}v Doo W ? ?? ? ^ ?? ?? ^ ?? ?? ,??}? d?]v???}v W ? ?? ? ?? r ?? ??? ?? ?? ? ?? r ?? ?? ?? DvZ??? }?v?}?v W ? ?? ? ?? ??? ?? ?? ? ?? ??? ?? D?]v d?]v???}v W ? Z ?  ??? ?? Z ?  ?? ?? D]o?}?v }?v?}?v W ? ?? ? ?? ??? ?? ?? ? ?? ?? ?? E??]?]v }?v?}?v W ?? ?? v v v E?,?v ‘?v d?]v???}v W ? Z ?  ?  ~}? ? ^ ??? ??? ?? ??? Z ?  ?  ~}? ? ^ ??? ??? ?? ?? ^}??Z]vP?}v ‘?v /u?}??]o L ?? / u?}??]o L ?? d????]oo ‘?v /u?}??]o L ? /u?}??]o L ?? t????? ‘?v d?]v???}v W ? Z ?  ?  ? : ~}? ? ?? ??? ??? ?? ?? Z ?  ?  ? : ~}? ? ?? ??? ??? ?? ?? t??,??}? v?? W ? ^ ? ?? r ?? ??? ?? ^ ? ?? r ?? ?? ?? t]v?}?>}l? ]??}?? W ? ?? ? ?? ??? ?? ?? ? ?? ??? ?? oo??v?]??}???u]v]u]?}v r ???uv????o}??}?W??D??}??]oX}uu??????~??????}????v}?]vo?X?]?]vP]??}v?v  ?u? P]?v?’}}PovZ?v]vG????9?}?]u?o?u}??o]??  ??8}v]?}v?XK?Z???Z???}??]o(}?uv?}(?Z??}??????}Lv ]u???o??}?Z?o]vP}??}??vP?]???}v?X&}?]v??vU?Z< ?  ? (?}uE??]?]v?}D]o?}?v?l?}???Z?u?u}??}?v??]? ???oo?o}vP?] v?Z}?Z?]??}vVZ ?  D r >]vl]?(??????u]v?????}vo???v??Z?]]o?X  ^}??Z]vP?}vvd????]ooolo}o?????]X ^???u? W?o]??v?]? ???  }( ??? ? do ??  ~?X ??? ?Z}??U?Z??v?}(???]]+??????vr ?oo?u}vP?Z??]}??.? r ?}????}???}?????v?o?r ??]v?Z???X~^?????(}????oUG?]o?}??U}uu???U v?Z??o??  }???}???v}?P]?vX?}vu]PZ?????? P]?v??Z]???]??]v}???}v?U?Z}???}??o?}???}vr ?]?o?]vZ}?8]v?o??Z???(}?u?Z]????]?X &]P?? ??  ?Z?}?PZ &]P?? ??  ~?X ???  Z?? ???o }uu}v ??(}?r uvu????X u??????}v}?P?v???v?X/vPv?oU](v}???}? ]??}u?]u]??v]vP?~v?Z???}u]v]u]????]]?U]?]?]v Z]?]v?????}.oo????]?Z?uv???]vP(????}??]o? oo?u?X? &]P?? ??  ~?X ??? ]v]??U?ZE?,?v]?]?]}v }(ddZE^/d??]??Zu}?????vP???]????Z}??}(}?r ??}v}v??P~??X?U(}oo}???Z^?u(}?U,??}?U ?]P?}??Uvt?????????u?]v?Z?}??XE??]?]v d?v??}???}v[? E? ?]?]v ??? (oo ]v ?Z u]o }( ?Z ?lU?]?Z??X???]????Z}??U?o]PZ?o?o}??ZD]o?}?vU D?]vUv???UvE}??ol????u?XddK[?E??]?]v vE??]?]vd?v??}???}v[? ?]??}o ?}?????(}?u ??r ??v?oo??}???Zvu}??}(?Z}?Z?????u?U  ???X?v?X? ??]????Z}??X dZ?.P??? ]u?o??Z??????]]?????o] ?]?Z ???? ?} uv }? ?Z? ?Z ???] }? v}? .? ?Z v?}(?}?v?o???}u??X’]?v?Z??]]o]??ZoovP? &]P?? ?? XW??vP???]????}???vPZ}?? 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 &]P?? ?? X}???????vP???]? $0 $2 $4 $6 $8 $10 $12 $14 ^???u? W?o]??v?]? ???  }( ??? ?Z?P]}v(?U?Z]?Wov}v?]???Zo?? u}?o]lo?X/vv? ?v?U &]P?? ??  ?Z}?oP]?}v???X??u?o?(?}u,??r (}?}v}?vulo?U(?}u?Z??v?}]v?}(.oo]vP???U ?Z? ]??}}u(}?]u??}?uv?]v?Z?P]}vX ???[????]?v}??Z}vo???(}?uvu????}??Z?}( }v?]??}vXsv????u?v}?8]v?}v?? r u]o ?]?U??]v?}u???Z?  v}?? r +??X~/(?Z}??? }(}???}v?o}?U?Zv?l??o?vv}?Z]PZX&?}u ?Z]??}]v? r }( r ?]?U?Z??}???}??]v?Z?P]}v(??}ur ?Z???X &]P?? ??  ?Z}???Z???}???}v?]vE??]?]v ??}?PZo?}u?????]?Zu}??}?Z?}???}v?]v?Z??? ?Zv]?}u??}?Z??o}???}??v??}???]vPo???vP?X W? r ???vP?}????u?lo?Z]PZ?(}??Z? ]??}o???}( ?Z????uV?(}?U?Z]?]u?o]??Z??Z?u?}??}???r v]???}??]vP]?}vo8]v?}??}(?Z??}???X &?U ]( v?U ??v??}???}v (]o]?? v ???]? }?? ?Z]? }???XdZ]?Z}o?v}?}vo?(}?oou}?}(??v?]???o?}(}? ?}?v]??}???X,}???U?ZP??}?Z]Z??v??}??r ?}v(]o]??v???]????]?}???](?v]vP??]??r u? oo?X/v??v?]?U?Z??v?P}(}???vP}????Z??lr ???o???(}?]???u?Z^(?}??}?????}X_??} }( ???9 ?}?o ]v]? ?Z? (?? }?? ?Z v?? }?? }( ??}?]]vP?Z????]V}v}(??}?}?o]u?o??Z???]]? }u?o? o????]]?~]XXUP???X &]P?? ??  ~?X ??? ??o ? P??]???v?u}vP?Z]o]??}(.? r ?}????}??r ?}???}?}??}????Z?}?PZ(???v?~}?U???v}?Z???U ?Z]? ?vv }v P}??vuv? ???]]?X ? &]P?? ?? U ?]P?}??[?’do?]v.vv]o??(}?uvXE??]?]v d?v??}???}v}u?v?[?E??]?]v?}???}u]vo}? ?}vU?]?ZZ]PZ??}}(??X?9XddK[??}???]v?Z]?? v E? ?]?]v d?v??}???}v[? ?] ??}o ?}??? ??(}?u (? ?}??UZ}???U?]?Z??}?}(??X?9v??X?9U?????o?X dZ??}}??Z}?]vP?]v]??Z??Z??}???u?}??o? ?vv?}v???]]?vu???]uv]??(}??r ?]?X &]P?? ?? X&?}??}?????} 0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% 40% ^???u? W?o]??v?]? ???  }( ??? do ?? X&]? r ?}? ???}???}v?]v}vv??? }v???}? ZP]}v ??,}??? W??vP?d?]?? D]o? d  dZE^/d~ ,E^  ,??}? ???U??? ??U???U??? ?U???U??? d  dZE^/d~ ,E^  E?,?v ???U??? ?U???U??? ?U???U??? d  dZE^/d~ ,E^  ^?u(}? ???U??? ?U???U??? ?U???U??? ddK E??]?]v ??U??? ???U??? ???U??? ‘d ?]P?}?? ???U??? ?U???U??? ?U???U??? ,Zd v??? ??U??? ???U??? ???U??? D]o?}?vd?v?]?]???]? D]o?}?v ??U??? ???U??? ???U??? D]o(}?d?v?]?]???]? D]o(}? ?U??? ??U??? ???U??? E ??]?]v d?v??}???}v}X ?]??}o ?U??? ??U??? ??U??? E??]?]vd?v??}???}v }X E??]?]v ??U??? ???U??? ???U??? E}??Z r ??d?v??}???}v }X t????? ??U??? ?U???U??? ???U??? E}??Z r ??d?v??}???}v }X D?]v ?U??? ???U??? ???U??? E}??Z r ??d?v??}???}v }X too]vP(}? ?U??? ??U??? ??U??? E}??old?v?]?]???]? E}??ol ??U??? ???U??? ???U??? E}??old?v?]?]???]? t???}?? ??U??? ??U??? ???U??? ^}??Z???d?v?]? ^}??Z?? ??U??? ???U??? ?U???U??? ddK=Ed }u]v ?]??}olE??]?]v ??U??? ???U??? ???U??? ^???u? W?o]??v?]? ???  }( ??? dZ????????]v??]???}(????u?Z?(?v?}v??? }?o(?v?}v??X^??o??}ou?Z?v]v?.? ?}?v?oZu????}?Z??o]??}(v????}???}?]??Z]? ]v?Z ????uXdZ?]vo??Z(}oo}?]vPW ?X }v?}o???}???XDv????}???]v?Z?P]}v}v}? (}oo}?o]v???Z?????(?}u?Zu]v?]?}(???o?} ?]????Z?]P}???]o??U}8??l?Uv???uv? }u?o??Xo?Z}?PZ?Z??]??vPv? ???]??]v??vr ???U???]vP?Zuv??]????l]vP?}????Z?}v?]?r o?]v???Z}u?o?]??}(?Z?}??v???Z ??}(???]XdZ?(?}?????Z+??o?o}( ???]?}??Zv??v??Z??Z?u??]???u}? ?} ?v?o?]???Zv?Z???X ?X >l}(????}??X/vu}??}(?Z?P]}vU?????v}vGP r }?v????u?]?Z}??v?.v?????}??XtZ]o?Z]?]v ?Z}?? v ul ???o u}? }v?v]v? ? oo}?]vP ?]l???v?}? r }+?o}???}}?]P]v?v??v?} v?U]v ?o]??]???}??????u?Z???}????v?o]o~?Z ??u]v?}v?Z?Z??}??}?]?u??Z]???}v}( ?Z?]??v?Z?o]vP?v??]?o~?Z]o]??}(?]r ???}u?lv]?u?l?v??}]v?}Lv?]o??]?r ??}v?Z ????Z??}??}????o}l}???}UP??o? ?o}?]vP???]X ?X >l}(?]PvPXtZ??Z??v}????}??U?Z?o?} ?v?}v}?]Pv?XdZ?v}(???}??]??]PvP~]vr o?]vP?u?o?vu??]v?Z?P]}vul?(}??? ????u?Z? ]? ???oo?]v?]?]o X ?X W}}?}vv??]??X?]????Uo?Z}?PZ???]v?Z?r P]}v } oo}? ??v?(??U ??v?(?? ? }Lv }u?o? v o}vP]v???}vU??Z?o??v}?o???}}?]v?X /v]?}vU?Zol}(?Z?}?PZ?}??vPv?o??]?o? o}o v??? }( ?Z ?? ???] ul? ]v???P]}vo v ]v??r u}o??]??ovP?Z?v]u???oX oo}(?Z?(?}???v?u]v?Z??o]??U8]v?U?]??Z]?U v?}o?v?}(?Z??v?]?????uX,}???Uv}v}(?Zu? ]v?}o?oUv W?o]d?v?]?  ~?X ?? ??}?}????P???}Zo? .??ZuX yWZ^^ dd ZE^/d??v???]?}(????????(}?}uu????XdZ? }(?Z?????Z?P]}vX,}???}(???]vo}?}v?(}??Z ?}???????uo?o]u]?X??????????]u?]o???v??]vP ???ZZ}??v???o??v?Z??}??o]??v}?v?}?v ,??}? }vo?Xt]?Z?Z???}v}(?ZWo]v?]oo>]???U?Z? }v}???}??}?v?}?v?}??}?vv???X????v?Uv}?r ???? ?? ?]?]?? ?Z }?? }( }?v?}?v ?]??}oU ^}??Z]vP?}v v??Uvd????]ooXdZ?P??u???????v?]??]??Z]? v??]vo?  o]u]??Z??o]??}(?Z???????????u(}?v}v r ?]?]vP}uu????X ^???u? W?o]??v?]? ???  }( ??? &]P?? ??  u?? ?Z ?}??? }( ?Z? ???U ?? ??yX ~d dZE^/d????o}o????Z?ul?}u???????v???r ??o?(?}u?Z}??Z?}vo???}?]????????]X  &]P?? ? ?  ?Z?}?PZ  &]P?? ??  ~?X ??? ]oo??????Z 8]v?}(?Z?r P]}v[??????????o???}?]u]o?}???}v??Z?}?PZ}?? ?Z^??X??Z.P????Z}?U?Z??}???????]o?]v?]r ??Z]?v}?? r 8]v?X/ vPv?oU???????????(?? ???vP????Z}??vv?]oZ]PZ?}????????vP???]? ~???}????X??J?Zvo}o???XtZ]o?l???]?vU]v uv???U(?}??}????Z]PZ?U?????????u]v ??v?]??}??}?]}v??? vP? r ??]??]?X/(?Z8]v? }(?Z?}??? r ??(}?u]vP?}???vv}?]u??}?U]?u? ?}??Z????]vP?oo}?vP?Z???]]?Z]v?Zu?}}?Z? ??v??}???}v???]??Z?o]??u}?vP(}??Z?lX &]P?? ?? X,??}? r ????????v??}?l ^???u? W?o]??v?]? ???  }( ??? &]P?? ?? X }???????vP???]? &]P?? ? ? X&?}??}?????} $0 $20 $40 $60 $80 $100 $120 $140 0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% 40% 45% 50% ^???u? W?o]??v?]? ???  }( ??? &]P?? ?? XW??vP???]????}???vP Z}?? do ?? X????????}??? E}X Eu ^?}?? /v r l}??}?v??v? ? hv]}v?]oo ^?XD??[?W?l?Z]Uhv]}v?]oo &?u]vP?}vW?l?Z]U?X?vd}?v&?uZ} ?l? ?l? ?? Wo]v?]ool?]??}o >l?X?Z?X???U?]??}o Wo]v?]oo>]???U??D]v^?XUWo]v?]oo ?l? ?l? ?? Z?Z]?l^}??Z]vP?}v W?l?Z]UZ?X?? v}??Z}(/ r ???UZ?Z]? W?l?Z]UZ?X??UWov???]oo~^}??Z]vP?}v ?l? ?l? ??y ,??}?lE??]?]v ?]E?]vP?}v ^u ? ?? U ?? v} ?]l??? ??v E??]?]vlE?]vP?}v??vv??oZ}? ?l? 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 ^???u? W?o]??v?]? ???  }( ??? do ?? X}uu????? }???}v?  ]v}vv??? }v???}? Z}??~????]v]?,??}???v?}v ??  ,}??? W??vP?  d?]?? D]o? ??}???}u?v? t]oo]uv? ? ?U??? ??U??? ???U??? }oo]v???}u?v? s?v}v ? ??U??? ???U??? ???U??? ddZE^/d~,E^ ,??}? ? ??U??? ???U??? ?U???U??? ddZE^/d~,E^ ^?u(}? r tZ]?Wo]v? ??U??? ???U??? ???U??? ddK Z?Z]? ? ?U??? ??U??? ??U??? ddK ,??}? r Ko^??}}l ?U??? ??U??? ???U??? ddK ?]??}o ? ?U??? ??U??? ???U??? ddK ,??}? r E?,?v ?U??? ??U??? ???U??? ‘d ^Zo?}v&o?? ?U??? ??U??? ??U??? :}ZvE?}v}vP r ]??v????u]vo? d?u]vo E??]?]v &?u]vP?}v ??? :]uu?[?^u}l^Z}? ??  tD]v^?X E??]?]vUd????? }vv??? d?u]vo ??  ???}vW?lZX &?u]vP?}vUd????? ,}??? }( }???}v ?W??D t  ??WD]o? ?W??  D t  ?W??  WDD}v r &?] ?W??D t  ?W??WD^? r ^?v ^???u? W ?o]??v?]? ???  }( ??? &]P?? ?? X d(???l  ?}?? ^???u? W?o]??v?]? ???  }( ??? Kd,ZWZKs/Z^ WZdZE^/d hv??Zu?]v??]?Z]?]o]???U?Z???o]??v?]? ]???}?]??]?uv}??}??]o?}???}v??]?Z ]?]o]??U ??]?ov?U ]?o r ??]o ???] u???  u?]oo~Z????v?]?[XW???v?]?}Lv?l??Z(}?u }(  uv r ???}v?]??v?XdZ??Z]o?U?Z]Z??]Pv ?}u}???]o?}???}v??]?Zo]u]?u}]o]??}?}?Z? Zv]??U ??? ?]?? ?]?Z]v  .? ???] ?U Pv?oo? ?Z? r ??????}(u]o(?}uv?]??vP??v?]?o]vX~^??] ?? v?]}v??}u?u?P}?}v?Z]?X??}?Z???uo? Z]PZ}??vo}P]??o}u?o?]??}(??}?]]vP?Z???]U??r ??v?]?]?}vo?}?v?}?Z}??Z}Z?v??.?o]P]r o 58  ?v??Z?[?P?]o]v?v}}l??]??]v?vX dZ’??? ,??}?d?v?]?]???]?v}?  uvP?????v?]? (}?v??o}vv???  ~?Zv??o}vv???ZP]}voWovr v]vPPv?(}?u?o?uvP?Z???] X &]???d?v?]?  ]??vr ? }v??? ?} }??? ?Z ???]U ]vo?]vP ??]? }}l]vPU ?Z?o]vPUv??} ???}vXdZ???]}???oo}(?]??}oU Wo]v?]ooUvE??]?]vU??oo??Z????}(?o]vU??r 58  ??.?}vu???(}?u?DWK}?v}?Z???v?]?]???]?]v?Z ^??X do ?? X>}?}v??]?Zo}vP r ]??v?????] ‘??Z}?v>]v? W??Wv?? ?]P?}?? ?}}lo?v vv v??? v]o?}v v.o &?u]vP?}v &}??}}??]v} ,??}? DvZ??? D}ZPv^?v?]v} D??? E??]?]v E?,?v E?>}v}v ^}??Z??? ^?u(}? ^?}??? d}??]vP?}v t????? t]oo]uv? t]v?? ?v(}? ?]P?}?? ?}}lo?v vv v??? ??,??}? v.o &]?.o &?u]vP?}v ‘o??}v??? ,??}? DvZ??? D]o(}? D??? E??]?]v E?,?v ^}??Z??? ^?u(}? ^?}??? ^???}? d}??]vP?}v t????? t]oo]uv? t]v?? ^???u? W?o]??v?]? ???  }( ??? o]vP?}vU?}u?ooU&?u]vP?}vUD?]vUD]o?}?vUE?]vPr ?}vUvt??,??}??Z?(oo?]?Z]v?Z? r ?????u]o?}(d dZE^/d?]??}olE??] ?]v]?]?]}v???}???X????? ? v??o}vv???[?  ????v?]???v?P?vv?oo}? ]v &]P?? ??  ~?X ??? X>]l?Z??o]???U????v?]???v?(?}u ?D?}?W??WDUD}v??Z?}?PZ^????U???]v?oo}? v????o??}v?Zu?U?Z????]??v?(?}u?D?} ?WDv?D?}?W DU?????o?XdZ?]?v}???]}v ^?v??}?Z}o]??X~W???v?]?u]??}???ZZ}???}(?P?o? ??v?]????]V?E??]?]vo}o?}?????vo??U?}U?}}U }?????v?]??Z?X ,]??}?]oo?U??]???Z??}???P]}vo}?v?]?~XPXU(?}u E? ?]?]v?},??}?Z?vi}]v???vP???v?(??X’]?v ?Z?Z??]ovuv?oZoovP??Z?uv??]??(U? ?oo??Z(???v?o?o}?u?P]vo}??}(??v??}??vP?]? oo?Z???}Z]?.vo??v?}v]v}v?Z]o U?Z  ‘???  ,?? }?d?v?]?]???]?~’,dZ?  P?v}+?]vP?]vPo r ?? ?]??}?}uo}?}v?X /v?Z}u]vP???U?Z,??}???r ??v?]?]???]?v?Zv??o}vv???????v?]?]???]? ?]oou?PUvP?vP?Zv(}??Z]????] X ???Z?  ?]vPo r ???]????}?] U?Z]Zv}u???????}(&?ur ]vP?}vvt??,??}?U??oo?oo}(,??}?UE?]vP?}vU t?Z??.oUZ}l?,]ooU?}u?ooUvD?]vU??v?? 59  dZ??Po]v?ul?X????]?????l?vX?????lvX ]v &]P?? ?? X  dZv??o}vv????P]}v  ?]oo}+???v?(? r (??]??}}?(?}u?Z?Z??v[?? ??}?]?Z}?]P]v }???v?}vo]??]?Z]v?ZP?v}??oo}?? Xd?]???Z? }?]P]v?v??u]v??o??]?o??]?Z]v ?Z??o]}??r ?]?Zv??o}vv????P]}v  v}v?v??}Zvo ?’,d [?,??}????]X~>]l?]?U?Zv??o}vv??? ?P]}v???]}(’,d  ?]oo}v?v??}????Z}??Z ??u]v ?}oo?]v?ZP?vv?oo}???X ??v???v??????}v?ul??}( v??o}vv??? ?P]}v[?  ????v?]? ???] ]v  P]?v ?Z? r u}v?Z ??]}U ?Z}?PZ?Z]?.P??]??]?]vP??]lo?X 59  dZv?u?}(o}oo]v?? v?}oo]vP]v?Z?? ?]]v???? r ????]??????X?9}???Z??r ]vP.?o??X 60  dZ?oo?}(???vP???]??u??Z??r ?]]?????X?9}???Z?u??]}XdZ?]v???o]lo? }??}P?}?]vP??v??}(?Z???]U??}???}vo(r .]v?Uvu}P??Z] ?Z]L?]v?Z?P]}v~vuo?P]vPX t]?Z}v?v?]u??}?uv???}?Z???]vP??]vP}(?Z ?}??o?}vUuv]?????}???P(???Z?X 60  dZ]?.P??}?v}?]vo?,??}??P]}v???}u????v??}?? ??Z v??o}vv????P]}v????v?]????]?}}?(?}u?Z?P]}vX ^???u? W?o]??v?]? ???  }( ??? &]P?? ?? XW???v?]????]? ] ^???u? W?o]??v?]? ???  }( ??? W???v?]?]?v}??8]v??}?Z?(}?u?}(??v?]?XW?r ??v?]??v??}v?]?o??uoo??Zv}?Z???v?]??Z]o? v u??? ??}?] ?? (}? ?ol? ?ZoZ]?? v ?}}???X dZ]?o]u]???Z]????vP??]???}(??}v}(?Z???o] ? ??v??]v??v???X/v]?}vU????v?]??Z]o? }v}?(}oo}?}v]?U????]?}????Z?Z?v?or }??}u?]u]??]??Z]?}v?? r u]o}??? r }oo?}??r ?]?X /v??U ?Z? ??}?] }v r uvU ?? r ?} r ?? ???] do ?? X ????v?]?}???}v?]v}vv??? }v???}? ZP]}v ??v?? ??,}??? W??vP ?d?]?? D]o? ZW E??]?]v r ?]??}o ? ?U???U??? ??U??? ??U??? ???U??? ‘????]P?}??d?v?]???Z}?]?? ?]P?}?? ? ?U???U??? ??U??? ??U??? ???U??? ‘??? ,??}?d ,??}? ? ?U???U??? ???U??? ???U??? ?U???U??? ‘???E?,?vd E?,?v ? ?U???U??? ??U??? ???U??? ?U???U??? ,Zd v??? ? ???U??? ?U??? ??U??? ??U??? D]o?}?vd D]o?}?v ? ???U??? ?U??? ??U??? ??U??? D]o(}?d D]o(}? ? ???U??? ??U??? ??U??? ???U??? E}??Z r ??d?v??}???}v}X t????? ? ?U???U??? ??U??? ??U??? ???U??? E}??Z r ??d?v??}???}v}X D?]v r too]vP(}? ? ???U??? ?U??? ??U??? ???U??? E}??old ^?u(}? ? ?U???U??? ??U??? ??U??? ???U??? E}??old E}??ol ? ???U??? ??U??? ??U??? ???U??? E}??old t???}?? ? ???U??? ?U??? ?U??? ??U??? ^d E?>}v}v ? ???U??? ?U??? ?U??? ??U??? soo?d ?? r ^?u}?? ? ???U??? ?U??? ??U??? ??U??? t]vZuZP]}vd t]vZu ? ??U??? ?U??? ?U??? ?U??? ^???u? W?o]??v?]? ???  }( ??? u?Zo]l ?Z?XdZ]?uv??Z?????v?]??Z]o? u???}Lv???oo}vP]??v??}?]l??v?}?}+?]??X ? ?Z &]P?? ??  ~?X ??? ?Z}??U ????v?]? ]v }v???v ??v??}???(?(?????vP????Z}???Zv v ??v }v Zo(v}v?v?Z?uv?? v ???XdZ?P]}v[?????v?]? ul?v??P}(?X?????vP???]????Z}??}(}???}vU ?Z]Zov??oo}??Zu]o???[?????v?]????]? ????ooo}??Zo??X dZ?(?}??}v??]??}ul????v?]?]???v?]?XdZ?}r ?o}??}(??vv]vP?Z????v?]????]]v?Z?P]}v(}??Z ???? r ????.?o ????  ? ?X?u]oo]}vV(}??Z ???? r ????.?o 61  dZ]?o]lo?}??U?o??]v???U?}?Z]??PZ?o? r ]??u??]???]?X ??]?????X?u]oo]}v XKv r ???l??}????X??U?Z]Z]? }?o?Z}????}v]vP??(?X?v??Z]???]U?Z?}vo? }??}??}v r ?v?Z}(?Z}??}(??}?]]vPZ??]?X &]P?? ??  ?]v??Z??Z?P]}v[?????v?]????]Z?o}???Zv ??P}????????vP???]?~???X??????oooP??Zor ??]v?Z????o?Pu?P]vX~soo?vD]o(}?d?v?]?  ]???]???o?}}+???]??(}??v????ZX 61  /v}vv???U?Z???vP?(?(}?????v?]?Z?v?? ?}?o?Z?(}?v??]?ov?o}o????]?X’]?v?Z?o}o ???Pv?oo?Z?P??v}vv??}}oo??(}??]U &]P?? ?? XW??vP???]????}???vPZ}?? 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0 &]P?? ?? X}???????vP???]? $0 $10 $20 $30 $40 $50 $60 ^???u? W?o]??v?]? ???  }( ??? ?Z]?o ??Z?PP???v]v}uv??v??(}?oo??r ??v?]?}???}??X^??]]?(?}u?Z???ul???Z]+?r vX &]P?? ??  ]v]???Z??Z ?????ui}?]??}(}??? (}?oo????v?]????]]v}vv???XKvP]vUD]o(}? v soo? d?v?]? ]???]?? o ?Z ?lV ?Z ?P]}v[? ??r ??v?]????](oo?????o?]v?Zu]o?]?Z???]?}(??9U (}??? r ?]???]?}(???X? ?X dZ??o}?? v v?Z?????]???]v]?]?o??]? v ?v? }vuv](}o(?}??U]vo?]vP?Z??v???U??]vPUvo}r ?}v}(?]l???v?}? r }+?Vvo?}v?vv} r ?Z}??V??8 }v]?}v?V?Z??Z?Vv?Zo]v??[]?]o]??XKv]v. ? ~??X?9 ????v?]? ??]?? ]v?}o??  o]v? ]v  ?ZoZ]? }? ?}}??XdZ?u]v]vP??X?9?u?o?}??XdZo??~??oo ? ?ZoZ]? ???? ?Z} ? ?vv?u? ? ]?}vo Zv]??????v?v}??}???v]??W](?Z?v????(?oo? Zo? ?}?l?v?P}(?]??vP?????]U????v?]??r ?v]????u???}?]vPo?X ‘?}??Z ]v ?]??Z]?Z? ????Z ?Z????v?]? ????uX ? &]P?? ??  ~?X ???  ??o?U????ZZ}??U?Z????v?]?G?]? ??v?oo?u?}??U?]?Zv]o?]??(}??????]?????]v ?u?~?W???}?W??Dv?W???}?W??WDX  62  dZ???o?]?o}? ?}v}?}o ?v(}?]v]v??U??Z???????}u??U??8 62  Z]v???o]vo???]v}?}(}v?????Z}??(}?vL??Z ??]v??uX/v}?Z??}??U?Z}o?uvooZ?W??[}u??]??oo??]?? }}l(}??]l????v?W??v?W??Xtlv??]???^?????}vo?X }vP??}vU }? ?l}?v?X tZv ??Z  }v?vPv? }? ?]?U ?Z ???o?? ? }Lv }v?]?o o?? ?Z? ? ?Z?}?PZ?ZG?(}??Z?u]v?}(?Z?Xvo?P]vP?Z ?]?}(?ZG?}? o?u??Z]???}ouU??]??}?oo?} }u?o?P}??X/?u?o?}?vv????U(}??ZG? vi}??}v?]?o}???]????]vPoo}?Z?Z}???}(?Z ?Xu}?}?? r +?????}Z?}???Z???}v?]?r &]P?? ?? X^??]???Z?}(?}?o}??}(}???}v? 50% 55% 60% 65% 70% 75% 80% 85% 90% 95% 100% ^???u? W?o]??v?]? ???  }( ??? v??}(???]?}?o?}  ?????v?]? r uvuvPr uv?U?Z?o]v???v}??P?}}}l?Z]???]??(}??Z ??}?PZ???Z??Zv?Z?l?Z??]v &]P?? ?? X ? &]P?? ??  ??o?U?]??Z]????v?]+?}v^????Xv? uv r  uvPuv?????P?}???]ooZ??}?l?Z]? ]v?}}?v?X /> r  r Z/ oo??vu?v]]?o]??]v?Z?P]}vv?ZZ?}??}??? ]o r  r Z]???]?(}??v]}?]??v?vU]v?}u??U?Z ]?oX dZ? ???]?U ?Z]Z ? ??? r ???]]?U ]v ??? }??o??]?Z?Z?P]}v[? ????v?]?~?Z?}???]v?Z?u ??]?Z?]u]o?}???vPZ}??????v}?]v?P???]?Z ?Z????]X/v?P??}v??v?Z????]?u?}+??]Pr v].v?}??}???v]??(}?]u??}????}u????]U??r ???}}?]P]v?v??v?} v?Uv}????]vP??Z?}?PZ}vr }u]?}(?oX &]P?? ?? X??P?l???]????Zo( r Z}?? 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 &]P?? ?? X??P?lv??]????Z o( r Z}?? 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 ^???u? W?o]??v?]? ???  }( ??? do ?? XD?v]]?o]o r  r Z]???]o]v?oU?Uv?u? D?v]]?o]?? o]P]o?]?? 63 ?}?? ,}???}(}???}v &? 64 ?o]v Z?]v????= ?o]v D} r &??W??D t  ? WD E}v ?]??}o Z?]v????= ?]??}o D} r &??W?? t  ?WD E}v ??o]vP?}v Z?]v????= ??o]vP?}v D}d?dZ ?W??  t  ?  WD t ?W??  t  ?W??  WD &??W??D t  ?W??WD E}v E??]?]v Z?]v????= E??]?]v D} r &??W??D t  ?WD E}v 65 Wo]v?]oo Z?]v????=  v  ?P]??? ?]??}oU&?u]vP?}vUE??]?]vU ^}??Z]vP?}vUE?]vP?}vsXX D} ?  D t  ?  WD d?tdZ ?  D t  ?  WD &? ?  D t  ?  WD ^? ~(}????]? E}vl ? ?X?? 66 Wo?u}??Z Z?]v?? ??=  v  ]?o ??]v?? ?]??}oUd}??]vP?}vUt?????  E?]vP?}vsXX D} r dZ  ??W??  D t  ?W??  WD &? ?W??  D t  ?W??  WD ^??W??D t  ??W??D E}v ^}??Z]vP?}v Z?]v????= ^}??Z]vP?}v D} r &??W??D t  ?W??WD E}v Z?}?? Z?]v??  ??=}(?o]vU E??]?]vUv Wo]v?]oo &?u]vP?}vU?o]vU?]??}oU E??]?]vU E?]vP?}vUWo]v?]oo D} r &??W r ??D t  ?W??WD ? ?X?? l ? ?X?? ?? 63  oo???]?oo}?]?o? ]??](?Z?v??]VZ}???U}vo?Wo?u}??Zo?}oo}??v}v r ?v]}?]?o???}v??}?]X 64  }???}?]??(}??]vPoU}v r ????]?X 65  ^?PP??}v?}v}(??X??X 66  E}(?????X??Z?P(}?^?v??]?X ^???u? W?o]??v?]? ???  }( ??? ^z^dZd dZ}vv???Kdo?}??}v?}??????u}(?v?(}?}ur u????vu  Z??????X[dZ??v?U?Z]Z?}???? dZZ]?Z?}u?v?Uv?Z}?????]?o?v?}v?Z ?]??}(??]vP?]?Z???v?Z?]o]o]??}(?]oo]vP?]?r ??U???v?o?????Z(}oo}?]vP?}???]v?Z?P]}vX~dZ? ???i??}Z vP?v??uXZ?}??ul?}v??v ]o?X do ?? X???????}??? E}X K?]P]v ^?}?? ??vr ?}v ?????? E??]?]v ,??}? v.o ?????? E??]?]v E?]vP?}v t??,?v ?????? ^}??Z]vPr ?}v ,??}? 67  d?]???]?Z]v?Zo}o?U  ?Z]Z}u??]???o]v~]vo?]vP???o]v vh^^ oo??vu?v]]?o]??]v?Z?P]}v]??o?}???}?}vr ????]?Z??]????}?]???}}??? ?Z}}o??G??XdZ? ???]?U?Z]Z???? r ???]]?U]vP?????}??o??]?Z ?Z?P]}v[???o]?????]?X/v?P??}vu}vP?Z???r ?]?u?}+??]Pv].v?}??}???v]??(}?]u??}????}u? ???]U ?? ?} }?]P]v? v ??v?} v?U v }?? ??]vP? ?Z?}?PZ}v}u]?}(?oX ^???u? W?]???Z]o? ???  }( ??? W?]???Z]o? d?v??}???}v]v?Z?P]}v?l??Z?]o??}????Z??}u}r ]oX? &]P?? ?? 68  ~?X ??? u}v?????U??}?v?(}??Z }???Zou]vP ui}?]??}( ??v??}???}v ?? ]v ?Z ? P]}vX  D}?? }( ?Z ?uU ?Z? ?Z]o? ? ??lV Z}??? ?Zv ?Z??]v??U?Z?Pu?P]v?Z?u}?}Lv?Zvv}?}vr ?]v?]vPo?]??vv}???vP??XD}????}v???}}o ?Zv?]??v?]??}?}?l]v?Z?P]}vU??}?Z??o??o? ?? ?Zv}uvX dZ??}?}??}v}(?}?l???Z}}uu???}?Z]?i}????}r u}]oZ?ZvP}???uX,}???U}u??]?}v}( &]P?? ??  ?]?Z???}(? ol]vPU]l]vPUv??v?]??]]vP~ &]P?? ??  v &]P?? ?? U?X  ???  v ??? }?v}???ov}???Z]vP??v ?}??}v????o?(}?u}(??v??}???}vX tZ]o  ?Z??}( ?]?]vP]v??]v????U]??u??}}v?Z????]v????X ^uoo]v???}???Z???????o?}?Z}?v(}??ol]vPU ]l]vPUv??v?]?~]v?}uu?v]]?o]??X K??ooU?Z??v (?}u?????}??????v]v??]v?]vPo}?? v??Z]o ????Z??v?}(?ol]vPU]l]vPUv??v?]?V(?}u?????} ????U?Z???vZ??????}?}u??v?X 68  >Pvv?u??? (??}?Z???????U????Uv????U?????o?X ?(?}u?ZhX^Xv??????U????v???Uv???????Uvu?]v }uu?v]??^???????? r ????X K??ooU???}(?]?]vPU??]oo?}(?]vPo r }??v??Z]o? ~?]?]vPo}vU?u]v???Z]PZXdZ?}}??}(?Z?}}??Z}?]vP (}? ??}}o?U ?Z]Z ?o?vP ? ? 9  ?}?? ?Z ?P]}v ? ?v ????v????  ~ &]P?? ?? 69 U?X ??? v?ol]vPU]l]vPUv ??v?]??uv](}o??o]lo?]vo?U?]????}?U?or ???v?]v???uv?]vo??v????}?]?]vPU??oo??Z ?o}?uv?}( v?? ????v ov???Z? }? v}?ov ]??o(?}??}}o?}???v?]?Uu]P??}v}(i}?}??}(?Z ?P]}vUv?Z??v?]}v}(o}?v??]v?ou?l??XdZ? ]?Uv}?}vo?Z???]v???u}??}????]v r U?o]?? r Uv ??v?]? r ?v(?]vo?}8v]v????]o??l?}???]}(Z]??}? ] }?v?}?v?U???Z?o?}???Z]?u?o}??(?}uo?P? P}P??Z]o?U}?Z?}?l?ZX[ &]P?? ??  ~?X ??? ]oo?u]v???Z??v??}?Z]Z?}?lvo]( Z?]??PXtZ]o?Zui}?]??}(?}?v[?v]?v?}v 69  ?(?}u?ZhX^Xv??????U????v???vu?]v}uu?v]?? ^???????? r ????X ^???u? W ?]???Z]o? ???  }( ??? o]? v  ?}?l?]?Z]v]??}?v?]?U?}? 70  ?Z?]??Z? ]v }vo??v }(?Z ? ??[? ??? ?}?v? v ]??X? &]P?? ??  ?Z}??U}vo??Z]???}(?Z???}?]v}?PZu?o}?uv??}??r ]?(??Z??]v?o}?(}?~]XXU?o??}v  i}???}?l? ?Z}o]??]v?}?vX/v}?Z??}??U(??}v}(?Z^??[???r ]v??o]??]?Z]v?Z}???]?}(?Z]??}?lV?v(??o]? ?]?Z]v?olX W??}( ?Z]?u??]?U??}?]v?}v(?}U?G??]v]?]?o?[ o](???oZ}]?X^}u??(?v}??}o]?o}??}?}?lX,}?r ??U???}(]?u????o?(?}u???o]???]o]?]?u??v 70  ? (?}u ?Z hX^X v??? ???U KvdZD? ??o]?}v v >, K?]P]v r ??v?}v u?o}?uv? ^????? ~P]vv]vP }( ? ????  u?o}?r uv?U?vY???? U  ???? X u?o}?uv?U?Zo}?u?l?UvZ}??]vPX&}???]}???r ?}v?U ]vo?] vP ?o??]}v?? ?}v]vPU ??v??}???}v ????u?U u}vP}?Z??}o]]?v???]]?UZ}??]vPv??]v???? }Lv?????P??]??v?X tZ????Z??Uu}??}(}vv???[?u?v]]?o]?? v oo ?Z}??}?v?v]???Z]v?]v &]P?? ?? v Z?r }u?}}u??????}?uoov?u?}(?P]}vou?o}?r uv?v???W?Z/ r ??}??]}???vE?,?vvD?r ?Z???? ~??]oo? ,??}?U &?u]vP?}vU v ?Z ????? &]P?? ?? XW?v?}(?}?l??}uu??vP???}u}]o 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% Berlin Bristol Burlington New Britain Plainville Plymouth Southington Drive alone 1990 Drive alone 2000 Drive alone 2013 Carpool 1990 Carpool 2000 Carpool 2013 ^???u? W?]???Z]o? ???  }( ??? v}??Z}( ,??}??}?o?/v??v?}vo]??}??U?Z}??}r ??v.vv]ov???}(?}??Z???&]?.o}?v??Uv?Z u?]?uUPuo]vPUv?Z?u??ov???}(?}??Z??r ?v}vv???X v??o}vv???]?v}???}v?}?Z]????vX &]P?? ?? ??  ?]??o]??Z}??vov?Z?]???]?X&?u]vP?} v????}??? ?X??i}?(}?Zuu?}(?Zo}?(}??Z}??]?]v ?}?vV]v}v????U?]??}oZ??X??Uv??o]vP?}vUu??X??X ??Z]v???}o?uv?]v]?U?]?Zv}v}(?Z?P]}v[?u?r v]]?o]????(}??o]v??}?]?i}???8]v?(?oo ??}u?o}? ]????]v??}?l(}?Xt]?Z??Z?P]}vo?Z}??Pv}??r oo????]]uov}(i}?UZ]PZ???}(}uu??vPUo?o? }(}vP??}vUv??v??}???}v??v????}???X ? &]P?? ??  ~?X ??? ?Z}??Uv}?Z?]v?Z?P]}v}?v}v ]v(}?? }(v??}?v[? u?o}? ??]v?? ?}?l ] v ?Z? ?u ?}?vX?]??}oZ??ZZ]PZ????u??v?}vU?]?Z??X?9}( ]??u?o}???]v???}?l]vP]v?}?vX??o]vP?}v~??}?o ???UP]?v]?????v?o}?uv????vZ??Z o}???U ?]?Z ?X?9X E? ?]?]v ??]o? ?]??}o ?  ????v? o u?P]vU???X?9XdZ]?]??????]?]vPUP]?v?Z]??[?v?U?olr o ??v (}?uV }?Z? ]?? ]v ?Z ??? ?Z]]? u?lo? Z]PZ????X~dZo}??}(u?Z}(E??]?]v[?}v}u]? v]????}?]u]??v?oov?Z]PZ??}vv?}v??}u?o}?r uv ?v???u???o]v?Z]?XK??ooU?Z???v?P???r ??v?o]v(?}u?o]???]}?X&?}u?????}????U?Z ?P]}vo}??i}?(}???]v??(????Zv]?P]v??]v??X &]Pr &]P?? ?? X:}?]v?}?v? ???]v??}?l? 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 &]P?? ?? XZvP]v??v?}(?}?l??}uu??vP? ??}}oU???? r ???? -60% -50% -40% -30% -20% -10% 0% ^???u? W?]???Z]o? ???  }( ??? ?? ??  ~?X ??? Z????Z??v?ZvP]v?Z(??}v}(ur ?o}???]v???Z}?}?l]vZu?v]]?o]??X&]P????vP  (?}u?X?9]v??o]vP?}v~?Z}vo?]v???} r ??X?9]v?o]v ~?ZP??????X/v}?Z??}??UP?}?]vPv?u???U ]?Z??v}?Z}]UZ?]vP?}P}}???]?Z?P]}v(}? ?}?lX tZ]o?Z]?????}vvo]??]v]?]?oZ}??Z}o??}u v.??U ??Z ? ?? ?} Z]PZ? r ?vl ?Z}}o?U ?Z ??? 71  Kvo?G}??}(?o????}Z?v?}uu??????]?X  ?(?}u?Z hX^Xv??????Uv???????X u}?v?}(???o]?v??]???v}????v?Z??v??}??r ?}v????uv]v????]Pv].v?}???(}??Z}v}u?U?}]r ??Uv?Zv?]?}vuv?X &]P?? ?? 71  ~?X ??? }vv???Z}????v?}?l??[}?]P]v? v??v?}v?X??Z.P??ul?o?U ‘???,??}?U ]vo?]vPv??o}vv???U]?}v}(?Z}uu?? r Z?]?? ????}(?Z???XKvo??Z/ r ??lE?,?v>]v}??]}?r ??v?ZE?z}?l???o]vv?Z,?v??]?o?]?(}?}ur u???}o?uX~>]v?Z]lv????u}o]???Zv?u?}( ?}?o ???o]vP ??v v? ??} u?v]]?o]??X dZ .P?? o?} &]P?? ?? XW?v? P}(?}?l]vP??]v???Z}?}?l]v?Z ?u?}?v &]P?? ?? XZvP]v??v?P}(?}?l]vP??]v???Z} ?}?l]v?Z?u?}?vU???? r ???? 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% -30% -25% -20% -15% -10% -5% 0% 5% 10% ^???u? W?]???Z]o? ???  }( ??? ?Z}???ZP?}(]v??}vv?}v]v’???,??}?v ?Z]??o??]?}vv?}v?}?ZE?z}?lu??}?}o]?v?W ?Z]o ,??}? v ]?? ????}?v]vP }uu?v]?? ? ? ?}r P?Z? ??Z]lo]v?U}vo??]???}v???v(?}uv????}(]??} E?,?vvt?????X &]P?? ?? ??  ~?X ??? vo?P??ZG}???}?Z}??]o??Z?r P]}voo?oXdZu?]v]???Z??Z}uu?v]??}(v??o }vv ??????}Z}?Z???oo?????}?v]vPu?r v]]?o]???}uu??G}??X~P]vUo]v?]?Z]???}?}??}vo ?}G}??}o?uU?]?Z?Z?Z]vv??o]v????v?vPG}?}( ??} r Z?v????}v?XdZZ?]??}uu??G}??]v?Z?r P]}v }?]v? ?}? ?Z??? r v}??Z??X dZ]? ]? }?v?? (}? ?Z Z??o?o?}(??8v}vP??}v}v?ZZ]PZ????Z??o? ?Z]?}??]}?Uv}?o?Z}????v??U/v???????Uv??ooo ???]o?X o?Z}?PZ?ZZ?]??G}??}?]v?v}??Z??Uv}????}? }uu???  ]v ?Z? ]??}vX Dv? ?}?o o?} ?}?l ?} ?Z ?}??ZXdZu}???}??o??}?l?o??v?}v?~]XXU?Z}?r v}???Z]lo]v??t?????UD?]vUvD]o?}?vU ??oo? v ?}?o]PZ?o?o?????v? v Z?Z]?vtoo]vPr (}?X’]?v?Z?]?}( ?Z?}uu?v]??U?Z]???}?]u]???}?Z ?P]}vUv?ZZ]PZ??]v(????????o]vl]vP?Zu?]?Z?Z?r P]}vU?Z????v???}???X &]P?? ??  ~?X ??? o?} ??o??]?o}uu??G}????vv]vP(?}u?}?v?]v?Z?r P]}v(??Z??}??Z?Zv?Z]?.?????}(??v?}v?XdZ?Z]lr ??}(?Z???v? ?}E?,?vU??G}???},uvvE}??Z ,?vU??oo??]P?}??Uv???UE}??olU^?u(}?Uv t???}???o?}?]?]oX ^???u? W?]???Z]o? ???  }( ??? D}??}(?Z?]??v?}?v?U?}P?Z??]?Z,??}?UZ? }uu}?]u?}??v??}uu????v?}v?(}??Z?r P]}v]v?v????X do ?? 72  ?Z }???Z??Z?uv?}(?Z? ??Z?????}?l??(?}u?Z?P]}vX^}u}(?Z? u?v??}?Z?}?l(}?U??P]?v?Zu?o}?uv?o}??? ?]v?]v?Z?o~oo}(?Z?P]}v?[u?v]]?o]??U???r o]vP?}v?Zi}?U]?]?u}?o]lo??Z ??Z?P]}v[??}?l?? ?  Z?]vP?}P}(??Z??}.v?}?l XdZ(]o??}(?Z?P]}v?} ??}?i}?(}?]???]??vPo}?(}?Uo?o}v(}?v??}?lr ??UZ???]}??]u?o]?}v?(}?^??[?o?? r ??v??v?r ?}???}v????uU??oo?(}??} ]??v?Zv?]?}vuv?U ??]oo?P]?v?Z??]???oo?oo?Z???ou???U?vr ??]??UZ??lv?Z(}?u}(??}u}]o?X~tol]vPv]lr ]vP?v}?(?]o}????ZP??]??v?VvU? /v?P?r ?}v?]?ZE?z}?l  v W?o]??v?]? U  ?X ??  v ??? U???r ??o? U]???? U??v?]?}vv?}v??}?Z?o}?}v??olr ]vPX 72  Kvo?G}??}(?o????}Z?v??}?l????Z}?vX?(?}u?Z hX^X v??? ???U KvdZD? ??o]?}v v >, K?]P]v r ??v?}v ur ?o}?uv?^?????~P]vv]vP}( ? ????  u?o}?uv?U?vY???? U  ???? X &]P?? ?? X}uu??G}???]?Z]v}vv??? ^???u? W?]???Z]o? ???  }( ??? &]P?? ?? X:}?]v?}?v????]v??}?l?~????] ^???u? W?]???Z]o? ???  }( ??? &]P?? ?? X}uu??G}???}l(?}u?Z?P]}v ^???u? W?]???Z]o? ???  }( ??? do ?? X d}?}uu????v?}v?(}??}?l??(?}u?Z ?P]}v D?v]]?o]?? t}?l?? (?}u?P]}v ZvPU ???? r ???? 9  }(oo?}?l?? (?}u?P]}v 9  ZvPU ???? r ???? ?]??}o ????? r ???? ??X?9 r ?X?9 E??]?]v ????? r ??? ?X?9 r ?X?9 ,??}? ????? ???? ?X?9 ??X?9 &?u]vP?}v ???? ?? ?X?9 ?X?9 ^}??Z]vP?}v ???? r ??? ?X?9 r ??X?9 Wo]v?]oo ???? r ??? ?X?9 r ??X?9 ?o]v ???? r ??? ?X?9 r ??X?9 E?]vP?}v ???? ??? ?X?9 ?X?9 t??,??r (}? ???? ??? ?X?9 ?X?9 t????? ???? ??? ?X?9 ??X?9 D]o?}?v ???? ?? ?X?9 ?X?9 D?]v ???? r ? ?X?9 r ?X?9 ??,??}? ???? r ?? ?X?9 r ?X?9 Z?Z]? ???? ??? ?X?9 ??X?9 too]vP(}? ???? ??? ?X?9 ??X?9 Z}l?,]oo ???? r ??? ?X?9 r ?X?9 o}}u.o ???? r ?? ?X?9 r ?X?9 t]v?}? ???? ?? ?X?9 ?X?9 E?,?v ???? ??? ?X?9 ??X?9 DvZ??? ???? ??? ?X?9 ?X?9 D?v]]?o]?? t}?l?? (?}u?P]}v ZvPU ???? r ???? 9  }(oo?}?l?? (?}u?P]}v 9  ZvPU ???? r ???? ?}v ???? r ?? ?X?9 r ?X?9 ^]u???? ???? r ?? ?X?9 r ?X?9 Wo?u}??Z ???? r ??? ?X?9 r ?X?9 ‘o??}v??? ??? ??? ?X?9 ??X?9 ?}u?oo ??? ?? ?X?9 ?X?9 d}??]vP?}v ??? r ??? ?X?9 r ??X?9 t?Z??.o ??? r ? ?X?9 r ?X?9 E}??Z,?v ??? ??? ?X?9 ??X?9 ^?u(}? ??? ?? ?X?9 ?X?9 ,uv ??? ??? ?X?9 ??X?9 ^}??Zt]vr ?}? ??? ?? ?X?9 ??X?9 v??? ??? r ? ?X?9 r ?X?9 t???}?v ??? r ?? ?X?9 r ?X?9 ??o]vP?}v ??? ?? ?X?9 ??X?9 D]o(}? ??? ?? ?X?9 ?X?9 E}??ol ??? ??? ?X?9 ??X?9 ?]P?}?? ??? ?? ?X?9 ?X?9 dZ}u??}v ??? ?? ?X?9 ?X?9 v?}v ??? ??? ?X?9 ??X?9 DvZ?v U Ez ??? ??? ?X?9 ??X?9 E?P??l ??? ? ?X?9 ?X?9 ^Zo?}v ??? ?? ?X?9 ?X?9 ^???u? W ?]???Z]o? ???  }( ??? D?v]]?o]?? t}?l?? (?}u?P]}v ZvPU ???? r ???? 9  }(oo?}?l?? (?}u?P]}v 9  ZvPU ???? r ???? v.o ??? r ?? ?X?9 r ?X?9 ^???}? ??? ?? ?X?9 ??X?9 t}o}? ??? ?? ?X?9 ??X?9 t???}?? ??? ??? ?X?9 ???X?9 s?v}v ??? ??? ?X?9 ??X?9 E}??]Z ??? ?? ?X?9 ??X?9 t]v?}? >}l? ??? r ?? ?X?9 r ??X?9 d??u?oo ??? ?? ?X?9 ??X?9 K?vP ??? ?? ?X?9 ??X?9 ^}??Z??? ??? r ?? ?X?9 r ??X?9 &]?.o ??? ?? ?X?9 ??X?9 ?v(}? ??? r ?? ?X?9 r ?X?9 ZK^ dZ????v??}?l]v?Z?P]}v]????}?]u?o??U???u]o?]v ovP?Zv}u??]??????Z]vP(?}u]???}??}o]u]? r r ??????????XDv??}?]v?Z?P]}v(oo?v??Z(r ?o]????u~???}?]u?o???X?9?u]oPX 73  do ??  ~?X ??? o]????Z?}?ou]oP}(?}?]v?Z????u??}?vU(?vr ?}voo??].?}vUv???ol??v??o]?X 73  d}?ou]oP(}?oo?}?v(?v? }voo? r o??].?}?u?o?r o?]+?v?o?X ??Z.P??? o}?  ]u?o?Uu]oP]?v}?oo}??vo?}v ???]??]??Z?}?PZ}???Z?P]}vXdZ]?]??}???U P]?v ?Z ]+?v? ]v o?o? }( ?o}?uv? u}vP  ?Z ?}?v?U ?Z]Z ?vP (?}u  v?U ??v v?]?}vuv? ~E? ?]?]v?}????o? r ?}??o????v}v~??o]vP?}vX &]Pr ?? ??  ~?X ??? ?Z}???Z??v??}?Z]Z?Zv?u?}(o]v? ?}(????]?~}?Z?}?ov}v? Z(?o????uU]XX (?v?}voo? r o??]. ?Puv?? ??]? ??v ?Z ?P]}v[? u?v]]?o]??X  74  ]????Z?E??]?]vv?]??}oU??]??? }(?Z]?v?]??U.?u}??}?o]v?}???v]?}(??vU? ?Z.P????Z}?U???v]?}(?}Xd Z]???o]v??Zo}???}? P??Z]v &]P?? ?? X/v?Zu?o??U??Zo}?v?u???v}? ?Z]vPV]vU?Z?]vP?Z?u??}???u}vPu}? ? }?o]??}o?}vP?}?v?}(.?o8]v?v?u?? P?}??ZX,}???Uu}?]v?v???o]??}vu?o?}??i?]vr (?????????}P?????????v??]?}??(???X W}??o?}vU?}P?Z??]?Z?Z]+?v?]vo]P]ou]oP? ?}?vUu?  ]v?????o]v?Z????v?o]v?? r u?v]]?o??]r ?}v]v(?o]?]???Z?P]}v[?]??v?}?v?}?? ?uX~^ &?o(?v]vP U?X  ?? U(}??]o?X 74  dZ?.P????G??Puv?ovP?Z}vo?Vv}?ov r u]o?}?}?Z?u?o?]r uv?]}vou????}(?}???]??X ^???u? W?]???Z]o? ???  }( ??? dZ&&/EKE’^d/ KE o?Z}?PZ??8iu?}l???Z?P]}v[?o]u]? r ???r ???????(?}u?u?}?uU}vP??}v]?v}?????]vP  ??}r ou(}??ZuX~dZv???Z}l?}]v??]v?Z^??[??????r ??????uv??}v]?? ?}v  ?Z?P]}v[?}?v?]?U XPX/ r ???Z?}?PZt?????vZ?Z]???oo???v t?? ,??}? v ??,??}?U / r ?? ??vt]v?}? v t?Z??.oUvZ}???]vD]o?}?vX &]P?? ??  v &]P?? ??  ~?X ???  v ??? U?????o?U?????o??Z}???8}vr ]?}v?(}??Z?P]}v??]vPD}v?u}?v]vPv&?]??vr ]vP???ZZ}???X??Zu???Z}?U?] ?Z?Z???}v}(?Z ????v ??u]v?? }( ?Z ??????? ??}v }( Z}?? ?? ]v Wo]v?]ooU ?Z]Z (?v?}v? ?  ?u?U ??? ? ? o?? ?? u]o???Z}???Z?}?PZ}???Z?P]}v[????????????uX tZv?Z??v?}(????]??}v?}??voo????}???U v}?i???o]u]? r ??????????U?Z?]???ZvP?u?lr o?X^}u?}???]}?vV?Z]o}?Z???}LvZ}l ?]?Z??8X &]P?? ??  ~?X ??? ]oo???????Z]??]?Z?}o?u r ?} r ?]????}?X~dZ?}v???Z??P ]o???8}v?} ???v?P}(?Z?]Pv?]??}(?Z?}V?ZZ]PZ? ?Z??}U?Zu}?Z?]o???8lv?}?v?oo?}vP?? 75  ???u??U?Z?.P????Z}?ov}????}i???(?}v?????}v??}r i??W?}o?u r ?} r ?]????}?}v}?v???]o??o??}o?o?}(}vP?r ?}v???]vX^}u?}????Z??Z]]?Z]PZ??}?u?}+?????]}? ?]?]vP???]v?Zv}v ??Z}???}v??o}??X ?Z?}]?X? &]P?? ??  ~?X ??? ?Z}??U?Z]o?}o?u r ?} r r ?]????}????o]vu?Z}(?Z?P]}vU??????}or ?uo??v?}????????] ??}v???o}(?Z?r P]}v[?l???v??}???}v}??]}??X }?]vP?}Kd??}i?}v?U?Z?]????]oo??]}??? ????XDi}??Z}?}?PZ(??]v?Z?P]}v?]oo?Z?]?oo?r o?U?]?Z?}o?u?}?}??]??XdZ???o??]oo o]lo? &]P?? ?? XZ}(??? ?]???}?v 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 On federal system Not on federal system ^???u? W?]???Z]o? ???  }( ??? ????]vP}vP??}v??lZ}???U](v}???]vP?Zv???X ??]vPv?o?P r ?o?]????v?]}vU]u?ouv??}v}( ??v??}???}vuvuvPuv?????P]?~dD}????]? ov r ??}v??}o?U}???}?]?]}v}(o??v????}?]?]vP U]?]??r ???Z?}??????u}(?Z?P]}v?]ooZ?]???X[dZ]?]? v]?Z??v]??v}??????]?]vPW??8]??Z??]?o???o?}( ?Z ?v????]vo ??} r v??] ???v? }( ?o}?uv? ?Z? ?Z?P]}vvU]vUu}??}(?Zv?}vZ?????? }???Z o?????o?X’]?v?Z]v(?]]o]??}(?]????vr ?]}v]v?P]}v??o}??v??o}vv???U](dDv ??v??}???}v}??}v??v}??}oo}??U]?]?v?]???Z? v ???u]vP?Z?Kd[?}?v??v??}i?}v??? ?? ?? v ?}??v]vP ??8 ?]oo ??]}??o? ]u?]? ?Z ??o]?? r }( r o]( v }v}u]?oo]vP}(?Z?P]}vX??Z??]vPu??ul o?U??}?}v}?}vo?? ????}??v?Puv?V?Z?o?} ZvP}???uX?????UZ}???U oo  ????}???]v?Z?r P]}v????U??U??U???U???Uv????]oov?U?U}?}? ?]??XdZ]?]vo??u?Z}(?Z?P]}v[????????u]oP do ?? X&?v?}voo??].?}v}(?}? d}?v &?v?}voo?? Z??o  u]X h?v  u]X d}?ou]X ?o]v K?Z?&???}???????? ?X?? ?X?? K?Z?W?]v]?o???]o ??X?? ??X?? D]v}????]o ?X?? ??X?? ??X?? }oo?}? ??X?? ??X?? Di}? }oo?}? ?X?? ?X?? D]v}?}oo?}? ?X?? ?X?? ?o]vd}?o ?X?? ??X?? ??X?? ?]??}o K?Z?W?]v]?o???]o ??X?? ??X?? D]v}????]o ??X?? ??X?? }oo?}? ??X?? ??X?? ?]??}od}?o ??X?? ??X?? ^???u? W?]???Z]o? ???  }( ??? d}?v &?v?}voo?? Z??o  u]X h?v  u]X d}?ou]X ??o]vP?}v K?Z?W?]v]?o ???]o ?X?? ?X?? D]v}????]o ?X?? ?X?? ?X?? }oo?}? ?X?? ?X?? Di}?}oo?}? ?X?? ?X?? D]v}?}oo?}? ?X?? ?X?? hvo??].~>}oh?P ?X?? ?X?? ??o]vP?}vd}?o ?X?? ??X?? ??X?? E??]?]v /v????? ?X?? ?X?? K?Z?&???}???????? ?X?? ?X?? K?Z?W?]v]?o???]o ?X?? ?X?? D]v}????]o ??X?? ??X?? }oo?}? ??X?? ??X?? Di}?}oo?}? ?X?? ?X?? E??]?]vd}?o ??X?? ??X?? Wo]v?]oo /v????? ?X?? ?X?? K?Z? &???}???????? ?X?? ?X?? K?Z?W?]v]?o???]o ?X?? ?X?? D]v}????]o ??X?? ??X?? }oo?}? ?X?? ?X?? hvo??].~>}oh?P ?X?? ?X?? ^???u? W?]???Z]o? ???  }( ??? d}?v &?v?}voo?? Z??o  u]X h?v  u]X d}?ou]X Wo]v?]ood}?o ??X?? ??X?? Wo?u}??Z K?Z?W?]v]?o???]o ?X?? ?X?? D]v}????]o ?X?? ?X?? }oo?}? ??X?? ??X?? Di}?}oo?}? ?X?? ?X?? Wo?u}??Zd}?o ?X?? ??X?? ??X?? ^}??Z]vP?}v /v????? ?X?? ?X?? K?Z?&???}???????? ?X?? ?X?? K?Z?W?]v]?o???]o ?X?? ?X?? D]v}????]o ??X?? ??X?? }oo?}? ??X?? ??X?? D]v}?}oo?}? ?X?? ?X?? ^}??Z]vP?}vd}?o ?X?? ??X?? ??X?? ‘?vd}?o ??X?? ???X?? ???X?? ^???u? W?]???Z]o? ???  }( ??? &]P?? ?? X?????????8UD}v?U?W??D ^???u? W?]???Z] o? ???  }( ??? &]P?? ?? X ?????????8U&?]?U?W??WD ^???u? W?]???Z]o? ???  }( ??? &]P?? ?? Xs}o?u?}?]????}?U???? ^???u? W?]???Z]o? ???  }( ??? &]P?? ?? Xs}o?u?}?]????}?U????~??}i? ^???u? W?]???Z]o? ???  }( ??? WZ</E' E}]v?v?}??}(??l]vP????o?vuvZ ?v?v?r ?lv]v?Z?P]}vU?}}vo??]}v??]8?o??}?ZX? ??}vv}?o?]vU]??????Z?U?]?Z(????}v?U ?Z?]?v}??l]vP?Z}??P]v?Z?P]}vX/(v??Z]vPU]vuv? ??U??l]vP(]o]??u?Z?v}???]o?X  K????}?]?]}v }(v???}??]?}Lv}?v????}???U??]?oUu]v?r vvUv}??}???v]??}????]v?}o?Xv??.]o???(]? }(??l]vPU?Z]Zu?v]]?o}?]vv?}Lv(}??o}??? ?}?]oU}LvZ?vP??}v???v?U??]v P?Z}?? }(????Z]o]v??]vP}?Z?}???XdZ]????o??]v??.]oo? r o??o?o?}(?]?]vPU?]?Z]???vv?]oo?~??8}vP?r ?}vU]?U???Uvv}]??}oo??}vV??8}vP??}vV??ZuU ?????U}?]??Uv?]}???o?]? ?Vo}??}(}?v?? ??oo?}uu?v]???Z???v(?]vo??}????]v?v ?o]???X d?}??l]vP???]?Z?v}v??]vv??o}vv?r ??]v?Z???(????XdZ.???????Zv??o}vv?r ??^??hv]???]??]vE??]?]vX dZ??????Z}??Z?? o????9}(?Z??l]vP???Uv}Lv}????9U???]or o?v?P]?v?uXdZ?}?PZ}??u}??}(?Z?U?o?? ?U?????}???u???XdZ?}v??????]v?ZWov???]oo ??}v}(^}??Z]vP?}vXdZ?????Z?]u] o????o??U?Z}?]vP ?Z? ??l]vP??o]??}v???(}??????]v}????9X /v?}u??]v]?]?o?????]vZ]PZ????~???} ??9X WZKd^ dZ}?PZ(???l]vP?v??}?]??Z?]?]vP??U??lv ?]o}??vo}??  ?Z]ou]o????oXKdu]v?]v????o ??lv?]o}??]vv?}?v?Z?P]}vXdZ?o}??oo}? }uu?????}u?(}???}}o?v?}}?o}ov????? ???XdZ?o?}???]u?}??v?}+ r ?l???}u??U?}}U??Z ? ???}v? ?v??}??] vP (}? ?Z? ]v????? ?Puv?? }v u] r  ?}o}vP r ]??v??]??X do ??  o]????Z??lv?]o}??}(?ZP??????}o??? ?} }uu?????}v(?}uv??o}vv???V}?????o]r ??}v]?o?}P]?vX??Z?o??o?U??lv?]o}???]?Z ?ZZ]PZ????o]??}v?o}??????????u??~Z]G? / r ??U??o?}Z}???X^??o}(?Z?o}????Z]??r ] ??}v(???v??]?Uv?]vP}uu?????Z]o]???}??l v?Z?(}??]U]?Z????}}o}???v?]?XtZ??}??]oU ?Z]?WovZ}o??Z???v?]}v}(o}????]??vl}??Z?r ?}v}(v?o}???}????Z?uv~XPX??}?}?v?Z  Z]PZ???v?]?}???}?Z}?o}v?]?X ^???u? W?]???Z]o? ???  }( ??? do ?? XW?lv?]o}??}(???}?Z?P]}v D?v]]?o]?? >}?}v ??]??? 76 ?]?? }?v? 77 ? ? ? ? ??P ??o]??}v 78 ?o]v }? W ?? ? ?? ?? ? ??9 ?]??}o Z}?????~D]o^?X?>l?X W> ?? hl hl hl hl v 79 ?]??}o d}^?X hl 80 ?? ?? ??? hl v Z?Z]? / r ???Z}????~?]??? W>d ??? ?? ?? ?? ?? ??9 Z?Z]? Z}????U,u]Xv}??Z}(/ r ???~?]?? W>d ??? ?? ?? ?? ?? ??9 &?u]vP?}v / r ??U&]vuvvZX~?]??? W>d ?? ?? ?? ?? v ??9 &?u]vP?}v Z}???/ r ????~?]??? d ?? ?? ? ?? ?? ??9 &?u]vP?}v Z}????^?XD????Z??Z W> ?? ?? ?? ?? ? ??9 &?u]vP?}v Z}????d}?v&?uZX >^ ?? ?? ?? ?? ?? ??9 E??]?]v Z}?????}??Z  }(t??&?u?Doo W>^ ??? ?? ?? ?? v ??9 Wo]v?]oo ‘?>??Z?vZ??Z E}? ? ? ? ? v ^}??Z]vP?}v / r ???Z}????~?]??? W>d ??? ?? ?? ?? ?? ??9 76  WW??V>Wo]?VdW?o?Z}vV^W?Zo??VW??????????]VWo}o?????]VZW?]o???]VZZ^W?]o?}??? ]X 77  ^]vPo r ?u?}]v??Z]o}?v??(?}u?Z(}oo}?]vP?}???W?U]?[??U]vPD??V?U?] oU]vPD??V?U^?oo]?U’}}PoD??V?U^???s]?U’}}Po D??X 78  ?}???(?}u}?v??? r ?X 79  dZ]?o}????o}?U?}??u?Z?v??.]oo?????X 80  hv?}v?????}vX ^???u? W?]???Z]o? ???  }( ??? ^}??Z]vP?}v Z}??????t?????d??v?]l W> ??? ?? ?? ?? ?? ??9 dZ}u??}v Z}????Z}???~?]??? W>d ?? ?? ?? ?? ?? ??9 ^&dzE^ddh^ /Ed^ Kd??o??]v??}v^??Z]PZ???X]v????? o?o?}v???Z]o r u]o?]?v}u???}?]?o ]v???(}?P]?vo}?}vX 81  ^Z}?o?Z??o]v? ????Z?]?o]v???Uv?o??. Lv]r v??Z?}???U?P]?vo}?}vU?ZZ]PZ??}(]r v??]?u?}?????oo??]Pv].v?~]XXU??}o?v}? G?lUv?Zo}?}v]??}Kd[?^?PP??>]??}( ^???]oov^]??~^>K^^X &]P?? ??  ~?X ??? ?o}??oo?}?Pr uv??v]v????}v?]v?Z^??Z]PZ??????u?Z??}v ?Z^>K^^X>]v?v?}]v?????}?}??}vo?}?Z??}}(?Z ??o?}?Z?]?o]v???U?}?Z ?Z]l??Zo]v}? ?}]v?U?Zu}????}?]v???Z??]?X ??Zu??Z}??U  82  ?]???]?Zv}?uoo?Z]PZ]v???? (oo]v?}?Z?????U]v}??}(?v]vP???ovW ?X }uu?]o ???]??X >v r ?? ]?]}v? ? u?v]]?o]?? Z?o?}u? ?]??o}?uv?}vui}??Z}?}?PZ(??X 81  dZo??]?}u?????Z?? r v?u???o]??}v??}ou ?Z}X 82  ?(?}uKd[?d?8]v?^???]oovZ?}??U???? r ????U(}??Zv??o}vv???ZP]}vX dZ]??o}?uv?Z???}u]vv?o??lv?Z(}?u}(???]? ??]oXtZ]o??Z?o}?uv?v????}??u?v]]?o]??[? P?vo]??U]?o?}]u?]???Z??o]??}(?Z^??[?v?u? ?}??????v??}???}vv??} ?lX^??]???]ov}?}vo?Pvr ???o?Pu}?}??Z]o??8?}o?u?X/?o?}?v??} ??}???}o](??}vv?u?}?????v]vPu}?uv??v ov?U?????U?]Pvo?Uv??}??]vPU?Z]Z]u??Z ?(v8]v?G}?}(?Z]?o??Z?}?PZ r ??8 vv}v r u}?}?]???v??}???}v??Z??ol]vPv]l]vPXZ]PZ ]v]v}(]v??]?}v???vX?u?o?}(vr P?}?????]??]v?Z?P]}v]vo?Z}?????]vE??]?]v ??v}?]v?v?vZ????]v?v?UZ}???]v ?]??}oUZ}?????  ]vWo]v?]ooUvZ}?????v???]v ^}??Z]vP?}vX ?X Zu??U]v??ZvP?Uvv?]?}v?X??}Z]PZ??8?}or ?u?U(???v????v]vPu}?uv??Uvo?P]???]??]v ??U???????????u??U]v??ZvP?Uv?Z?}? ?Z?(]v?}U??]oo? ?Zv?Z??}uu?]o???]?? vu?o?ovZ]PZ???Uo?}?v?}?Z?]?}(v}?r uoo?Z]PZ]v????XdZ?u????vZ}????v ^???u? W?]???Z]o? ???  }( ??? ?? ?}??Z }( t???u? Doo ]v E? ?]?]vU ?Z Z}?? ??l????u??v???????????u]v??]vWo]v?]ooU? Z / r ??l??  ]v??ZvP ]v Wo]v?]ooU ?Z / r ??l??? ?u?? ]v ^}??Z]vP?}vUv?ZZ}????l???]v??ZvP]v?o]v?r u?o](??Z]?X ?X Z??o v o}?? r ??8 ?}? ?]?Z ?]Pv ??}ou?X o?r Z}?PZ]v(???v?U??]v?}?]v?Z?P]}v??+?(?}u ?]Pv]??? ??Z?U?Z]o?Z?}v}??v??Z?}?v?( ???Uu?]?}v??}?]v??]????}}????Z]??r Z]o?]vv?v?(uvv?XdZ?]vo??Z????r ?}v?}(Z}?????v?]v??o]vP?}vU??oo?Z}??? ???}Z]vP?ZWo?u}??Z?}?vo ]vUv???o]v???r ?}v?]v?Z?P]}v~XPX?ZZ}????v???]v??o]vP?}vU Z}?????vE}??Z????]?]vWo]v?]ooUZ}????v ?? Z} ]v ?]??}oU Z}??? ??? v t}}ov ^??? ]v ?]??}oUZ}?????v??^???]vE??]?]vUv ?Z Z}??????]? r ??]v????}v]v?o]vX hv(}???v?o?U}u??o]v??(}?o}o?}?]?v}? ?]ooX?}v???vU?Z]o?Z^>K^^u????} i???(??(??]u??}?uv??U]??Z}?ov}??????Z?}o?]r ??]}vX~d}??}?] ???]?(}???}i??o??}vv?r o?}vU?Z]?Wov??}?}???} /u??}??}oo?}v U?X ??  ^???u? W?]???Z]o? ???  }( ??? &]P?? ?? X^]???]?Zv}?uoo?Z]PZ]v???? ^???u? W?]???Z] o? ???  }( ??? WsDEdKE/d/KE dZ?P]}v[???v??}???}vv??}?lu???uo]??o?}?? ????uU???vo]l???]?v?]v?U]? }?v}?Zo]??o(X/(]? ]??}}v?v?(?v?}v]vP]v?(U8]v?uvv?U]?u??? u]v?]vXZ}?ul???Zo?P?????}(?Z??v??}??r ?}v v??}?l vU ? ??ZU ???]? ?Z u}?? ?v?}v ~v (?v]vP]v}???}u]v?]v?Zu]v ??o}v]?}vX Z}u]v?vv?Z?o????u]v?}v??r uv?}v]?}vXdZ??}??]u??u??]?Kd????}???? ??uv? }v]?}v ? ?Z W?uv? }v]?}v /v? ~W/ v/v??v?}voZ}?PZv??/v?~/Z/X 83  Kdu????v ?}??  ??uv??(}????u]o?}(?}?Puv??]v?Z ?P]}vX do ??  P]???]PZ???P?}(?Z??uv?}vr ]?}vu??]?}(?Z?}?Puv??]v  Z?}?vv?Z?P]}v ??Z}oXdZ.P???]v]??Z??Z?}?]v?Z?P]}v? Pv?oo?(]??}P}}Uo?Z}?PZ?Z?]???]?}vu}vP?Z ?}?v?X??o]vP?}v?}??]v?Z??}v]?}vU?Z]o?]??}o ?}??vl?Z?}}???X~dZ?? ??]?(?}u}vo? ?u?o }( ?} ?Puv?? v ?Z}?o  ]v????? }?r ]vPo?XE}?}?Puv??Z?W/o}???Zv?U?????Pr uv?????}???}Z?v/Z/Z]PZ??Zv???U?Z]Zul? 83  dZW/]?v?u?]o]v???v?v??Z?u?????Z???????o }???}vo}v]?}v}(?Z??uv?X/?]??????ou???v ?r ??]??uv?o?????}(?Z??uv?XdZ?o?}v?Z]???vW/v ?Z}??oo??vP}(?Z??uv?]??Z}?v]v?Z?oo}?X ?ZuZ?v??oX[dZ?oo?}P]???Z??P ??uv? ??U ?Z]Z ????v?? ?Z uv ? }( o?? ??]vP (}? oo u????Puv??]vZ?}?vXKv??P?Z??uv?}v ?Z?}???]v?Z?P]}v]?}???v???}oX do ?? XD?????uv?}v]?}v??}?v D?v]]? o]?? ??P W/ ??PX /Z/  ~]vXlu]X ?PX W?uv? z? ?o]v ?X?? ???X?? ????X? ?]??}o ?X?? ???X?? ????X? ??o]vP?}v ?X?? ???X?? ????X? E? ?]?]v ?X?? ???X?? ???? X? Wo]v?]oo ?X?? ???X?? ???? X? Wo?u}??Z ?X?? ???X?? ????X? ^}??Z]vP?}v ?X?? ???X?? ????X? ZP]}v ?X?? ???X?? ????X? Z/’^ ?]P??v]v?P?o???}(v???v??}???}v????uU}?Z ?} ?}?? ov (???? v ?} ??}?] P? ????}v }?? dZ/Z/]????}.vZ???]??}(?Zo}vP]??]vo??}.o}(???r o ?Zo??l v }v??????  ?? v?]? ?}?PZv?? u???uv?X dZ]v?]?u???]v]vZ???u]oXdZ&,to??v/Z/??r o](]?]?o???Zv???vP}}](]?]??v???X ^???u? W?]???Z]o? ???  }( ??? }?Z???v??}???}v]v(????????XdZ??????]P??}?o ]v ?Z ?P]}vX E]v?? r ??v }( ?Z? Z?  ??v }( ? o?? ??v??(?U?Z]Z]??Zu]v]u?uv????]v}???}??o](? (}?(?o(?v]vPX,]PZu??]ovo}?]v????ul?]P?  }??o??}?]ov??]?VZ}???U?Z?]?l?P]vP?]P??}? o?}uv??Z????]??(??u}v]?}?]vPvU?Zvoo(}?U ?Z]o]??}v }? ??ouv?X Kd ]v???? v ]???? ??8r ]v???vP?(}?oo?]P?]v?Z?P]}vX do ??  ~?X ??? P]?? v }???]? }( ?Z ?P]}v[? ?]P ??}l ? u?v]]?o]??X ~ ?]P? U?X ??? Uo]???oo?]P?]v?Z?P]}v}(?o????v?? (?X t]?Z ]v?Z?P]}v??Z?Z]??}?]?]P?W ?X E??]?]vW???? v }v???Z?]P}v^?vo?Y??r ??W?lZ}X ?X E??]?]vW???? v }v???Z?]P}v^?vo?W?l Z}^_X ?X Wo?u}??ZW???? v }v???Z?]P}vd?vvoZ}U oov^???v^}??Z D]v^???X 84 dZ ??]u?? ??}v? ?]P? ??]}?? ? ??Z?U o}?U ?}o?u}(??8Uv]]vP}???}v?X??]P??]}r ???U]??}v]?}v??vP?P??oo?o]v?}?}}?XW??v?? u]v?vvv??v?Z??(?oo](}(???????  ????vr ?oo?X,}???Uui}??Z]o]??}v}???ouv??]oo?o?r u?o?  ???]?X tZv  ??????? ?]??  ?}}? ??8r ]v???vPU?Z?]P]?]v?.?v]?(}??Z]or ]??}v}???ouv?X 85  do ??  ~?X ??? o]???oo??Z?]P? ]v?Z?P]}v?}(??]?vPX do ?? X?]P??u?v]]?o]?? ?]PovP?Z ?o]v ?]??}o ??o]vP?}v E??]?]v Wo]v?]oo Wo?u}??Z ^}??Z]vP?}v ZP]}v E?u? }(?]P? D??LX ?? ?? ?? ?? ? ?? ?? ??? H??LX ?? ?? ? ?? ? ?? ?? ?? 84  }vv???,]??}?]?]P/v?v?}??U&]voZ?}??W/v?v?}??WZ?X^?? }(dU???uv ?}(d?v??}???}vXu?U????X 85   ?]P?]?Z ??8]v???vP}(o???Zv????v?]?o]P]o(}??r Z]o]??}v X  Kv?]?Z??vP}( o???Zv?? ]? o]P]o(}???ouv?X ^Z}?o?Z?]Pu ??(?o U?Z?]P]???}P?uu (}?  ?Z]o]r ??}v}???ouv?X~^}u?]P?u?v}o}vP?v????X dZ]?v ?l???o??? ??}?}]ovv?]?}vuv?o]??????oo?oPov vP]v?]vP }v?v??Z?u?????? ??]}??} }v?????}vX / v]??vP ?Z]???}??  ?Zv?Z.????}}???vP]?]v?. Pv?oo? oo}????8]v? ?u(}??]Pvv}v?????}vX ^???u? W?]???Z]o? ???  }( ??? oo ?? ?? ?? ?? ? ?? ?? ??? ??P ??8]v???vP D??LX ??X?9 ??X?9 ??X?9 ??X?9 ??X?9 ??X?9 ??X?9 ??X?9 H??LX ??X?9 ??X?9 ??X?9 ??X?9 ??X?9 ??X?9 ??X?9 ??X?9 oo ??X?9 ??X?9 ??X?9 ??X?9 ??X?9 ??X?9 ??X?9 ??X?9 ??Pd D??LX ???X? ???X? ??X? ???X? ???X? ???X? ???X? ???X? H??LX ?U???X? ?U???X? ???X? ?U???X? ?U???X? ???X? ?U???X? ?U???X? oo ?U???X? ?U???X? ???X? ?U???X? ?U???X? ???X? ?U???X? ?U???X? ??P ???]o? D??LX ????X? ????X? ????X? ????X? ????X? ????X? ????X? ????X? H??LX ????X? ????X? ????X? ????X? ????X? ????X? ????X? ????X? oo ????X? ????X? ????X? ????X? ????X? ????X? ????X? ????X? do ?? X?]P??]?Z?}}???8]v???vP? E}X d}?v &?????] &????}?? >}?]}v z? ?]o? z? ?}vX /v???X? Z?]vP ???? ?o]v ??vZu^?X ^?ZZ]?? ???(?X???}(Z?X??? ???? ???? ?l?l???? ??X??9 ???? ?o]v &?u]vP?}v?X ^?ZZ]?? ???(?X(?}ui?X?lZ?X??? ???? ?l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ?]??}o :?}u?X EP?},]oo?}}l ???(?X?}??Z}(}}o]P^?X ???? ??l?l???? ??X??9 ???? ?]??}o Z}?? ?? ~D]v^?X W???lZ]?? ??vX Z]???]?X?^Z}}o ^?X ???? ?l?l???? ??X??9 ???? ?]??}o D?o?X W}ol?]oo?}}l X??u]X??}(Z?X?? ???? ?l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ?]??}o Du}?]oo?X W???lZ]?? K??W???lZ]?? ???? ???? ?l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ??o]vP?}v s]v?? ZX ??o]vP?}v?}}l ???(?X???}(Z?X? ???? ?l??l???? ??X??9 ^???u? W?]???Z]o? ???  }( ??? E}X d}?v &?????] &????}?? >}?]}v z? ?]o? z? ?}vX /v???X? Z?]vP ???? E??]?]v W?oDv(}???X ^??u ?X?u]???}(i?X?lZ?X??? ???? ???? ?l??l???? ??X??9 ???? E??]?]v l?U D]???U v W]. }?? ?}???X ~u]?o?U ?}u}??}?vvU]v????o?U]v}?v(?]PZ?o?}???? ?Z?o}?}v?XdZ]?]v]???Z??Z?P]}v[?}?Z?Z]PZ???U ?v??????????Z??U ??Uv/ r ???U?}(o]u]???o]?? ?}?Zu??}(?Z?}?PZ(?]PZ?X &]P?? ??  ~?X ??? ?Z}??????}?????Z??v?P}(?r Z]o? ?Z? ? ???l?X /v?????? ?? v ??? ?Z]]? ?Z]o u]???]?Z?ZP??????}?}??}v}(???l?XZ}?????v ?? v ??? v Z}?? ??? o?} ?}???? }? r ??P Z]PZ ???l?Z??U?}?Z}?????}??Z}(<v?]vP?}vXo?Z}?PZ }?Z??}???]v?Z?P]}vu?v}????o?Pu}?v?}( (?]PZ?]v?}o????u?U???l?}}?v?(}??]Pv].v???}r ?}??}v}(?Z?Z]o??Z????o}v?ZuX &]P?? ??  o?}?]???ZZ]??}?]?]ov??}?l]v?Z?P]}vXdZ ?]o?}? ?Z? (??] ???vP?? ? ??] ?v? Z]o  ~ ? X ???  o?} ??] (?]PZ?X Z]o?}? ????? ?Z? ]v??}vr v??}????Z?}?PZ?Z?P]}vW ?X ?]P?}???Z?}?PZt?????v}?ZE?]vP?}vv <v?]vP?}v ~?]t???]ooU,v}ll'????}vUW ???lU?]??}oU &}????]ooUWo]v?]ooUvE??]?]v ?X E?,?v?}^??]vP.o ~?]D?]vUZdWX dZ >ZdW]?]v?v?}(}??]?r ???]}v?]v?Z?P]}v?]v?(?]vP???v?v(????v? ]v??u?}(Pv?o v??]. ZvP??}?Z??v??}???}v ????uX dZ >ZdW  }??? ?? r ?? ??]}~??? ? r ????(}??Z]? }?uv?vu??????v}?????(}?????X dZ o?? >ZdW??}??]vD?????X dZ >ZdW  ????? ?Z?]?(}?uv?}?Z?DWK +}?? ?U]vr o?]vP ?Zd?v??}???}v/u??}?uv?W?}P?u~d/WX  dZd/W ]? ?Z?Z?o(}??Z??v]vP}((?o (?v? }v??v??}??r ?}v]v?Z?P]}v}?? .? r ????]}X  dZ d/W ?]??(?}u ?Z]?WovU]v?Z(}?u}(??o??}i???]?Z??]Pv (?v]vPX WZKhd/KEE/DW> DEdd/KE dZ Wov]??Z??}??}(}oo}??}v??v DWK U ]?? uu? ?Uv?Z??o]X~DWK [? W?o]W??]??}vWov  ?]o?  ?Z??o]]v?}o?uv???}???Z DWK  (}oo}??]v?Z ?o}?uv?}(?Z]?WovXdZ]?Wo vZ?v]v(}?u??r ??Zvvo??]???oo?}v??o??}v?]?Z??lZ}o?? ?Z?}?PZ}?? ?Z ?P]}vX ~ DWK  P?Z? ]v??? (?}u ?Z ]r ???P?}????Z?ul???Z?P]}v?]??]??}(uv?V }?v?? }( ?Z]? }v??o??}v v  (}?v ]v ?Z } ?uv? W?o]]v???}v?Z>}vP r ZvPd?v??}???}vWo v(}?v??o }vv???U???? r ???? X W????}v}(?ZWov]????}v]v ?Z}u??Zv?]?U}v?v?]vP U  v}}?]v???v??}???}v ?ovv]vP??}P?u  ????DWKX  d} v??? ?Z? ?Z Wo v ?u]v ? v ??U o]?]vP }?uv?U DWK  u}v]?}???Z?P]}v}vv}vP}]vP?]?XdZPv?[? ??]???}?Z]?v]vo?W ?X /v?(?]vPU ??v?(?]vPU v ??]}?]??]vP ??v??}???}v v?]v?Z?P]}v ?X ?o}?]vP??}?}?o?v????v]?]vP??}i?? ?X t}?l ]vP?}????Zv??Wov??? ?X }}?]v?vP  ?]?Z  Kdv}?Z?^??v?P]}voPvr ]? U ?Z &?o ,]PZ?? u]v]????}vU ?Z &?o d?v?]?u]v]????}vU?Z?P]}v[? uu??U v ]????v?r ?}???}v??}?]?? lP?}?v ^??????v??}?? ???  }( ??? Kd,ZW>EE/E’ /v ]?}v?}?Z> ZdWvd/WUDWK  ?v??l???]??}( }?Z??ovv]vP??l?XdZ?  ??l?  ???oo}??]v?]o]v?Z Pv?[?hv].Wovv]vPt}?lW?}P?u~hWtWXdZhWtW o??}???Z??v??}???}v?ovv]vP??]???ZPv??r ????}?v??l}????} r ????]}XdZ???v?hWtWU ?Z]Z }????Z???? r ????.?o?? U??v?}vP}]vPv}v r ?u??]??U}?Z??]o??}i??[XDv?}(?Zo??}??r ??}v?}??}i??]v?.]v?Z]?WovXdZ?]vo?W Z???]vP??]?? ?X W???]vU?o]?? Uv?Z]?o???8}?v?? ?X }vP??}vu}v]?}?]vP ?X d?v??}???}v???]? ?X ^????ov??v????vo??? Kv r ?u??]?? ?X ZP]}vo]?o?ovW?o}?uv?}(?P]}v r ?]]?o ?}???U ]vo?]vP  u??? u? v ?}uuv ???r uv??U(}? ]u?ouv??}vXdZ?}????]oo}vv?}?vr ?}?v?U?}?vv???Uvui}???v?}v?~XPX}uu?r ]ovu?o}?uv?Z??U??oo?o]vl???]?Z?]??vP ??]o?vv]PZ}?]vP?P]}v?X ?X v??o }vv??? ^?? hv]???]?? d?v??}???}v WovW }v?v ?]u?ouv??}v}(}u??Zv?]??o??}v}( ?Z?v]???]??[???v??}???}v????uv?ov(}?ul]vP Z]PZ???}vu}???]ov+}?oU??]vP }vP??}vUvvZv]vP8]v?v????]v]o]??X ?X  d?v?]? }uu?v]?? }ooP d?v??}???}v WovW }u??r Zv?]? ?o??}v }( ?Z }ooP[? ??v??}???}v ????u v?ov(}?ul]vPZ]PZ???}vu}???]ov +}?oU ??]vP }vP??}vU v vZv]vP 8]v? v????]v]o]??X ?X ??o]vP?}vd}?vv??????W?? ??}(]u??}?uv???} Z}????v????oo?iv??}?v]v????}v? ?}(]o]?????}?Z?ovv?}?vv??v]u??}? ?(??Xd}???]?v?U????]v r (?]vo??u}??Z? v??}vP??}vU(}?uv]v??vo]??o?}v?] oo }v?]?????}(?Z??}i?X ?X &?u]vP?}vvo,?]?Pd?]oP?o}???W?ov?}?o?P ?ZP?]vWo]v?]oov^}??Z]vP?}vXdZ?ov]?]v?v ?}?ou]v?]v?Z?o?}(.vo?]Pv?}?Z??Z??}i? v?v?}?Z}v?????}v? ?PX ?X Wo?u}??ZZ???}]???]o}vv?}vW?ov(}?v?o?}v }(  .vo ?}?? ?} o]vl ?Z ????}]? ??}???? ?]?Z ?Z dZ}u??}vuv?ZE?P??lZ]??’?v??U}vr v?vP?Z?}?v?}ui}?u?o? r ????]oXdZ]???}i??]oo  }u?o???ZE?P??lsoo?}?v]o}(’}??vr uv??]v???v??Z]??]?Z?Zd}?v}(Wo?u}??ZX lP?}?v v?]?}vuv?ov?}]o}v?v? ???  }( ??? v?]?}vuv?o v?}]o }v?v? tZ]o??v??}???}vvvv]v]??o( v ?}?]?}?o?? ??]???V??vv??Ui}PP??U?ol??Vv??? }vo?]o}??U?]or }??Uv?o]??? 86 v ?vo?P]?????? uv?  ?}vvX /vU?Z?}?PZu?]vZ]??}??U}v}u]?o}?uv?Z? ??}}??Z??]u??v}(??v??}???}vXdZ]????]??G? ]v?Z?}(?Z?o??o]?U?}?lUv?o?U (?}u?}?????Z u}??Z?}(?]???U?}]???ui}??]o?}i?v?}v?U?}}ur u?]o ???]?? v o????? }v ???]o? v ? ??????? ?u??X tZ]ov}?oo??v??}???}v??}i??Z??]o}v}u]r ?o}?uv? v ?}}? ]v???uv?? ?o}u??}+ v ?Z? oo Z? }v???v?X^}u}(?Z????v]??XZ?}????o]ur ]?Uul]vP?? r }+?]v?]?oX}oo???v?}v??v??}??r ?}v]?}oo??Z?}?oZ?v??v?o??Z?U?}?v?oo? ?]?ZZ]PZ???}(????vXd?v??}???}vvP}}  ]vr ???uv?U]u??}?]vP}??o}?U??]?vo?}??]v}??}vU ??]?]vP}?Z?v?v?Z}??ZvP]vP?Z(????X???]vr ???uv?]v}v??}i?????v??]?]}v v}?  ?}]v???]v }?Z??}??]o??U](v}?u}?Uu?]?}?]}??}v?XdZ?]?U??v?r ?}? ??}vZ?v }??}???v]??}?? X 86  ?v]v?Z???U??v??}???}v]?v}?o????Z?}ovXK?Z?}ur u}vv?]vo??o???U.?v??Uv]v}uX /(??v??}???}v]v???uv???Z?U?Z}??}???v]??}?? ?}?ov}??}??Z??]?vP}??X,}???U?Z?]???o??Z ?Xd?v??}???}v]v???uv??U??]oo?ui}??]?o??}r i??U Z? ?o? ]v ??] ?} ?Z ??v? ?Z? }??]vP oo ??v??}???}vv?}?o????oo?l?ZvlXtZ]or }?v?vP????u?}????Z]P?]???U(?v???v }v}v??v??}???}v??}i?}v}?i????????(?}uv}?Z? ??v??}???}v ??}i?V ]v ?Z vU ?Z? ? l ?? (?}u oo ??v]vP}voo?Z}?Z????]?????vuv}(}?? P}??vuv?XtZ]o]?u?]u???o.v]??o??}??v?(? ?Z}??}???v]??}???}(v?]v???uv?~}??}???v]???o]ur ]?o??U ?Z? }??? ?Z}?o}?v]v u]v ?Zv  ??]?]vP ??v??}???}v]v???uv??X dZ]?Wov?u????}}?}???}r ?}?]vP}vo???}i???Z? ]???u]v? (?]oU]XX.??]?Z]v ?Z?P]}v[?.vv]o}v???]v??v}v}?????v?]???}r ?}??}v?  }?]v??]?o  ?]v}v]????}???X  ~&} ?u}?]vr (}?u?}vU? &]vv? U?X  ?? X ,}???U?Z??v}??Z}vo?}????Z?]v???uv?]v??v?r ?}???}vX d?v??}???}v ??}i??U o]l oo ?}v?U Z? ?o }v???v??}v?ZZ?Z? r ]([???o?}v}???Z?Z? lP?}?v v?]?}vuv?ov?}]o}v?v? ???  }( ??? ???(?v??}?o????v?}v?}u?Z]vPo?X^}u} ( ?Z?}v???v??]v?vU??Z????}v]v}vr P??}v~(}?]v??v????o?}(?]????v?]}vU??}?Zr ???v}?U??Z??????v??}?v]v}vP??}v~XPXU ??}?Zuv?Z???v?]}vv]v?XE}???Z? v??? ]o?}v.v?}?Z??v??}???}v??}?v????u o}vXd?v??}???}v??}i??vvZ?Z}v???v? (}? ?Z }v}u?U ?}]??U v ?Z v?]?}vuv?X ^?Z }v?r ??v?U ?Z]Z ?}?v ?} v }?Z??]? ?v]v?}o? ?Z]? ????U ? oo ???vo]?? X ???vo]?? u?  ?}?]?? ~v.??}?vP??~}???X}?Z?}????P?o?o?]v??v?r ?}???}vX???vov.??~(}??u?oU??}???????]?}v v?o}?uv?Z?}Lv.P??U}???o?}?}???o?U]v?Z ???Z(}?}v}?u} ???v??}???}v??}i??~XPXUZ]PZ?? ?u?V}v???o?U???vo}???Z]??}?]oo?Z?vPo}?? }??}?]Pv}?XtZ]o???vov.??U?Z?v???}.?vP}( ??]v????u???u??vlo}v??]??P?}?v?U?Z?} v}?v?]ov?}o ??o}??}vv?}?[?Zo(X???vo}???U ]v}v????U}W?Z?o??}?o}??o??}??}+XdZ?r ?v?v]v?v?]?v??}(?Z??v??}???}v????uul?(}? v??]oo?Z]PZ?}?v?o(}???Zo}??V]vU?ZP?}??Z v}???}v}(?Z?? v??}???}v????u?P?o?Z?]ur ?}??ZP???????vo}???}(v?Z?uv?}v}???Z }???}(?Zo??v????X dZ]???}v?????Z?}v?v?XtZ]o]?u?v}?o ?}P]??}o??}v?U]??l??}P]v]????]}v}(?Z??}ou ? ?Z???v??}???}vv??}?XdZ]v?v?]??}???v?}v ?}?Z?vP?????vo]???}?Z?(????]v???uv?u? }v]?}(v?????]v??Z???Z?]v??vo]??~]XXU ???Z?o}???}?U?v??U???v???ZuX Es/ZKED Ed>KEZE^ d?v??}???}vvZ????]u???}v]?UovUv???X dZ?u??]?]voo??P?}(????u?o}?uv?v??U (?}u}v?????}v?}}???}v?vu]v?vvX???]ur ???v]vo?U???v}?o]u]??}W ? ]??}oo??}v ? ]?]v ? o]u?ZvP ? ????](??Z?P ? ]?????}v}(?]oo](}??]}??vu]P??}v ? vvP?uv?}(]v]Pv}????]? ? &o}}]vP ? ,]??(?Puv??}v ? ,?]?ov? ? >v??ZvP ? >]PZ??}oo??}v ? >}??}(]}u? ? >}??}(}?v?? ? E}]? ?}oo??}v ? K]o??]oo? ? Z?}???Z???}v lP?}?v v?]?}vuv?ov?}]o}v?v? ???  }( ??? ? ^}]o?}?]}v ? ^??}(]v??]???]? ? ^???o ? ^??(vP?}?v????}oo??}v ? t]oo](u}??o]?? /?]? DWK [??}o]??}??]?]v???uv?]v?Z??v??}???}v ????u(}????]u?????Z??Z}?o]??} ?v?}U ?Z P???? ??v? (?]oU ?}] ?ZuX ~D]?P?}v u? }v?]??Z?]u?????v?}]oX >E/ZdED EDEd^ Z]PZ??v?P}(?Zv?}v[?]???o]????}ou??o?]r ??o??}?}oo??v?? u]? ???v??}???}v? }???X   }v?v }???Z]???}ou P??]??} ?Z ( ?oov]??}(????U ?Z]Z??o]?Zv?}vou]v?]???o]????v??(}??Z ?}v u}v}?] ~KU }?]? }( v]??}Pv ~EK y  v }?Z??X  EK y Uo}vP?]?Z??]}??Z? ?}?}v?~,U]? ??(}? }vr ?v??}]????}v]v?Z???v}(??vo]PZ??}(}?u v}?r ]}?? ?Z}?}Zu]o}?]v? ? U}?Z??]? lv}?v?Z?u}P X [ dZov]??U?uv}???Z???U  ??o]?Z??}r ??}(?]Pv?}vvo??].?}v(}????}?v?Z} ?vr ????]?Z?P??} ?Z ?]vuv?}(v?}vou]v?]???o]?? ??v?? (}? }?}vU?}vu}v}?]Uv????o?u??X  dZ?? .?  o?o?}(v}v r ?]vuv?Wu?P]voU u}??U ?r ?]}??U ??? v ???uX  dZ ,??}? h?v]? ? U }( ?Z] Zv??o}vv???]????U  ]?o??].? u}??  v} v r ?]vuv??(}?}?}vv>]u]?D]v?vvWov ?????  ?(}??}vu}v}?]X ZP]}vo ?? v??}???}v?ov?v??}P?u?U]vo?]vP?Z]?WovU u??? }v?]??v?? ]?Z(?ov ^??o??U?P?o?}v?Uv ?ov??o?vP?}]???o]??Xoo>}vP r ZvPd?v??}???}vWov? vd?v??}???}v/u??}?uv?W?}P?u?]????}??]v ?Z]v??}v}(?Z]???}P?uZ?v(}?v]v}v(}?u]?? ?]?Z?Z????]?uv??XKdZ???]? ?Zui}???}i?? v?u??]v?Z]?Wovv??u]v?Zu?}]v}v(}?ur ]???]?Z?Z?P??]v?Z???v?^??/u?ouv??}vWov (}?]???o]??X}??}(?Z???vv?vo??]?v(}?v]v ?Z}?uv? K?}v]?Y?o]????u]v?}v} ( ?Z????Zr P]}vod?v??}???}vWov?v?Z&z???? r ????d?v??}??r ?}v/u??}?uv?W?}P?u?uvuv??(}??Z}vv??? ?}??}v}(?ZE?z}?l r E}??Z?vE?:??? r >}vP/?ovUEz r E: r dK?}vE}v?]vuv??v?Z’???}vv??? K?}vE} v?]vuv??X ^K/>KEZE^ d?v??}???}vu?o?}Z?vP??+??}v?}]??U?or ???Uv?Z}v}u?X??]?Z?Zv?]?}vuv?U+??u? ?]? ?v??}]v? ]v ????u?o}?uv? v ??X W}?v?o vP??+??]vo?W ? ??}u}]o? vv ? ?ZU]vi???Uv??}????uP lP?}?v v?]?}vuv?ov?}]o}v?v? ???  }( ??? ? ???Z??]o??]?? ? ?vv}v(}?]Pv??}??? ? ]?]v???uv?]v?]??vP?? ? ?}?]}v}(??}?????o?? ? ?o??]}v}(]??v?PP?}???(?}u???]??}v]v?}r ]??v?Z}v}u?~XPXUv}v r ?]? ??U?]??? ? ,o?Z}u?o]?}v?~XPXU???]??}??]??? ? ,]PZ?Z}??Z}o??v?? ? ,]PZ???o]???]}??? ? >](???o r ?o?]oov???~XPX}?]??U]?? ? >}??}(?v?}(?o ? >}??}(o]?o]Z}}? ? >}??}(???}vouv]?? ? >}??}( ?}]o?]?o ? >}??}(?v]?o? ? >}??}(??}????v??o???? ? >}??}(?u ? W?o]v??]??? ? ^}]}}v}u]v?o???o?P?P?}v ? ^???o ? ^???? /?]? DWK [??}o]??}??]?]v???uv?]v?Z??v??}???}v ????u(}????]u????? Z??Z}?o]??}?v?}U 87  hX^X???uv?}(:???U  Z??Wll???X??}iXP}?l??l}?l}}?l??o?]XZ?u X ?Z P???? ??v? (?]oU ?}] ?ZuX ~D]?P?}v u? }v?]??Z?]u?????v?}]oX ????K???????Ud]?os/}(?Z????]?]oZ]PZ???Uv ?o? (?ov^?? P?]v Z?]v(}?u?Z]? WovU]vr o?]vP??}i??o?}vv?o}?uv?XdZ???]G? ??]o}?X&???Z??]o}v DWK [?d]?os/vv?]r ?}vuv?oi?????]??u?(}?v]v]?? W?o]W??]?r ?}vWov(}??Zv??o}vv???ZP]}v  v hv]. Wovr v]vPt}?lW?}P?u X d/d>s/K&d,????  /s/>Z/’,d^d d]?os/}(?Z????]?]oZ]PZ?????}Z]]??]??]u]v?}v}v ?Z?]?}(?U}o}?Uvv?}vo}?]P]v]v??}P?u?vr ??]?? ?]?]vP (?o .vv]o ??]??vX 87  dZ]? ]v]?? ?Z?]?]?]u?}??v??}ul????Z?(?oo? r ??}v?}???}r i??}v}??????]vP?}???v]Pv}?}?vP??o?+? }?Z??X  d?v??}???}v??}i???uv??}]v??u}]o]?? v?(??(}??Z???o]vP??o]X  /((?v]vP}vo?Zo??~}?] ?r ??}?}??}v?o?Z?????}?o}(????o?P?}??}?P?}???U d]?os/Z?v?]}o?X lP?}?v v?]?}vuv?ov?}]o}v?v? ???  }( ??? Es/ZKEDEd>:h^d/  ????K?? ????? ]?????(?oPv??}ul v?]?}vuv?oi??????}(]??u]??]}v?]v?(?]vPvr ???]vP?Z+? ?}(oo??}P?u?U?}o]]?v??]??}v u]v}?]??vo}? r ]v}u?}??o?}v?X  +????v??}???}v ]?]}vul]vP?v???}v?v???v]vPv??}??o?r ???]vP?Z?v]??v?}(]+?v??}]}}v}u]P?}???X  dZ???Z???]v]?o?}(  v?]?}vuv?oi????Z?u??? ??? W 88 ?X ?}]Uu]v]u]?}?u]?P?]???}?}??}v?o?Z]PZvr ???Z?uvZo?Zvv?]?}vuv?o+??}vu]v}?]?? vo}? r ]v}u?}??o?}v?X  /v??v??}???}v?ovv]vP?Z]? uv??o??vP?Zu}?v?}(] ????v?????r 88  h X^XKd  v?]?}vuv?o:??? U  Z??Wll???X,?X}?XP}?lv?]?}vuv?li????XZ? u  ]}????v??}???}v??}i???}??u]v?Z?Z?]???}r ?}??}v??Z?}(?Z]?]????v]?}???]vP]vu]v}?]?? vl}?o}? r ]v}u?}??o?}vo?????X ?X W??v??Zv]o}(U???}v]v}??]Pv].v?o?]v?Z ?]??}(  v.???u]v}?]??vo}? r ]v}u?}??o?}v?X  ,??Z?]??v}(??o]??v??}???}v]vu]v}?]??v o}? r ]v}u?}??o?}vo?????v?o??X ?X v????Z(?oov(]????]??}v?oo?}?v?oo?(r (?}uu?v]??]v ?Z??v??}???}v]?]}v r ul]vP ??}??X  dZ ]v?v? ]??} vZv ?Z??o] r ]v?}o?uv? ??}??U ???vP?Zv }uu?v]?? r ? ???v??Z]?? v ??}?]u]v}?]??vo}? r ]v}u?}??o?}v??]?Z}??}?r ??v]???}o?v}??v]u??}??Z??o]??v??(? or v??}(??v??}???}v]v?Z]?o]??X lP?}?v ^&d r >hWovv]vP(?}?? ???  }( ??? ^&d r >hWovv]vP(?}?? dZ???]}??Z]PZ??(?v]vP]ooU ^&d r >h U  }v?]v   ]PZ? ?ovv]vP(?}???Z]Z??]Pv?}P?]?Z]??}v}( DWK?]v??u?}(}u?}vv??}(??v??}???}v?Z ??Z}?o }v?]? ]v ??? ?ovv]vP ??]??X tZ]o ^&d r >h Z? v ??????DW r ??U ?Z ?ovv]vP (?}?? ?u]v ]v ?oX Wov??Z}?oW ?X ^???}?? ?Z }v}u] ?]?o]?? }( ?Z hv]? ^???U ?Z ^???Uv}vu??}?}o]?v??vu??}?}o]?v ??U?r ?]oo? ? vo]vP Po}o }u????v??U ??}???]??U v8]v?X  ?}?v??v??}???}v????u]??]?o(}??Z ?P]}v[?}v}u]Zo?ZX  Z}?U??o]??v??}???}vU?]oU o??v????v??}???}vv]???v??}???}voo?}?l?} ] v??8]v?]v?]vP]vPP}}?v?}?l??]v?}v }??}(?Z?P]}vX ?X /v???Z?(??}(?Z??v??}???}v????u(}?u}?}?r ]?vv}v r u}?}?]?????X  ?????Uuv??Z?v ]vi??]?}??}v?Z??v??}???}vv??}?lX  /?]?]u?}??v? ? Z? ??v??}???}v (?v]vP v ??}i? ??]}?]???}v ]vr o?u?????}??]vi??]?v(?o]??U?Z]Zu? }??}v?}????Z?}v}?Z??Z Z]PZ?? ]v?v?ur ??X  /?]???oo?]u?}??v??}?u]vv?ov(}??Z ?(??}(v}v r u}?}?]?? ?v??}???}v??????Z?}?]?? ?]?Z?Z??}u}]oX ?X /v???Z???]??}(?Z??v??}???}v????u(}?u}r ?}?]?vv}v r u}?}?]?????X  /v?Zo]PZ?}(?Z?v?? }(?l??v?????v???v?]? r ????}?]?u]v>}v}v v D?]U ?Z ??v??}?? ?}v ????u v? ?} ??? (?}u}u??v]v??v?}vo???}?]?uX  dZ]?o]vP}( ??v??}???}v????u?]??oo r ?}?v??]vv???X  /vr ?? ?]P]ov ? ??}?]?? v ???? }( oo u}? }( ??v??}???}v]???v?o?}???????uX ?X /v ???Z??]]o]??vu}]o]??}??}v??]oo?} ?}?ov(?]PZ?X  /?]?]u?}??v??}]v??u}]o]??]v}?r ? ?} ]u??}? ???}vo  u}]o]??X  ? Z?uv u}]o]?? ]vr ???U?}}????}i}?U?Z}??]vPv???}vX  ? (?]PZ?u}]o]?? ]v???U?}}?}v}u]?]]o]??X  /?]? ]u?}??v??}?}Pv]??Z?uv???]v??}v}?Z??r ?}u}]o??v?Z???o]??v??}???}vU]?ov ????]v??}i??v]v??u}]o]??X ?X W?}?? v vZv ?Z v?]?}vuv?U ??}u}? v?P?  }v????}vU]u??}??Z??o]??}(o](Uv??}u}?}vr ?]??v???v??v??}???}v]u??}?uv??v^?? vo}o?ovvP?}??Zv}v}u]?o}?uv???r ??v?X  tZ]o ??v??}???}v ????u? P? ?}?o ?} ?Z? ?Z??v??}P}v??}?](}? }v}u]?o}?uv?U]? ]?]u?}??v??}?uu??Z??Z?o?}v???}oo?r lP?}?v ^&d r >hWovv]vP(?}?? ???  }( ??? ?}vU}?? r }v??u??}v}(v?P?v}?Z?vP?????r vo]??X  d?v??}???}v ????u? v  ?ovv ]v  ?? ?Z?u]v]u]??v?]?}vuv?ouPv?ZvP??(r (??}v  ??o]??}(o](X ?X vZv?Z]v?P??}vv}vv??]??}(?Z??v??}??r ?}v ????uU ?}?? v ??v u}? ?Z?}?PZ}?? ?Z ^??U(}??}?ov(?]PZ?XDv???]??]v?}o?u}??Zv }v ??v??}???}v u}X /? ]? ]u?}??v? ?} }vv? oo u}? ?(o ? v 8]v?o?X ?u?o? ]vo?W ]u??}? ??}u}]o???}v]??}??U]u??}????l???} ?]o?}v?Z]vo??]}v}(]?o?l?}v??o]??v?r ?}???}v?Z]o?X ?X W?}u}?8]v?????uuvPuv?v}???}vX8r ]v?????uuv Puv?v}???}v]v????Z???r ?u[?}??oo?(??v8]v?X ?X u?Z?]??Z??????}v}(?Z?]??vP??v??}???}v ????uX/v?Zvu}(Z]?]vPvZvu}]o]??U]?]? v???o?}?v??}??v??}v?Z???v???v?? }???}v ????uX,}???Uo]u]???}???v???Zv?} ?]PZ  ????u??v?]}vP]v??u]v?vv}(?Z???v? ????uXt]?Z}??u]v?vv}(?Z?]??vP????uU?Z ????uvv}???(}?u}??uoo? X lP?}?v W?}i??o?}v ???  }( ??? W?}i? ? o?}v ??]v ( ?o??v??}???}v ??}P?u?oo}?(}?DWK ?  ?}?r o???}i?? ]??o? (}?(?v]vPX  d }  v????Z?(?v??]r ???}?Zu}?????]vPv(?]o??}i?? U DWK  Z? ?o}? ?o??}v?]??] (}? v]? ??}i??X 89  dZ?r o?}v??}??]? ?]Pv?}???(?(?o???]?uv??(}? ?Z?????(?v]vP??}P?uU??oo?u?^??v(r ?o?P?o?}v?(}???o]]v?}o?uv?X 90 ?}(??]?vPU ^dW r h ?vv]??d?v??}???}vo??v???~d ???P}?? ????v?  ?Z }vo? (?o (?v?  }?? ?Z]Z 89  dZ}?uv? W?}i??o??}v?]??]  ?]o??Z?o??}v??}??X  DWK  Z?]????Z}?]?? XDWK  ]?Pv?oo? oo}? r ??v?Z?v(}??u]oo]}v}oo??]v ^dW r h v r d (?v ??? ?? X ?]??]??}(??}i??u?(?v?v?^dW r hv dX?]o?^dW r hvdW??}i?o]P]]o]??u?(}?v ? Z??Wll???X,?X}?XP}?lu???lP?]vlP?]???X(u  v Z??Wll???X,?X}?XP}?lu???lP?]vlP?]??X(u X 90  dZ}?uv? W?o]W??]??}vWov  ?]o?DWK[???o]]v?}o?r uv???]??X ??v]??  ?}v?u? ???  }( ??? Appendixes ??v]?? ?}v?u? dZ(}oo}?]vP?}v?u????]v?Z]?WovX  u?]v??]?Z]?]o ]???  ov]??  ov]??uvuv?? DY }vP??}vD]?P?}vv]?Y?o]??W?}P?u D,^ }vv??? ???uv? }( u?Pv? DvPr uv?v,}uov^??]?? Kd }vv??? ???uv?  }(d?v??}???}v : v?]?}vuv?o :??? W v?]?}vuv?oW?}??}vPv? & &?o?]?}vu]v]????}v ‘/^ ‘}P??Z]/v(}?u?}v^???u? ‘W^ ‘o}oW}?]?}v]vP^???u? >ZdW >}vPZvPd?v??}???}vWov DWK D??}?}o]?vWovv]vPK?Pv]??}v E,^ E?}vo,]PZ??^???u ZWK ZP]}voWovv]vPK?Pv]??}v ZZ Z]o?} ^/W ^??/u?ouv??}vWov ^d/W ^??d?v??}???}v/u??}?uv?W?}P?u ^dW ^??(d?v??}???}vW?}P?u d d?v?]?]???]? dD d?v??}???}vuvDvPuv? d/W d?v??}???}v/u??}?uv? W?}P?u dD d?v??}???}vDvPuv?? dK d?v?]? r K?]v??o}?uv? hWtW hv].Wovv]vPt}?lW?}P?u h^Kd hv]?^??????uv?}(d?v??}???}v sDd sZ]oD]o?d??o ??v]?? ????(?}u?ZE}??Z??}??]}?D???Wov ???  }( ??? ????(?}u?ZE}??Z?? }??]}?D???Wov dZ(}oo}?]vP]??lv(?}u W??//W???v?v&????^??] v/v(?????????^Puv?  ~ ? X?? r ??}( dZE}??Z??}?r ?]}?/v(????????D???Wov W W,z^/>^^d^ dZ]?  ?? ? u]o  ?vZ  }(  ?Z  E  ]?  }?v  v  }???  ?  u??l  v  ??v?  ??ooo  ?}  /v?????  ??  ?Z?}?PZ  ,??}?X  dZ  ^??]vP.o  >]v  }vv??  ?}  ?Z  E  D]v  >]v  ?  D]oo  Z]??  :?v?}v  v?  E?  ,?v  v  ^yd[?  }??}v  ^?]?]?]}v  ?  ^??]vP.oX  dZ  ?vZ  o]v  ]?  ??}  ??l?  ??v  D]oo  Z]??  v  ?  ]v??o}l]vP?  v  ?]vPo ? ??l  ?]?Z  ?]]vP?  ??v  ?  /v??o}l]vP  v  ^??]vP.o  hv]}v  ^??}vX ^??]vP.o  hv]}v  ^??}vU  ?  ?Z  v}??Z?v  ??u]v??  }(  ?Z  ?vZU  ]?  ???  ?  ??}  u??l  ]v??]??  ?}???  ]vo?]vP  ?Z  >l?Z}?  >]u]?  }???vP  ??v  Z]P}  v  }??}v  v   s?u}v??  ??v  t?Z]vP?}v  v  ^?X  ov?U  s?u}v?X  hvr ]}v  ^??}v  E?  ,?v  ?  ]?  ?Z  ?vZ[?  ?}??Z?v  ??u]v??  v  ?Z?  ?  u??l  o  ?????U  ZP]}voU  ?Z  s?u}v??  v  ]v??]??  ???]?U  ?  ?oo  ?  ^>  v  DEZ  }uu???  ?]o  ??r ?]?X  dZ  ?Puv?  ]?  ???  }(  ?Z  o?P?U  (?oo? ?]Pv?  u?o? ? ?}??  E}??Z?v  E?  vPov  ,]PZ ? ^?  Z]o  }??]}?  ?Z]Z  ??v?  ?Z?}?PZ  ?Z  ????  }(  s?u}v?U  E?  ,u??Z]?U  D]vU  D??Z????U  }vv???U  v  E?  z}?lX hZZEd  KWZd/KE^ u??l  ~???vP?  v  ^ydU  }vv???  ^}??Z?vU  v  Wv  u  ^}??Z?v  ~(?]PZ?  }???  ]v  ?Z  ?Puv?X  u??l  }????  ??  ??]v?  ~?]?  ?}?v  ??]??  ]o?  ??v  ^??]vP.o  v  E?  ,r ?v  ]vo?]vP  ?}?v  ??]??  (}?  s?u}v??  v  ZP]}vo  ???]?U  ??}?]]vP  ???]  ?}  E?  z}?l  v  ?}]v??  ?}??ZX  dZ  ?u]v]vP  ]PZ?  ??]v?  ~(}??  ?}?v  ??]??  ?  ^Z??o  ?}???  ?Z]Z  }???  Z  ?l?  ??v  E?  ,?v  v  ^??]vP.o  }vv?vP  ?}  E  ZP]}vo  ??]v?  ?  E?  ,?vX  dZ?  ]?  v}  }uu???  ?]o  ???]  ???v?o?  }???vP  }v  ?Z  ?Puv?X  ???v?  v  (????  ???vP?  ?]o  }???vP  ??????  ?  ??}?]  ]v  do  ??  ??????? }?X &????  Wov?  }vv???  ]?  ?o}?]vP  ?ov?  (}?  E?  ,?v ? ,??}? ? ^??]vP.o  ~E,,^  }uu???  ?]o  ???]  o}vP  ?Z]?  ?Puv?X  /v]?o  ?ov?  oo  (}?  ??  ??]v?  ~??  ?}?v  ??]??  Z  ?U  ??}?]]vP  Zo( Z}??o?  ???]  ??]vP  ?Z  ?l  Z}???  v  ???}?r ]u?o?  Z}??o?  ???]  ?Z?}?PZ}??  ?Z  ?X  dZ]?  ???]  ?}?o  ??v]?? ????(?}u?ZE}??Z??}??]}?D???Wov ???  }( ???   ????}??  ?  v  o??].U  }?o ? ??l  ]v(????????X  /v]r ?oo?U  ???]  ?}?o  }???  o}vP  ?Z  ^??]vP.o  >]vU  ?]?Z  r ]?}vo  ???]  ?}??]o  ?}  ^?u(}?U  dX  dZ  ^??]vP.o  >]v  ]?  ???  }(  ?Z  (?oo? ? ?]Pv?  E}??Z?v  E?  vPov  ,]PZ ? ^?  Z]o  }??]}?X ]o?  u??l  ???]  ??v  ^??]vP.o  v  E?  ,?v  ?]oo  ]v??  (?}u  ??  ??]v?  ~?  ?}?v  ??]??  ?}  ??  ~??  ?}?v  ??]??  ??}?]]vP  v?  Z}??o?  ???]  ?Z?}?PZ}??  ?Z  ?X  o??v?  ??]v?  ?]oo  ??u]v?  ?  E?  ,?vU  }?  }v?v?  ?}  Wvv  ^??}v  E?  z}?l  }?  t?Z]vP?}v  XX  ^??]  }v  ?Z  o]v  ?}?o    (??r ?Z?  ]v?P??  ?]?Z  u?P]vP  }??]}??  ??Z  ?  ?Z  /vov  Z}??  ?]  }??}v  v  t}????  v  ?Z  ]v  ]vo??  ]v??or o?}v  }(  ^^  ???]  ??v??}v??  ]v}??}??vP  ?}?]??  ??}?  v  ]?]o  ??  }v??}o  ]v  ??  }(  ?Z  }??]}?  ?Z?  ^^  ]?  v}? ???v?o?  ]v??oo  ~}???vP  ???  P???  ?Zv???  u?Z  ?  uv?  ?  dZ  Z]o  ^(??  /u??}?uv?  ?  }(  ????X  Wd  ?]Pv  (}?  ?Z  <v}?oP  }??]}?  v  /vov  Z}??  ?]oo    ??u]v  ?  Wv  u  ^}??Z?v  v  ^yd  (}?  ?Z]?  ?????  ?}???X ^??}v  /u??}?uv?? ? ? ???u X  ^??}v  ]u??}?uv??  ?  r ?]Pv  ?}  u?    v  ^'Z  ???]?uv??U  (]o]??  ?}(  ???oU  v}??P  ]v??u}o]?uU  v  ]v?P??  ???}v?  ]v?}  ?Z  }v}u]  (?]  }(  ?Z  }uu?v]??  ?Z?  ???X  dZ?  ?  ??v  ??}i??  ]v  ?Z]?  ??}P?uU  ?]?  }(  ?Z]Z  ??o?  ?}    v  ^'Z  ]u??}?uv??X  dZ  ]??  }(  ^??]vP.o  v  ]?? u??}?}o]?v  ?ovv]vP  }?Pv]??}v  ?  ???v?o?  ?o??vP  o??v???  (}?  ?Z  ?}?v?o  ???}??}v  }(  Z]??}?]  ^??]vP.o  hv]}v  ^??}vX/(    ]?]}v  ]?  u  ?}  ?Z  ?Z  Z]??}?]  ???}vU?o?}?u  v  ??l  u}].?}v?  ?]oo    ]vo?  ?}  +??o?  ???  ??]v?  }???vP  ?]  ?Z  ]v  v  /vr ov  Z}??  ?}  }??}vX  oo  ?]??vP  ]v??]??  ???}v?  ]vo?]vP  ,??}?  ?]oo  ???]?  ?r ?v?]}v  v  u}].?}v?}  }uu}?  }?o  ??l]vP  }(  ?Z  o]vX  D}].?}v?  ?]oo  ]vo?  ]?}vo  ? o?}?u?U    }u?o]v  v  (]o]??  ?}  }uu}?  ???  ]uv?]}v  (?]PZ?  ??8  ?Z]?uv??X  /v  ]?}vU  ?Z?  v?  }uu???  ??r ?}v?  ?  ??}?}?  o}vP  ?]?Z??v?]}v  }(  ^??  ^???  ^??}v  ]v  E?  ,?vX ??v]?? ,]??}?]o?]o?}?u?o? ???  }( ??? ,]??}?]o?]o?}?u?o? Kvo?]?? }vv?}v???]?X~W??vP???Z}}?o?}o???Z}???}u}??o?}????o?}?]o?Zu?o??}( ???ou}?]o???]????v?Z?P]}vv?ZE?z}?lv}??}vu??}???]??Z}??Z}?vX&}??Z?l}(?? ?vr ??}vU?Z ?u?o?o}?Z?v?]PX 91 do ?? Xd?]v?(?}uE?z}?l]???}?Z?P]}vU???? ^??}vl??]v ??? ??? ??? ? l ??? ?? l ??? ??? ??? ?? D} r &? ^ D} r &? D} r ^ D} r ^ D} r ^ D} r &? d]u}(? D D D D WD WD WD Ez’?v v??o ?W?? ??W?? ^?u(}? ?W?? ??W?? E}??ol ??W?? ?]P?}?? ?W??l?W?? ?W??l?W?? t????? ?W?? ?W?? ?W?? ??W??l??W?? ?W??l?W?? ?W?? d????]oo ?W?? ?W?? ?W?? ?]??}o ?W?? ?W?? ?W?? ??W?? ?W?? ?W?? ?W?? &}????]oo ?W?? ?W?? ?W?? ??W?? ?W?? ?W?? Wo]v?]oo ?W?? ?W?? ?W?? ??W?? ?W?? ?W?? 91  dZ(}oo}?]vP]v(}?u?}vZ?v}u]?W ??}????vt?????vE?z}?l]??’? vv??o}?Z??Zv?]P?}??UE}??olUv^?u(}?V??}?? ??vt]oo]uv?v}??}vVv}??}v}(GP??}??v??]vZvP?V ??]oZ}o]??Z?o?V  PPP??]P]v?????}v?V?????Vv?u?(}???]v? ?}l(?}udZ}u??}vUd}??]vP?} vUvt]v??vW?}?]vX ??v]?? ,]??}?]o?]o?}?u?o? ???  }( ??? E??]?]v ?W?? ?W?? ?W?? ??W?? ?W?? ?W?? ?W?? E?]vP?}v ?W?? ?W?? ?W?? ?W?? W?l?]oo ?W?? ?W?? ,??}? ?W?? ?W?? ?W?? ??W?? ?W?? ?W?? ?W?? do ?? Xd?]v?(?}u?Z?P]}v?}E?z}?l]??U???? ^??}vl??]v ??? ??? ??? l ??? ??? ??? ??? ?? D} r ^ D} r ^ D} r ^ D} r &? D} r ^ D} r &? d]u}(? D D WD WD WD WD ,??}? ?W?? ??W?? ?W?? ?W?? ?W?? ?W?? W?l?]oo ?W?? ?W?? E?]vP?}v ??W?? ?W?? ?W?? ?W?? E??]?]v ?W?? ??W?? ?W?? ?W?? ?W?? ?W?? Wo]v?]oo ?W?? ??W?? ?W?? ?W?? ?W?? ?W?? &}????]oo ?W?? ??W?? ?W?? ?W?? ?W?? ?W?? ?]??}o ?W?? ??W?? ?W?? ?W?? ?W?? ?W?? d????]oo ??W?? ?W?? t????? ?W?? ??W?? ?W??l?W?? ?W?? ?W?? ?]P?}?? ?W??l?W?? E}??ol ?W?? ^?u(}? ?W?? ??v]?? ,]??}?]o?]o?}?u?o? ???  }( ??? Ez’?vv??o ?W?? do ?? Xd?]v?(?}u?Z?P]}v?}}??}vU???? ^??}vl??]v ??? l ??? ??? l ??? ??? l ??? ??? ?? D} r &? ^ D} r &? D} r ^ d]u}(? D D D WD t????? ?W?? ?W?? ?W?? ?W?? ?]??}o ?W?? ?W?? ?W?? ?W?? &}????]oo ?W?? ?W?? ?W?? ?W?? Wo]v?]oo ?W?? ?W?? ?W?? ?W?? E??]?]v ?W?? ?W?? ?W?? ?W?? ,??}? ?W??l?W?? ?W??l?W?? ?W??l?W?? ?W??l?W?? DvZ??? ?W?? ?W?? ?W?? ?W?? t]oo]uv? ?W?? ??W?? ??W?? ?W?? }??}v^}??Z^?X ??W?? ??W?? ??W?? ?W?? do ?? Xd?]v?(?}u}??}v?}?Z?P]}vU???? ^??}vl??]v ??? ??? l ??? ??? ?? D} r ^ D} r &? D} r ^? d]u}(? D WD WD }??}v^}??Z^?X ?W?? ?W?? ?W?? ??v]?? ,]??}?]o?]o?}?u?o? ???  }( ??? t]oo]uv? ??W?? ?W?? ?W?? DvZ??? ??W?? ?W?? ?W?? ,??}? ??W??l??W?? ?W??l?W?? ?W??l??W?? E??]?]v ??W?? ?W?? Wo]v?]oo ??W?? ?W?? &}????]oo ??W?? ?W?? ?]??}o ??W?? ?W?? ??W?? t????? ??W?? ?W?? ??W?? do ?? Xd?]v?(?}uE?,?v?}t]oo]u???PUD??Z????U???? ^??}vl??]v ???? ???? ?? D} r ^ D} r ^ d]u}(? D WD E?,?v ?W?? ?W?? D?X?uo ?W?? ?W?? ?}}l??o ?W?? ?W?? Z?Z]? ?W?? ?W?? D]ooo ?W?? ?W?? Wov???]oo ?W?? ?V?? ^}??Z]vP?}v ?W?? ?W?? Wo]v?]oo ?W?? ?W??l?W?? ??v]?? ,]??}?]o?]o?}?u?o? ???  }( ??? &?u]vP?}v ?W?? ?W?? ?}v ?W?? ?W?? t?}P? ?W?? ?W?? ^]u???? ?W?? ?W?? ‘?v? ?W?? ?W?? }vPu}v ?W?? ?W?? ^}??Z?]l ?W?? ?W?? t??]o ?W?? ?W??l?W?? ^}??Zu??}v ?W?? ??Zu??}v ?W?? E}??Zu??}v ?W?? t]oo]u???PZ:?v?}v ?W?? do ?? Xd?]v?(?}ut]oo]u???PUD??Z?????}E?,?vU???? ^??}vl??]v ???? ???? ?? D} r ^ D} r ^ d]u}(? D WD t]oo]u???PZ:?v?}v ?W?? E}??Zu??}v ?W?? ??Zu??}v ?W?? ^}??Zu??}v ?W?? ??v]?? ,]??}?]o?]o?}?u?o? ???  }( ??? t??]o ?W?? ?W?? ^}??Z?]l ?W?? ?W?? }vPu}v ?W?? ?W?? ‘?v? ?W?? ?W?? ^]u???? ?W?? ?W?? t?}P? ?W?? ?W?? ?}v ?W?? ?W?? &?u]vP?}v ?W?? ?W?? Wo]v?]oo ?W?? ?W?? ^}??Z]vP?}v ?W?? ?W?? Wov???]oo ?W?? ?W?? D]ooo ?W?? ?W?? Z?Z]? ?W?? ?W?? ?}}l??o ?W?? ?W?? D?X?uo ?W?? ?W?? E?,?v ?W?? ?W?? ??v]?? ?]P? ???  }( ??? ?]P? dZ(}oo}?]vP?o o]???oo?]P??]?Z??v}(?o????v??(?]v?Z?P]}vX ?]P v}X d}?v &?????] &????}?? >}?]}v z? ?]o? z? ?}vX d ^?????? ovP?Z ?? r ?? ?]?Z /v???}v ? ^?((]]v? ??]vP ???? ?o]v E}??}vZX u??l ???[}(}??>vZX ^?ZZ]?? X??u]X^}(i?X&?u]vP?}v?X ???? ? ?U??? ?? ?? ??l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ?o]v t}??Z]vP?}vZXE}X? ^?ZZ]?? X?u]E}(t?Z??(]oZX ???? ???? ??? ?? ??X? ?l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ?o]v uo?lZX u??l X??u]X}(<v?]vP?}vZX ???? ???? ??? ?? ?? ?l?l???? ??X??9 ???? ?o]v D]o?}?vZX ^????}}l ?X??u]X}(i?X?l^Z?? ???? ? ??? ?? ??X? ??l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ?o]v t?Z??(]oZX ^?ZZ]?? :?X}(lo?D]oo?ZX ???? ? ?U??? ?? ??X? ?l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ?o]v K?Z?ZX u??l ????[ti?XKod??v?]lZX ???? ? ??? ?? ?? ?l?l???? ??X??9 ???? ?o]v K?Z?ZX ?}}l X?u]Xt}(?o]vd?lX ???? ? ?U??? ?? ? ?l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ?o]v ?o]v^?X ^?ZZ]?? ???[D??????^?X ???? ? ??? ?? ?? ??l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ?o]v t]o?u?ZX oZ??}}l ?X?u]X}(i?X?l?Z}ZX ???? ? ??? ?? ? ?l?l???? ??X??9 ???? ?o]v vX ???? ? ??U??? ?? ? ?l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ?o]v ??vZu^?X ^?ZZ]?? ???[t}(Z?X??? ???? ???? ?U??? ?? ??X? ?l?l???? ??X??9 ???? ?o]v &?u]vP?}v?X ^?ZZ]?? ???[(?}ui?X?lZ?X??? ???? ? ?U??? ?? ?? ?l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ?o]v E}??}vZX oZ??}}l ?X?u]X}(i?X?l^Z?? ???? ???? ?U??? ?? ??X? ?l??l???? ???? ?]??}o ??]?v^?X }???D]v?}}l ???[(?}ui?X?lZ}}??X ???? ? ?U??? ?? ??X? ?l?l???? ??X??9 ??v]?? ?]P? ???  }( ??? ???? ?]??}o :}?^?X W???lZ]?? ?X??u]Xt}(Z?X?? ???? ???? ?U??? ?? ?? ??l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ?]??}o Doov^?X W???lZ]?? ???[^}(Z?X??i?X ???? ? ?U??? ?? ?? ?l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ?]??}o >}?]?]v?X }???D]v?}}l ???[(?}ui?X?l?}}l^?X ???? ???? ?U??? ?? ?? ?l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ?]??}o ol?o^?X }??}v?D]vZ]o r ?} X?u]Xt}(Z?X?? ???? ???? ?U??? ?? ?? ??l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ?]??}o Do??^?X }???D]v?}}l X?u]Xt}(^?((}??X ???? ? ?U??? ??? ?? ??l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ?]??}o ???]??^?X }??}v?D]vZ]o r ?} X?u]Xt}(Z?X?? ???? ? ?U??? ?? ?? ??l?l???? ??X??9 ???? ?]??}o &??]l^?X }???D]v?}}l ??[(?}ui?X ?l???]???X ???? ???? ?U??? ?? ?? ??l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ?]??}o v??o^?X?? W???lZ]?? :?XZ?X???v??o^?X? ???? ? ??U??? ?? ??X? ??l?l???? ??X??9 ???? ?]??}o ^??v?^?X }???D]v?}}l X?D}(:?}u?X ???? ? ?U??? ?? ?? ?l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ?]??}o ??^?X W???lZ]?? E?i?XDu}?]oo?X ???? ???? ?U??? ?? ?? ?l?l???? ??X??9 ???? ?]??}o }?v?^?X W???lZ]?? E?i?XDu}?]oo?X ???? ???? ?U??? ?? ??X? ?l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ?]??}o :?}u?X }???D]v?}}l ??[(?}ui?X?l^Z??ZX ???? ? ?U??? ?? ?? ?l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ?]??}o E}??ZW}v^?X }??}v?D]vZ]o r ?} E????]?^?X ???? ???? ?U??? ??? ?? ??l?l???? ??X??9 ???? ?]??}o E}??ZD]v^?X?Z]?? r ?]?X W???lZ]?? :?XE}??ZD]v^?X?Z]???]?X ???? ? ??U??? ?? ? ??l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ?]??}o v???^?X W???lZ]?? ??[(?}ui?X?l&??]l^?X ???? ???? ?U??? ?? ?? ??l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ?]??}o >l?X v??v>l}u?}?v ?]??}o r ^}??Z]vP?}vd}?v>]v ???? ? ?U??? ?? ??X? ??l?l???? ??X??9 ???? ?]??}o t??t?Z]vP?}v^?X }???D]v?}}l X?u]X}(Z?X??? ???? ? ?U??? ?? ??X? ?l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ?]??}o :?}u?X EP?},]oo?}}l ???[^}(}}o]P^?X ???? ? ?U??? ?? ??X? ??l?l???? ??X??9 ???? ?]??}o Z}????~D]v^?X W???lZ]?? ??vXZ]???]?X?^Z}}o^?X ???? ? ?U??? ?? ? ?l?l???? ??X??9 ???? ?]??}o D?o?X W}ol?]oo?}}l X?u]X}(Z?X?? ???? ? ?U??? ?? ??X? ?l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ?]??}o Du}?]oo?X W???lZ]?? K??W???lZ]?? ???? ???? ??U??? ?? ??X? ?l??l???? ??X??9 ????? ?]??}o W?l]v?^?X ]?PW}v?}}l X?u]X^}(i?X?lZ?o^?X ???? ??? ?? ??X? ?l?l???? ????? ?]??}o ??ZX ^}??ZD}?v?]v?}}l ?X?u]X}(i?X?lZ?X?? ???? ??? ?? ??X? ?l??l???? ??v]?? ?]P? ???  }( ??? ????? ?]??}o D]?^?X W}ol?]oo?}}l ?X?u]XE}(i?X?lZ?X? ???? ?U??? ?? ??X? ?l??l???? ???? ??o]vP?}v Z???}]?,]ooZX tZ]P?]oo?}}l :?X^?}v?,]ooZ} ???? ? ??? ?? ?? ??l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ??o]vP?}v ovZX?? ??o]vP?}v?}}l ???}?X????[E}(Z?X? ???? ???? ??? ?? ??X? ??l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ??o]vP?}v &}}?ZX ??o]vP?}v?}}l ????[E}(Z?X? ???? ? ??? ?? ??X? ?l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ??o]vP?}v ?v?,]ooZX ??o]vP?}v?}}l ???[E}(Z?X?i?X ???? ? ??? ?? ?? ?l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ??o]vP?}v ^}??ZD]v^?X }???D]v?}}l ????[}(Z?X?? ???? ? ??? ?? ??X? ?l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ??o]vP?}v s]v??ZX ??o]vP?}v?}}l ???[t}(Z?X? ???? ? ?U??? ?? ??X? ?l??l???? ??X??9 ????? ??o]vP?}v D]v^?X tZ]P?]oo?}}l ?X?u]X^X}(i?X?l^?}vZX ???? ??? ?? ??X? ?l?l???? ???? E??]?]v ^}??Z^?X u??l ???? ? ??U??? ??? ?? ?l??l???? ??X??9 ???? E??]?]v >]v}ov^?XE}X? t]oo}??}}l ???[^}(Z?X??? ???? ? ?U??? ?? ?? ??l??l???? ??X??9 ???? E??]?]v ]o?u}?^?X ^v??}}l ???? ???? ??? ?? ?? ?l??l???? ??X??9 ???? E??]?]v oo]?^?X }??}v?  D]vZ]o?} ?v}(??X??Z?X?E ???? ? ??U??? ?? ?? ?l??l???? ??X??9 ???? E??]?]v ^?vo?W?lZX ???}}l^?]oo?? ???[X}(^?vo?X^?X ???? ? ??? ?? ?? ?l??l???? ??X??9 ???? E??]?]v W?oDv(}???X ???u ?X?u]Xt}(i?X?lZ?X??? ???? ???? ??? ?? ?? ?l??l???? ??X??9 ???? E??]?]v X ???? ? ??? ?? ??X? ?l??l???? ??X??9 ???? Wo?u}??Z vo^?X W???lZ]?? X?u]Xt}(Z?X?? ???? ???? ?U??? ?? ?? ?l??l???? ??X??9 ???? Wo?u}??Z u]?^?X W???lZ]?? ?u]Xt}(Z?X?? ???? ? ??? ?? ?? ?l??l???? ??X??9 ???? Wo?u}??Z :?ZX W}ovZ]?? ???[}(Z?X?? ???? ? ??? ?? ??X? ?l??l???? ??X??9 ???? Wo?u}??Z E}??ZD]v^?X W}ovZ]?? ???[t}(Z?X?? ???? ? ?U??? ?? ?? ??l??l???? ??X??9 ???? Wo?u}??Z E?}?X W???lZ]?? X?u]X}(,??]v?}v?X ???? ? ??? ?? ? ?l??l???? ??X??9 ???? Wo?u}??Z W???}vZX W}ovZ]?? ???[t}(Z?X?? ???? ? ??? ?? ?? ??l??l???? ??X??9 ?????? Wo?u}??Z ^}??ZD]v^?X ?vvu?}}l X?u^}(Z?X? ???? ? ?U??? ?? ??X? ?l??l???? ???? ^}??Z]vP?}v Kod??v?]lZX Y?]vv]?]Z]?? K??Y?]vv]?]Z]?? ???? ???? ?U??? ?? ?? ??l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ^}??Z]vP?}v t??v??^?X Y?]vv]?]Z]?? ???[(?}ui?X?l^?uv?^?X ???? ???? ?U??? ?? ?? ??l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ^}??Z]vP?}v ^??]vP^?X Y?]vv]?]Z]?? X?u]Xt}(Z?X?? ???? ? ?U??? ?? ?? ??l?l???? ??X??9 ???? ^}??Z]vP?}v t??D]v^?X Y?]vv]?]Z]?? ???[t}(Z?X?? ???? ? ??U??? ?? ?? ??l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ^}??Z]vP?}v t??v??^?X??X ]PZ?D]oZ]?? iv?d}/ r ?? ???? ? ?U??? ?? ?? ?l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ^}??Z]vP?}v D?]}v?X ]PZ?D]oZ]?? /v????]}v}(t??^?X ???? ???? ??U??? ?? ??X? ??l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ^}??Z]vP?}v v??^?X Y?]vv]?]Z]?? ???[t}(t??^? ???? ? ?U??? ?? ?? ??l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ^}??Z]vP?}v >??>vZX Y?]vv]?]Z]?? ???[t}(i?X?lZ?X?? ???? ? ?U??? ?? ?? ??l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ^}??Z]vP?}v E?oo^?X Y?]vv]?]Z]?? ?X?u]XE}(t??Y?v^? ???? ? ?U??? ?? ??X? ?l?l???? ??X??9 ???? ^}??Z]vP?}v D]oo^?X Y?]vv]?]Z]?? X?D]o?t}(Z?X?? ???? ? ?U??? ?? ?? ??l?l???? ??X??9 ???? ^}??Z]vP?}v ???]??^?X Y?]vv]?]Z]?? X?u]Xt}(Z?X?? ???? ? ?U??? ?? ??X? ??l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ^}??Z]vP?}v ,??^?X Y?]vv]?]Z]?? X??u]Xt}(Z?X?? ???? ? ?U??? ?? ?? ??l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ^}??Z]vP?}v Kod??v?]lZX dvD]oZ]?? ???[E}(Z?X??? ???? ???? ?U??? ?? ?? ?l??l???? ??X??9 ??v]?? ?]P? ???  }( ??? ???? ^}??Z]vP?}v W?}???^?X ]PZ?D]oZ]?? ???[}(/ r ?? ???? ???? ?U??? ?? ??X? ?l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ^}??Z]vP?}v t??v??^?X??X ??}v?}}l X?u]Xt}(:?]o^?X ???? ? ?U??? ?? ? ??l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ^}??Z]vP?}v ????^?X Y?]vv]?]Z]?? K((Z?X???/ r ???]??? ???? ???? ??? ?? ?? ??l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ^}??Z]vP?}v :?>v ]PZ?D]oZ]?? X?D]ot}(i?X/ r ?? ???? ? ?U??? ?? ? ??l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ^}??Z]vP?}v ^}??ZvZX D]????}}l ???[(?}ui?X?lD??ooE}o?X ???? ???? ?U??? ?? ?? ??l??l???? ??X??9 ???? ^}??Z]vP?}v t??Y?v^?X Y?]vv]?]Z]?? ???[(?}ui?X?l Z??}v^?X ???? ? ?U??? ?? ??X? ??l??l???? ??X??9 ??v]?? }u?o?^????o?~’^?? r ???( ???  }( ??? }u?o?^????o?~’^?? r ???( (a) &}??Z????}??}(?Z]???]}v (1) ????uv??uv??Z???uv?}(d?v??}???]}vV (2) ?&?v??uv?v?(?v?(?}u?Z^?]o d?v??}???]}v &?vU}voo}?]}v?vv?}?Z??}???Z?]??]or o(}??Z}v?????]}vUu]v?vvv??]?}(?}?]v ?Z]????V (3) ^h???uv?u}?}?]??U??v?]????U????]v}?]?r o]??V (4) ?]l???uv?v??}U????U??Z}??? ?Z]Z]v ?}uuvv?]???](]oo??]Pv?(}?]?o???oU]vr o?]vP ?Z ??}?]?]}v }(  ]?o ovU ?P?o?? }( ?Z?Z???Z(]o]??]??]Pv?(}??Z?o??]???}( ]?o?}?]??}?Z??]?Z}?Z?u}?}(??v??}??r ?]}vVv (5) ?d }?o??}i?}???uv??Z}??}(?Zv?]?}??]}? ?ov??}i?X (b) }uu}?]}v?(}?oo?????Zoo?}??]v???}(?Z?ovr v]vPU?]PvU}v?????]}vv}???]vP?]?]?]?}(ooZ]PZr ???U?(]v]v??]}v?? r ?U]v?Z]????X (c) &?}u(?v ??]???Z???uv?}?v?u?v]]?o]??(}? ?Z }v?????]}vU ???}??]}vU ?Z]o]??]}v }? ?o}?]}v }( Z]PZ???U?}?}??????U??}vou}?v??Zoo?r ?v?}??}?](]o]?]?(}?oo????U]vo?]vPU??v}?o]ur ]??}U]l? ??v?]?ol??]?Z???}??]??????v ?u??XKvv(??K?}??U????Uv}?o???Zv}v??v? }(?Z?}?ou}?v?}(v???Z(?v??]?]vv?(]?o?? ?Zoo?}??vXdZ???uv?}?u?v]]?o]???Zoo?l (??????v?]?  ??v?]}v?ov?]v?}}?v??Z????}??]?X E}??]?Z??v]vP?Z??}?]?]}v?}(?Z]?????]}vU??Z??}?]r ?]}v??Zoov}???o?]v?Z?v?}(???}?u?v]]?o??v?r ?}???]}vu?Pv?X (d) }u}?]}v???]??????v??}????]}v  ~}(?Z]???]}v v?Z??}?]?]}v}((]o]?]??????v??}????]}v~}(?Z]? ??]}v?Zoov}????]?](?Z}uu]??]}v?}(d?v??}?r ??]}v}?u?v]]?ooP]?o?]?}???u]v?U?]?Z???? ?}Z]PZ??U?}}??????Z?W~?E}vu }?}?]???P]???}r Z]]?V~??Z?]?u}v?????v}(vV~??Zr }uu}?]}v}(oo?????}?ov???]?o???v?]? }u?}vv?}(?Z?}?o??}i?}??V}?~??Z}uu}?]}v }(oo????]?v}?}v?]??v??]?Z?Z?????}?  ??Zu?v]]?o]r ????U????]?o?U??}P?u}(}v?????]}vUu]v?vvv?r ?]?X ??v]?? W}o]?}?v}v??/v(}?u?}v ???  }( ??? W}o]?}?v}v??/v(}?u?}v DhE//W>ZWZ^Ed d/s^ D?v]]?o]?? >}v??v??o d/  uu?? ?o]v v]?DE]?U d}?vDvP? ??^]u}v]v ?]??}o U d}?vDvP? :}Zv}??] Wo?u}??Z ?]D?Zv?U D?}? Z?o? t]P?? ^}??Z]vP?}v ‘?????ulU d}?vDvP? :]u’???}v ??v]?? W}o]?}?v}v??/v(}?u?}v ???  }( ??? KEdd/E&KZDd/KE D]o]vP??? ???D]v^???U&}???Z&o}}?U,??}?Ud????? do?Z}vl(?  ~?????? r ???? /v??v? Z??Wll???X?}PX}?Pl??v??}???}vlu?}XZ?uo /v? &]P??? ???  }( ??? Index /v? /v? &]P??? &]P???X^v]?}?]vv?}?v?Z?P]}v ……………….. ?? &]P???X?]Pv??}??v??}?lv??]ou? …………….. ?? &]P???Xo}? r ??}(?}?v?o?]??]o? …………………………. ?? &]P???XZP]}v?~}? r ??????o?? ………………… ?? &]P???X,?uvv}v}u]?Z??]?Zo}(E?z}?l ]??v,??}?u??}??lu?l?? ………………. ?? &]P???X/v???P]}vo??v?]?]v?P??}v …………………………. ?? &]P???XE?,?v r ,??}? r ^??]vP.o?]ou? …………… ?? &]P???XW}?v?ov]??(}????? ………………………….. . ?? &]P???XW}?v?oo??v??}???  v?]Pvo}?}v? ………. ?? &]P????X&? oZ]PZ????v]vP}???u ………………… ?? &]P??  ??X^???]??v??}???}v(?v]vP}???u ……… ?? &]P????XW}??o?}vP?}??Z? ………………………….. ?? &]P????XW}??o?}vv?]??~???}v???????u]o ……. ?? &]P????Xvv?o?vu?o}?uv???? ………………………….. . ?? &]P????Xd??ou}?]v}uP?}?? ………………………….. ?? &]P????X}??}(o]?]vP?/W}? …………………………. ? ? &]P????XD]vZ}??Z}o ]v}u?v???o}l P?}?? ………………………….. ………………………….. …….. ?? &]P????X,}??Z}o?o}????9}(?Z?}????o?o? v???o}lP?}?? ………………………….. ……………… ?? &]P????XP]+?v???v?Z?P]}vv]?? u?v] ]?o]?? ………………………….. ……………………… ?? &]P????X]?ovo?o??v???o}lP?}?? ……… ?? &]P????X^o( r ]v?.?Zv]]??~E}v r ,]??v]v ,]??v]}vo? ………………………….. ……………………… ?? &]P????XW?v?P}(Z}??Z}o??Z?]??o?? …………. ??? &]P????XD?v]]?o?]?olv??}?l? …………………………. ??? &]P????XW}?v?o???v??ol??vv??]?ol? ??}?Puv? ………………………….. ………………… ??? &]P????X,]l]vP??]o?]v?Z?P]}v ………………………….. ….. ??? &]P????Xtol]vPv]l]vP}???u ………………………… ??? &]P????Xtol?}?u?}(?]??}ovE??]?]v ………. ??? /v? &]P??? ???  }( ??? &]P????X}oo]?]}v?]v?}o?]vP????]v?l?o]???  ??} ??? ………………………….. ………………………….. ……… ??? &]P????XW?}]o]??  }(?Z?????]u???? ………… ??? &]P????X}oo]?]}v?}v^??Z]PZ????]?Z????]v? ??]?u???vv?u? ………………………….. …. ??? &]P????Xd?v?]??]??Z]????v?}(oo  ?}?l??? ?o}(??]v ………………………….. ……………… ??? &]P? ???XZvP]v??v?]?u}?Z?}???u? ??v}uu???? ………………………….. ………………. ??? &]P????XW?v?}(}uu??????]vP??v?]?]v?o? ?P]}v?v]?? ………………………….. ……………….. ??? &]P????X,]??}?]o??]vv??}?l ………………………….. ……. ??? &]P????X,]??}?]o??uv??}?l ………………………….. ……. ??? &]P????X>}o???}??? ………………………….. ………………. ??? &]P????XW??vP???]????}???vPZ}?? …………………. ??? &]P????X}???????vP???]? ………………………….. …….. ??? &]P????X&?}??}?????} ………………………….. ……… ??? &]P????X,??}? r ????????v??}?l ………………… ??? &]P????X}???????vP???]? ………………………….. …….. ??? &]P????X&?}??}?????} ………………………….. ……… ??? &]P????XW??vP???]????}???vPZ}?? …………………. ??? &]P????Xd(???l?}?? ………………………….. ………………… ??? &]P????XW???v?]????]? ………………………….. …….. ??? &]P????X}???????vP???]? ………………………….. …….. ??? &]P????XW??vP???]????}???vPZ}?? …………………. ??? &]P????X^??]???Z?}(?}?o}??}(}???}v? ….. ??? &]P????X??P?l???]????  Zo( r Z}?? ………………. ??? &]P????X??P?l v??]????Zo( r Z}?? ……………… ??? &]P????XW ?v?}(?}?l??}uu??vP???}u}]o … ??? &]P????X:}?]v?}?v????]v??}?l? …………………… ??? &]P????XZvP]v??v?}(?}?l??}uu??vP? ??}}oU???? r ???? ………………………….. ……………. ??? &]P????XW?v?P}(?}?l]vP??]v???Z}?}?l]v ?Z?u?}?v ………………………….. …………………… ??? &]P????XZvP]v??v?P}(  ?}?l]vP??]v?? ?Z}?}?l]v?Z?u?}?vU???? r ???? …………… ??? &]P????X}uu??G}???]?Z]v}vv??? ……………….. ??? &]P????X:}?]v?}?v????]v??}?l?~????] ….. ??? &]P????X}uu??G}???}l(?}u?Z?P]}v ………………… ??? &]P????XZ}(????]???}?v …………………………. ??? &]P????X?????????8UD}v?U?W??D ……………… ??? &]P????X?????????8U&?]?U?W??WD …………………. ??? &]P????Xs}o?u?}?]????}?U???? ……………………… ??? &]P????Xs}o?u?}?]????}?U????~??}i? …….. ??? &]P????X^]???]?Zv}?uoo?Z]PZ]v???? ……….. ??? &]P????Xvv?o?}v?}(???l(?]PZ???8(?}u?Z ,??}?u??}? ………………………….. …………… ??? /v? do? ???  }( ??? &]P????Xvv?o?}v?}(???l(?]PZ? ??8?}?Z ,??}?u??}? ………………………….. …………… ??? &]P????Xvv?o?}v?}(???l(?]PZ??Z?}?PZ?Z ,??}?u??}? ………………………….. …………… ??? &]P????X&?]PZ??]oo]v?v???l?Z?}v^??  ?}? .. ??? &]P????Xv??o}vv? ???P]}v ………………………….. .. ??? do? do?XE?}vo??(}?uvP}o? ………………………….. …….. ? do?Xd?]o??}?}?v?? ………………………….. ……………………. ?? do?Xd?]ou]oPv???????}?v …………………………. ?? do?XZZ r (?v??}i??]v?Z?P]}v …………………….. ?? do?X&?oZ]PZ??(?v]vP???]?? }uu?v]??U???? r ? ??? ………………………….. ………… ?? do?X^dW r h???v?P}(ood/W r o]??(?v? …………. ?? do?XW?v?}(^dW r h?Z??]???}?v ……………… ?? do?X^dW r h(?v]vP?u?v]]?o]??  ~???? …………………. ?? do?X^dW r h(?v]vP?u? v]]?o]?????]? ……………… ?? do??X &????^dW r hW?}i??~????v}v?? ………….. ?? do??X>Kd/W??}i??(}????? ………………………….. ……… ?? do??XW?}i??]oo??v??}???}v(?v?? ?P]}v~?Z?}?PZ???? ………………………….. ………….. ?? do??XW?}i??]oo??v??}???}v(?v???? ……. ?? do??XW}??o?}v?u?v]]?o]?? ………………………….. …… ?? do??XP]???]??}v ………………………….. ………………….. ?? do??X^o( r ]v?.? ………………………….. ………………. ?? do??X,}??]vP??? ………………………….. ………………………. ?? do??Xs?ov?o???]vi??]?v?Z? …………………. ??? do??XK???vP??????(}??ZE?,?v r ^??]vP.o?]o}??]}? ………………………….. ……….. ??? do??Xu??l??]v?Uv}??Z}?v ………………………….. …. ??? do??Xu??l??]v?U?}??Z}?v ………………………….. …. ??? do??X}uu}v?}???v???o?u?~u]v???? u} ………………………….. ………………………….. …… ??? do??X&]? r ?}????}???}v?]v}vv??? ……….. ??? do??X????????}??? ………………………….. …………….. ??? do??X}uu?????}???}v?]v}vv??? ………… ??? do??X>}vP r ]??v????u]vo? ………………………….. .. ??? do??X>}?}v??]?Zo}vP r ]??v?????] ………….. ??? do??X????v?]?}???}v?]v}vv??? ……….. ??? do??XD?v]]?o]o r  r Z]???]o]v?oU?U v?u? ………………………….. ………………………….. ??? do? ???  }( ??? do??X ???????}??? ………………………….. ……………… ??? do??Xd}?}uu????v?}v?(}??}?l??(?}u?Z ?P]}v ………………………….. ………………………….. ….. ??? do??X&?v?}voo??].?}v}(?}? …………………….. ??? do??XW?lv?]o}??}(???}?Z?P]}v ……………… ??? do??XD?????uv?}v]?}v??}?v …………… ??? do??X?]P??u?v]]?o]?? ………………………….. ……… ??? do??X?]P??]?Z?}}???8]v???vP? ……………….. ??? do??Xd?]v?(?}uE?z}?l]???}?Z?P]}vU???? …… ??? do??Xd?]v?(?}u?Z?P]}v?}E ?z}?l]??U???? …… ??? do??Xd?]v?(?}u?Z?P]}v?}}??}vU???? …………….. ??? do??Xd?]v?(?}u}??}v?}?Z?P]}vU???? …………….. ?? ? do??Xd?]v?(?}uE?,?v?}t]oo]u???PU D??Z????U???? ………………………….. ………….. ??? do??Xd?]v?(?}ut]oo]u???PUD??Z?????} E?  ,?vU???? ………………………….. ………………. ???

Summary PM 2.5 Air Quality Conformity Determination May 2017

PM2.5 Air Quality Conformity Determination Page | 1 Emissions Results Summary REGIONAL AIR QUALITY EMISSIONS ASSESSMENT PM2.5 NAAQS for the Conn ecticut portion of the NY -NJ -CT PM2.5 Attainment/Maintenance Area May 201 7 The Clean Air Act Amendments (CAAA) of 1990 and the federal transportation regulations and legislation r ecognized the major contributions of transportation sources to the overall air quality problem evidenced throughout the country. To effectuate a reduction i n transportation – related emissions and a corresponding improvement in air quality, areas designated as non – attainment or maintenance for a criterion pollutant were required to demonstrate that their transportation plans, programs and projects contributed t o the attainment of National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS) and would not cause a new violation or delay attainment of the NAAQS . This process is referred to as Air Quality Conformity . The US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) promulgated national ambient air quality standards (NAAQS) for fine particulate matter in 1997. Fine particulate matter is referred to as PM2.5 and is a mixture of microscopic solids and suspended liquid solids in the air. It is formed directly as a by -product of combustion, such as smoke or automobile exhaust, or indirectly from chemical reactions in the atmosphere. Fairfield and New Haven Counties are included in the New York -New Jersey -Connecticut (NY -NJ -CT) P M2.5 non -attainment area. On April 17, 200 7 the Connecticut Department of Energy and Environmental Protection (CTDEEP) submitted a revision to the State Implementation Plan to establish interim progress for achieving the NAAQS for fine particulate matter and motor vehicle emission budgets. The annual emission budgets for the Connecticut portion of the NY -NJ -CT non -attainment area were determined to be adequate and are used in future analysis years. The EPA has also determined Connecticut’s PM2.5 attainment demonstration SIP to be administratively and technically complete as of January 8, 2009. Effective October 24, 2013, the Connecticut portion of the multi -state PM2.5 non -attainment area was re -designated as “attainment /maintenance.” EPA’s guidance for mai ntenance plans calls for a demonstration of continued compliance by showing that future emissions during the maintenance period will not exceed the level of emission in the attainment inventory. The end of the maintenance period is 2025. The Connecticut D epartment of Transportation is responsible for conducting the air quality emissions assessments for the metropolitan planning organizations in Connecticut. The CTDOT uses the statewide travel demand model to estimate vehicle miles of travel for various cla sses of highways and during various time periods. The future transportation network includes all planned improvement projects and is based on the complete implementation of the transportation improvement program (TIP) and the long range transportation plan s. The MOVES2010b emissions model is used to establish emissions budgets for the 2017 and 2025 analysis years. Emission estimates were developed for each scenario year using PM2.5 Air Quality Conformity Determination Page | 2 Emissions Results Summary MOVES2014a for direct PM2.5 and indirect PM2.5 emissions based on the estimate of NOx emissions, the most critical precursor of PM2.5. The conformity test requires the emissions from the future transportation system expected to be in place in 2017 to be less than the EPA -approved budget for 2017 and the emissions from the 2025 build scenario and subsequent years to be less than the 2025 budget. The emissions analyses were conducted for the following years: • 2013 – Attainment year • 2017 – Motor Vehicle Emissions Budget year • 2025 – Motor Vehicle Emissions Budget year; End maintenance per iod • 2035 – Interim modeling year • 2040 – Long range transportation plan horizon year The results of the quantitative emis sions analysis conducted by CT DOT are shown i n the following table and the analysis year trends are depicted in the charts following the table. CENTRAL NAUGATUCK VALLEY PLANNING REGION 2015 -2040 LONG RANGE TRANSPORTATION PLAN REGION EMISSIONS ANALYSIS RESULTS Fine Particulate Matter (PM 2.5 ) Annual NAAQS Connecticut Portion of the NY -NJ -LI -CT Area Direct PM 2.5 Emission Analysis NO x Emission Analysis Analysis Year Action SIP Budget Difference Action SIP Budget Difference 2018 Emissions 284.10 575.80 -291.70 7,192.70 12,791.80 -5,599.10 2025 Emissions 202.30 516.00 -313.70 4,361.80 9,728.10 -5,366.30 2035 Emissions 154.40 516.00 -361.60 2,726.30 9,728.10 -7,001.80 204 0 Emissions 144.60 516.00 -371.40 2,572.00 9,728.10 -7,156.10 PM2.5 Air Quality Conformity Determination Page | 3 Emissions Results Summary 0.00 100.00 200.00 300.00 400.00 500.00 600.00 700.00 2018 2025 2035 2040 Estimated Direct PM 2.5 Emissions by Analysis Year Compared to Approved EPA Budget CT Portion of the NY -NJ -LI-CT Attainment/Maintenance Area Estimated Direct PM 2.5 Emissions (Tons/Year) SIP Budget (Tons/Year) 0.00 2,000.00 4,000.00 6,000.00 8,000.00 10,000.00 12,000.00 14,000.00 2018 2025 2035 2040 Estimated NOx (Indirect) Emissions by Analysis Year Compared to Approved EPA Budget CT Portion of the NY -NJ -LI-CT Attainment/Maintenance Area Estimated Nox (Indirect) Emissions (Tons/Year) SIP Budget (Tons/Year)

Summary Ozone Air Quality Conformity Determination May 2017

Ozone Air Quality Conformity Determination Page | 1 Emissions Results Summary REGIONAL AIR QUALITY EMISSIONS ASSESSMENT OZONE NAAQS for the Connecticut portion of the New York -Northern New – Jersey -Long Island Ozone Nonattainment Area and the Greater Connecticut Ozone Nonattainment Area May 201 7 The Clean Air Act Amendments (CAAA) of 1990 and the federal transportation regulations and legislation r ecognized the major contributions of transportation sources to the overall air quality problem evidenced throughout the country. To effectuate a reduction in transportation – related emissions and a corresponding improvement in air quality, areas designated as non – attainment or maintenance for a criterion pollutant were required to demonstrate that their transportation plans, programs and projects contributed to the attainment of National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS) and would not cause a new violati on or delay attainment of the NAAQS . This process is referred to as Air Quality Conformity . Connecticut is divided into two non -attainment area for the 8 -hour ozone NAAQS , both are classified as “ Moderate ” non -attainment areas . Fairfield, New Haven and M iddlesex counties are included as part of the New York -Northern New Jersey -Long Island (NY -NJ -CT) non – attainment area. The remainder of the state is designated as the Greater Connecticut non – attainment area. In June, 2004, the EPA finalized the 8 -hour co nformity for Ozone non -attainment areas and the designated the Connecticut portion of the New York -Northern New Jersey -Long Island non – attainment area as a “moderate” non -attainment areas for the 8 -hour Ozone standard. Subsequent decisions by the EPA and r evisions to the approach for classifying non -attainment areas re -designated both of Connecticut ’s non -attainment area s as a “marginal” non – attainment area s with an attainment date of December 31, 2015. Based on 2012 -2014 air quality data, the EPA determined that Connecticut’s non -attainment areas did not attain ozone standards by July20, 2015. Both the Greater Connecticut and the New York -New Jersey -Long Island areas were reclassified as “Moderate,” eff ective June 3, 2016. The new attainment date for these two areas is July 20, 2018. The Connecticut Department of Transportation is responsible for conducting the air quality emissions assessments for the metropolitan planning organizations in Connecticut. The CTDOT uses the statewide travel demand model to estimate vehicle miles of travel for various classes of highways and during various time periods. The future transportation network includes all planned improvement projects and is based on the complete implementation of the transportation improvement program (TIP) and the long range transportation plans. The MOVES201 4a emissions model is used to calculate emissions from transportation travel . The 8 -hour budgets were developed jointly by CTDOT and CTDEEP . The budgets were found to be adequate by EPA and can be used in comparing future transportation -related emission to determine conformity. Ozone Air Quality Conformity Determination Page | 2 Emissions Results Summary The conformity test requires the emissions from the future transportation system to be less than the EPA -approved budgets for all analysis years. The emissions analyses were conducted for the following years: • 201 8 – New attainment year and near term analysis year • 2025 – Interim modeling year • 2035 – Interim modeling year • 2040 – Long range transportation plan horizon year The results of the quantitative emis sions analysis conducted by CT DOT are shown in the following tables and the analysis year trends are depicted in the charts following the tables. CENTRAL NAUGATUCK VALLEY PLANNING REGION 2015 -2040 LONG RA NGE TRANSPORTATION PLAN REGION EMISSIONS ANALYSIS RESULTS 8-Hour Ozone NAAQS Connecticut portion of the New York -Northern New Jersey -Long Island, NY -NJ – CT Ozone Nonattainment Area VOC Emission Analysis NO X Emission Analysis Analysis Year Action SIP Budget Difference Action SIP Budget Difference 201 8 Emissions 16 .56 27.4 0 -10 .84 22.39 54.6 0 -32 .21 2025 Emissions 12.3 3 27.4 0 -15.0 7 13.2 6 54.6 0 -41.3 4 2035 Emissions 7.2 6 27.4 0 -20.1 4 7.8 6 54.6 0 -46.7 4 2040 Emissions 6.6 8 27.4 0 -20.7 2 7.3 5 54.6 0 -47.2 5 1. A small reduction in VMT and emissions in the Greater Connecticut area will occur from the ECO program in the Connecticut portion of the NY -NJ -LI area due to travel between the areas. 2. VOC & NOx e mission s are in tons per summer day and are calculated using Connecticut’s vehicle mix . 3. HMPS 14 Functional Class system used. 4. National Low Emission Vehicle (NLEV) program included in 2008 and future years. 5. Eight Hour Ozone emission budgets effective June 27, 2008. 6. Series 31C with 20 iterations equilibrium assignment. Ozone Air Quality Conformity Determination Page | 3 Emissions Results Summary 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 2018 2025 2035 2040 Estimated VOC Emissions by Analysis Year Compared to Approved EPA Budget CT Portion of NY -NJ -LI-CT Non -Attainment Area Estimated VOC emissions (Tons/Day) EPA VOC Budget (Tons/Day) 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 2018 2025 2035 2040 Estimated NOx Emissions by Analysis Year Compared to Approved EPA Budget CT Portion of NY -NJ -LI-CT Non -Attainment Area Estimated NOx Emissions (Tons/Day) EPA NOx Budget (Tons/Day) Ozone Air Quality Conformity Determination Page | 4 Emissions Results Summary CENTRAL NAUGATUCK VALLEY PLANNING REGION 2015 -2040 LONG RANGE TRANSPORTATION PLAN REGION EMISSIONS ANALYSIS RESULTS 8-Hour Ozone NAAQS Greater Connecticut Non -Attainment Area VOC Emission Analysis NO X Emission Analysis Analysis Year Action SIP Budget Difference Action SIP Budget Difference 201 8 Emissions 15. 07 26.3 0 -11.23 19 .74 49.2 0 -29 .46 2025 Emissions 11.3 8 26.3 0 -14.9 2 11.8 6 49.2 0 -37.3 4 2035 Emissions 6.65 26.3 0 -19.6 5 6.9 1 49.2 0 -42 .29 2040 Emissions 6.1 5 26.3 0 -20.1 5 6.4 8 49.2 0 -42.7 2 1. A small reduction in VMT and emissions in the Greater Connecticut area will occur from the ECO program in the Connecticut portion of the NY -NJ -LI area due to travel between the areas. 2. VOC & NOx emissions are in tons per summer day and are calculated using Connecticut’s vehicle mix. 3. HMPS 14 Functional Class system used. 4. National Low Emission Vehicle (NLEV) program included in 2008 and future years. 5. Eight Hour Ozone emission budgets ef fective June 27, 2008. 6. Series 31C with 20 iterations equilibrium assignment. Ozone Air Quality Conformity Determination Page | 5 Emissions Results Summary 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 2018 2025 2035 2040 Estimated VOC Emissions by Analysis Year Compared to Approved EPA Budget Greater CT Non -Attainment Area Estimated VOC emissions (Tons/Day) EPA VOC Budget (Tons/Day) 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 2018 2025 2035 2040 Estimated NOx Emissions by Analysis Year Compared to Approved EPA Budget Greater CT Non -Attainment Area Estimated NOx Emissions (Tons/Day) EPA NOx Budget (Tons/Day)

PM 2.5 Air Quality Conformity Determination May 2017

1 Table of Contents Con n e ct ic u t Department of Transpo rta tion Ce nt ra l Naugatu ck Valley M etropolit an Plannin g Organiza tio n Grea ter Br idg epo rt Valley M etropolit an Plannin g Organi zatio n Sout h C ent ra l Re gion Me tropolit an Planni ng Organiza tio n Sout h W estern Re gio n Me tropolit an Plannin g Organi zatio n Hous atoni c Valley M etropolit an Plannin g Organi za tio n PM 2.5 Air Q u al ity C o n fo rm ity D eterm inati on of the 201 5 Region al Tra nspo rtation Plans and the FY 2018 -2021 Tra nspo rtation Im prove m ent Pr og ra m s A m endme nt s for the Connec ticut po rtio n of the NY -NJ-CT PM 2.5 Attainm ent/ Ma int enance Area May 2017 Note: The five Connecticut MPOs (CNVMPO, GBVMPO, HVMPO, SCRCOG and SWRMP O) are pa rt of the larger NY – NJ-CT PM2.5 Attainment/Maintenance Area and this do cume nt incl ud es the do cume ntation of the regional analysis for the entire Connecticut po rtion of the Attainm ent/Mainte nance area, as well as do cumentation and info rmation on the processes an d procedu res undertaken by CTDOT, coo rdinator of the Air Qua lity Con formity for the five Connecticut Met ropo litan Planning Org anizatio ns. 2 Table of Contents 1) Overview…………… … …………………………… ……………………… … … 4 2) Purpose and Need…… ……………………………… …………………… …….. 5 3) Conne ctic ut PM2. 5 Attainment Mai ntenance Area……………………………… 12 4) Interagency Consultation…………………………… ……….……… … …… …. 12 5) Public Consultation………………………………… …..… ………………… ….. 13 6) PM 2.5 Emission Analysis…………………………… ………….… .…… ………. 14 7) Connecticut PM2.5 Regional Emissions Analysis Compo nents………… … …… 15 8) Annu al Inventories for PM2.5………… ……………… ………….……… … ……. 15 9) VMT and Emission Analysis………………………… ……………… … ……… … 16 10) Analysis Results……… ……………………………… …………………………… 39 11) Conclusion………… ……………………………… ………………… …… … …… 40 3 Lis t of Tabl es Table 1: Adequate Motor Ve hicle Emission Budgets – MOV ES2 010 b……… … …… … …. 14 Table 2: List of Connecticut Ne twork Changes…… … …… … …… … ……… … …… … …. 17 Table 3: Direct PM2.5 and NOx Emissions Budget Test Results (tons per year )……… … … 40 Lis t of Figu res Figure 1: Connect icut Portion of the NY-NJ-CT PM 2.5 Attai nment/M aintenance Area… …… 10 Lis t of App endice s App endix A: Interagency Consultat ion Mee ting Minutes…… … …… …… ……… … …… … … 41 App endix B: PM2.5 and NOx Precursor Emission Outputs By Analysis Year………… … ……. 45 App endix C: PM2.5 Input Files to MOVES 2010 b………………… … …… ……… … …… … …. 47 App endix D: Acronyms……………………………………………………. .…… 104 4 R egio n al Em issions A na lysis 1) OVER VIEW In March 20 07, th e Me trop olitan Plann ing Organizations (M POs) in Conn ecticut proposed to up date th eir Long Range Tr anspo rtation Plans (LRTPs). These revision s to Con ne cticut’s LRTPs req uired a new multi-state transportation conf ormity de termination for fine particulate matte r (PM 2.5). Therefore, th e Novemb er 2006 NY-NJ -CT PM 2.5 no n-attainmen t area conf ormity determination was revised to reflect emission projections from th e new or revised, non -exempt projects in Conn ecticut ’s 200 7-2035 LRTPs. On April 17, 2007, the Conne cticut De partmen t of Energy and Environ ment al Prot ection (CTDEEP) submi tted to th e U.S. En viro nmen tal Prot ection Age ncy (EPA) its State Implemen tation Plan (SIP) Re vision for Establishment of Interim Progress for the Fine Particle National Am bien t Air Qual ity Standard (NAA QS) and early fine particulate (PM 2.5 ) transportation conformity emission budge ts. The SIP revision ide ntified year 2009 annu al direct PM 2.5 and annu al nitrogen oxides (NO x) M otor Ve hicle Emission Bud gets (M VE Bs) associa ted with the Interim/ Early Progress SIP. The annu al 2009 M VEBs for th e Conn ecticut portion of th e New Yor k-Northern New Jer sey-Long Island, NY-NJ-CT PM 2.5 Area we re 360 tons per year of dire ct PM 2.5 and 18,279 tons per year of NO x.1 Th ese emissi ons bu dgets were foun d adeq uate as of Jun e 20 , 2007 and were approved into the Con necticut SIP on August 30, 2007. The annu al 2009 mot or vehicle emissions bu dgets for the Con ne cticut portion of th e New Yor k- North ern New Jer sey-Long Island, NY-NJ-CT PM 2.5 Area were de termined adeq uate through a May 24, 20 07 letter from Anne E. Arn old, M anager Air Quali ty Planning Uni t, EPA New England Reg ional Office to Anne Go bin, Chief CTDEE P and a June 5, 2007 Federal Regist er Notice of Adeq ua cy. The adeq uacy pro cess ma de the MV EBs effe ctive June 20, 2007 for transportation con formity dete rminations. The annu al 2009 motor vehicle emissions bu dgets for th e Conn ecticut portion of the New Yor k- North ern New Jersey-Long Island, NY-NJ -CT PM 2.5 Ar ea we re app roved into th e Con ne cticut SIP through a direct final rulemaking Fed eral Register on August 30, 2007 (72 FR 50029). This SIP element “2009 Early Progress Direct PM 2.5 and NOx M otor Vehicle Emission Budgets (M VEB s) for Tran sportation Conformity Pu rposes; Conne cticut; New Yo rk-Northern New Jer sey-Lon g Island, NY -NJ-CT PM 2.5 Area” became effective on Octo ber 29, 20 07. On Decemb er 14, 2009, EPA ’s final rule desi gna ting areas for th e 2006 PM 2.5 NAAQS became effective. This Air Quality Conformity analysis is being prepared to meet bo th th e 1997 Ann ual PM 2.5 NAAQS and the 20 06 24 -hou r PM 2.5 NAAQS . 1 Lett er from U.S. EPA to Anne Gob in, Chief CTDE P, dated May 24 , 200 7. 5 This rep ort was prep ared to documen t th e emission s analysis that was com pleted to evaluate Fis cal Year 201 5-20 18 Conformity of th e Statew ide Transportation Improvemen t Program (STIP) Ame ndments and the 2015 LRTPs to the SIP for air quality. This submi ttal incorporates th e FY 2015 – 2018 STIP and 2015 LRTPs from Con ne cticut ’s Regional Planning Organi zations (R PO), and the 2017 and 2025 M OVES2 010b emi ssions budgets dee med ade quate by EPA and effective as of February 20, 20132. EPA’s guidance for mainten ance plans calls for a demo nstration of cont inue d compliance by s howing that futu re emi ssions du ring the mainte nance pe riod will not ex ceed the level of emi ssion in th e attainment inven tory. The en d of the mainten ance period was established as 20 25, consistent with th e CAA section 175A (a) requ iremen t that the plan provide for mainten ance of th e NAAQS for at least 10 yea rs after EPA formally approves the red es ignation req uest. Emi ssion estimate s were develope d for direct PM 2.5, as well as for th e most im portant PM 2.5 pre cursor NO x. Em issio ns are projected to dec rease from the levels in the 20 07 attainment inven tory th rough th e en d of th e mainten ance period in 2025, including in the selected inte rim year of 201 7, thu s prov iding for cont inuing mainte nance of th e NAA QS. The rep ort is sub mitt ed to sa tisfy th e req uirements of th e SIP, as revi sed. 2) PURPOSE AND NEED a – What is Transp or tation Conformity? Transportation Con formity is the process, establishe d by joint guidance from th e United States Department of Tran spo rtation (USDOT) and th e United States Env ironmen tal Prot ection Agency (EPA) that ensures that transportation investmen ts will con tribute to improv ing air qu ality in areas whe re concen trations of certain pollut ant s ex cee d national air quality stand ard s. Transportation conformity as it curren tly exists emerg ed from the passage of env ironmental and transportation leg islation in th e early 19 90s (Clean Air Act Amen dments of 1990 and the Int ermod al Surface Transportation Efficienc y Act of 19 91). EPA promulgated a transportation con formity rule initially in 1993. The latest amen dmen t to th e tran spo rtation conf ormity rule, Transportation Conformity Rule, Amen dmen ts to Implemen t Provisions Containe d in the Safe, Ac count able, Flexible, Efficient Transportation Eq uity Act: A Legacy for Users, Final Ru le was pu blished Janu ary 24, 20 08 (73 FR 44 20). Oth er rec en t con formity rules related to particulate matter include: PM 2.5 and PM 10 Hot -Spo t Analyses in Project-Level Transportation Con formity De termination s for th e New PM 2.5 and 2 Federal Register, February 15, 2013 . EPA-R01-OAR-201 3-0020 ; A-1-FRL -9776-2 Adequacy Sta tus of Motor Ve hicles Emission Budgets for Transportation Conformity Purposes; Connecticut http:/ /ww w.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/FR-2013 -02-05/pdf/2013-02492.pdf 6 Exi sting PM 10 National Ambient Air Qual ity Stand ards; Final Rule M arch 10, 2006 (71 FR 12468); Transportation Con formity Rule Amend men ts for th e New PM 2.5 National Am bient Air Quality Standard: PM 2.5 Precursors; Final Ru le M ay 6, 2005 (70 FR 24 280), [Note: On Jun e 1, 2005, (70 FR 31354), EPA pub lished a Fina l Rule correc tion effective June 6, 2005 for Transpo rtation Conformity Rule Amen dme nts for the New PM 2.5Nation al Am bient Air Qua lity Standa rd: PM 2.5 Precurso rs]; and, Transportation Conformity Rule Am end men ts for the New 8-hour Ozone and PM 2.5 National Am bien t Air Quality Standards and M iscellaneou s Revisions for Ex isting Areas; Transportation Conf ormity Rule Amend ment s: Res ponse to Court Decision and Addition al Ru le Ch an ges; Final Rule July 1, 2004 (69 FT 40004). Re cently E PA pub lishe d Transportation Conformity Ru le PM 2.5 and PM 10 Amend men ts, Final Rule March 24, 201 0 (75 FR 1425 9-14 285). Transportation Conformity rulemaking action s can be foun d on EPA’s Office of Transpo rtation and Air Quali ty we b s ite at URL add ress: htt p://www .epa.gov/o taq/statere sou rces/trasconf/con f-regs .htm Transportation con formity wor ks in th e following way:  EPA establishes Nation al Am bient Air Quality Standards (NAAQ S) ba sed on pu blic health research. The standard s set maxim um concentrations of six criteria pollut ants in the am bient (outdo or) air.  EPA designates parts of th e cou ntry where th e NAAQS are ex ceede d as a “non- attainmen t area.” States th at have non -attainment areas with in th eir bo und aries are req uired to submi t State Im plemen tation Plans (SIPs) to EPA to demon strate how the non-attainment areas will im prove the ir air quality and meet th e NAAQS in the tim eframe spe cified by the Clean Air Act.  Non-attainment areas must conf orm their tra nspor tation plans, programs and projects to th eir area’s mot or vehicle emissio ns bu dget that is containe d within its SIP. If a sta te does no t yet have SIP emi ssions bu dgets in place, interim emi ssion tests must be pas sed to show conf ormity. Un der th e Conformity Rules, th e following test for PM 2.5 and NOx must be me t:  TEST: Emissions from fut ure Action Scenarios from 20 17 on, must be less than th e 2017 Mo tor Ve hicle Emission Budg ets  TEST: Emissions from fut ure Action Sc enarios from 2025 on, must be less th an the 2025 Mo tor Ve hicle Emission Budg ets 7 To do this, MPOs use a model create d by the EPA th at applies emission factors to th e region ’s vehicle flee t. These emissi on factors are combined with vehicle miles traveled data, which is gen erated by an MPO’s travel deman d model. The trav el de man d mod el uses the region’s highway networ k, estimated trav el con ditions and demographic data to es tima te where trips begin and end. It is im portant to note th at th e transportation con formity de termination is based on the mix of new and ex isting projects and th e current infrastructure. Some projects, par ticularly highway capacity expansions, may be individually de leterious to air qu ality but are offset by be neficial initiatives such as new transit projects and engineering imp rovem ents th at mitiga te local congestion or red uce vehicular travel. The conformity regulations rec ognize th is balance betwee n projects that increase and red uce emissions by req uiring that M POs de monstrate that the overall set of investmen ts moves th e reg ion to ward cleane r air, in kee ping with EP A policies. b – Ba ckground on Fi ne Pa rticulate Matter ( PM 2.5) Fine particulate matte r, also called PM 2.5, is a mixture of microsco pic solids and liquid droplets su spen ded in air, where th e size of the particles is equal to or less than 2.5 micrometers (abou t one-thirtieth th e diamet er of a huma n hair). Fine pa rticles can be emitted direc tly (such as smoke from a fire, or as a componen t of auto mobile exhaust) or be forme d indirectly in the air from powe r plant, ind ustrial and mobile sour ce emissio ns of gases such as sulfur dioxide and nitrogen oxides. The health eff ects associa ted with exposure to fine pa rticles are serious. Sc ien tific stu dies ha ve shown significant a ssociations between eleva ted fine particle levels and premature death . Effects associated with fine particle exposure include ag grav ation of resp iratory and card iovas cular disease (as indicated by increased hospital admissions, emergency ro om visits, absences from school or wor k, and restricted activity da ys), lung disea se, dec reased lun g function, as thma attac ks, and certain card iovas cular problems such as heart attac ks and card iac arrhythmia. W hile fine particles are un healthy for anyone to breath e, peo ple with heart or lung disease, asth matics, olde r adults, and children are es pecially at ris k. c – PM 2.5 National Ambient Air Quality Standard s In July 1997, EPA issue d NAAQS for PM 2.5, designed to prot ect th e pu blic from exposure to PM 2.5 at levels that may cause he alth problem s. The stand ard s include an annu al standard set at 15 microgra ms per cub ic meter, bas ed on the th ree year average of ann ual PM 2.5 8 concent ration s and a 24-hour standard of 65 mi crograms per cubic meter based on the thre e- year average of 24 -hou r concentrations. In gene ral, areas nee d to mee t both standards to be cons ide red to attain PM 2.5 NAAQS. Ar eas not mee ting the PM 2.5 NAAQS are called PM 2.5 non -attainmen t areas. These areas have had or con tribu ted to PM 2.5 levels higher than allowed und er the N AAQS. No n-attainmen t areas are subject to transportation con formity, through wh ich local transportation and air quality officials coordinate plann ing efforts to en sure that transportation projects do no t hinde r an area’s ability to reach its clean air goals. Transportation conf ormity requiremen ts become effective on e year after an area is designated as a no n-attai nment area. EPA issued official designations for the PM 2.5 standard on Decemb er 17, 2004 and mad e mod ifications in April 2005. On April 5, 2005, de signations un der the nation al air qu ality standards for fine particle pollution or PM 2.5 became effective. Th erefore, by April 4, 200 6, all PM 2.5 non-attainment areas we re req uired to implemen t transpo rtation con formity. Under the EPA designation, non -attainmen t areas are req uired to me et the PM 2.5 NAAQS as soon as pos sible, but no later th an 2010. EPA may gran t attainmen t date extensions of up to five years in areas with mo re se vere PM 2.5 problems and where emissions cont rol measures are no t availa ble or fea sible. EPA has de termined that mee ting the PM 2.5 NAAQS nationwide will ann ually prevent at least 15,000 premature deaths; 75,000 cases of chronic bronchitis; 10,000 hospital admissions for respiratory and cardiova scular disease; hund red s of tho us and s of occurrences of ag grava ted asthma; and 3.1 million pers on-days of missed work due to sympt oms rel ated to particle pollut ion exposure. On April 17, 2007, Connecticut Dep artment of Environ ment al Prote ction submi tted a SIP Re vision for 200 9 Early Progress Direct PM2.5 and NOx M oto r Vehicle Em ission Budg ets fo r Transportation Conformity Purposes; Connecticut; New York -Northern New Jersey -Long Island, NY-NJ -CT PM2.5 Ar ea. (Se e http://www.regulations.gov search on docket number EPA -R01 – OAR – 2007 -0373). States with designated PM 2.5 non -attainmen t areas had to submi t SIPs that out line how the y will me et the PM 2.5 NAAQS within th ree years of April 5, 200 5. On Nov ember 18, 2008 CTDEE P sub mitt ed a SIP Rev ision “Attainmen t Demo nstration for th e 199 7 Ann ual PM 2.5 Nation al Am bient Air Quality Standard for the Con ne cticut portion of the New Yor k-No rthern New Jersey-Long Island, NY-NJ-CT PM 2.5 Non -attainmen t Area”. EPA dete rmine d Con ne cticut’s PM 2.5 attainmen t demonstration SIP to be admi nistratively and te chn ically com plete on Janu ary 8, 2009. 9 On Octobe r 17, 2006, EPA issued a final rule which tighte ned th e 24-ho ur PM 2.5 NAAQS from the 1997 level of 65 mi crograms per cubic meter (ug/ m3) to 35 ug/m 3 (71 FR 611 44). In this final rule, EPA retained the 1997 ann ual PM 2.5 NAA QS of 15.0 ug/m3. EPA ’s final rule designating non-attainment areas for the 20 06 PM 2.5 NAAQ S, pu blishe d in the Fe deral Reg ister on Nov em ber 13, 20 09, was effective Decemb er 14, 2009. A MPO and the U.S. Department of Transportation (U.S.DOT) must ma ke a conf ormity determination with regard to the 2006 PM 2.5 NAAQS for the metrop olitan transportation plan and TIP with in on e year after the effective date of the initial non-attai nme nt designation for this NAAQS, as stated in 40CFR Part 93, “Transportation Conformity Rule PM 2.5 and PM 10 Ame ndments; Final Rule”, dated M arch 24, 2010. On June 22, 2012, CT DE EP submitte d a “PM 2.5 Redesignation/ M ainte nance State Implemen tation Plan” which establishe d new Mo tor Vehicle Emission Budgets for 20 17 and 2025 using new EPA req uired software, M OVES 2010b. These budgets were dee med adequ ate by EPA and effective as of Feb ruary 20, 2013. M onitoring da ta show that th e NY-NJ-CT multi-state area has achieved com plia nce with bot h th e 1997 annu al and 2006 24-hour PM 2.5 NAAQS since 2009. On Novemb er 15, 20 10, EP A pu blished a formal de termination that the NY -NJ-CT multi-state area had achiev ed mea sured attainmen t of the 1997 annu al PM 2.5 NAAQS. EP A pu blished a similar finding for th e 2006 24 – hour PM 2.5 NAAQS on Dec ember 31, 20 12. DEEP monitoring data also ind icate that Conn ecticut com plies with th e 2012 ann ual NAA QS. On June 22, 2012, DE EP formally submi tted to th e EPA, th e final PM 2.5 red esignation reque st and maint enance plan State Implemen tation Plan (SIP) for Connecticut’s portion of th e NY -NJ – CT PM 2.5 Non attainmen t Area. The plan demo nstrated that Conn ecticut’s air quality met bot h th e 19 97 annual and the 2006 24 -ho ur PM 2.5 NAAQS due to a combination of national, region al and local cont rol measures im plemen ted to red uce emissions and presented a mainten ance plan th at ensures con tinu ed attainmen t th rough th e year 202 5. On Sept emb er 24 , 2013, EP A pu blished its approv al of th e PM 2.5 red es ignation req uest, establishing Octobe r 24, 2013 as the effective date of redesignation to attainment/ mainte nance for Conn ecticut’s portion of the NY – NJ -CT Area for bot h the 1997 ann ual and 2006 24-hour PM 2.5 NAAQS. This report was prepared to show conf ormity for th e 1997 Ann ual PM 2.5 NAAQS and the 2006 PM 2.5 24 -hou r NAAQS by me eting new M OVES2 010b 2017 and 2025 mot or vehicle bu dgets as discus sed above. 10 The Me trop olitan Planning Organ izations (M POs) with in this area are as follows: 1. Sou th We ste rn Regi on M etropoli tan Pla nning Organi zation (SWRM PO) 2. Housat onic Valley M etropoli tan Pla nning Org anization (HVMPO) 3. Central Nauga tuck Valley M etropo litan Planning Organ ization (CNV M PO) 4. Greater Bridgeport Valley M etropolitan Planning Or ganization (GBVM PO) 5. Sout h Cent ral Region Me trop olitan Plann ing Organization (SCRM PO) Figure 1 bel ow shows the Connecticut count ies include d in th e PM 2.5 attainment /maint enance area . Figure 1: Connecticut Portion of the NY -NJ-CT PM 2.5 Attainment /Ma intenance Area 11 d – PM 10 Attain me nt/M aintenance Area EPA previou sly designated the City of New Hav en as No nattainmen t with respect to the Nation al Ambien t Air Quali ty Stand ard s (NAAQS) for particulate matter with a nominal diamet er of ten microns or less (PM 10). The PM 10 Nonattainmen t statu s in New Hav en was a local problem stemming from activities of several busines ses located in the Stiles Stree t section of th e City. Numero us violation s in the late 1980’s and early 19 90’s of Se ction 22 a-174-18 (Fugitive Dust) of CTD EEP re gulations in that se ction of the city led to a no nattainmen t des ignation (CTDE EP, 1994: Narrative Con necticut De partment of En ergy and Env iron mental Prot ection, State Implemen tation Plan Re vision For PM 10, March 19 94). Corrective a ction s were subseq uen tly iden tified in th e State Implemen tation Plan and implemen ted, with no violation s of the PM 10 NAAQS since the mid-1990’s. All construction activities un dertaken in the City of New Haven are required to be performed in com plia nce with Section 22 a-174-18 (Con trol of Particulate “Emissions”) of the CTDEE P regulation s. All reasonable available con trol measures must be implemente d du ring construction to mitiga te particulate matt er emi ssions, including wind -blow n fugitive dust, mud and dirt carry out , and re-en traine d fugitive emi ssion from mobile eq uipmen t. Th e projects contained in th e STIP and Plans, designated wi thin the City of Ne w Haven, are exp ected to have little effect on the overall projected vehicle mi les of trav el for the area and are not exp ected to cause significant add itional air borne particulat e matter to be generated. Th e transportatio n projects initia ted in Ne w Hav en are not designed to enh ance developme nt in th e area. There fore, th e projects und ertaken in this area will no t hav e a detrimental effect on PM 10 in Ne w Haven . On October 13 , 200 5, EPA pub lished in the Federal Regis ter (Vol. 70, No. 197 ), approval of a requ est by CTDEE P for a Limited Mai ntenance Plan and redesignatio n of th e Ne w Haven No nattai nme nt Area to Attainme nt for th e National Ambient Air Quality Stand ards for PM 10. This direct final rule became effective on De cembe r 12, 2005. As with limited mainten ance plans for oth er po llut ants, emissions bud gets are con sidered to satisfy transportation con formity’s “b udget test”. However, fut ure “p roject level” conf ormity determination may req uire “h ot spot ” PM 10 analy ses for new tran spo rtation projects with significant die sel traff ic in ac cordance with EPA’s Final Rule for “PM 2.5 and PM 10 Hot -Spo t Analyses in Pro ject-level Transportation Conformity Rule PM 2.5 and PM 10 Amend men ts; Final Rule (75 FR 42 60, M arch 24, 2010) which beca me eff ective on April 23, 20 10. 12 3) CON NECTICUT PM 2.5 ATTAIN M ENT M AIN TENANCE AREA The New Jersey – New York – Conn ecticut multi-state non-attainment area was des ignated by EPA beca use th is region’s air quality fails to me et th e ann ual PM 2.5 NAAQS. As EPA Ne w England has det ermined th e M OVES2010 b 2017 and 2025 moto r vehicle emissio ns bu dgets sub mitt ed on June 22, 2012 to be adequ ate for transportation conform ity purposes, the emissio ns analysis in this repo rt will be limited to these areas only and the bu dgets effective as of February 20, 2013. The non-attainment areas un der th e 2006 PM 2.5 24 -hou r NAAQS are the same as unde r the 1997 PM 2.5 non -attainmen ts areas. Since the 1997 PM 2.5 non -attainmen t area has an adequ ate bu dget, E PA states th at to be consistent with the Clea n Air Act, the areas must mee t the bu dget test for th e 20 06 PM 2.5 NAAQS using existi ng ade quate or approved SIP bu dgets for th e 1997 PM 2.5 NAAQS. Effective Octo ber 24, 2013, the Connecticut portion of the New Jersey – New York – Conne cticut multi-state PM 2.5 No n-Attainmen t Areas were red esignated as Attainmen t M ainten ance. 4) IN TERAGEN CY CO NSULTATION An Int eragency Consultation M ee ting was he ld onFebruary 7, 2 0 17 to review th e air quality codes for projects fun ded in th e regions ’ Transpo rtation Im provemen t Plans and the 2015 Lon g Range Tran spo rtation Plans. The mee ting also discussed the analysis years to be mode led. The project Air Quality coding is as follows: CC – Con formity Analysis Complete d M – Mod eled in the Dep artmen t’s highway or transit networ ks NM – Requ ires mod eling and will be included int o th e De partmen t’s highw ay and transit networks prior to conf ormity analysis NRS –a highway or tran sit project on a fac ility that does no t ser ve reg ion al nee ds or is not normally include d in th e regional travel simulation model and does not fit int o an exem pt project category in Table 2 or 3 of th e Final Rule (40 CFR 93). RS – Regio nally significant refers to a t ransportation project in th e TIP and /or STIP (othe r than an exemp t project) that is on a fac ility which ser ves regional tran sportation nee ds (su ch as access to and from th e area out side of th e region , major activity centers in the regio ns, major p lanne d devel opm ent such as new retail malls, sports complexes, etc., or 13 transportation terminals as well as most terminals themselves) and would normally be included in the mode ling of a metrop olitan area’s tran spo rtation networ k, includ ing at a mi nim um all principal arterial highways and all fixed guide-way transit facilities th at offer an alternative to regional high way tra vel (40 CFR 93.101). Once a pro ject is iden tified as region ally si gnificant , it must be include d in th e analysis regar dless of fun ding source. Ex em pt Project – a project listed in Table 2 or 3 of the Final Rule (40 CFR 93) th at primarily enh ances safet y or aesthe tics, maint ains mass tran sit, con tinu es curren t levels of ridesharing, or bu ilds bicycle and ped estrian facilities . X6 – Project exem pt from the req uirement to de termine con formity und er 40 CFR 93.126 X7 – Project ex empt form regi onal emission s analysis requiremen ts unde r 40 CFR 93.127 X8 – Traffic synchron ization projects may be app roved, funde d and im plemente d withou t satisfying conf ormity requ iremen ts un der 40 CFR 93.128 It was agreed up on that the 201 1 vehicle reg istration data file wo uld be utilized for this Conformity De termination a nd CTDEEP and CT DOT staff would discuss u pdate of this file at a May 2016 me eting . A copy of th e mi nut es of th e Int eragency Consultation Mee ting is includ ed in Appen dix A, as well as a list of attende es and call-in participants. The final emissions analysis was prepared and th e rep ort was distribu ted for th e 30 -day pub lic commen t period. 5) PUBL IC CONSULTA TION As req uired by the Final Ru le, the transportation confo rmity pro cess must includ e public consultation on th e emissio ns analysis and conf ormity dete rmination for PM 2.5 determinations. This includ es posting of releva nt document ation and analysis on a “c learingho use” we bpage maintaine d th rou gh the interagency consultation process. All M POs in the Conn ecticut PM 2.5 non-attainmen t area must provide thirty-day pu blic commen t pe riods and address any commen ts receive d. For th is PM 2.5 transpo rtation conf ormity determ ina tion , all Conn ecticut M POs will hold a thirty-day pub lic commen t peri od. 14 6) PM 2.5 EM ISSIONS AN AL YSIS As stated above, EPA has foun d that the 20 17 and 2025 M VEBs in th e Jun e 22, 2012 Conne cticut SIP re vision are adequ ate for transportation con formity purposes and effective as of February 20, 20 13. Table 1 shows th e M OVES2010 b M VE Bs for 2017 and 202 5. Table 1: Adequate M oto r Vehi cle Emission s Bud gets – M OV E20 10b Direct PM 2 .5 NOx (Tons/Year) (Tons/Year) Ye ar 201 7 MVEBs for the Connecticut 57 5.8 12,791 .8 porti on of the New York- Northern New Jersey-, Lo ng Island, NY-NJ-CT PM 2.5 Area Ye ar 202 5 MVEBs for the Connecticut 51 6.0 9,728 .1 porti on of the New York- Northern New Jersey-, Lo ng Island, NY-NJ-CT PM 2.5 Area The PM 2.5 bu dget emissions are th e am oun t to which projected fut ure emissions resulting from implemen tation of Plans and TIPs will be compared. Per 75 FR 14271, as the non-attainment bound ary for th e 2006 Conn ecticut portion of the NY – NJ -CT PM 2.5 Non -attainmen t Ar ea is exactly th e same as th e 1997 PM 2.5 boun dary, th e bu dget test for th e 20 06 PM 2.5 NAAQS must use th e existing adequate or app roved SIP bu dgets for the 1997 PM 2.5 NAA QS. EPA regu lations require that emissions analysis be cond ucted for spec ific analysis years. Se ction 93.119(g) of the Final Rule states th at the se analysis years must include :  Attainmen t or near term year  The last (horizon) year of th e region s’ lon g range transportation plan  An int ermed iate year or years such that the analysis ye ars are no more than 10 years apart 15 The attainmen t year is based up on the Clean Air Act section 172(a)(2) which states that the attainmen t year for the 2006 PM 2.5 areas will be 2014, five years after th e eff ective date of des ignations (December 14, 2009). The year 20 17 is also with in five years (nea r-term) of the year in which th e analysis is being perfo rme d (2015). Furthermore, because th is attainment /mainte nance area includes multiple MPOs, the last year of all of the M PO s’ Plans must be include d as analy sis years. W ith in the Co nn ecticut PM 2.5 attainmen t area, the plan horizo n year is 2040. Int ermed iate years of 2025 and 2035 have be en selected so that no two- analysis years are more than 10 years apart. Th erefore, the analysis years for this conf ormity determination are 2017, 2025, 203 5 and 2040. 7) CON NECTICUT PM 2.5 RE GIO NAL EM ISS IONS ANAL YSIS CO M PONEN TS PM 2.5 emissions can result from bot h direct and indirect sources. Ga soline and diesel on -road vehicles em it bot h direct PM 2.5 and oth er gases that react in the air to form PM 2.5 . Direct PM 2.5 emissio ns can result from particles in exhaust fume s, from brake and tire we ar, from road du st kicke d up by vehicles, and from highway and transit construction. Ind irect PM 2.5 emissio ns can result from one or more of several exhaust com pone nts, including nitrogen oxides (NOx), vola tile orga nic compoun ds (VO Cs), sulfur oxides (SO x), and ammonia (NH3). For the region al analy sis of direct PM 2.5 emissions, EPA has ruled th at bot h exhaust and brake/tire we ar must be include d. However, EPA has also ruled that emissio ns analysis for direct PM 2.5 sho uld includ e ro ad du st only if road dust is foun d to be a significant contribut or to PM 2.5 by either the EPA Regio nal Admi nistrator or a state air quality age ncy. For the Conne cticut PM 2.5 no n-attainmen t area, ne ithe r th e EPA Region al Admi nistrators nor th e state air quality agency have found that road dust is a significant PM 2.5 contribut or. For th e regional analysis of indirect PM 2.5 emission s (also called PM 2.5 precursor s), EPA has iden tified fou r poten tial transportation-related PM 2.5 precursors: NO x, VO Cs, SO x, and NH3. The only indirect PM 2.5 compo nen t that nee ds to be considered in th e Con necticut PM 2.5 non – attainmen t area is NO x. 8) ANNUAL IN VENTO RIES FOR PM 2.5 Bec ause th e multi-state PM 2.5 non-attainment area did no t me et th e ann ual PM 2.5 NAAQS, the emissio ns analysis for PM 2.5 cons idered ann ual emi ssions. Gu ida nce from EPA (dated Nov em ber, 2015) presen ted two possible op tions for deve lop ing an ann ual invento ry before a SIP is develope d: using a typical seas onal day or an annual inve nt ory th at is based on mon thly es timtes. The twelve-mont h app roach for the Conn ecticut PM 2.5 no n-attainmen t area was utilize d. 16 9) VEHICLE M ILES OF TR AVEL AND E M IS SIONS ANALYSIS Ve hicle M iles of Tra vel (VMT) estimates we re de ve lop ed from th e Conne cticut Department of Transportation’s (CTDO T’s) statewide network-bas ed travel model sup plemen ted by off-mode l analysi s. The 20 15 travel model networ k, to th e exten t practical, represen ts all state highways and major conn ecting non-state streets and roads as well as th e rail, local bu s and express bus systems th at current ly exist. Future highway ne two rks for 2018, 2020, 2025 and 20 30 and transit networ ks for 2016, 2020, 2030 and 2040 we re bu ilt by adding STIP, TIP and LRT P projects (prog ramme d for op ening after 2 015) to th e 2015 ne twor k. Th ese networ ks we re used to run trav el models and cond uct emi ssions analysis for the years 20 18, 2025, 2035 and 2040. Ta ble 2 lists th e projects for ea ch mod el analy sis year for wh ich ne two rk cha nges we re req uired. 17 TABLE 2 LIST OF NETWORK CHANGES 2018 NETWORK CHANGES NEW MPO DESCRIPTION LANES PROJECT NUMBER FROM TO HIGHWAY NAME TOWN IMPROVEMENT CAPITAL REGION 0131 -0190 Remove Bridge Number 00518 Reconstruct 10/322 Intersection 1/1 0/0 ROUTE 10 SOUTHINGTON CCD 11/2017, TIP BRIDGE REMOVAL GREATER BRIDGEPORT 0015 -TMP1 Realignment of Lafayette Circle and establishment of bidirectional traffic on Fairfield Avenue 0/1 1/1 LAFAYETTE CIRCLE BRIDGEPORT CCD 2017, TIP REALIGNMENT 0036 -0184 Main Street Derby from Bridge Street to Route 8 South Exit15 On/Off Ramps (Ausonio Street) 1/1 2/2 ROUTE 34 DERBY CCD 2018, TIP WIDENING HOUSATONIC VALLEY 0034 -0347 State Route 806 (Newtown Road) from Old Newtown to Plumtrees & from Eagle to Industrial Plaza, Danbury – Widening from 1 lane each direction to 2 lanes each direction 1/1 2/2 SR 806 NEWTOWN ROAD DANBURY CCD 2016, TIP SOUTH CENTRAL 0079 -XXXX Multiple lane and directional changes in the center of town. Conversion of multiple one way streets to two ways. Conversion of a two way street to one way. Reduction of one lane in each direction for one street CCD 2018, TIP VARIOUS WEST MAIN STREET MERIDEN DIRECTIONAL AND LANE CHANGES 18 TABLE 2 LIST OF NETWORK CHANGES (CONT’D) 2018 NETWORK CHANGES NEW MPO DESCRIPTION LANES PROJECT NUMBER FROM TO HIGHWAY NAME TOWN IMPROVEMENT SOUTH CENTRAL (CONT’D) 0092 -0531 Q Bridge Replacement and demolition; Contract E 3/3 5/5 I-95 CCD 2016, TIP NEW HAVEN BRIDGE REPLACEMENT 0092 -0532 Q Bridge Replacement and demolition; Contract B 3/3 5/5 I-95 CCD 2016, TIP NEW HAVEN BRIDGE REPLACEMENT 0092 -0627 Q Bridge Replacement and demolition; Contract B2 3/3 5/5 I-95 CCD 2016, TIP NEW HAVEN BRIDGE REPLACEMENT 0092 -XXXX Removal of North Frontage Road between State Street & Orange Street 1/1 0/0 NORTH FRONTAGE ROAD NEW HAVEN CCD 2016, TIP ROADWAY REMOVAL 0100 -0175 Project to widen Sackett Point Road from 1 lane to 2 lanes CCD 2018, TIP 1/1 2/2 SACKETT POINT ROAD NORTH HAVEN WIDENING 19 TABLE 2 LIST OF NETWORK CHANGES (CONT’D) 2018 NETWORK CHANGES NEW MPO DESCRIPTION LANES PROJECT NUMBER FROM TO HIGHWAY NAME TOWN IMPROVEMENT SOUTH WESTERN 0102 -0325 Addition of a through lane on Route 1 Northbound from France Street to Route 53 1/1 1/2 ROUTE 1 NORWALK CCD 2018, TIP WIDENING 0135 -0301 Reconstruction of I -95 off ramps and Atlantic Street in vicinity of Metro North Railroad Bridge No. 08012R 2/2 3/3 ATLANTIC STREET STAMFORD WIDENING CCD 2018, TIP GREATER BRIDGEPORT 0138 -0211 Addition of a through lane on Route 1 Southbound from Nobel Street to Soundview Avenue 1/2 2/2 ROUTE 1 STRATFORD CCD 2018, TIP WIDENING CENTRAL NAUGATUCK VALLEY 0017 -0182 Addition of a second through lane on Route 6 Eastbound from Carol Drive (Mix Street/Brook Street) to Peggy Lane (Camp Street) 1/1 2/1 ROUTE 6 BRISTOL WIDENING CCD 2018, TIP 20 TABLE 2 LIST OF NETWORK CHANGES (CONT’D) 2020 NETWORK CHANGES NEW MPO DESCRIPTION LANES PROJECT NUMBER FROM TO HIGHWAY NAME TOWN IMPROVEMENT CAPITAL REGION 0051 -0259 Interchange improvements at Routes 4, 6, and 9 including a new EB C/D Roadway N/A I84/RT4/RT6 FARMINGTON BID 12 -31 -08, CCD 2019, TIP INTERCHANGE BSWY 0063 -0703 Relocation and Reconfiguration of Interchange 29 on I-91; New additional lanes Rte. 15 NB from 2 to 3 lanes exit 90 to 0.5 miles beyond Exit 91 3/3 4/3 I-91, EXIT 29 HARTFORD WIDENING CCD 2020 Long Range Plan 0155 -0156 Add an Operational Lane WB between Interchanges 42 & 39A; Add an Operational Lane EB between Interchanges 40 & 41 CCD 2018 3/3 4/4 I-84 WEST HARTFORD OPERATIONAL LANES CENTRAL NAUGATUCK VALLEY 0151 -0273 Interstate 84 2/2 3/3 I-84 CCD 11/2020, TIP WATERBURY WIDENING 0151 -XXXX TIGER Grant includes various roadway changes including reconstruction/extension of Jackson Street. Extension will meet at Freight Street and continue to West Main N/A 1/1 DOWNTOWN AREA WATERBURY ADDED ROADWAY CCD 2019, Long Range Plan 21 TABLE 2 LIST OF NETWORK CHANGES (CONT’D) 2020 NETWORK CHANGES NEW MPO DESCRIPTION LANES PROJECT NUMBER FROM TO HIGHWAY NAME TOWN IMPROVEMENT GREATER BRIDGEPORT 0015 -HXXX Reconstruct and widen Route 130 from Stratford Avenue bridge to Yellow Mill bridge 1/1 2/2 ROUTE 130 BRIDGEPORT Long Range Plan WIDENING 0124 -0165 **As of 2/15/2011current scope from consultant is spot improvements for from Swan Avenue to Franklin Street Project Manager** Bank Street from West Street to North Main St is full scope being reviewed by consultant 1/1 2/2 ROUTE 67 SEYMOUR MAJOR WIDENING Long Range Plan 0124 -XXXX Between Interchange 22 and 23 to improve access N/A ROUTE 8 Long Range Plan SEYMOUR INTERCHANGE 0124 -XXXX Realign interchange with new extension of Derby Road N/A ROUTE 8 SEYMOUR Long Range Plan INTERCHANGE 0126 -XXXX Interchange 11 – Construct new SB entrance ramp, Widen Bridgeport Avenue N/A ROUTE 8 SHELTON Long Range Plan MAJOR WIDENING 22 TABLE 2 LIST OF NETWORK CHANGES (CONT’D) 2020 NETWORK CHANGES NEW MPO DESCRIPTION LANES PROJECT NUMBER FROM TO HIGHWAY NAME TOWN IMPROVEMENT GREATER BRIDGEPORT (CONT’D) 0126 -XXXX Between Huntington Avenue and Constitution Boulevard 1/1 2/2 ROUTE 714 SHELTON Long Range Plan MAJOR WIDENING NEW MPO 0138 -0248 Reconstruct Interchange 33 on I -95 to provide full interchange from partial to full diamond interchange N/A I-95, EXIT 33 STRATFORD INTERCHANGE RECONSTRUCTION CCD 2020, Long Range Plan HOUSATONIC VALLEY 0008 -XXXX Operational Improvements on White Street at Locust Avenue and Eighth Avenue 1/1 1/2 WHITE STREET DANBURY CCD 2020, Long Range Plan WIDENING 0096 -0204 Addition of a through lane on Route 34 EB from Wasserman Way to Toddy Hill Road. Addition of I -84 WB and EB on -ramp from Route 34 WB 1/1 2/1 ROUTE 34 NEWTOWN WIDENING CCD 2020, TIP SOUTH CENTRAL 0092 -XXXX Intersection Improvements at Route 69 and Pond Lily Avenue N/A ROUTE 69 NEW HAVEN Long Range Plan INTERSECTION IMPROVEMENTS 23 TABLE 2 LIST OF NETWORK CHANGES (CONT’D) 2025 NETWORK CHANGES NEW MPO DESCRIPTION LANES PROJECT NUMBER FROM TO HIGHWAY NAME TOWN IMPROVEMENT CAPITAL REGION 0042 -0317 Removal of the Cambridge Street to Route 2 Westbound On -Ramp and the Sutton Avenue to Route 2 Eastbound Off -Ramp. New through lane on Main Street Northbound underneath Route 2 at the approach to the Route 2 Westbound Off -Ramp 0/1 0/2 ROUTE 2 EAST HARTFORD WIDENING CCD 2021, TIP 0055 -0142 Addition of a second through lane on Route 20/189 Westbound from Route 10/202 to Route 20 and Route 189 split. Addition of a second through lane on Route 20 Westbound from Hungary Road to Route 10/202. Addition of a second through lane on Route 10/202 Northbound from Route 189 to Route 20/189. VARIOUS ROUTE 10 & 202 GRANBY WIDENING CCD 2022, TIP LOWER CT RIVER VALLEY 0082 -0316 Reconfiguration and realignment of Route 17 On – Ramp onto Route 9 from Main Street. Removal of the Harbor Drive to Route 9 Northbound On -Ramp N/A ROUTE 17 MIDDLETOWN INTERCHANGE RECONFIGURATION CCD 2025, TIP 0082 -0318 Removal of a through lane on Route 9 Southbound from just North of Miller Street to just South of Washington Street. Route 9 access to Washington Street/DeKoven Drive has been limited to an on – ramp to Route 9 Southbound. N/A ROUTE 9 MIDDLETOWN REMOVE LANE CCD 2021, TIP 24 TABLE 2 LIST OF NETWORK CHANGES (CONT’D) 2025 NETWORK CHANGES NEW MPO DESCRIPTION LANES PROJECT NUMBER FROM TO HIGHWAY NAME TOWN IMPROVEMENT SOUTHEASTERN Addition of a second through lane on Route 85 Northbound from just North of Chesterfield Road to just South of Deer Run. CCD 2024, TIP 1/1 2/1 0120 -0079 ROUTE 85 MONTVILLE WIDENING SOUTH WESTERN 0102 -0358 Reconfiguration of the interchanges between Route 7, Route 15, and Main Avenue. These changes include multiple new and reconfigured on and off ramps designed to allow access to and from all three major roadways CCD 2025, TIP N/A ROUTE 7 AND ROUTE 15 NORWALK INTERCHANGE RECONFIGURATION 25 TABLE 2 LIST OF NETWORK CHANGES (CONT’D) 2028 NETWORK CHANGES NEW MPO DESCRIPTION LANES PROJECT NUMBER FROM TO HIGHWAY NAME TOWN IMPROVEMENT SOUTHEASTERN ROUTE 82 Removal of a through lane on Route 82 Eastbound from just West of Pine Street to just West of Fairmont Street N/A NORWICH REMOVE LANE CCD 2027, TIP 26 TABLE 2 LIST OF NETWORK CHANGES (CONT’D) 2030 NETWORK CHANGES NEW MPO DESCRIPTION LANES PROJECT NUMBER FROM TO HIGHWAY NAME TOWN IMPROVEMENT CAPITAL REGION VARIOUS TOWNS New Haven/Hartford/Springfield Rail Service Governor’s Transportation Initiative Long Range Plan N/A NEW COMMUTER RAIL 0109 -XXXX New Britain Avenue Cooke Street to Hooker Street 1/1 2/2 PLAINVILLE Long Range Plan ADD LANE CENTRAL NAUGATUCK VALLEY 0080 -0128 Add auxiliary lanes at Int. 17 and on Routes 63/64 1/1 2/2 I-84, Routes 63 -64 Long Range Plan MIDDLEBURY/WATERBURY WIDENING GREATER BRIDGEPORT 0036 -0179 Interchange 18 – Construct New NB entrance ramp. N/A ROUTE 8 Long Range Plan ANSONIA INTERCHANGE 27 TABLE 2 LIST OF NETWORK CHANGES (CONT’D) 2030 NETWORK CHANGES NEW MPO DESCRIPTION LANES PROJECT NUMBER FROM TO HIGHWAY NAME TOWN IMPROVEMENT GREATER BRIDGEPORT (CONT’D) 0036 -XXXX Route 8 Interchange 16 and 17; Construct new NB ramps. Close old ramps N/A ROUTE 8 DERBY Long Range Plan INTERCHANGE 0126 -XXXX Interchange 14 – Construct new SB entrance ramp N/A ROUTE 8 Long Range Plan SHELTON INTERCHANGE HOUSATONIC VALLEY 0018 -0124 South of Old State Road to Route 133 1/1 2/2 US 202 Long Range Plan BROOKFIELD WIDENING 0034 -0288 From Kenosia Avenue easterly to I -84 (Exit 4) 1/1 2/2 ROUTE 6 Long Range Plan DANBURY ADD LANES 0034 -XXXX From I -84 (Exit 2) East to Kenosia Avenue 1/1 2/2 ROUTE 6 Long Range Plan DANBURY ADD LANES 0034 -XXXX From Route I -84 (Exit 6) Northerly to Jeanette Street 1/1 2/2 ROUTE 37 DANBURY Long Range Plan ADD LANES 28 TABLE 2 LIST OF NETWORK CHANGES (CONT’D) 2030 NETWORK CHANGES NEW MPO DESCRIPTION LANES PROJECT NUMBER FROM TO HIGHWAY NAME TOWN IMPROVEMENT HOUSATONIC VALLEY (CONT’D) 0034 -XXXX Between Interchanges 3 and 4.Between Interchanges 12 and 13 3/3 4/4 I-84 DANBURY, NEWTOWN, SOUTHBURY Long Range Plan ADD LANES 0034 -XXXX Widen Kenosia Avenue from Backus Avenue to Vicinity of Lake Kenosia 1/1 2/2 DANBURY ADD LANES Long Range Plan 0034 -XXXX Widen Backus Avenue from Kenosia Avenue to Miry Brook Road 1/1 2/2 DANBURY ADD LANES Long Range Plan 0034 -XXXX From South Street northerly to Boughton Street; 1/1 2/2 ROUTE 53 Long Range Plan DANBURY ADD LANES 0034 -XXXX From Route 53 (Main Street) northerly to I -84 (Exit 6) 1/1 2/2 ROUTE 37 DANBURY Long Range Plan ADD LANES 0096 -XXXX New Road across Old Fairfield Hills Hospital Campus, From Route 6 South to Route 860 0/0 1/1 NEWTOWN NEW ROAD Long Range Plan ADD LANES 29 TABLE 2 LIST OF NETWORK CHANGES (CONT’D) 2030 NETWORK CHANGES NEW MPO DESCRIPTION LANES PROJECT NUMBER FROM TO HIGHWAY NAME TOWN IMPROVEMENT SOUTH CENTRAL 0014 -XXXX East Haven Town Line to Alps Road (Echlin Road Private) 2/2 2/3 ROUTE 1 BRANFORD Long Range Plan WIDENING 0014 -XXXX Route 146 to Cedar Street 2/2 2/3 ROUTE 1 Long Range Plan BRANFORD WIDENING 0014 -XXXX Cedar Street to East Main 1/1 1/2 ROUTE 1 Long Range Plan BRANFORD WIDENING 0014 -XXXX East Main to 1 -95 Exit 55 1/1 1/2 ROUTE 1 Long Range Plan BRANFORD WIDENING 0014 -XXXX I-95 Exit 55 to Leetes Island Road 1/1 1/2 ROUTE 1 Long Range Plan BRANFORD WIDENING 0059 -XXXX Bullard Road extension to Route 77 0/0 1/1 BULLARD RD Long Range Plan GUILFORD WIDENING 30 2030 NETWORK CHANGES NEW MPO DESCRIPTION LANES PROJECT NUMBER FROM TO HIGHWAY NAME TOWN IMPROVEMENT SOUTH CENTRAL (CONT’D) 0059 -XXXX State Street to Tanner Marsh Road 1/1 1/2 ROUTE 1 Long Range Plan GUILFORD WIDENING 0061 -XXXX Washington Avenue to Route 40 2/2 2/3 ROUTE 10 Long Range Plan HAMDEN WIDENING 0061 -XXXX Route 40 to Todd Street 2/2 2/3 ROUTE 10 Long Range Plan HAMDEN WIDENING 0061 -XXXX Todd Street to Shepard Avenue 1/1 2/2 ROUTE 10 Long Range Plan HAMDEN WIDENING 0061 -XXXX River Street to Cheshire Town Line 1/1 2/2 ROUTE 10 Long Range Plan HAMDEN WIDENING 0061 -XXXX Olds Street (Hamden) to Sackett Point Road 1/1 2/2 ROUTE 5 Long Range Plan HAMDEN, NORTH HAVEN WIDENING 31 TABLE 2 LIST OF NETWORK CHANGES (CONT’D) 2030 NETWORK CHANGES NEW MPO DESCRIPTION LANES PROJECT NUMBER FROM TO HIGHWAY NAME TOWN IMPROVEMENT SOUTH CENTRAL (CONT’D) 0073 -XXXX New Rail Station near Salemme Lane in Orange N/A ORANGE CCD 2030 Long Range Plan NEW RAIL STATION 0079 -XXXX Wallingford Town Line to Olive Street (Route 71) 1/1 2/2 ROUTE 5 Long Range Plan MERIDEN WIDENING 0083 -XXXX From West of Old Gate Lane to Gulf Street/Clark Street to Route 1 1/1 2/2 ROUTE 162 MILFORD Long Range Plan WIDENING 0092 -0649 Long Wharf access Plan Widen I -95 (in separate project), Eliminate Long Wharf Drive to expand park, add new road from Long Wharf Drive VARIES NEW HAVEN Long Range Plan 0092 -XXXX From Route 63 to Landin Street 1/1 2/2 ROUTE 69 Long Range Plan NEW HAVEN, WOODBRIDGE WIDENING 0092 -XXXX From Dayton Street (NH) to Landin Street (Wdbg) 1/2 2/3 ROUTE 63 Long Range Plan NEW HAVEN, WOODBRIDGE WIDENING 32 TABLE 2 LIST OF NETWORK CHANGES (CONT’D) 2030 NETWORK CHANGES NEW MPO DESCRIPTION LANES PROJECT NUMBER FROM TO HIGHWAY NAME TOWN IMPROVEMENT SOUTH CENTRAL (CONT’D) 0098 -XXXX From East Haven Town Line to Doral Farms Road and Route 22 to Guilford Town Line 1/1 1/2 ROUTE 80 NORTH BRANFORD Long Range Plan WIDENING 0106 -XXXX From West Haven Town Line to US 1 1/1 2/2 ROUTE 162 Long Range Plan ORANGE WIDENING 0148 -XXXX From South Orchard Street. to Ward Street and Christian Road to Meriden Town Line 1/1 2/2 ROUTE 5 WALLINGFORD Long Range Plan ROUTE 5 0148 -XXXX From Route 71 overpass South of Old Colony Road to Route 68 1/1 1/2 ROUTE 150 WALLINGFORD Long Range Plan ROUTE 5 0156 -XXXX Route 1 to Elm Street 1/1 2/2 ROUTE 122 Long Range Plan WEST HAVEN WIDENING 0156 -XXXX Campbell Avenue to Orange Town Line 1/1 2/2 ROUTE 1 Long Range Plan WEST HAVEN WIDENING 33 TABLE 2 LIST OF NETWORK CHANGES (CONT’D) 2030 NETWORK CHANGES NEW MPO DESCRIPTION LANES PROJECT NUMBER FROM TO HIGHWAY NAME TOWN IMPROVEMENT SOUTH CENTRAL (CONT’D) 0156 -XXXX Elm Street to Greta Street 2/2 2/3 ROUTE 162 Long Range Plan WEST HAVEN WIDENING 0156 -XXXX Bull Hill Ln to Orange Town Line 1/1 2/2 ROUTE 162 Long Range Plan WEST HAVEN WIDENING VARIOUS TOWNS New Haven/Hartford/Springfield Rail Service Governor’s Transportation Initiative Long Range Plan N/A NEW COMMUTER RAIL SOUTH WESTERN 0035 -XXXX Add Lane from Stamford Exit 8 to Darien Exit 10, Operational Lane 3/3 4/4 I-95 Darien -Stamford Long Range Plan WIDENING 0102 -0269 Upgrade to full interchange at Merritt Parkway (Route 15) BID 01 -09 -08 N/A US 7/RT 15 NORWALK CCD 2030, Long Range Plan UPGRADE EXPRESSWAY 0102 -0297 East Avenue from the vicinity of the I -95 Ramps southerly to the vicinity of Van Zant Street 1/1 2/2 EAST AVE #1 NORWALK WIDENING Long Range Plan 34 TABLE 2 LIST OF NETWORK CHANGES (CONT’D) 2030 NETWORK CHANGES NEW MPO DESCRIPTION LANES PROJECT NUMBER FROM TO HIGHWAY NAME TOWN IMPROVEMENT SOUTH WESTERN (CONT’D) 0102 -0312 Reconstruction of Interchange 40 Merritt Parkway and Route 7 (Main Avenue). Breakout of 0102 -0269 Phase 1 N/A ROUTE 7/15 NORWALK UPGRADE EXPRESSWAY CCD 2030, Long Range Plan 0102 -XXXX Express Bus/BRT between Norwalk and Greenwich N/A NORWALK -GREENWICH Long Range Plan BRT 35 TABLE 2 LIST OF NETWORK CHANGES (CONT’D) 2040 NETWORK CHANGES NEW MPO DESCRIPTION LANES PROJECT NUMBER FROM TO HIGHWAY NAME TOWN IMPROVEMENT GREATER BRIDGEPORT 0015 -XXXX New Rail Station near Barnum Street in Bridgeport N/A NEW RAIL STATION CCD 2040 Long Range Plan 36 The PM 2.5 inpu t file int o MO VES20 14a for each analysis year con sisted of “annual ave rag e” scenari o. All mont hs were selected for an “a nnual avera ge” evaluation. Approp riate minim um/ma ximu m temp eratures were emp loyed, as well as annu al average FUEL RVP, SPEE D VMT, and DIESEL SULF UR values. Annu al emission facto rs we re ob taine d for each coun ty by roadway clas sifica tion. In add ition, mod el run s incor por ate th e effect of the Emp loyer Commut e Opt ions (EC O) Program in Sou th west Co nn ecticut (Fairfield County). In respo nse to federal leg islation , Conne cticut has restructured the ECO program to emph as ize volunt ary participation , combine d with positive incent ives, to encourage emp loyees to rideshare, use transit and con tinu e to expa nd the ir trip red uction activ ities. In addition , th e program has bee n mad e available to all employers. It is felt that this pro cess is an effective me ans of achieving Connecti cut’s clean air targe ts. Fund ing of this effort und er th e Congestion M itigation and Air Quali ty Improvemen t (CM AQ) prog ram is included in th e TIP for FY 2018 -2021 . It is es timat ed th at this prog ram, if fully succes sful, could red uce VM T and mob ile source emi ssions by 2% in Sout hwest Conne cticut. It should be noted that TIP and LRT P projects, which have negli gible imp act on trip distribu tion and/or highway capacity, have not been incorporated into th e network. These includ e, bu t are not lim ited to, geo me tric improveme nts of existing interchanges, short section s of climbing lanes, interse ctio n improveme nts, transit projects dealing wi th equ ipme nt for existing faciliti es and vehicles, and transit operating assistance. Essentia lly, those projects that do no t im pact th e travel demand forecasts are not includ ed in the netwo rk and/ or analysis. The ne two rk-ba sed travel mo del used for this analysis is the mod el th at CTDOT utilizes for transportation planning, programming and design req uiremen ts. This travel demand mode l u ses demograp hic and land use as sumptions based on the 2010 Census po pulation and C onne cticut Dep artmen t of Labor 201 0 employmen t estimates. Pop ulation and employ men t projection s for th e years 2020, 203 0 and 2040 were de velope d by th e Connecticut De partmen t of Transpo rtation, Travel Deman d and Air Quality M od eling Unit and app roved by all th e regio nal planning agenc ies in early 2012. Th e model uses a constrained equ ilibrium app roa ch to alloca te trips among links. The model was cali brated using 20 13 groun d counts and 20 13 HPM S VM T data. Pe ak hour directio nal traffic volume s were estimated as a percentage of the Average Dail y Traffic (ADT) on a link-by-link basis . Based on automatic traffic recorder data, 9.0 percent, 8.5 percent, 8.0percent and 7.5 percent of th e ADT occurs during the fou r highest hours of the day. A 55:4 5 directio nal split was assumed. Hourly volume s were then converted to Service Flow Levels (SF L) and Vo lume to Capacity (V/ C) ratios calculat ed as follows: 37 SF L = DHV/PHF*N VC = SFL / C whe re: DHV = Directio nal Hourly Vo lume PHF = Peak Hour Factor = 0.9 N = Number of lanes C = Capacity of lane Pe ak pe riod spee ds were estimated from th e 2000 Highway Capacity M anu al based on th e design spee d, facility class, area type and calculat ed V/ C ratio. On th e expresswa y system, Conne cticut- based free flow speed data was av ailable. This data was deeme d more app ropriat e and sup erse ded the ca pacity ma nual speed value s. The ex press way free flow speeds were upd ated in 2005 . For th e off – peak hours, traffic volume is not the controlli ng facto r for vehicle speed. Off-peak link spee ds were based on the Highway Capacity M anual free flow spee ds as a function of facility class and area type. As before, Conn ecticut-based speed data was sub stit uted for exp ressway trav el, whe re availa ble, and was als o updated in 200 5. Two special cas es exist in th e trav el demand modeling process. The se are centroid conn ectors and intrazonal trips.  Centroid conn ectors represe nt the local roads used to gain access to th e model netwo rk from centers of activity in each traffic analysis zon e (TAZ). A spee d of 25 mph is ut ilized for these links.  Intrazonal trips are trips that are too sho rt to get on to the model network. VM T for intrazonal trips is calculat ed based on th e size of each ind ividu al TAZ. A speed of 20 to 24 mph is utili zed for peak period and 25 to 29 mph for off – peak. Th e Dail y Vehicle M iles of Travel (DVM T) is calculat ed using a methodolo gy based on disaggreg ate spee d and summ arized by inventory area, fun ctional classificatio n, and spee d. The annual VM T and speed profiles de veloped by this process are then combined with the em ission factors from th e M OVES 2014 a model to produ ce emission estimates for each scenario and time frame . M OVES 2014 a PM 2.5 and NOx ann ual emis sions by County ma y be found in App end ix B. Th e M OVES 2014 a inpu t files are in App end ix C. Appendix D lists va rious ac ronyms used in the repo rt. In all cas es the transportatio n program and plan meets the requ ired conform ity tests:  For years 201 7 to 2024, Direct PM 2.5 in th e Conn ecticut portion of th e Ne w Yo rk-No rthern Ne w Jerse y-Lo ng Isl and attai nme nt/maintenance area must be less than 575.8 ton s per year. 38  For years 2017 to 2024, NOx in th e Conn ecticu t portio n of the Ne w Yo rk-No rthern Ne w Jerse y-Lo ng Isl and attai nme nt/maintenance area must be less than 12 ,791.8 tons per year.  For year 2025 and sub se qu ent years, Direct PM 2.5 in th e Conn ecticut portion of th e Ne w Yo rk-No rthern Ne w Jers ey-Lo ng Isl and attai nment/maintenance area must be less than 516.0 tons pe r year.  In year 2025 and sub sequ ent years, NOx in th e Conne cticut portio n of th e Ne w Yo rk- No rthern Ne w Jersey -Lo ng Isl and attai nme nt/maintenance area must be less than 9,728.1 tons pe r year. This analysis in no way reflects th e full benefit on air quality from th e transportatio n plan and program . The network-based modeling process is capable of as sessing the impact of majo r ne w highway or transit ser vice. It does not reflect the impact from th e many projects, which are categ oricall y ex clud ed from th e requ irement of confo rm ity. These projects includ e nu mer ous im provements to inters ections, which will allow traffic to flow more efficiently, thu s redu cing de lay, fue l usa ge and emissions. Includ ed in the TIP, but not reflected in this analysis , are many projects to maintai n existing rai l and bu s systems . Wi thout these projects, those system s could not offer th e high level of ser vice the y do . W ith them, the mas s transit systems fun ctio n more efficiently, improve safety, and provide a more dependable and aestheticall y app eali ng servi ce. These advantages will retai n existing patrons and attract add itio nal riders to the system . Th e techno logy to quantify the air quality benefits from these program s is not currently availa ble. As sho wn in this analysis, tra nsportatio n emiss ions are de clining dramati call y and will continu e to do so. This is primarily du e to programs such as reform ulat ed fuels, enhanced inspectio n and maintenance programs , stage two va por recovery (area source), the low emissions veh icles (LEV) program , and th e Tier 2 / Sulfur-in-Ga s redu ctio n program . M OVES2014a includes there new em iss ion control program s ass ociated with regulation promulgated since the re lea se of M OVES2010b:  Tier 3 emiss ion standar ds that phase in beginning in 2017 for cars , light-duty truck s, m edium -du ty pass enger vehicles, and some hea vy-duty trucks, and Tier 3 fuel standards th at re quire lower sulfu r gas oling beg inning in 2017 .  Hea vy-du ty engine and vehicle greenhouse ga s (GHG) re gulations that phase in during model years 20 14-2018.  The second phase of light-dut y vehicle GHG re gulations that phase in for mo del 39 year s 2017 -20 25 cars and light truck s. M OVES2014a estimates exhaust and evapo rative emissions as well as brake and tire wear emission s from all type s of on-road vehicles. M OVES2014a also uses a vehicle classification system based on the way vehicles a re clas sified in th e FHW A’s High way Performance M on itoring Sy stem (HPMS). Other parameters include vehicle miles traveled (VMT ) by vehicle and road type, vehicle hou rs traveled (VHT) by vehicle and road type, the numbe r of each type of vehicle in th e fleet, vehicle age distribut ion , model year, travel spe ed, roadway type, fuel information , meteor ological data, such as ambient tempe ratur e and hu midity, and applicable cont rol measures such as reformulated gasoline (RFG) and inspe ction and mainten ance (I/M ). Local inpu ts were coo peratively developed by CTDE EP and CTDOT, where app lica ble, using EP A Recomme nde d methods .3 Changes in th e transportation system will not produ ce significant emiss ions redu ctions be ca use of the massive ex isting rail , bus, highway systems , and land development already in place. Ch ange in these aspects is always at the mar gin, producing very small impacts. 10) ANAL YSIS RESUL TS As part of th e red esignation request, th e State submi tted a mainte nance plan as req uired by se ction 175A of the Clean Air Act. Elemen ts of th e section 175A mainte nance plan includ e a con tingency plan and an obliga tion to submit a sub sequ ent mainte nance plan revision as req uired by th e Clean Air Act. The PM 2.5 maint enance plan also establishes 2017 and 2025 M VEBs for the Ar ea. Con necticut is establishing 2017 MV EBs of 575.8 to ns per year (tpy) for direct PM 2.5 and 12,79 1.8 tp y for NOX, and 2025 M VEBs of 516 tpy for direct PM 2.5 and 9,728.1tp y for NOX, for the Sout hwestern CT Ar ea for mainten ance of th e 19 97 ann ual and 2006 24 – hour PM 2.5 standards. The emissions analysis re sults for the Connecticut portion of the Ne w Yo rk-No rthern Ne w Jerse y-Lo ng Island multi-state attainment/mainte nance area are presen ted in Table 3 on the next pa ge. 3 “MOVE S201 4 and MOVES2 014a Technical Gui dance: Us ing MOV ES to Prepare Emission Inventori es for State Impl eme ntation Pla ns and Tra nsport ation Con formity”, EPA-42 0-B-15-093. November 2015 40 Table 3: Direct PM 2.5 and NOx Emission Budget Test Results (tons per year) Series 31C Bud gets Difference Ye ar Direct PM 2.5 NO x Direct PM 2.5 NO x Direct PM 2.5 NOx 2018 284.1 7,192.7 575 .8 12, 791. 8 -291.7 -5,599.1 202 5 202.3 4,361.8 516 .0 9,728. 1 -313.7 -5,366.3 203 5 154.4 2,726.3 516 .0 9,728. 1 -361.6 -7,001.8 204 0 144.6 2,572.0 516 .0 9,728. 1 -371.4 -7,156.1 11) CON CLUSION This em issions analy sis transpo rtatio n conform ity has been dem onstrated for th e Conn ecticut portio n of the NY -NJ-CT PM 2.5 Attai nment/Mai ntenance Ar ea based upon the direct PM 2.5 and the NOx emis sion bud ge ts for 2017 and 20 25 effective as of February 20, 2013 . The region has attained National Am bient Air Qualit y Sta nd ards and EP A pub lished its approva l of th e PM 2.5 redesignatio n reque st, establishing October 24, 2013 as the effective date of redesignatio n to attai nme nt for Conn ecticut ’s portio n of th e NY-NJ-CT Area for both th e 1997 annual and 2006 24- hour PM 2.5 NAA QS. Pleas e direct any questions you ma y have on the air quality emission analysis to: Conn ecticut Department of Transportatio n Bureau of Policy and Pla nn ing Division of Coo rdina tio n, M odeling and Crash Data – Unit 5753 1 2800 Berlin Turnp ike Ne wi ngton, CT. 06111 (860) 594-2032 Ema il: Jud y.Raymond @ ct.go v 41 APPE NDIX A Inte ragency Consultation Me eting Minutes 42 IN TERAGEN CY CONSU LTATION MEETI NG Stat ewide T ransport ation Impro vement Program Co nne cticut Departm ent of Transportat ion Ro om 2307 – February 7 , 20 17 Go To Meeting Atten dees : Eloise Powell – FHW A Ken Shooshan-Stoller, FHW A Leah Sirmin – FTA Ariel Garcia – EPA Je nnifer Carrier – CRCO G C a r a R a d z i n s – CRCOG R o b A l o i s e – CRC OG Mark Nielson – CN VMPO Christian Meyer – CN VMP O Ben Muller – CNVMPO Meghan Sloan – CT Metro COG Robert Haramut – LCRV CO G Stephen Dudley –SCRCOG Chris Rappa – SCRC OG Ri cha rd Guggenheim – SECC OG Kate Rattan – SECCOG Rob Sachnin – W es tern COG Mari beth W ojenski – CTDOT Ju dy Raymond – CTDO T Robbin Cabelus – CTDOT Roxane Fromson – CTDOT Grayson W right – CTDO T Sara Radacsi – CTDO T Matthew Cegielski- CTDOT Rya n Dolan – CTDOT Greg Pacelli – CTDOT Kara Chandler – CTDOT 43 Th e Interagency Consu ltation Meeting was held to review projec ts su bmitted for the 2018 – 2021 STIP. Both the Ozo ne and PM 2.5 reports will be elect ronica lly distributed to the MPOs in the appropriate Nonattainment/Maintenance areas, FTA, FHW A, DEE P an d EP A. The MP Os will nee d to hold a 30 da y public comm ent and review period. At the end of this review period , the MP O will h old a Policy Board meeting to endorse the Air Quality Con formity determination. There was also a brief discuss ion on the trav el mo del an d emissions software planning assumptions emp loyed in the conform ity analysis. Th e sch edule for the 2018 -2021 Regional Transp ortation Impro vem ent Plans Conform ity Determina tion Analysis is as follow:  MPOs transmit signed and dated Concurrence Form to judy.raymond@ ct.gov by F e b r u a r y 1 0 , 201 7.  CTDOT Travel Demand Model Unit perform s the air quality analysis an d se nds the Air Qu ality Conformity Determina tion Reports electronica lly to all MPOs in e a r ly s umme r 20 17  MPOs adve rtise and hold a 30 -da y public rev iew an d co mm ent pe riod for the Air Qu ality Conformity.  MPOs hold a Policy Board meeting approving an d endo rsing the Air Quality Conformity and transmit resolutions to judy.raymond@ct.gov after Policy Board meeting . It is importan t tha t all MPOs follow this schedule to ensu re that the TIP/STIP Con formity Determ inations can go forward on schedule. 44 PLANNING ASSUMPTIONS Ozone and PM2.5 2018 -2021 Statewide Transportation Improvement Program February 7, 2017 Planning Assumptions for Review Frequency of Review * Responsible Agency Year of Data Socioeconomic Data At least every 5 years CTDOT 2010 Census Data available 2012 DMV Vehicle Registration Data At least every 5 years CTDEEP 2011 Data available 2012 State Vehicle Inspection and Maintenance Program Each conformity round CTDEEP Same as currently approved I&M SIP State Low Emission Vehicle Program Each conformity round following approval into the SIP CTDEEP Same as SIP VMT Mix Data At least every 5 years CTDEEP 2010** Analysis Years – PM 2.5 Each conformity round CTDOT/CTDEEP 2018, 2025, 2035, 2040 Analysis Years – Ozone Each conformity round CTDOT/CTDEEP 2018, 2025, 2035, 2040 Emission Budget – PM2.5 As SIP revised/updated CTDEEP 2017 / 2025 PM 2.5 Emission Budget – Ozone As SIP revised/updated CTDEEP 2009 SW 2017 Gr.CT Temperatures and Humidity As SIP revised/updated CTDEEP X Control Strategies Each conformity round CTDEEP X HPMS VMT Each conformity round CTDOT 2013 * Review of Planning Assumptions does not necessarily prelude an update or calibration of the travel demand model. ** Data not available until 2011 45 APPE NDIX B PM 2.5 A ND NOx PR ECURSOR EM ISSION OUTPUTS BY ANALYSIS YE AR 46 MOVES2014a 2018 County Summary: County Total Energy Consumption Pollutant Emission Quantities (Tons/Day) 91 NOx PM 2.5 (Joules/Day) 3 110 116 117 County Oxides of Nitrogen Engine Exhaust Breakwear Tirewear Total Fairfield 4.11827E+16 3586.62256 106.55599 24.77817942 11.09023355 142.42441 New Haven 4.09128E+16 3606.08619 107.63560 23.09482299 10.93306084 141.66348 Totals 8.20955E+16 7192.70875 214.19159 47.87300 22.02329 284.08789 MOVES2014a 2025 County Summary: County Total Energy Consumption Pollutant Emission Quantities (Tons/Day) 91 NOx PM 2.5 (Joules/Day) 3 110 116 117 County Oxides of Nitrogen Engine Exhaust Breakwear Tirewear Total Fairfield 3.52662E+16 2160.90967 64.00689 26.31050899 11.59185784 101.90926 New Haven 3.53198E+16 2200.86379 64.07627 24.81785853 11.5051571 100.39929 Totals 7.0586E+16 4361.77346 128.08316 51.12837 23.09701 202.30855 MOVES2014a 2035 County Summary: County Total Energy Consumption Pollutant Emission Quantities (Tons/Day) 91 NOx PM 2.5 (Joules/Day) 3 110 116 117 County Oxides of Nitrogen Engine Exhaust Breakwear Tirewear Total Fairfield 2.96699E+16 1311.95123 35.35190 28.14450918 12.16987 75.66628 New Haven 3.1165E+16 1414.39240 36.81089 29.27745982 12.63104337 78.71939 Totals 6.08349E+16 2726.34363 72.16278 57.42197 24.80091 154.38567 MOVES2014a 2040 County Summary: County Total Energy Consumption Pollutant Emission Quantities (Tons/Day) 91 NOx PM 2.5 (Joules/Day) 3 110 116 117 County Oxides of Nitrogen Engine Exhaust Breakwear Tirewear Total Fairfield 2.90795E+16 1231.66300 29.59599 28.6206817 12.31633363 70.53301 New Haven 3.0721E+16 1340.38513 31.07283 30.073911 12.85454305 74.00128 Totals 5.98005E+16 2572.04813 60.66882 58.69459 25.17088 144.53429 47 APPE NDIX C PM2.5 and N Ox INPUT FILES TO M OVES201 4a 48 2018 Fairfield 49 51 54 55 2018 New Haven 56 58 61 62 2025 Fairfield 63 65 68 69 2025 New Haven 70 72 75 76 2035 Fairfield 77 79 82 83 2035 New Haven 84 86 89 90 2040 Fairfield 91 93 96 97 2040 New Haven 98 100 103 104 APPE NDIX D ACRO NYMS 105 Acron yms Acronym Me aning CA AA Cle an Air Act Am endments (1990) CO Carbon Mon oxide COG Coun cil of Gov ernm ent CTD OT Conn ecticut Departm ent of Trans portation CT DEEP Conn ecticut Departm ent of Env ironme ntal Prot ection EPA U.S. En viron me ntal Protec tion A gency FSD Final S cope Developm ent (Now PD) ISTEA Inte rmodal Surface Trans po rtation E fficien cy Act MA P-21 Moving Ah ead for Pro gress in the 21 st Centu ry Act MO VES Mobile Vehicle Emission Simulator MPO Met ropolitan Pl anning Organization NAAQS Nation al Ambient Air Quality Sta ndards NH 3 Ammonia NOx Ni tro gen Oxides PD Pr eliminary Design (Forme rly FSD) PDWP Pr oject D evelopm ent W ork Pro gram PM 2.5 Fine Particulate Matt er PMT Person M iles T raveled RA Regional Admi nist er ROP Rate of Pro gress RTP Regional Transp ortation Plan (generally refers to Regional Transp ortation Plan Upd ate) SA FETEA-LU Safe, Accoun table, Flexible, Effici ent T ransport ation Equi ty Act: A Legacy for Us ers SD Stu dy and D evelopme nt SIP State Impl eme ntation Plan SOx Sulfur Oxides STIP St atewide Transpo rtation Improv eme nt Pro gram TCM Transpo rtation Co ntrol Me asure TIP Transpo rtation Improv ement Pro gram USDOT U.S. D epartm ent of Transport ation USEPA U.S. En viron me ntal Protec tion A gency VMT Vehicle M iles T raveled VOC Vol atile Organic Comp ound

Ozone Air Quality Conformity Determination May 2017

Co n n e c ti c ut Dep a rtm en t of T ra n sp o rt a tion O Z O NE Air Q u a lity C o n fo rm ity D eterm in at ion of the 201 5 Regio nal Tr ansport atio n Pla ns and th e FY 201 8-2021 Tr ansp ort atio n Im prov em ent Prog ram s Am end m ents for th e Conn ect icut portion of th e New York-Nort her n New Jer sey-Long Isl and , NY -NJ-CT Oz one Nonattai nm ent Are a and th e Gre ate r Connect icut O zone Nonattai nm ent Area May 2017 Note: The Conn ectic ut po rtion of the New Yo rk-Northern New Jersey-Lo ng Island Nonattainme nt area (Fairfield, New Haven an d Mid dlesex counties) an d the Greater Conn ectic ut Nona ttainme nt area (Hartford, New Lo ndon , Tolland, Win dha m and Litchfield counties) ha ve been desi gna ted as Mo derate Nona ttainme nt areas. This do cume nt incl udes the do cume ntati on of the regiona l ana lys is for bo th nona ttainme nt areas within the State of Connecticut, as well as do cume ntati on and information on the processes an d procedu res und ertaken by Conn ectic ut De pa rtme nt of Tran spo rtatio n, coordinator of Air Qua lity Con formity for the Conn ectic ut Re gional Planning Org an izatio ns. Table of Contents 1) Introduction…………… ……………………………… ………………… 4 2) Vehicle Emissions…..…… …………………………… ………………… .. 8 3) Ozone Nonattainment Areas…………… ……………… …………………. 9 4) CO Attai nment/Mai ntenance Areas… ………………… ………………… 11 5) Conformity Test s……………………………………………………………………………. 11 6) Interagency Consultat ion……………………………… ………….… .…. 13 7) Public Consultation…… ……………………………… ……. ..……… …. 14 8) VMT and Emissions Estimates.…… ………………… ……………. ……. 15 9) PM 10………………… ……………………………… …………………. 40 10) PM 2.5………………………………………………………………………………………… 41 11) Other Planning Documents………………………… ………………… .. 42 12) Tra nsportation Planning Work Program..………… …………………… 42 13) Conclusions…… …………………………………… ………………… .. 43 2 3 List of Tables Table 1: Classificati on Categories and Attai nment Dat es…… …… … ……… … …… … …… 6 Table 2: List of Connectic ut Ne twork Changes…… … …… … …… … ……… … …… … …… 16 Table 3: VMT Ozone Emissions SIP Budgets ………………………………………………………………. 38 Figure 1: List of Fig ures Connect icut Ozone Nonattai nment Areas and PM2.5 Attai nm ent/Mai ntenance Area 10 Figure 2 Connect icut CO Attai nment/ Mai ntenance Area s……… …… ……… … …… … ……. 11 List of App endices App endix A: Interagency Consultat ion Mee ting Minutes…… … …… …… ……… … …… … …… 44 App endix B: MOVES 2014 a Tabulatio ns… ……… … …… … …… … …… ……… … …… … …… 48 App endix C: MOVES 2014 a Input Ozone Emission Runs…… … …… … ……… … …… … …….. 50 App endix D: Acronyms………………………………………………………………………… … 258 4 INTR O D UC TIO N This report was prepared to do cum en t the em iss ions an alysis that was completed to evaluate Transportation Co nformity of the Metropolitan Re gional Plan ning Or ga nizat ions’ Fiscal Year 2018-2021 Transpor tation Im provem ent Program s (TIP ) and the 201 5 Re gional Long Range Transpor tation P lans (L RTP) to the S tat e Implem entation Plan (SI P) for air quality. Th is sub m ittal incorporates the FY 20 18- 20 21 TIPs an d 201 5 LRTPs from Conn ecticut’s Re gional P lanning Or ganization s (RPOs), and Mobile Ve hic le Em iss ion Budg ets (MVE Bs ). The rep ort is sub m itted to satisfy the requirements of the SIP , as revised . The statewi de travel de m and m od els were reru n, along with accompa nying Ve hicle Miles of Travel (V MT) and the MOVES2014 a em ission s m odel. The results of these runs show a dec rease in em iss ions in the affected area an d therefore the transpor tation program an d plan continue to con form to the St ate’s air qu ality pla n. On Novem ber 15, 199 0, the Clea n Air Act Amend m en ts (CAAA) of 199 0 was signe d into law. On Au gust 15, 199 7, the En viron m ental Protection Agency (EP A) publis he d the Final Co nformity Rule. Effective Feb ruary 17, 20 04, EPA appro ved a revision to the Con necticut SIP for the attainm en t an d maintena nce of the one-hour National Ambien t Air Quality St andard (NAAQS) for groun d level ozone.1 Em iss ions budgets for the 2007 Volat ile Or ga nic Com po und s (VOC) and Nitroge n Oxide s (NO x) m ot or vehicle em iss ions were calcu lat ed using MOBI LE6. 2 for the Conn ecticut portion of the New Yor k-Northern New Jerse y-Long Island Nonat tainm en t area an d the 2007 m otor vehicle em iss ion s bud get s (M VEB s) for the Greater Con necticut Nonattainm en t area . Procedures an d criteria contained in that docum ent provided the basis for this Con form ity determ inat ion. Implementa tion of these rules has been accomplishe d through a coop erative effort of the Region al Plan ning Or ganization s (RP Os), EPA, Fe der al Transit Ad ministration (FTA ), Fed eral Highway Ad m inistration (FHW A), 1 40CFR Part 52 5 Con necticut Dep artm ent of Transpor tation (CTD OT) and the Conne cticut Dep ar tm en t of Ener gy and Environm ental Protection (CTDEEP). In June of 20 04, EP A finalized eight -hour conform ity rules for ozone nonat tainmen t areas in Conn ecticut, which becam e effective in June of 2005 . These ar eas were desi gnated as ‘Moderate’ Non attainment for the eight -ho ur standa rd: the Conn ecticut portion of the New Yor k-Northern New Jersey-Lo ng Island eight-hour ozon e Non attainment Area, cons isting of Fairfield, New Ha ven and Middlesex count ies an d the Gre ater Conn ecticut eight-hour ozon e Non attainment Area, cons isting of Hartford, Litch field, New Lon don , Tolland an d W indh am cou nties. Em issions were tested against the new eight-ho ur budg ets, which were de velo ped jointly by C TDE EP an d CTD OT, a nd foun d ade quate by EP A on Jun e 27, 200 8. The 20 09 MVEBs establishe d in 200 8 for each of Conn ecticut’s n on attainm ent areas represented CTDEEP’s planning estimate at that time of the level of motor vehicle em iss ions that would be necessary to prod uce tim ely atta inment of the 19 97 8-hour ozon e NA AQS. The ap propr iaten ess of the 20 09 MVE Bs was con firm ed by ac tual m onitored 2009 desi gn values, which de m on strated that both nonat tainm en t ar eas had achieved timely attainm ent of the NAAQ S. On August 23, 2010 , CTDEEP requ ested EPA to retain the 200 9 MVEBs as ad equat e ozon e pr ec ur sor bu dgets for future transportat ion c on form ity determ ination s and for EPA to withdraw the ade quacy determ ina tion for the 201 2 MVEBs, which were set at lower em iss ion levels in case attainm ent was not achieved by 2009 . On Decem ber 30, 2010 EPA inform ed CTDE EP that it was withdrawing its previous ade quacy finding on the 201 2 out year MVEBs contained in Conn ecticut’s 8-hou r ozone attainm en t de m onstration SIP. Conne cticut ’s withdra wal of the 201 2 MVE Bs was pu blishe d in the Fe deral Register on February 15, 2011 and the bu dget chan ge became effective 15 days after publication of the an nou ncem en t. On May 21, 20 12, the Fed eral Register (77 FR 30 160) established the ap proach for class ifying nona ttainment areas, set attainment dea dlines, and revoked the 199 7 Ozon e 6 standard for transpor tation conform ity pur poses. Areas designate d nonat tainment for class ifying nona ttainment areas, set attainment dea dlines, and revoked the 199 7 Ozon e standard for transpor tation conform ity pur poses. Areas designate d nonat tainment for the 20 08 Ozon e NAA QS were class ified into one of the followi ng categories, ba sed on the severity of their ozone problem: Mar ginal, Moderate, Ser ious, Severe, or Extreme. EPA establishe d attainment dates for the 20 08 pr imary ozone NAAQ S ba sed on the area’s class ification , as sho wn in Tab le 1.2 Both of the St ate’s nona ttainm ent areas were classi fied as “Mar ginal” for the 2008 Ozon e NAAQ S. TABLE 1: Class ificati on Cat eg ories and Atta inm ent Da tes Classif icatio n Attainment Date Marginal Decem ber 31 , 2015 Moderate Decem ber 31 , 2018 Serious Decem ber 31 , 2021 Severe Decem ber 31 , 2027 Extreme Decem ber 31 , 2032 The EPA has determ ined that 11 Mar ginal areas did not at tain the 20 08 ozone stan dards by the July 20, 2015, attai nment da te, and that the se ar eas do not qual ify for a 1-year attai nment date extension, and that they m ust be reclass ified as Moderate bas ed on their 20 12-20 14 air qual ity dat a. Both the Gre ater Co nnectic ut and the New Yor k-Nort hern New Jersey -Long Isl and (NY-NJ-CT) are as were two of the ele ven ar eas .3 The “bum p- up” d esignation to Mod erate was effecti ve on June 3, 20 16. In this action, the EPA is also est ablishing a due date of January 1, 2017, by which states with new ly-reclassi fied Moderate areas m ust su bm it St ate Implem entation Pl an (SIP) re visions to address Modera te nonatta inm ent area re quire m ents for those area s. The 2Source: Table 4 in 77 FR 30160 3 http s://ww w.epa. gov/sites/prod uctio n/files/201 6-04/docu ments/20160411 fact sheet.pdf 7 reclassi fied ar eas m ust atta in the 2008 ozone standards as exped itiously as practica ble. On March 20, 2017, EPA notified C TDEEP that EPA has determined the M VEBs for the Greater Connecticut Ozone non -attainment area , submitted as a SIP revision by CTDEEP to EPA on Jnauar y 17, 2017, to be adequate for transportation conformity purposes. The VOC and NOx emissions shown for the Greater Connecticut area do not exceed the new ly determined adequate budgets. These new budgets will be effective fifteen days after EPA publishes a Notice of Aduquacy in the Federal Register. Final ly, for the New Yor k-Northern New Jerse y-Long Island, NY -NJ-CT, ar ea, the EPA is rescin ding the clean data determ ination iss ued in June 20 12, and is issuing a new SIP cal l, for t he 1997 ozone NAA QS. The states in the New York City area m ay satisfy the SIP call for the 1997 NAAQS by m aking tim ely sub m ittals to m eet the Modera te area SIP re quirem ents that now apply to this area for the 2008 ozone NA AQS .4 MOVES 2014 a inc lude s three new em ission con trol program s ass ociate d with regulat ion p rom ulgate d since the re lease of MOV ES2010 b:  Tier 3 em ission standards tha t ph ase in beg inning in 201 7 for cars, light- du ty t ruc ks, m edium -du ty passenger vehicles, and som e he avy-duty trucks, and Ti er 3 f uel sta ndards that require lower sulfur gasoline beginning in 201 7.  Heavy -duty engine an d vehic le greenho use gas (GH G) re gulations that ph ase in dur ing m od el years 201 4-2018 .  The secon d ph ase of light-du ty ve hic le GHG regu lations tha t ph ase in for m odel yea rs 20 17-202 5 cars and light trucks. MOVES 2014 a also includ es new an d upd ated em ission s da ta from a wide range of test p rogram s an d other sour ces. The most significant cha nge s includ e new effects of fuel p rope rties such as ga soline sulfur and etho anol, new data on evap orative em ission s from f uel leaks and from vehicles par ked for m ultiple days, new analysis of particulate 4ht t ps : / / ww w. f edera lreg ist er.go v /a rt ic les/ 2 0 16 / 0 5/ 0 4 /2 0 16 -0 9 7 29 / det erm inat io ns -of-a tt a inm ent -by-t he – a t t a inm ent – da t e -ext ensio ns -of-t he -a t t a inm ent -da t e -a nd#h -41 8 m atte r (PM) data related to PM spec iation an d temperature effects on running PM em issions and new real wor ld in-use em issions for heavy-duty ve hicles using data from portable em iss ion m onitor ing system s. MOVES 2014 a estim ates exha ust and evapo rative em ission s as well as brake and tire wear em iss ions from all typ es of on -road vehicles. MOVES20 14a also uses a vehicle class ification system based on the way veh icles are classified in the FHW A’s Highway Perform ance Monitoring Sys tem (HPMS). Other param eters inc lud e vehicle m iles 5 traveled (VM T) by vehic le and ro ad type , vehicle ho urs traveled (VH T) by veh icle and road type, the nu m ber of each typ e of vehicle in the fleet, veh icle age distribu tion , m od el year, t ravel spe ed, roadway type, fuel inform ation, m ete orological da ta, su ch as ambient tem perature an d hu m idit y, and ap plicable control m ea su res such as reform ulate d ga soline (RFG) and inspe ction and m aintena nce (I/M). Local inp uts were coop eratively develope d by CTDEEP and CTDOT, where ap plicable, using EPA 5 re comm end ed method s. Em iss ions are now tested against the establishe d eigh t-hour bu dge ts, which were developed jointly by CT DE EP and CTD OT, and found adequate by EPA on June 27, 2 008 . In No vem ber 20 12, EP A con firm ed by teleph one to CTDEEP that future con form ity det erm inations utilizing the MOVES201 0b model can be made by comparing e m iss ion results to the existing MOB ILE 6.2 bu dge ts for Ozo ne. Therefore, as the 200 9 MVE Bs are ad equat e ozon e precursor budge ts, this Air Qual ity C on form ity anal ysis will com pa re future year em iss ions to this ba se. Ve hicle Em iss ions Ozone Gro und level ozon e is a m ajor componen t of sm og. It is form ed by sunligh t and heat 5 “MOVES201 4 and MOVES2014a Techn ical Guidance: U s i ng MOV ES to Prepare Emiss ion Inventories for State Implementation Plans and T r a nsportation Conf o rmity”, EPA-420 -B-15-09 3, November 20 15 9 acting up on fuel com bustion products such as nitrogen oxides and hydrocarbo ns. Ozo ne occurs naturally in the up per atmosph ere and shields the ear th from ultraviolet radiation . However, at ground level, ozon e is a se vere irritant. Because ozone form ation is directly related to atm ospheric tem pe ratures, problem atic ozone levels occur m ost frequently on hot summ er afternoo ns. Ozo ne exposure is linked to respiratory illnesses such as as thm a and lung inflamm ation and can exacerbate e xisting respiratory ailm ents. Ozo ne pollution can a lso se verely da m age veget at ion , including agricultural crops an d forest habitats. Nit rogen Oxides (NOx) Mob ile sou rce nitrogen oxides form whe n nitroge n and oxy gen atom s che mically react inside the high pre ss ur e and tempe rature cond itions in an en gine. Ni troge n oxides are precursors for ozon e and can also con tribu te to the forma tion of acidic rain. Hydro carbo ns or Volatile O rganic Co m poun ds (VOC) Hydr oc ar bon em ission s are a product of pa rtial fuel combustion , fuel evap or ation and ref ueling loss es caused by spillage an d vapor lea ka ge. VOC reacts with nitroge n oxides and sunlight to form ozon e. Carbon Mon oxide (CO) Carbon m ono xide is produced by the incomplete bu rning of carbon in fuels, including gasoline. High conc en tratio ns of CO occur along roadsi des in heavy traf fic, particularly at m ajor inter sections and in enclosed ar eas such as gara ges and poo rly ven tilate d tunn els. Peak concentrat ions occur dur ing the col der m on ths of the year whe n CO veh icular em iss ions are great er. O zone No nattainme nt Area s On Mar ch 27 , 200 8, EPA finalized new ozone standards which tight ened the stand ard to 0.075 parts per m illion (pp m ) from the previous, 19 97 ozon e standard of 0.0 8 pp m. 10 On May 21, 2012 , EP A finalized designa tions for this new ozone standard, effective July 20, 201 2. The nona ttainm ent areas ha ve chan ged un der the latest 200 8 ground-level ozon e eigh t-ho ur stand ard. The Conn ecticut portion of the New Yor k-Northern New Je rsey-Long Isla nd Non attainment Ar ea (Fairfield, New Ha ve n an d Middles ex counties) a n d the Gre ater Con necticut Ar ea (Hartford, New Londo n, Tollan d, W indham and Litch field coun ties) ha ve been designate d as Mod er ate Non attainm ent areas, effective Jun e 3, 201 6. Figure 1 below shows the two Moderate Non attainment areas in Con necticut. Fig ure 1: Conne ctic ut Ozone Nonat tainment Areas and PM2.5 Attainmen t/Maintenance Area 11 CO No natta inm ent Area s There were form er ly three CO Non attainment Areas in the state. These were the Southwest portion of the state, the greater New Ha ven area, an d the greater Ha rtford area. The rem ainder of the state was in attainm ent for CO. At tainm en t was de m onstrated in each of these ar eas an d, subsequently, they were designa ted as Full Maintena nce areas. On Septe m ber 13 , 2004 , EPA approved a CTDEEP sub m ittal for a SIP revision for re-design at ion of these areas to Lim ited Maintena nce Plan status, thus elim ina ting the nee d for bud get testing. Effecti ve Ja nuary 2, 201 6, the Gre ater Hartford Area was in full attai nament status. In the future, “hot-spo t” ca rbo n m onoxide analyses will be perform ed to satisfy “project level” conformity det erm inations. Figure 2 below shows the CO attainm ent/maintena nce areas in Conne cticut. Fig ure 2: Conne cticut Carbo n Mono xide Maintenac e and Attainme nt Area s 12 Con for m ity Test s Un der the Con form ity Rules, the following test for VOC/NOx must be m et:  TES T 1 For VOC an d NOx, transpor tation em ission s from the Action Scen ar ios m ust be less t han the 200 9 transpo rtat ion em iss ion budgets if analysis year is 2009 or later. As the CO areas have be en ap proved by EPA for Lim ited Maintena nce Plan status, no t ests for CO are required. The ACTION SCE NARIO is the future tran sportat ion sys tem that will result from full i mplem entation of the Transpo rtation Im provem en t Programs (TIP) and Long Range Transportat ion Plans (LRTP ). VOC/NOx em iss ion an alysis was con ducted for summ er con ditions and for the following yea rs:  2009 (eigh t-hour MVE B yea r)  2018 (New Attainment year and near term an alysis year)  2025 (Interim m od eling year)  2035 (Interim m od eling year)  2040 (Long Range Transportation Pl an hor izon year) At this time, the following eight -hour em ission budgets have been appro ved by EPA for use in this con form ity an alysis: 1. In 200 9 and subseque nt years, VOC in the Con necticut portion of the New York- Northern New Jerse y-Long Islan d Moderate Non attainm ent area must be less than 27.4 tons per summer da y. 2. In 200 9 and sub se que nt year s, NOx in the Conn ecticut portion of the New 13 York- Northern New Jerse y-Long Islan d Moderate Non attainment area m ust be less than 54.6 tons per summer da y. 3. In 2017 and subseq uen t years, VOC in the Greater Conn ecticut Moderate Non attainm ent area m ust be less than 15.9 tons per summer day. 4. In 2017 and subseq uen t years, NOx in the Greater Connecticut Moderate Non attainment area m ust be less than 22.2 tons per summer day. Inte ragency Con sul tat ion An Intera gency Consultation Mee ting was held on February 7 , 2017 to ad dress the need to prep are an Air Quality De term ination Anal ysis for these TIP am end m en ts. All Metrop olitan Planning Or ga nization s (MPO ’s), rural COGs, FHW A, FTA, EP A, and CTDEEP were invited to review and comm ent on the project’s Air Quality codi ng, analysis years to be m od eled , and comm ents on the latest plann ing ass um ptions to be utilized for this con form ity. The project Air Quality coding is as follows: CC – Con form ity An alysis Com pleted M – Mod eled in the Dep ar tmen t’s highway or tra nsit networks NM – Re quires m odeling and will be inclu de d into the Dep artm en t’s highway and tra nsit net works pr ior to conformity analysis NR S –a highway or tra nsit project on a faci lity that do es not ser ve re gional needs or is not normally inclu ded in the region al travel sim ulat ion m odel and does no t fit into an exem pt project category in Tab le 2 or 3 of the Final Rule (40 CFR 93). RS – Re gionally Si gnifican t refers to a tran sportat ion project in the TIP and /or STIP ( other tha n an exem pt pro ject) that is on a facility which ser ves re gion al transpo rtation nee ds such as access to an d from the area outside of the re gion , m ajor a ctivity ce nters in the re gion s, m ajor planne d develop ment such as new ret ail m alls, sports complexes, etc., or transportation term inals as well as m ost term inals t hem selves) and would norm ally be inc luded in the modeling of a m etropolitan a rea’s transpor tation net work, inclu ding at a m inim um all pr incipal arterial highways and all fixed guid e-way tra nsit faci lities that offer an alternati ve 14 to re gion al highway t ravel (40 CFR 93.10 1). Once a pro ject is iden tified as region ally significa nt, it must be included in the an alysis re gardless of funding sour ce. Exem pt Project – a pro ject listed in Ta ble 2 or 3 of the Final Rule (40 CFR 93) that pr im ar ily en han ces safety or ae sthetics, m aintains mass transit, cont inu es curren t le vels of rideshar ing, or b uilds bicycle and ped estrian faci lities . X6 – Project exempt from the requ irem ent to det erm ine conform ity und er 40 CFR 93.12 6 X7 – Project exem pt form regional em iss ions anal ysis re quirements under 40 CFR 93.12 7 X8 – Traffic synchr onization projects may be ap proved , funde d and implem ented without satisfying con formity re quirem ents un der 40 CFR 93.12 8 It was agreed upo n that the 201 1 vehic le reg ist ration dat a file wou ld be utilized for this Con form ity De termi nation and CTDEEP and CTDOT staff would discuss up date of this file. A copy of the Interagency Co nsultat ion Meeting m inut es is include d in Appen dix A. The final em ission s an alys is was pre pared an d the rep ort was distributed for the 30 day public comm ent per iod . Public Con sultat ion As re qu ire d by the Final Rule, the transportation con form ity proce ss m ust include public consultation on the em iss ions an alysis and conform ity determ ina tion for Ozon e determ ina tions. This includes post ing of relevan t docum en tation and analysis on a “clea ringho use” webpag e m ainta ined through the interagen cy con su ltation process. All MPOs in the Conn ecticut Ozon e Non attainm ent areas m ust provide thirty day public comm en t per iods and address any comm ents rec eived. For this Ozo ne transportat ion con form ity de term ination, all Con necticut MPOs will hold a thirty day public comm ent per iod. 15 VM T and Em iss ions Estim ates VMT estimates were developed from CTDOT’s statewide net work -based travel m odel. The 2015 travel mode l n e t w o r k , to the extent practical, represen ts all state highways and m ajor conne cting non-state str eets an d roads, as well as the ra il, loc al bus, and express es bus sys tems that cur rently exist. Future highway net works for 2018 , 202 0, 2025 an d 2030 and trans it ne twor ks for 2018, 2020 , 203 0 and 2040 were built by adding Sta tewide Transportat ion Improvem ent Program (STIP), TIP and LRTP projects (p rogramm ed for open ing after 201 7) to the 2017 network year. Th ese networ ks were used to run travel m od els and cond uct em iss ions an alysis for the years 2018, 2025 , 2035 , an d 2040 . Projects for each m odel an alysis year for which net work chan ges were re quired are sho wn on Table 2 as follows: 16 TABLE 2 LIST OF NETWORK CHANGES 2018 NETWORK CHANGES NEW MPO DESCRIPTION LANES PROJECT NUMBER FROM TO HIGHWAY NAME TOWN IMPROVEMENT CAPITAL REGION 0131 -0190 Remove Bridge Number 00518 Reconstruct 10/322 Intersecti on 1/1 0/0 ROUTE 10 SOUTHINGTON CCD 11/2017, TIP BRIDGE REMOVAL GREATER BRIDGEPORT 0015 -TMP1 Realignment of Lafayette Circle and establishment of bidirectional traffic on Fairfield Avenue 0/1 1/1 LAFAYETTE C IRCLE BRIDGEPORT CCD 2017, TIP REALIGNMENT 0036 -0184 Main Street Derby from Bridge Street to Route 8 South Exit15 On/Off Ramps (Ausonio Street) 1/1 2/2 ROUTE 34 DERBY CCD 2018, TIP WIDENING HOUSATONIC VALLEY 0034 -0347 State Route 806 (Newtown Road) from Old Newtown to Plumtrees & from Eagle to Industrial Plaza, Danbury – Widening from 1 lane each direction to 2 lanes each direction 1/1 2/2 SR 806 NEWTOWN ROAD DANBUR Y CCD 2016, TIP SOUTH CENTRAL 0079 -XXXX Multiple lane and directional changes in the center of town. Conversion of multiple one way streets to two ways. Conversion of a two way street to one way. Reduction of one lane in eac h direction for one street CCD 2018, TIP VARIOUS WEST MAIN STREET MERIDEN DIRECTIONAL AND LANE CHANGES 17 TABLE 2 LIST OF NETWORK CHANGES (CONT’D) 2018 NETWORK CHANGES NEW MPO DESCRIPTION LANES PROJECT NUMBER FROM TO HIGHWAY NAME TOWN IMPROVEMENT SOUTH CENTRAL (CONT’D) 0092 -0531 Q Bridge Replacement and demolition; Contract E 3/3 5/5 I-95 CCD 201 6, TIP NEW HAVEN BRIDGE REPLACEMENT 0092 -0532 Q Bridge Replacement and demolition; Contract B 3/3 5/5 I-95 CCD 2016, TIP NEW HAVEN BRIDGE REPLACEMENT 0092 -0627 Q Bridge Replacement and demolition; Contract B2 3/3 5/5 I-95 CCD 2016, TIP NEW HAVEN BRIDGE REPLACEMENT 0092 -XXXX Removal of North Frontage Road between State Street & Orange Street 1/1 0/0 NORTH FRONTAGE ROAD NEW HAVEN CCD 2016, TIP ROADWAY REMOVAL 0100 -0175 Project to widen Sackett Point Road from 1 lane to 2 lanes CCD 2018, TIP 1/1 2/2 SACKETT POINT ROAD NORTH HAVEN WIDENING 18 TABLE 2 LIST OF NETWORK CHANGES (CONT’D) 2018 NETWORK CHANGES NEW MPO DESCRIPTION LANES PROJECT NUMBER FROM TO HIGHWAY NAME TOWN IMPROVEMENT SOUTH WESTERN 0102 -0325 Addition of a through lane on Route 1 Northbound from France Street to Route 53 1/1 1/2 ROUTE 1 NORWALK CCD 2018, TIP WIDENING 0135 -0301 Reconstruction of I -95 off ramps and Atla ntic Street in vicinity of Metro North Railroad Bridge No. 08012R 2/2 3/3 ATLANTIC STREET STAMFORD WIDENING CCD 2018, TIP GREATER BRIDGEPORT 0138 -0211 Addition of a through lane on Route 1 Southbound from Nob el Street to Soundview Avenue 1/2 2/2 ROUTE 1 STRATFORD CCD 2018, TIP WIDENING CENTRAL NAUGATUCK VALLEY 0017 -0182 Addition of a second through lane on Route 6 Eastbound from Carol Drive (Mix Street /Brook Street) to Peggy Lane (Camp Street) 1/1 2/1 ROUTE 6 BRISTOL WIDENING CCD 2018, TIP 19 TABLE 2 LIST OF NETWORK CHANGES (CONT’D) 2020 NETWORK CHANGES NEW MPO DESCRIPTION LANES PROJECT NUMBER FROM TO HIGHWAY NAME TOWN IMPROVEMENT CAPITAL REGION 0051 -0259 Interchange improvements at Routes 4, 6, and 9 including a new EB C/D Roadway N/A I84/RT4/RT6 FARMINGTON CCD 2019, TIP INTERCHANGE BSWY 0063 -0703 Relocation and Reconfiguration of Inter change 29 on I-91; New additional lanes Rte. 15 NB from 2 to 3 lanes exit 90 to 0.5 miles beyond Exit 91 3/3 4/3 I-91, EXIT 29 HARTFORD WIDENING CCD 2020 Long Range Plan 0155 -0156 Add an Operational Lane WB between Interchanges 42 & 39A; Add an Operational Lane EB between Interchanges 40 & 41 CCD 2018 3/3 4/4 I-84 WEST HARTFORD OPERATIONAL LANES CENTRAL NAUGATUCK VALLEY 0151 -0273 Interstate 84 2/2 3/3 I-84 CCD 11/2020, TIP WATERBURY WIDENING 0151 -XXXX TIGER Grant includes various roadway changes including reconstruction/extension of Jackson Street. Extension will meet at Freight Street an d continue to West Main N/A 1/1 DOWNTOWN AREA WATERBURY ADDED ROADWAY CCD 2019, Long Range Plan 20 TABLE 2 LIST OF NETWORK CHANGES (CONT’D) 2020 NETWORK CHANGES NEW MPO DESCRIPTION LANES PROJECT NUMBER FROM TO HIGHWAY NAME TOWN IMPROVEMENT GREATER BRIDGEPORT 0015 -HXXX Reconstruct and widen Route 130 from Stratford Avenue bridge to Yellow Mill br idge 1/1 2/2 ROUTE 130 BRIDGEPORT Long Range Plan WIDENING 0124 -0165 **As of 2/15/2011current scope from consultant is spot improvements for from Swan Avenue to Franklin Street Project Manager* * Bank Street from West Street to North Main St is full scope being reviewed by consultant 1/1 2/2 ROUTE 67 SEYMOUR MAJOR WIDENING Long Range Plan 0124 -XXXX Between Interchange 22 and 23 to improve a ccess N/A ROUTE 8 Long Range Plan SEYMOUR INTERCHANGE 0124 -XXXX Realign interchange with new extension of Derby Road N/A ROUTE 8 SEYMOUR Long Range Plan INTERCHANGE 0126 -XXXX Int erchan ge 11 – Construct new SB entrance ramp, Widen Bridgeport Avenue N/A ROUTE 8 SHELTON Long Range Plan MAJOR WIDENING 21 TABLE 2 LIST OF NETWORK CHANGES (CONT’D) 2020 NETWORK CHANGES NEW MPO DESCRIPTION LANES PROJECT NUMBER FROM TO HIGHWAY NAME TOWN IMPROVEMENT GREATER BRIDGEPORT (CONT’D) 0126 -XXXX Between Huntin gton Avenue and Constitution Boulevard 1/1 2/2 ROUTE 714 SHELTON Long Range Plan MAJOR WIDENING NEW MPO 0138 -0248 Recon struct Intercha nge 33 on I -95 to provide full interchange from partial to full diamond interchange N/A I-95, EXIT 33 STRATFORD INTERCHANGE RECONSTRUCTION CCD 2020, Long Range Plan HOUSATONIC VALLEY 0008 -XXXX Operational Improvemen ts on White Street at Locust Avenue and Eighth Avenue 1/1 1/2 WHITE STREET DANBURY CCD 2020, Long Range Plan WIDENING 0096 -0204 Addition of a through lane on Route 34 EB from Wasserman Way to Toddy Hill Road. Addition of I-84 WB and EB on -ramp from Route 34 WB 1/1 2/1 ROUTE 34 NEWTOWN WIDENING CCD 2020, TIP SOUTH CENTRAL 0092 -XXXX Intersection Impr ovements at Route 69 and Pond Lily Avenue N/A ROUTE 69 NEW HAVEN Long Range Pl an INTERSECTION IMPROVEMENTS 22 TABLE 2 LIST OF NETWORK CHANGES (CONT’D) 2025 NETWORK CHANGES NEW MPO DESCRIPTION LANES PROJECT NUMBER FROM TO HIGHWAY NAME TOWN IMPROVEMENT CAPITAL REGION 0042 -0317 Removal of the Cambridge Street to Route 2 Westbound On -Ramp and the Sutton Avenue to Route 2 Eastbound Off -Ramp. New through lane on Main Street No rthbound underneath Route 2 at the approach to the Route 2 Westbound Off -Ramp 0/1 0/2 ROUTE 2 EAST HARTFORD WIDENING CCD 2021, TIP 0055 -0142 Addition of a second through lane on Route 20/189 Westbound from Route 10/202 to Route 20 and Route 189 split. Addition of a second through lane on Route 20 Westbound from Hungary Road to Route 10/202. Addition of a second through lane on Route 10/202 Northbound from Route 189 to Route 20/189. VARIOUS ROUTE 10 & 202 GRANBY WIDENING CCD 2022, TIP LOWER CT RIVER VALLEY 0082 -0316 Reconfiguration and realignment of Route 17 On – Ramp onto Route 9 from Main Street. Removal of the Harbor Drive to Route 9 Northbound On -Ramp N/A ROUT E 17 MIDDLETOWN INTERCHANGE RECONFIGURATION CCD 2025, TIP 0082 -0318 Removal of a through lane on Route 9 Southbound from just North of Miller Street to just South of Washington Street. Route 9 access to Washington Street/De Koven Drive has been limited to an on – ramp to Route 9 Southbound. N/A ROUTE 9 MIDDLETOWN REMOVE LANE CCD 2021, TIP 23 TABLE 2 LIST OF NETWORK CHANGES (CONT’D) 2025 NETWORK CHAN GES NEW MPO DESCRIPTION LANES PROJECT NUMBER FROM TO HIGHWAY NAME TOWN IMPROVEMENT SOUTHEASTERN Addition of a second through lane on Route 85 Northbound from just North of Chesterfield Road to just South of Deer Run. CCD 2024, TIP 1/1 2/1 0120 -0079 ROUTE 85 MONTVILLE WIDENING SOUTH WESTERN 0102 -0358 Reconfiguration of the interchanges between Route 7, Ro ute 15, and Main Avenue. These changes include multiple new and reconfigured on and off ramps designed to allow access to and from all three major roadways CCD 2025, TIP N/A ROUTE 7 AND ROUTE 15 NORWALK INTERCHANGE RECONFIGURATI ON 24 TABLE 2 LIST OF NETWORK CHANGES (CONT’D) 2028 NETWORK CHANGES NEW MPO DESCRIPTION LANES PROJECT NUMBER FROM TO HIGHWAY NAME TOWN IMPROVEMENT SOUTHEASTERN ROUTE 82 Removal of a through lane on Route 82 Eastbound from just West of Pine Street to just West of Fairmont Street N/A NORWICH REMOVE LANE CCD 2027, TIP 25 TABLE 2 LIST OF NETWOR K CHANGES (CONT’D) 2030 NETWORK CHANGES NEW MPO DESCRIPTION LANES PROJECT NUMBER FROM TO HIGHWAY NAME TOWN IMPROVEMENT CAPITAL REGION VARIOUS T OWNS New Haven/Hartford/Springfield Rail Service Governor’s Transportation Initiative Long Range Plan N/A NEW COMMUTER RAIL 0109 -XXXX New Britain Avenue Cooke Street to Ho oker Street 1/1 2/2 PLAINVILLE Long Range Plan ADD LANE VARIOUS TOWNS New Haven/Hartford/Springfield Rail Service Governor’s Transportation Initiative Long Range Plan N/A NEW COMMUTER RAIL CENTRAL NAUGATUCK VALLEY 0080 -0128 Add auxiliary lanes at Int. 17 and on Routes 63/64 CCD 2030 1/1 2/2 I-84, Routes 63 -64 Long Range Plan MIDDLEBURY/WATERBURY WIDENING GREA TER BRIDGEPORT 0036 -0179 Interchange 18 – Construct New NB entrance ramp. N/A ROUTE 8 Long Range Plan ANSONIA INTERCHANGE 26 TABLE 2 LIST OF NETWORK CHANGES (CONT’D) 2030 NETWORK CHANGES NEW MPO DESCRIPTION LANES PROJECT NUMBER FROM TO HIGHWAY NAME TOWN IMPROVEMENT GREATER BRIDGEPORT (CONT’D) 0036 -XXXX Route 8 Interchange 16 and 17; Construct new NB ramps. Close old ramps N/A ROUTE 8 DERBY Long Range Plan INTERCHANGE 0126 -XXXX Interchange 14 – Constru ct new SB entrance ramp N/A ROUTE 8 Long Range Plan SHELTON INTERCHANGE HOUSATONIC VALLEY 0018 -0124 South of Old State Road to Route 133 1/1 2/2 US 202 Long Range Pla n BROOKFIELD WIDENING 0034 -0288 From Kenosia Avenue easterly to I -84 (Exit 4) 1/1 2/2 ROUTE 6 Long Range Plan DANBURY ADD LANES 0034 -XXXX From I -84 (Exit 2) East to Kenosia Av enue 1/1 2/2 ROUTE 6 Long Range Plan DANBURY ADD LANES 0034 -XXXX From Route I -84 (Exit 6) Northerly to Jeanette Street Long Range Plan 1/1 2/2 ROUTE 37 DANBURY ADD LANES 27 TABLE 2 LIST OF NETWORK CHANGES (CONT’D) 2030 NETWORK CHANGES NEW MPO DESCRIPTION LANES PROJECT NUMBER FROM TO HIGHWAY NA ME TOWN IMPROVEMENT HOUSATONIC VALLEY (CONT’D) 0034 -XXXX Between Interchanges 3 and 4. Between Interc hanges 12 and 13 3/3 4/4 I-84 DANBURY, NEWTOWN, SOUTHBURY Long Range Plan ADD LANES 0034 -XXXX Widen Kenosia Avenue from Backus Avenue to Vicinity of Lake Kenosia 1/1 2/2 DANBURY ADD LANES Long Range Plan 0034 -XXXX Widen Backus Avenue from Kenosia Avenue to Miry Brook Road 1/1 2/2 DANBURY ADD LANES Long Range Plan 0034 -XXXX From South Street northerly to Boughton Street; 1/1 2/2 ROUTE 53 Long Range Plan DANBURY ADD LANES 0034 -XXXX From Route 53 (Main Street) northerly to I -84 (Exit 6) 1/1 2/2 ROUTE 37 DANBURY Long Range Plan ADD LANES 0096 -XXXX New Road across Old Fairfield Hills H ospital Campus, From Route 6 South to Route 860 0/0 1/1 NEWTOWN NEW ROAD Long Range Plan ADD LANES 28 TABLE 2 LIST OF NETWORK CHANGES (CONT’D) 2030 NETWORK CHANGES NEW MPO DESCRIPTION LANES PROJECT NUMBER FROM TO HIGHWAY NAME TOWN IMPROVEMENT SOUTH CENTRAL 0014 -XXXX East Haven Town Line to Alps Road (Echlin Road Private) 2/2 2/3 ROUT E 1 BRANFORD Long Range Plan WIDENING 0014 -XXXX Route 146 to Cedar Street 2/2 2/3 ROUTE 1 Long Range Plan BRANFORD WIDENING 0014 -XXXX Cedar Street to East Main 1/1 1/2 ROUTE 1 Lo ng Range Plan BRANFORD WIDENING 0014 -XXXX East Main to 1 -95 Exit 55 1/1 1/2 ROUTE 1 Long Range Plan BRANFORD WIDENING 0014 -XXXX I-95 Exit 55 to Leetes Island Road 1/1 1/2 RO UTE 1 Long Range Plan BRANFORD WIDENING 0059 -XXXX Bullard Road extension to Route 77 0/0 1/1 BULLARD RD Long Range Plan GUILFORD WIDENING 29 TABLE 2 LIST OF NETWORK CHANGES (CONT’D) 2030 NETWORK CHANGES NEW MPO DESCRIPTION LANES PROJECT NUMBER FROM TO HIGHWAY NAME TOWN IMPROVEMENT SOUTH CENTRAL (CONT’D ) 0059 -XXXX State Street to Tanner Marsh Road 1/1 1/2 ROUTE 1 Long Range Plan GUILFORD WIDENING 0061 -XXXX Washington Avenue to Route 40 2/2 2/3 ROUTE 10 Long Range Plan HAMDEN WIDEN ING 0061 -XXXX Route 40 to Todd Street 2/2 2/3 ROUTE 10 Long Range Plan HAMDEN WIDENING 0061 -XXXX Todd Street to Shepard Avenue 1/1 2/2 ROUTE 10 Long Range Plan HAMDEN WID ENING 0061 -XXXX River Street to Cheshire Town Line 1/1 2/2 ROUTE 10 Long Range Plan HAMDEN WIDENING 0061 -XXXX Olds Street (Hamden) to Sackett Point Road 1/1 2/2 ROUTE 5 Long Range Plan HAMDEN, NORTH HAVEN WIDENING 30 TABLE 2 LIST OF NETWORK CHANGES (CONT’D) 2030 NETWORK CHANGES NEW MPO DESCRIPTION LANES PROJECT NUMBER FROM TO HIGHW AY NAME TOWN IMPROVEMENT SOUTH CENTRAL (CONT’D) 0073 -XXXX New Rail Station near Salemme Lane in Orange N/A ORANGE CCD 2030 Long Range Plan NEW RAIL STATION 0079 -XXXX Walling ford Town Line to Olive Street (Route 71) 1/1 2/2 ROUTE 5 Long Range Plan MERIDEN WIDENING 0083 -XXXX From West of Old Gate Lane to Gulf Street/Clark Street to Route 1 1/1 2/2 ROUTE 162 MILFORD Long Range Pla n WIDENING 0092 -0649 Long Wharf access Plan Widen I -95 (in separate project), Eliminate Long Wharf Drive to expand park, add new road from Long Wharf Drive Long Range Plan VARIES NEW HAVEN 0092 -XXXX From Route 63 to Landin Street 1/1 2/2 ROUTE 69 Long Range Plan NEW HAVEN, WOODBRIDGE WIDENING 0092 -XXXX From Dayton Street (NH) to Landin Street (Wdbg) 1/2 2/3 ROUTE 63 Long Range Plan NEW HAVEN, WOODBRIDGE WIDENING 31 TABLE 2 LIST OF NETWORK CHANGES (CONT’D) 2030 NETWORK CHANGES NEW MPO DESCRIPTION LANES PROJECT NUMBER FROM TO HIGHWAY NAME TOWN IMPROVEMENT SOUTH CENTRAL (CONT’D) 0098 -XXXX From East Haven Town Line to Doral Farms Road and Route 22 to Guilford Town Line 1/1 1/2 ROUTE 80 NORTH BRANFORD Long Range Plan WIDENING 0106 -XXXX From West Haven Town Line to US 1 1/1 2/2 ROUTE 162 Long Range Plan ORANGE WIDENING 0148 -XXXX From South Orchard Street. to Ward Street and Christian Road to Meriden Town Line 1/1 2/2 ROUTE 5 WALLINGFORD Long Range Plan ROUTE 5 0148 -XXXX From Route 71 overpass South of Old Colon y Road to Route 68 1/1 1/2 ROUTE 150 WALLINGFORD Long Range Plan ROUTE 5 0156 -XXXX Route 1 to Elm Street 1/1 2/2 ROUTE 122 Long Range Plan WEST HAVEN WIDENING 0156 -XXXX Campbell Avenue to Orange Town Line 1/1 2/2 ROUTE 1 Long Range Plan WEST HAVEN WIDENING 32 TABLE 2 LIST OF NETWORK CHANGES (CONT’D) 2030 NETWORK CHANGES NEW MPO DESCRIPTION LANES PROJECT NUMBER FROM TO HIGHWAY NAME TOWN IMPROVEMENT SOUTH CENT RAL (CONT’D) 0156 -XXXX Elm Street to Greta Street 2/2 2/3 ROUTE 162 Long Range Plan WEST HAVEN WIDENING 0156 -XXXX Bull Hill Ln to Orange Town Line 1/1 2/2 ROUTE 162 Long Range Plan WEST HAVEN WIDENING VARIOUS TOWNS New Haven/Hartford/Springfield Rail Service Governor’s Transportation Initiative Long Range Plan N/A NEW COMMUTER RAIL SOUTH WESTERN 0035 -XXXX Add Lane from Stamford Exit 8 to Darien Exit 10, Operational Lane 3/3 4/4 I-95 Darien -Stamford Long Range Plan WIDENING 0102 -0269 Upgrade to full interchange at Merritt Parkway (Route 15) BID 01 -09 -08 N/A US 7/RT 15 NORWALK CCD 2030, Long Ra nge Plan UPGRADE EXPRESSWAY 0102 -0297 East Avenue from the vicinity of the I -95 Ramps southerly to the vicinity of Van Zant Street 1/1 2/2 EAST AVE #1 NORWALK Long Range Plan WIDENING 33 TABLE 2 LIST OF NETWORK CHANGES (CONT’D) 2030 NETWORK CHANGES NEW MPO DESCRIPTION LANES PROJECT NUMBER FROM TO HIGHWAY NAME TOWN IMPROVEMENT SOUTH WESTERN (CO NT’D) 0102 -0312 Reconstruction of Interchange 40 Merritt Parkway and Route 7 (Main Avenue). Breakout of 0102 -0269 Phase 1 N/A ROUTE 7/15 NORWALK UPGRADE EXPRESSWAY CCD 2030, Long Range Plan 0102 -XXXX Express Bus/BRT between Norwalk and Greenwich N/A NORWALK -GREENWICH Long Range Plan BRT 34 TABLE 2 LIST OF NETWORK CHANGES (CONT’D) 2040 NETWORK CHANGES NEW MPO DESCRIPTION LANES PROJECT NUMBER FROM TO HIGHWAY NAME TOWN IMPROVEMENT GREATER BRIDGEPORT 0015 -XXXX New Rail Station near Barnum Street in Bridgeport N/A NEW RAIL STATION CCD 2040 Long Range Plan 35 In ad dition, the travel m od el incorporates the effect of the Em ployer Comm ute Option s (ECO) Program in S ou thwest Conn ecticut (part of the Conne cticut Portion of the NY-NJ- LI Mar ginal Nona ttainm ent area). In respon se to federal legislation, Conn ecticut has restructured the ECO Program to empha size voluntary participat ion, combine d with pos itive incentives, to encourage em ployee s to rides hare, use transit, and con tinue to expa nd their trip re du ction activities. This pro gram has bee n m ad e available to all employer s. It is felt that this pr oc ess is an effective m ea ns of achieving Co nnecticut’s cle an air tar gets. Funding for this effort un der the Congestion Mitiga tion and Air Quality Impro vem ents (CMAQ) Pro gram is incl uded in the TIP for FY 201 8-20 21 . It is esti m ated that this program , if fully successf ul, cou ld redu ce Ve hicle Miles of Travel (VM T) an d mobi le source VOC em issions by two percent in So uthwestern Con necticut. It sho uld be noted that TIP an d LRTP projects which have ne gligible impact on trip distribu tion and/or highway capac ity have not bee n incorporated into the network. These inc lud e, but are not lim ited to, geo m etric impro vem ents of exist ing interchan ges, short secti ons of climbing lanes, inter section improvem ents, and trans it projects dealing with equipm ent for exist ing facilities and vehicles, an d tra nsit op erating assistance. Essen tially, tho se p rojects that do no t im pact the tra vel dem an d forecasts are not included in the net works and /or analysis. The ne twor k-ba sed travel mode l used for this ana lysis is the mo de l that CTDOT utilizes for tra nspo rtation plann ing , program m ing and design requiremen ts. This travel de m and m ode l uses de mogr aph ic an d lan d use ass um ption s ba sed on the 201 0 Cen sus popu lation an d Con ne cticut Depa rtmen t of Labo r 20 10 em ploym en t estim ate s. Popu lation an d employm en t projection s for the yea rs 2020 , 203 0 an d 204 0 were de velope d by the Conne cticut Depa rtm en t of Tran spo rtat ion , Travel Dem an d an d Air Qua lity Mode ling Unit and app roved by all the regiona l plann ing agencies in ea rly 2012 . The mo de l uses a constraine d equilibr ium app roa ch to allocate trips amon g links. The model was calibra ted using 20 13 grou nd counts an d 201 3 Highway Pe rforma nce Mon itoring System (HPMS) Veh icle Miles of Travel data. 36 Pea k hour dire ctional traffic volum es were estima ted as a pe rcen tage of the ADT on a link by link ba sis . Based on autom atic traffic recorde r dat a, 9.0 pe rcen t, 8.5 percent, 8.0 pe rcent and 7.5 percent of the Average Daily Traffic (ADT) occ urs dur ing the fou r high est hours of the day. A 55:45 directional split was assum ed . Hou rly volum es were then converted to Service Flow Le vels (SFL) an d Volum e to Capa city (V/ C) ratios calculated as follows:  SFL = DH V/PHF* N  VC = SFL / C whe re:  DH V = Directiona l Hourly Vo lume  PHF = Peak Hou r Factor = .9  N = Numb er of lane s  C = Capa city of lane Pea k period speeds were estima ted from the 200 0 Hi ghway Capa city Manua l ba sed on the de sign spe ed, facili ty class , are a type an d the calculated V/ C ratio. On the express way system , Conne cticut-ba sed free flow speed data was available. This data was deem ed more appropr iate an d supe rseded the cap acity manual spe ed value s. The express way free flow spee ds were updated in 200 5. For the off-peak hours, tra ffic volum e is no t the con trolling factor for veh icl e speed. Off- pea k link spee ds were based on the Hi ghway Cap acity Ma nual free flow spe eds as a function of facil ity class an d are a type. As be fore , Conne cticut-ba sed speed dat a was substituted for expressway facili ties and was updated in 20 05. Two spe cial cases exist in the mo deling process: cen troid con nectors an d intrazona l trips.  Centroid conn ectors represen t the local road s used to gain access to the m od el network f rom cen ters of activity in ea ch traffic analysis zone (TAZ). A speed of 25 37 m ph is assum ed for these links .  Intrazona l trips are trips tha t are too short to get on to the m ode l networ k. VMT for intrazonal trips is calculated based on the size of each individual TAZ. A speed of 20 to 24 mph is assum ed for the pea k pe riod an d 25 to 29 mph for the off–pe ak pe riod. The Daily Vehicle Mil es of Travel (DVMT) is calculated using a method ology ba sed on disaggregate spe ed, converted to sum mer an d winter VMTs, an d summa rized by Nonattainm ent area, functiona l class, and spe ed. The VMT and spee d pro files develope d by this process are then comb ine d with the em ission factors fro m the MOVES2014a model to produce em iss ion estim ates for ea ch sc ena rio and tim e fram e. The MOV ES 201 4a input an d output dat a may be found in the Append ices. Tab le 3 on the following pa ge sho ws the 20 18 thro ugh 20 40 Action Emissi ons an d Eight- Hou r Budge ts for Volatile Org an ic Com pou nds (VO C), an d Ni troge n Ox ide s (N Ox) resulting from this process. 38 TABL E 3 VM T – OZONE EM ISSIONS – SIP BU DGETS Series 31C Year Oz one Area Series 31 C Bu dg ets Differen ce VOC NOX VOC NOX VOC NOX 2018 CT Portion of NY-NJ-LI Area 16.56 22.39 27 .40 54 .60 -10.84 -32.21 Gre ater CT Portion 15 .07 19. 74 26.3 0 49 .20 -11.2 3 -29.46 2025 CT Portion of NY-NJ-LI Area 12.33 13 .26 27 .40 54 .60 -15.07 -41.34 Gre ater CT Portion 11 .38 11 .86 26.3 0 49 .20 -14.92 -37 .34 2035 CT Portion of NY-NJ-LI Area 7.26 7.86 27 .40 54 .60 -20.14 -46.74 Gre ater CT Portion 6.65 6.91 26.3 0 49 .20 -19.65 -42 .29 2040 CT Portion of NY-NJ-LI Area 6.68 7.35 27 .40 54 .60 -20.7 2 -47.25 Gre ater CT Portion 6.15 6.48 26.3 0 49 .20 -20 .15 -42 .72 No te: 1 A small redu ction in the Gr ea ter Connecticut area will occur from the EC O program in the Connecticut portion of the NY-NJ-LI due to travel betwe en the areas. 2 VOC & N OX em issions are in tons per summer day and are calculated using Connecticut’s veh icle mix. 3 HPM S 14 Functional Class system used. 4 Na tional Low Em iss ion Ve hicl e (N LEV) program included in 2008 and all future years. 5 Eight Hou r Oz one emissi on budgets effective June 27, 2008 6 Series 31 C with 20 iteration equi librium assignmen t. 39 In the NY -NJ -LI portion, the tran sportation program an d plan meet the required con form ity test:  Action yea r em issions are less than approved 200 9 budge ts for VO X/NOx In the Greater Connecticut area, the transportation program and plan meet the required conformity test:  Action year emissions are less than approved 2017 budgets for VOX/NOx This analysis in no way re flects the full bene fit on air quality from the tran spo rtation plan an d progra m . The ne twork-ba sed m ode ling pr ocess is capable of assess ing the impa ct of m ajor ne w highway or tran sit service. It does no t reflect the im pact from the m an y projects which are categorically exclud ed from the requiremen t of conformity. These projects include num ero us impr oveme nts to intersection s, which will allow tra ffic to flow m ore effici en tly, thu s red ucing de lay, fuel usage an d em iss ions. The prog ram also includes a significant numb er of miles of resurfacing. Stud ies have shown that smoo th pa vemen t reduces fuel con sump tion and the attendan t CO an d VO C em issions. Includ ed in the TIP bu t no t reflected in this analysis are m any projects to m aintain existing rail and bus systems. W ithou t the se projects, those system s could no t offe r a high level of service. W ith the m, the mass transit system s function more efficiently, with imp roved safet y, and provide a more depe ndab le an d aesthetically appe aling service. These advantages will retain existing patro ns an d att ract ad ditional riders to the system . The technology to quantify the air qua lity be ne fits fro m these program s is no t currently availab le. As shown in this ana lys is, transpo rtation em issi ons are decli ning dram atically an d will continue to do so. This is primarily du e to prog ram s such as reform ulated fue ls, enh an ced inspe ction an d m ainten ance (I/M) program s, stage two vapor recover y (area sou rce), and th e low em iss ions veh icles (LEV ) progra m . MOVES 2014 a inc lude s three new em ission con trol program s ass ociate d with regulat ion p rom ulgate d since the re lease of MOV ES2010 b: 40  Tier 3 em ission standards tha t ph ase in beg inning in 201 7 for cars, light-du ty t ruc ks, m edium -du ty passenger vehicles, and som e he avy-duty trucks, and Tier 3 f uel sta ndards that require lower sulfur gasoline beginning in 201 7.  Heavy -duty engine an d vehic le greenho use has (GH G) re gulations that ph ase in dur ing m od el years 201 4-2018 .  The secon d ph ase of light-du ty ve hic le GHG regu lations tha t ph ase in for m odel yea rs 20 17-202 5 cars and light trucks. Changes in the tran spo rtation syst em will no t produce significant emiss ion red uctions because of the m ass ive existing rail, bus, highway system s, and land de velopmen t alre ad y in place. Change in these aspects is usually marg inal, pro ducing ver y sm all impa cts . PM 10 EP A previously design ated the City of New Haven as Nona ttainm en t with res pect to the Natio nal Am bie nt Air Quality Standards (NAAQS) for par ticulate m atter with a nom inal diamet er of ten m icron s or less (P M10). The PM10 No nattainment status in New Ha ven was a local probl em stemm ing from activities of several bus inesses loc ated in the Stiles Stre et section of the City. Num erous violations in the late 198 0’s and early 199 0’s of Section 22a-17 4-18 (Fugitive Dust) of CTDEEP re gulation s in that section of the city led to a nona ttainm ent de signa tion (CTDEEP, 19 94: Na rrative Conne cticut Departm ent of E ner gy and Environ mental Protection , Stat e Imp lem entation Plan Re vision For PM10, Mar ch 19 94 ). Cor recti ve acti ons were subsequently identified in the Stat e Im plem ent at ion Plan an d im plemente d, with no violations of the PM10 NAAQS since the m id-19 90’s. All construction acti vities un dertaken in the City of New Ha ve n are required to be p erform ed in com pliance with Secti on 22 a-17 4-18 (Control of Particulate “Em issions”) of the CTDEE P re gulations. All reasonable availab le con trol m easures 41 m ust be implem ented during constructi on to m itigate particulate matter em iss ions, including wind-blown fugitive du st, m ud an d dirt carry out, and re-entrain ed fugitive em iss ion from m obi le equipm en t. The projects con taine d in the STIP and Plans, de signa ted within the Ci ty of New Haven, are expected to ha ve little effe ct on the overall projected veh icle m iles of travel for the area an d are no t expe cted to cause significan t additional airbo rne pa rticulate matter to be gene rated. The tran spo rtation projects initiated in New Haven are no t designe d to en han ce de velopme nt in the are a. There fore, the projects unde rtaken in this are a will no t have a det rime ntal effect on PM10 in New Haven. On Octob er 13 , 20 05, EPA pub lished in the Federal Register (Vo l. 70, No. 19 7), ap proval of a request by CTDEEP for a Lim ited Maintenan ce Plan and rede signation of the New Haven Non attainm en t Are a to Att ainmen t for the Nationa l Amb ien t Air Qua lity Standards f or PM10. This dire ct final rule be cam e effective on Decemb er 12, 20 05. As with lim ited m aintena nce plans for other pollutan ts, em iss ions bu dge ts are considered to sat isfy transpor tation con form ity’s “bu dge t test”. However, future “proje ct level” conformity determ ination may re quire “hot spot” PM10 analys es for new transpo rtation projects with significant diesel traf fic in acco rda nce with EPA’s Final Ru le for “P M2.5 and PM10 Hot-Sp ot An alys es in Projec t-level Transportation Con form ity Rule P M2.5 an d PM10 Am end m ents; Final Rule (75 FR 4260 , March 24, 20 10) which became effective on Apr il 23 , 20 10. PM 2.5 In Decem ber of 20 04, EPA sign ed the final rulema king not ice to de signa te atta inme nt and Nonattainm ent are as with respect to the Fine Pa rticles (PM2.5) National Amb ien t Air Quality Stan da rds, becom ing effective Ap ril 5, 200 5. In Conn ecticut, Fairfield and New Haven counties are include d in the New York-Northern New Jersey-Lon g Island, NY-NJ – CT PM2.5 Nona ttainmen t area. Tran sportation plans an d transportation imp rovemen t program s (TIPS ) for the tri-state nona ttainmen t are a 42 were foun d to be collectively con form ing as of Novembe r 2006 . On Jun e 20 , 200 7, PM2.5 bud gets were foun d to be adequ ate for the ea rly progr ess SIP. As EPA New England has determine d the MOVES 201 0b 201 7 an d 202 5 m otor vehicle em iss ions bu dge ts sub m itted on June 22, 2012 to be ade quate for transportation con form ity purposes and effective as of February 20, 20 13. On Se ptem ber 24 , 20 13, EPA publishe d its approval of the PM2.5 redesigna tion req uest, est ablishing October 24, 20 13 as the effective da te of redesi gnat ion to attainment/maintena nce for Con necticut’s portion of the NY-NJ-T Area for bot h the 199 7 annu al and 24 -hours PM2.5 NAAQ S. The PM2.5 Conform ity Sub m ittal is a sepa rate do cum ent which currently include s da ta specific to Conne cticut’s five MPO ’s containe d in tha t attainmen t/ma intenan ce area. O the r Pl an ning Documen ts The ena ction of Se ction 81 of Con ne cticut Public Act 13-27 7 repea led Section 13b- 15 of the Connecticut General Statutes, no longer mandating a bien nial Master Tra nspo rtation Plan effective July 1, 2013. The Dep artment’s Capital Plan has be en expand ed to includ e much of the project inform ation that was formerly include d in the MTP. In ad dition, the Existing Systems docum ent and the Statewide Lon g Ran ge Tra nsportation Plan contain othe r information that was includedin various MTPs. Tran sportation Pl anning W ork Pr og ram CTDOT’s FY 20 17 -201 8 Tran sportation Plan ning W ork Pro gram contains a description of all planning efforts (inc luding those related to air qua lity) to be spo nsored or undertaken with federal assistance during FY 2017 and 2018. Inclu ded with this p rogram are several tasks directly related to CTD OT’s responsibilities un der C on necticut’s SI P for Air Quality. Additional functions, such as those sup po rting the p repa ration of pro ject level co nform ity an alysis, are fund ed un der project related tasks . This work program is available at CTDOT for review. 43 Con clusions CTDOT ha s assessed its com pliance with the applic able conform ity criteria requiremen ts of the 199 0 CAAA. Based up on this analysis , it is con clud ed tha t all elem ents of CTDOT’s tra nspo rtation program an d the Regional Long -Range Tra nspo rtation Plan s conform to applicab le SIP and 199 0 CAAA Con formity Gu idance criteria an d the ap proved tra nspo rtation conform ity bud gets. In add ition to the informa tion required for a confor m ity de termina tion , the following is attached:  Appendix A: Interagency Consultation Meeting Minutes  Appendix B: The MOVES2014a tabulations for each analysis year  Appendix C: The MOVES2014a Input Ozone Emission Runs  Appendix D: ACRONYMS Please direct an y que stions you m ay ha ve on the air qu ality emiss ion analysis to: Conn ecticut Depa rtmen t of Tran spo rtation Bu reau of Po licy an d Planning Di visi on of Coo rdina tion, Modeling an d Crash Data – Unit 5753 1 Travel Demand / Air Quality Modeling Unit 280 0 Be rlin Turn pike Newington, CT. 061 11 (860) 594 -203 2 Email: Jud y.Raymon d@ ct. gov 44 APP EN DIX A Interagen cy Consultation Mee ting Minu tes 45 IN TERAGEN CY CONSU LTATION MEETI NG Stat ewide T ransport ation Impro vement Program Co nne cticut Departm ent of Transportat ion Ro om 2307 – February 7 , 20 17 Go To Meeting Atten dees : Eloise Powell – FHW A Ken Shooshan-Stoller, FHW A Leah Sirmin – FTA Ariel Garcia – EPA Je nnifer Carrier – CRCO G C a r a R a d z i n s – CRCOG R o b A l o i s e – CRC OG Mark Nielson – CN VMPO Christian Meyer – CN VMP O Ben Muller – CNVMPO Meghan Sloan – CT Metro COG Robert Haramut – LCRV CO G Stephen Dudley –SCRCOG Chris Rappa – SCRC OG Ri cha rd Guggenheim – SECC OG Kate Rattan – SECCOG Rob Sachnin – W es tern COG Mari beth W ojenski – CTDOT Ju dy Raymond – CTDO T Robbin Cabelus – CTDOT Roxane Fromson – CTDOT Grayson W right – CTDO T Sa ra Radacsi – CTDO T Matthew Cegielski- CTDOT Rya n Dolan – CTDOT Greg Pacelli – CTDOT Kara Chandler – CTDOT 46 Th e Interagency Consu ltation Meeting was held to review projec ts su bmitted for the 2018 – 2021 STIP. Both the Ozo ne and PM 2.5 reports will be elect ronica lly distributed to the MPOs in the appropriate Nonattainment/Maintenance areas, FTA, FHW A, DEE P an d EP A. The MP Os will nee d to hold a 30 da y public comm ent and review period. At the end of this review period , the MP O will h old a Policy Board meeting to endorse the Air Quality Con formity determination. There was also a brief discuss ion on the trav el mo del an d emissions software planning assumptions emp loyed in the conform ity analysis. Th e sch edule for the 201 8-2021 Regional Transp ortation Impro vem ent Plans Conform ity Determina tion Analysis is as follow:  MPOs transmit signed and dated Concurrence Form to judy.raymond@ ct.gov by F e b r u a r y 1 0 , 201 7.  CTDOT Travel Demand Model Unit perform s the air quality analysis an d se nds the Air Qu ality Conformity Determina tion Reports electronica lly to all MPOs in e a r ly s umme r 20 17  MPOs adve rtise and hold a 30 -da y public rev iew an d co mm ent pe riod for the Air Qu ality Conformity.  MPOs hold a Policy Board meeting approving an d endo rsing the Air Quality Conformity and transmit resolutions to judy.raymond@ct.gov after Policy Board meeting . It is importan t tha t all MPOs follow this schedule to ensu re that the TIP/STIP Con formity Determ inations can go forward on schedule. 47 PLANNING ASSUMPTIONS Ozone and PM2.5 2018 -2021 Statewide Transportation Improvement Program February 7, 2017 Planning Assumptions for Review Frequency of Review * Responsible Agency Year of Data Socioeconomic Data At least every 5 years CTDOT 2010 Census Data available 2012 DMV Vehicle Registration Data At least every 5 years CTDE EP 2011 Data available 2012 State Vehicle Inspection and Maintenance Program Each con formity round CTDE EP Same as currently approved I&M SIP State Low Emission Vehicle Program Each conformity round following approval into the SIP CTDE EP Same as SIP VMT Mix Data At least every 5 years CTDE EP 20 10** Analysis Years – PM 2.5 Each conformity round CTDOT/CTDE EP 2018 , 2025, 2035, 2040 Analysis Years – Ozone Each conformity round CTDOT/CTDE EP 2018 , 2025, 2035, 2040 Emission Budget – PM2.5 As SIP revised/updated CTDE EP 2017 / 2025 PM 2.5 Emission Budget – Ozone As SIP revised/updated CTDEEP 20 09 SW 2017 Gr.CT Temperatures and Humidity As SIP revised/updated CTDE EP X Control Strategies Each conformity round CTDE EP X HPMS VMT Each conformity round CTDOT 20 13 * Review of Planning Assumptions does not necessarily prelude an update or calibrati on of the travel demand model. ** Data not available until 2011 . 48 APP EN DIX B MOVES 2014 a tabulations 49 2018 MOVES 2014a Cou nty Summ ary: Pollutants 2017 Emission Quantities (Tons/Day) NY/NJ/CT Non-Attainment Area Greater CT Non-Attainment Area Statewide ID Name Fairfield Middlesex New Haven Subtotal Har tford Litchfield New London Tolland Windham Subtotal 1 Hydrocarbons 7.6274 1.6437 7.1406 16.4117 7.8156 1.8309 2.6416 1.4939 1.1044 14.8865 31.2981 3 Nox 9.9661 2.4093 10.0105 22.3859 10.5144 1.8126 3.8446 2.1539 1.4138 19.7393 42.1252 79 NM Hydrocarbons 7.2531 1.5533 6.7620 15.5684 7.4237 1.7720 2.4988 1.4078 1.0508 14.1531 29.7215 87 VOC 7.7097 1.6517 7.1948 16.5562 7.9072 1.8841 2.6612 1.5020 1.1199 15.0744 31.6306 2025 MOVES 2014a Cou nty Summ ary: Pollutants 2025 Emission Quantities (Tons/Day) NY/NJ/CT Non-Attainment Area Greater CT Non-Attainment Area Statewide ID Name Fairfield Middlesex New Haven Subtotal Har tford Litchfield New Londo n Tolland Windham Subtotal 1 Hydrocarbons 5.7190 1.2515 5.4076 12.3781 5.9992 1.3967 1.9892 1.1474 0.8431 11.3756 23.7538 3 Nox 5.8467 1.4415 5.9709 13.2592 6.3827 1.0401 2.2826 1.3132 0.8443 11.8629 25.1221 79 NM Hydrocarbons 5.3595 1.1620 5.0 332 11.5547 5.6067 1.3457 1.8484 1.0597 0.7907 10.6512 22.2059 87 VOC 5.7175 1.2404 5.3766 12.3345 5.9939 1.4340 1.9759 1.1353 0.8457 11.3848 23.7193 2035 MOVES 2014a Cou nty Summ ary: Pollutants 2035 Emission Quantities (Tons/Day) NY/NJ/CT Non-Attainment Area Greater CT Non-Attainment Area Statewide ID Name Fairfield Middlesex New Haven Subtotal Har tford Litchfield New London Tolland Windham Subtotal 1 Hydrocarbons 3.3318 0.7501 3.3393 7.4212 3.5313 0.8082 1.1954 0.7082 0.5127 6.7559 14.1771 3 Nox 3.3550 0.8533 3.6562 7.8644 3.7133 0.5187 1.3589 0.8207 0.5005 6.9120 14.7765 79 NM Hydrocarbons 3.0337 0.6739 3.0076 6.7152 3.2015 0.7726 1.0743 0.6305 0.4683 6.1472 12.8624 87 VOC 3.2779 0.7294 3.2559 7.2633 3.4657 0.8309 1.1638 0.6850 0.5072 6.6526 13.9159 2040 MOVES 2014a Cou nty Summ ary: Pollutants 2040 Emission Quantities (Tons/Day) NY/NJ/CT Non-Attainment Area Greater CT Non-Attainment Area Statewide ID Name Fairfield Middlesex New Haven Subtotal Har tford Litchfield New London Tolland Windham Subtotal 1 Hydrocarbons 3.0376 0.6925 3.0718 6.8019 3.2469 0.7390 1.1028 0.6601 0.4774 6.2262 13.0281 3 Nox 3.1171 0.8020 3.4334 7.3524 3.4812 0.4695 1.2780 0.7816 0.4722 6.4824 13.8348 79 NM Hydrocarbons 2.7468 0.61 74 2.7452 6.1094 2.9223 0.7050 0.9834 0.5828 0.4335 5.6271 11.7365 87 VOC 2.9989 0.6754 3.0034 6.6777 3.1970 0.7657 1.0767 0.6399 0.4743 6.1537 12.8313 50 APPE NDIX C MOV ES 20 14a Input Oz on e Em iss ion Runs 51 2018 Fairfiel d 53 54 55 56 57 201 8 Hartford 58 59 60 61 62 63 201 8 Litchfield 64 66 68 69 201 8 Middlesex 71 73 74 75 201 8 New Haven 77 79 80 81 201 8 New London 83 85 86 87 201 8 Tolland 89 91 92 93 201 8 Windham 95 97 98 99 2025 Fairfield 101 103 104 105 2025 Hartford 107 109 110 111 2025 Litchfield 113 115 116 117 2025 Middlesex 119 121 122 123 2025 New Haven 125 127 128 129 2025 New London 131 133 134 135 2025 Tolland 137 139 140 141 2025 Windham 143 145 146 147 2035 Fairfield 149 151 152 153 2035 Hartford 154 155 159 160 2035 Litchfield 161 162 166 167 2035 Middlesex 168 169 173 174 2035 New Haven 175 176 180 181 2035 New London 182 183 187 188 2035 Tolland 189 190 19 4 195 2035 Windham 196 197 201 202 2040 Fairfield 203 204 208 209 2040 Hartford 210 211 215 216 2040 Litchfield 217 218 222 223 2040 Middlesex 224 225 229 230 2040 New Haven 231 232 236 237 2040 New London 238 239 243 244 2040 Tolland 245 246 250 251 2040 Windham 252 253 257 258 APP EN DIX D AC RON YMS 259 Acr onym s Acronym Me aning CA AA Cle an Air Act Am endments (1990) CO Carbon Mon oxide COG Coun cil of Gov ernm ent CTD OT Conn ecticut Departm ent of Trans portation CT DEEP Connecticut Departm ent of Env ironme ntal Prot ection EPA U.S. En viron me ntal Protec tion A gency FSD Final S cope Developm ent (Now PD) ISTEA Inte rmodal Surface Trans po rtation E fficien cy Act MA P-21 Moving Ah ead for Pro gress in the 21 st Centu ry Act MO VES Mobile Vehicle Emission Simulator MPO Met ropolitan Pl anning Organization NAAQS Nation al Ambient Air Quality Sta ndards NH 3 Ammonia NOx Ni tro gen Oxides PD Pr eliminary Design (Forme rly FSD) PDWP Pr oject D evelopm ent W ork Pro gram PM 2.5 Fine Particulate Matt er PMT Person M iles T raveled RA Regional Admi nist er ROP Rate of Pro gress RTP Regional Transp ortation Plan (generally refers to Regional Transp ortation Plan Upd ate) SA FETEA-LU Safe, Accoun table, Flexible, Effici ent T ransport ation Equi ty Act: A Legacy for U sers SD Stu dy and D evelopme nt SIP State Impl eme ntation Plan SOx Sulfur Oxides STIP St atewide Transpo rtation Improv eme nt Pro gram TCM Transpo rtation Co ntrol Me asure TIP Transpo rtation Improv ement Pro gram USDOT U.S. D epartm ent of Transport ation USEPA U.S. En viron me ntal Protec tion A gency VMT Vehicle M iles T raveled VOC Vol atile Organic Comp ound

CNV MPO TIP FTA

Federal Transit Administration Thursday, June 15, 2017 Central Naugatuck Valley Region MPO 2018-2021 Transportation Improvement Program DRAFT Project #: 0170-XXXX Municipal Grant Program Region: Route/System: Advanced Construction Phase: Year: Tot$(000): Fed$(000): Sta$(000): Loc$(000): FACode: Air Quality Code: Statewide Various 70 OTH 2018 $5,000 $0 $5,000 $0 9-N/A OTH 2019 $5,000 $0 $5,000 $0 9-N/A OTH 2020 $5,000 $0 $5,000 $0 9-N/A OTH 2021 $5,000 $0 $5,000 $0 9-N/A Project #: 0170-XXXX Section 5310 Program-Enhanced Mobility of Seniors/Individuals with Disabilities-Other Urban Region: Route/System: Advanced Construction Phase: Year: Tot$(000): Fed$(000): Sta$(000): Loc$(000): FACode: Air Quality Code: Other Urban Area Various Bus X6 70 OTH 2018 $540 $432 $0 $108 5310E OTH 2019 $556 $445 $0 $111 5310E OTH 2020 $573 $458 $0 $115 5310E OTH 2021 $590 $472 $0 $118 5310E Project #: 0170-XXXX Section 5310 Program-Enhanced Mobility of Seniors/Individuals with Disabilities-Rural Region: Route/System: Advanced Construction Phase: Year: Tot$(000): Fed$(000): Sta$(000): Loc$(000): FACode: Air Quality Code: Rural Various Bus X6 70 OTH 2018 $250 $200 $0 $50 5310E OTH 2019 $257 $206 $0 $51 5310E OTH 2020 $265 $212 $0 $53 5310E OTH 2021 $273 $218 $0 $55 5310E Page 1 of 5 Central Naugatuck Valley Region MPO 2018-2021 Transportation Improvement Program DRAFT Project #: 0170-XXXX Transit Capital Planning Region: Route/System: Advanced Construction Phase: Year: Tot$(000): Fed$(000): Sta$(000): Loc$(000): FACode: Air Quality Code: Statewide Various X6 70 OTH 2018 $450 $360 $90 $0 5307C OTH 2019 $500 $400 $100 $0 5307C OTH 2020 $550 $440 $110 $0 5307C OTH 2021 $600 $480 $120 $0 5307C Project #: 0171-XXXX CTfastrak Infrastructure/Station/Facility improvements Region: Route/System: Advanced Construction Phase: Year: Tot$(000): Fed$(000): Sta$(000): Loc$(000): FACode: Air Quality Code: Various CTfastrak X6 71 CON 2018 $1,642 $1,313 $328 $0 5337H CON 2019 $1,683 $1,346 $337 $0 5337H CON 2020 $1,725 $1,380 $345 $0 5337H CON 2021 $1,768 $1,414 $354 $0 5337H Project #: 0400-XXXX CTtransit Facility improvements Region: Route/System: Advanced Construction Phase: Year: Tot$(000): Fed$(000): Sta$(000): Loc$(000): FACode: Air Quality Code: Various CTtransit X6 79 CON 2018 $4,440 $3,552 $888 $0 5339 CON 2019 $4,551 $3,641 $910 $0 5339 CON 2020 $4,665 $3,732 $933 $0 5339 CON 2021 $4,781 $3,825 $956 $0 5339 Page 2 of 5 Central Naugatuck Valley Region MPO 2018-2021 Transportation Improvement Program DRAFT Project #: 0400-XXXX CTtransit Facility improvements/Misc Admin Capital Region: Route/System: Advanced Construction Phase: Year: Tot$(000): Fed$(000): Sta$(000): Loc$(000): FACode: Air Quality Code: Various CTtransit X6 79 OTH 2018 $12,000 $9,600 $2,400 $0 5307C OTH 2019 $8,250 $6,600 $1,650 $0 5307C OTH 2020 $6,625 $5,300 $1,325 $0 5307C OTH 2021 $25,000 $20,000 $5,000 $0 5307C Project #: 0400-XXXX CTtransit Systemwide Bus Replacements Region: Route/System: Advanced Construction Phase: Year: Tot$(000): Fed$(000): Sta$(000): Loc$(000): FACode: Air Quality Code: Various CTtransit X6 79 ACQ 2018 $4,440 $3,552 $888 $0 5339 ACQ 2019 $18,750 $15,000 $3,750 $0 5307C ACQ 2019 $4,551 $3,641 $910 $0 5339 ACQ 2020 $4,665 $3,732 $933 $0 5339 ACQ 2020 $25,375 $20,300 $5,075 $0 5307C ACQ 2021 $15,000 $12,000 $3,000 $0 5307C ACQ 2021 $4,781 $3,825 $956 $0 5339 Project #: 0431-XXXX Waterbury – ADA Operating Region: Route/System: Advanced Construction Phase: Year: Tot$(000): Fed$(000): Sta$(000): Loc$(000): FACode: Air Quality Code: Waterbury Waterbury X6 05 OTH 2018 $1,943 $0 $1,943 $0 9-N/A OTH 2019 $1,943 $0 $1,943 $0 9-N/A OTH 2020 $1,943 $0 $1,943 $0 9-N/A OTH 2021 $1,943 $0 $1,943 $0 9-N/A Page 3 of 5 Central Naugatuck Valley Region MPO 2018-2021 Transportation Improvement Program DRAFT Project #: 0431-XXXX Waterbury – Fixed Route Region: Route/System: Advanced Construction Phase: Year: Tot$(000): Fed$(000): Sta$(000): Loc$(000): FACode: Air Quality Code: Waterbury Waterbury X6 05 OTH 2018 $4,504 $0 $4,504 $0 9-N/A OTH 2019 $4,504 $0 $4,504 $0 9-N/A OTH 2020 $4,504 $0 $4,504 $0 9-N/A OTH 2021 $4,504 $0 $4,504 $0 9-N/A Project #: 0431-XXXX Waterbury Dial-A-Ride Region: Route/System: Advanced Construction Phase: Year: Tot$(000): Fed$(000): Sta$(000): Loc$(000): FACode: Air Quality Code: Waterbury Waterbury X6 05 OTH 2018 $732 $0 $732 $0 9-N/A OTH 2019 $732 $0 $732 $0 9-N/A OTH 2020 $732 $0 $732 $0 9-N/A OTH 2021 $732 $0 $732 $0 9-N/A Project #: 0442-XXXX Bristol Local Region: Route/System: Advanced Construction Phase: Year: Tot$(000): Fed$(000): Sta$(000): Loc$(000): FACode: Air Quality Code: Bristol Bristol X6 05 OTH 2018 $319 $0 $319 $0 9-N/A OTH 2019 $319 $0 $319 $0 9-N/A OTH 2020 $319 $0 $319 $0 9-N/A OTH 2021 $319 $0 $319 $0 9-N/A Page 4 of 5 Central Naugatuck Valley Region MPO 2018-2021 Transportation Improvement Program DRAFT Project #: 0450-XXXX Bristol Commuter Region: Route/System: Advanced Construction Phase: Year: Tot$(000): Fed$(000): Sta$(000): Loc$(000): FACode: Air Quality Code: Bristol Bristol X6 05 OTH 2018 $233 $0 $233 $0 9-N/A OTH 2019 $233 $0 $233 $0 9-N/A OTH 2020 $233 $0 $233 $0 9-N/A OTH 2021 $233 $0 $233 $0 9-N/A Page 5 of 5